5 ms·
Have they not heard of Adam Smith's The Wealth of Nations? * IIRC, prior to Smith's famous book, the wealth of nations was viewed in terms of gold kept in the
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
Have they not heard of Adam Smith's The Wealth of Nations? *
IIRC, prior to Smith's famous book, the wealth of nations was viewed in terms of gold kept in the coffers of the kings. This was increasingly a source of puzzlement because it was failing to explain why some nations were thriving and others were not. This seminal work has been credited with being single-handedly responsible for transforming our understanding of wealth as "gold in the king's coffer" to what we now refer to as GDP. Wealth of a nation is measured by its productivity, not the money in the bank.
While I agree we need to do something about the current trend towards concentrating money in the hands of the few, clearly at the expense of the many, this is not the way to do it. This in no way protects the productivity that gives rise to these riches. In fact, it is likely to undermine said productivity.
There is no limit to how much people can spend. If you just cut everyone a check, whether you call it Basic Income or American Equity, the money will get pissed away. It will not get invested in a better future.
We have to find ways to address the underlying structural problems that are causing the 1 percent to effectively bleed the masses for more. We also must do so without creating perverse incentives. This is a case of "the cure they are recommending is worse than the disease."
* https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations
- shove 9y agoHow is the 600 billion spent annually on the military anything of productive value that is in any way significantly different than it getting "pissed away"? It's offensive to suggest more of that money will get spent on entertainment (etc) than food, clothing, shelter, education, medical expenses (etc)
- DoreenMichele 9y agoIf we do away with the US military, we will promptly be invaded and taken over by someone else. The military allows the country to exist at all. The world is not full of live-and-let-live hippies who all love the US and its people. The military is also a source of medical training, new medical knowledge, various forms of stability, and research that helps create new products. I am advocating for people not being bled by the 1 percent to begin with. Charity never provides anyone a secure, comfortable life. It makes you their bitch and thus de facto undermines quality of life. I want people to have the money they deserve, but not by saying it is okay for the rich to first bleed us and then we will ask for some piddling check afterwards and kiss their butts and say "Thank you, massah." They outlawed slavery in the US. I would like it to really die and not come back from the grave with a new name.
- shove 9y ago1) Yeah, the 300 million firearms in the US wouldn't be any impediment at all to an invasion C'mon. There are no barbarians at the gate. 2) Yes, there are good economic side effects that come from spending 600B on just about anything. Lifting people out of poverty a few inches couldn't possibly be less economic waste than grossly disproportionate military spending. 3) You've got a pretty novel definition of slavery.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYou've got a pretty novel definition of slavery. Perhaps. FWIW, my definition of slavery is that the value of your productivity is owned and controlled by someone else, not you. I see the movement towards basic income as the promotion of a world of poor people in chains. Money grows out of power, not the other way around. If money alone created power, lottery winners would all promptly take their place in the halls of power. They don't. Most wind up bankrupt within 5 years.
- Aushin 9y agoFWIW, my definition of slavery is that the value of your productivity is owned and controlled by someone else, not you. I see, so you too consider capitalism a form of slavery.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoWhen things are done right, capitalism does not have to mean that. Employees can, for example, own stock in the company where they work. Some companies basically insist that employees do so and intentionally develop an employee-owned company culture. Of course, when workers and stockholders are entirely separate classes of people, then, basically, yes. But that is not an inevitable outcome, even though it seems to generally be the state of things currently.
- shove 9y ago(thread fail sorry) Your definition of slavery pretty neatly matches capitalism, I hope you notice ...
- vannevar 9y ago"...the money will get pissed away." This is a common misconception about money. It never gets 'pissed away', it just changes hands. How fast it changes hands, and the degree to which it leaves productive assets in its wake, are the determining factors for economic health. The question is whether money spent by individuals on daily necessities would ultimately be better for the economy than money spent by high speed traders exchanging commercial paper or by a surgeon buying a second yacht. I don't know the answer to that question, but in no case is the money 'pissed away'. To paraphrase Al Gore, there is no 'away' to piss it into.
- DoreenMichele 9y ago"Easy come, easy go" is a well known phenomenon. How you get your money influences how and what you spend it on. Most lottery winners are bankrupt within 5 years (about 2/3s of them). I know someone who got fired, got six weeks severance pay, drove to a vacation spot with a friend and blew six weeks pay in one three day weekend on sex workers and cocaine. They then moved back home because they couldn't afford their apartment anymore. Six weeks severance pay plus unemployment benefits could have bought them their ongoing independence. I would call that pissing money away. Edit: Changed hookers to sex workers. They were called hookers back in the day.
- shove 9y agoanecdote != data
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYou only need one example to the contrary to rebut an assertion of never.
- falcolas 9y agoHowever you need much more than one to avoid delineating the exceptions which prove the rule. Also, your anecdote had a safety net - parents willing to take them in. What impact would the absence of that safety net have had?