5 ms·
Coinbase Obtains Partial Victory Over IRS
- jasonrhaas 9y agoCoinbase should have to follow the same rules as everyone else. They are a commodity exchange, plain and simple.
- scott00 9y agoCommodity exchanges are actually largely unregulated in the US. The existence of a large complicated federal law called the "Commodity Exchange Act" may at first blush make you think otherwise, but the CEA establishes rules for futures exchanges (including commodity futures exchanges), not commodity exchanges.
- testvox 9y agoThat was coinbase's argument in this case. Commodity trading is largely unregulated in the United States and this request from the IRS is highly unusual for commodity exchanges (mostly it's very broad scope) .
- mtgx 9y agoThe "partial victory" was small. The "partial loss" was much larger. The IRS still got 14,000 people's data in bulk. It just wasn't all of Coinbase's customers, as the IRS initially wanted. But it's still a far cry from investigating each person rather than fishing for crimes among thousands of people.
- thisisit 9y agoWow, this sounds like a desperate attempt to put positive spin on a losing case. > we were proud to accomplish two important victories for our customers. > First, the government vastly narrowed the scope of its summons. This was already their previous "win": https://blog.coinbase.com/coinbase-irs-update-ed9c966c7747?source=user_profile---------2---------------- https://blog.coinbase.com/coinbase-irs-update-ed9c966c7747?s... Repeating this over and over again means there weren't many positives from this decision. > Second, the quantity of data we must produce for the approximately 14,000 customers who remain in scope has been significantly reduced. And what is this "quantity of data"? Are they stripping PII or transaction information from the data? If not then knowing the user information and transaction information is enough for the IRS.
- dmix 9y agoA 97% reduction from the original request does seem like a 'partial' victory to me. IRS asked for all users data it seems and they reduced it to only users with $20k in transactions with a particular timeframe. The original proposition by the government may have been totally ridiculous and over-reaching. Maybe the IRS never fully intended it to work. But I'm not so sure that's the case, given the US gov's liberal sweeping up of data. IRS also has a history of getting what it wants. But as far as tangible 'wins' here I believe you would have to be dumb to have trusted Coinbase to protect your privacy. They have always been very obviously corporate 'straight-edge' service and very willing to follow every financial rule in an effort to be fully legitimate. Given the amount of capital they raised and their US residency this is all not surprising. So I'm kinda surprised they weren't already handing over every users information... that's a win in my books. But obviously I've viewed them with very low standards.
- ironjunkie 9y ago97% reduction? Not really. Given how the price of BTC/ETH is going up, they will soon have to report pretty much every user that put more than a couple hundred dollars initially.
- thisisit 9y agoSure it was a victory. But that was not the point of the case. IRS had already agreed to the 97% reduction as seen from the previous post. They went to court because they wanted it to reduce even more. That didn't happen here.
- logfromblammo 9y agoIf your intent is to hide something from the government, you really need to only do your business on the black market, with people who are already strongly disincentivized to cooperate with the government. Otherwise, just pay your capital gains tax and feel good about supporting the general welfare, because every last person that depends on being in the good graces of the government in order to earn their living will roll on you in an instant. All you U.S.-based Bitcoin speculators have been paying your capital gains taxes, right?~ If you don't want to realize a taxable gain, never buy anything from the U.S. with it, especially dollars. If you don't want to realize a taxable gain that the IRS will know about, don't buy anything from anyone with an EIN. If you're going to be a criminal, please at least be an intelligent criminal. The only justification the IRS has for invading the privacy of thousands of people is because the stupid criminals are embarrassing them. They estimated only 7-9% of Bitcoiners declare and pay tax on capital gains? So if you don't want Coinbase to be forced to turn over your records, your other option is to volunteer to give them to the IRS yourself. Not much of a choice, but the government wants money, and they prefer to take it from the people who obviously have it, because it's easier. So you illegally conceal, or you legally comply. You can't do it half-assed in either direction. If your intent is the former, you cannot do it through Coinbase, because they must comply to exist. While I unequivocally despise the usual tactics of the government with respect to taxation, they are at least predictable, so anyone who is relying on Coinbase to protect them is acting foolishly.
- ironjunkie 9y agoCan we stop the marketing hype and call this what it is ? A complete loss of this case? Also, I couldn't find information on how the 20k $ was calculated. Is this based on the amount of money in? Or the amount of money after selling ?
- linsomniac 9y agoI had assumed Coinbase needed my SSN because they were reporting to the IRS. If they aren't reporting to the IRS, what in the world are they using my SSN for?!?
- dumbfounder 9y agoMy guess is that they know they will need to report eventually, so they are covering their bases now, but still fighting to put it off as long as possible.
- andy_ppp 9y agoIn which case the court case is just a form of marketing and not intended to stop full and retrospective reporting?
- modeless 9y agoThey were complying with strict AML/KYC laws that essentially require them to ask for this information.
- PatientTrades 9y ago> narrowed summons affects approximately 14,000 of the highest-transacting customers from 2 to 4 years ago. The rest of the 480,000 customers remain unaffected, Seems like the IRS is only going after the big fish for now. I wouldn't be surprised if we see a micro crash in the next couple of weeks as the big players go to the sidelines to see how this plays out. Once the IRS gets involved regulations for transparency usually follow. just my 0.02
- searine 9y ago>Thanks to Coinbase’s efforts, more than 480,000 customers’ records were preserved from disclosure. If you think they're giving up, you got another thing coming. Reliable exchanges mean eventual taxation.
- ska 9y agoReliable exchanges mean eventual taxation. There is nothing eventual about the taxation. You are either already reporting it, or you are already unlawfully evading it. Whether or not an exchange also reports it is a separate issue.
- gedrap 9y agoThis whole thing looks rather silly. Like, you either find a decent exchange, expect it to be legit and that includes cooperating with IRS and other parts of the government when needed. You know, like you expect responsible financial institutions to do. Or just find some maybe less legit ones at your own risk. Coinbase can't be both legit and 'oh look we resist The Man'. Urgh.
- 3327 9y agoIF coinbase is naive enough to think they can win a fight with the IRS it will be interesting to see them go down throwing punches into thin air in round 2.
- skizm 9y agoTo be a completely legal user of Coinbase, do I need to do anything other than report gains as income on my tax return?
- mdip 9y agoOn my end, I made the assumption that the IRS was going to get this data, anyway. Though Coinbase doesn't fall under the same blanket as my bank, with the way they operate and what they do, it's only a matter of time before they're required to provide the same records that my bank provides -- 1099 and other tax-related forms. No transaction you perform with a typical bank is secret, that data is used to determine what you must pay in taxes and the IRS is rather consistent in getting that information and coming down hard -- even on small tax cheats -- when you fail to report your earnings properly. I'm just "the little guy" and that $3,000 or so of ETH that I cashed out will be appearing as a line-item on my tax filings in the early part of next year. It's a stupid thing to pay a penalty/fine on. I'm not a fan of how we're taxed in this country or how the IRS operates[0] but I'm not interested in trying to solve the problem by attempting to get away with breaking the (bad) laws and as someone with friends who have tried to get away with such things and lost pretty horribly, I'll learn from other's mistakes rather than make them myself. When I saw that they asked for all of Coinbase's records, I not only wasn't surprised -- I fully expected they'd actually get all of them. While I'm glad that I was wrong in that expectation, it's not something that should motivate anyone into thinking they'll fly under the radar with unreported earnings. Now ... how on earth I am supposed to claim this income -- all made from mining, not "purchased" using currency -- will have to be figured out by my CPA. I'm just glad that all of my coins are old enough that they (hopefully) qualify as long-term capital gains, but IANACPA. [0] It always seemed curious to me that financial transactions -- provided they go through a bank (which the vast majority of them do) are effectively free of 4th Amendment protection, and it bothers me that tax related crimes are handled unlike any other crime in the US -- an IRS audit is, effectively, "We think you're guilty; prove to us otherwise or pay the fine"
- vel0city 9y agoIn relation to your footnote, banks are third-party and would clearly fall under the ideas of third-party doctrine[0]. While this was only clearly put into place in relation to telecom in the 70s, this basic concept has existed in common law for a long time. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_doctrine
- jshaqaw 9y agoMy equities broker has to report my transactions to the irs. Why should bitcoin be any different.
- kapauldo 9y agoBitcoin is not private like sotoshi imagined.