3 ms·
"Easy come, easy go" is a well known phenomenon. How you get your money influences how and what you spend it on. Most lottery winners are bankrupt within 5 year
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
"Easy come, easy go" is a well known phenomenon. How you get your money influences how and what you spend it on. Most lottery winners are bankrupt within 5 years (about 2/3s of them).
I know someone who got fired, got six weeks severance pay, drove to a vacation spot with a friend and blew six weeks pay in one three day weekend on sex workers and cocaine. They then moved back home because they couldn't afford their apartment anymore. Six weeks severance pay plus unemployment benefits could have bought them their ongoing independence.
I would call that pissing money away.
Edit: Changed hookers to sex workers. They were called hookers back in the day.
- shove 9y agoanecdote != data
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYou only need one example to the contrary to rebut an assertion of never.
- falcolas 9y agoHowever you need much more than one to avoid delineating the exceptions which prove the rule. Also, your anecdote had a safety net - parents willing to take them in. What impact would the absence of that safety net have had?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThe judgement of the parents may have been part of why he felt compelled to leave town and get thoroughly wasted. Perhaps had they not been there, he would have been facing a very different mental and emotional landscape entirely and made other choices. You cannot change one element of an equation without impacting all parts. Thinking you can is a common logical error.
- vannevar 9y agoIt doesn't matter as much what he got for his money, as where it goes from there. The question is whether the money has a faster path to productivity via the sex worker or drug dealer than it would via a hedge fund manager. And that is not an easy economic question to answer, all moralizing aside.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI think that completely discounts the negative long term impact on his life, which seems particularly egregious in a discussion where I am being criticized as if my remarks are an act of callous disregard for the welfare of the common person. You don't care that he flushed his own life down the toilet, just as long as sex workers and cocaine dealers invested it well after they cleaned him out. And then you criticize me for "moralizing."
- vannevar 9y agoYou're correct, it does discount the impact on his life because that impact, however emotionally compelling, is irrelevant to the point of the subthread. Which is that, short of literally destroying it, money is never 'pissed away'---it simply moves on to someone else. People often confuse the benefits (and moral implications) for the spender (which are often pretty clear, as in this case) with the broader economic benefit of the transaction to the economy (which is much less clear). Ie, "someone made a bad moral choice in spending their money, so that must be bad for the economy." Not necessarily.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoSo, his inability to buy a house for himself and the fact that he continued to live with parents for many years has no bearing on our discussion of the economy and the creation of wealth? I don't want to give a lot more details about this person's life. It is a real person and giving too many details amounts to gossiping about them. But I think you are in error. The impact it had on this person's life has other impacts. I don't know why you think this is some appeal to emotion. It isn't. A person who cannot get their life together because of one youthful indiscretion has long term consequences that impact the wider economy. This is likely part of why such stories are emotionally compelling: Because it actually matters. I am not generally not talk about morality in the sense that other people do. I am not too happy to have the concept of morality injected into the discussion in such a way that it slings mud all over me at every step of the way. I am not talking about morality. I am talking about what makes for a healthy system that serves both the commoner and the rich person well. Our current approach doesn't do that. One of the reasons it does not do that is because I have seen a number of statements by wealthy people to the effect that they live with a lot of fear due to their wealth plus the state of the world. I thin this fear is legitimate and I think it tells us that a system that makes the ultra rich richer by bleeding the common person is a fundamentally unhealthy system that serves no one well, not even the rich people soaking up the extra money and wondering if they will need to abscond to Australia in their jet should the crap hit the fan. I think this fear is part of why so many tech giants talk so much about things like creating basic income. They want to be able to stop living in fear that someone is going to want them dead because the world is going to hell for so very many people and this makes them a potential target.