6 ms·
It's going to become increasingly expensive and politically complex to operate an Internet company at Internet scale. That process of country to country divisio
by adventured 9y ago
It's going to become increasingly expensive and politically complex to operate an Internet company at Internet scale. That process of country to country division (legally/politically), will continue to accelerate.
Although they're getting the first punches to the face because they're easy and obvious targets, companies like Google or Facebook, will trivially withstand it over time. They can afford whatever compliance cost and complexity is involved. It's everyone else that is going to suffer, including all start-ups attempting to offer an Internet-wide service (something that not so long ago could be mostly taken for granted). The effect will be to lock-in the position of the existing giants and protect them from new companies that might challenge their global dominance.
If I want to offer an Internet-wide service in the near future, I'll need to comply with dozens of different Internet-related legal/political frameworks to spread into dozens of nations. It'll be realistically impossible to accomplish for smaller entities, so start-ups will be stuck even more than they already are in struggling to reach beyond their local audiences. This will particularly harm start-ups in smaller countries in Latin America, Africa and Europe. Start-ups in the US and China will gain a further advantage (an advantage which they've already utilized to produce most of the Internet giants to this point), because they get to start out with massive home markets with heavily unified rules and then push to the rest of the world from their large base.
This process destroys the Internet as it has been known the last two decades and it appears nothing is likely to stop it from getting dramatically worse in the next 10-15 years.
- zaarn 9y agoI doubt it. The GDPR and other european privacy laws are a problem if you operate from overseas. On the other hand, if you start in europe and are thusly aware of the privacy laws it becomes much easier to design as service that complies with them. The Netzdurchsuchungsgesetz in Germany even goes as far as only making big social networks responsible for content and small startups get a free pass.
- hnarayanan 9y agoEven if this is so, could you think of a better alternative for some modicum of consumer protection?
- adventured 9y agoSure, but it'll never happen. North America, the EU+Eurozone, Australia/New Zealand, Japan, and as much of Latin America & Africa as possible, should come up with a common framework that gets you an extremely high degree of compliance out of the gate if you follow it (with some expected smaller issues that are likely to be unavoidable on a nation to nation basis). WTO for the Internet. It's probably an inevitable outcome in some manner. The difficulty (cost, compliance and just plain frustration) will get great enough such that this will happen. The primary question is what form it'll take, what authority body/bodies it falls under, who initiates it, who the stragglers are, and so on. China would never sign on to it, and several dozen other nations also would likely lag or refuse. In China's case, they've always operated their own Internet, so they're irrelevant to the context that's occurring.
- Normal_gaussian 9y agoThe nations set the consumer laws and the companies follow it; the most restrictive case is no unauthorised tracking, no unauthorised analytics, local warehousing. If your system can cope with the most restrictive case, you can tag the data with the jurisdictions (easy), and then enable tracking / analytics / shared warehouses for more complex data. It sounds like a reasonable startup idea to help manage this.
- ionised 9y agoThe internet has not been like this for two decades. It has been like this since Google and Facebook became ubiquitous, which didn't start until the mid 2000's. Before then, the internet was still the internet, only without most of the data hoovering. I am totally in support of legislation that curtails this kind of thing. This isn't a case of the internet being made worse, it's a case of consumer protections catching up to technology.
- adventured 9y agoI don't know what you're talking about. The Internet has been globally widely open since the mid 1990s (except for a few countries like China), when it comes to commerce. That has only begun to slowly change in the last ten years. Even now, the Internet is still widely globally open. Compliance challenges are still relatively modest. The point is, that's beginning to change at an accelerating rate.
- ionised 9y agoYou're misunderstanding what I'm saying. The internet has been open for over two decades yes, but the ubiquitous surveillance of users and tracking and advertising across various websites and services is something that only really became a reality as Facebook and Google began to dominate. Again, that seemed to start happening after the mid 2000's.
- SCHiM 9y agoTotally agree. It used to be that one could browse the internet, and the only ads you'd see were the ads that the webmasters had personally negotiated for. These days everywhere you go your data is sucked in, and your 'reward' is a 'targeted' ad. The degradation in quality of service is staggering and sad. That said, I hope the legislation in this case will be sound. I hope that it at least leads to less invasive tracking. I hope it will be the combination of this legislation and the increasing amount of ad blockers that finally kill obtrusive ads and tracking. When I use a computer without an adblocker(tracking blocking included) these days there's a major chilling effect. It's gotten so bad that I don't dare search for certain things on my mobile (andoid) because I know somewhere a model is being trained on what I do and type. It makes me uncomfortable and suspicious, and also angry at tech companies that are using my behavior to earn money. I already paid for your phone, you don't deserve anything more. Cryptomining in a users browser, when not done through an exploit with hidden windows, is a perfect solution to website financing for larger websites. The smaller ones need to make up their mind about finding a balance between micro payments/subscriptions/patreon/free content.
- alkonaut 9y ago> It'll be realistically impossible to accomplish for smaller entities, so start-ups will be stuck even more than they already are in struggling to reach beyond their local audiences. Wasn't this always the case for businesses? If you are a physical company selling physical things then logistics, legal etc was always a huge barrier to expansion beyond your local market. I think the misconception is that the "normal" state is that the internet is a single normalized market where anyone can grow from zero to global in a way that a physcal company can't. I don't think that's realistic. What happened was simply that regulators couldn't keep up, as is always the case in the beginning of something. > This process destroys the Internet as it has been known the last two decades and it appears nothing is likely to stop it from getting dramatically worse in the next 10-15 years. But wasn't the internet in the past decades just a wild west where things like privacy etc always took a back seat? Is this development really such a bad thing (for consumers, I mean)?
- adventured 9y agoAbsolutely it has mostly always been the norm, throughout business history. The last 20 some odd years with regards to the Internet have been a freak of history; in that sense it's not at all surprising to see that abnormality end, barriers go up, complexity and cost go up, and so on. It's a shame, it was an extraordinary experiment.
- dalbasal 9y agoNormal is however things are/were. Atm, the norms are whatever environment Google, FB, etc. grew up under, over the last decade. Before that, it was even more anarchic. Before that, the internet didn't exist. Global-scale many-to-many media and communications didn't exist. I don't understand the desire to argue for an internet descibed by analogy to phone or radio or somesuch. The comparison isn't that strong, and the outcome is not desirable. The internet exposed the flaws in those, if anything has informed anything. Is this devils' advocacy? I do understand incumbents. They're safer and more protected the more rules get made. I understand politicians who are trying to deal with some other problem (financing terrorism, child porn), and don't understand or care about side effects. I understand the naive public, who just want their leaders to just solve these problems they keep taalking about. I understand judges ruling on specific cases, without regard (not their job) for the delay facto policy implications. The HN-er who wants an internet rulebook, I don't get it.
- codedokode 9y agoJust stop spying on your users.
- seanwasere 9y agoregulation creates monopolies.
- tanilama 9y agoLaw applies to start-ups as well. Internet has become the dominative media in the past decade, it is naive to think the powers in real world will give it a free pass.
- simion314 9y agoIf you respect the hardest privacy laws everywhere then you are fine, if you want to have different code paths like this guys in EU I can't spam them, I can't store private data without permissions but the other guys there I can do whatever I want but the other guys I can only do X but not Y, I suggest to just respect the best/strongest privacy law, a good product is one that helps people do their work and gain more free time, I do not see how invading privacy will affect good products. P.S. I am wondering what laws made it so today most emails have an Unsubscribe link at the bottom, this is such a good thing, I would hate some companies not adding it for the countries where it is not mandatory.
- codev 9y agoThe law in the US is the CAN-SPAM act in 2003. It requires email to have unsubscribe instructions at the bottom of the email and to take people off the list within 10 days of a request. There are similar laws, many of them stricter, in different jurisdictions. https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/can...
- simion314 9y agoThank you for the information, I think the anti regulation people appreciate this law.
- emiliobumachar 9y agoThis might work for the "privacy" topic in isolation, but I think the GP's point still stands. Laws are much more complex than a one-dimension easy-to-hard scale, and frequently plainly contradict each other. How does your right to be forgotten square with my right to protest your misdeeds? How does stopping fake news square with protecting free speech? Right to offend vs right not to be offended? Each nation makes its own decisions about that, with a lot of overlap but also a lot of non-overlap. And internet businesses will more and more have to navigate all that, or opt out of foreign markets. Just like non-internet businesses.
- 9y ago
- CaptainZapp 9y agoIt's everyone else that is going to suffer, including all start-ups attempting to offer an Internet-wide service (something that not so long ago could be mostly taken for granted). If a startup violates the privacy of their users intentionally and witth gusto they deserve to get smacked in the face; hard!
- JoshTriplett 9y ago> If I want to offer an Internet-wide service in the near future, I'll need to comply with dozens of different Internet-related legal/political frameworks to spread into dozens of nations. No, you don't. You'll have it a lot easier than Google or Facebook, because you don't have local offices in more than one country, and you should keep it that way as long as you possibly can. As long as you have offices in exactly one jurisdiction, you are only subject to the laws of that jurisdiction. You can generally safely ignore the attempted overreach of others.