4 ms·
The ignorance displayed by very smart people with regards to cryptocurrencies is fascinating.
by colordrops 9y ago
The ignorance displayed by very smart people with regards to cryptocurrencies is fascinating.
- deweller 9y agoAny truly transformative technology is very polarizing. The printing press and cars (horseless carriages) were followed by people who HATED these things when they were first introduced into society.
- sanderjd 9y agoHowever, it does not follow that every very polarizing technology is truly transformative.
- kasey_junk 9y agoCan you outline those ignorances in some sort of testable way? Or is this just a long way of saying “I disagree”?
- Frogolocalypse 9y agoThe ignorance stems from some sort of belief structure that allows one to believe that it would even be possible to outlaw bitcoin. Either bitcoin is valuable, or it is not. If it is, one should question why it is, and more importantly, why it is more valuable to people than the alternative. But rather than admit the problems of the alternative, he suggests something that is completely impractical (and downright sinister) because he would prefer not to discuss the reasons for its value in the first place.
- kasey_junk 9y agoSo to state your hypothesis as a testable bet, your claim is that a government could not outlaw the possession, sale or purchase of Bitcoin. His claim is they could. If any government does this you’re the ignorant one? And if they try and fail he is?
- Frogolocalypse 9y agoNo. We have historical precedent : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102 The only thing it did was increase the value of gold. And our world is far far far more able to circumvent any order like this, as any wealthy person storing their money in panama will tell you. Bitcoin is the reckoning for that belief. Rather than discuss the reason for the failure of their fiat system, which is what they're discussing right now, they want to restrict your freedom of exchanging the fruits of your labor for tokens in a system outside of their control. Freedom isn't about you asking the the government what you can do. Freedom is about the government asking your permission to govern in the interests of their constituents. If they can't convince you to use their token, they should start working now to come to a resolution that respects the rights of the people who choose not to buy their token for anything other than taxes.
- kasey_junk 9y agoA counter argument https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederate_States_dollar https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederate_States_dollar
- Frogolocalypse 9y agoThat isn't really a counter to any argument I'm making. If anything, it supports my argument. The government that supported that fiat ceased to exist, therefore the fiat ceased to exist. Sounds like a pretty good example of the dangers of fiat, and the advantages of a decentralized store of wealth.
- kasey_junk 9y agoOwning a particular currency was made illegal by a government. That government enforced that policy by force of arms. That currency ceased to exist. Ergo it is not ignorant to claim that s government can eliminate a currency & quite the opposite it’s ignorant to say its impossible.
- 21 9y agoAn obvious form of ignorance is saying "bitcoin has no value", (maybe with the "intrinsic" word thrown in there), despite the manifest fact of a market price, and of a huge run up. Value is like beauty, in the eye of the beholder, and dismissing bitcoin, or CounterStrike skins, or World of Warcraft assets as valueless is ignorant. They can't see the simple "repetition becomes truth" driver of bitcoin price, as in the longer the price is not zero, and the longer people talk between themselfs about the bitcoin price, the more real the idea that bitcoin has value becomes. This is how money is born, by a shared belief.
- kasey_junk 9y agoHe specifically says that Bitcoins value derives from perception. He further says that it’s value is largely derived from its “potential for circumvention”. The idea that random dude on the internet can call a Nobel Laureate & one of the most cited economists in history “ignorant” about these issues is hilarious.
- cwkoss 9y agoI think Stiglitz is coming from the position that ALL 'circumvention' is a societal harm. He is working from a position which supports Federal govt first, and individuals second. Confiscating money from child pornographers is a pretty clear moral good. Civil asset forfeiture, the confiscating the cash a poor single-mom is taking to buy the car because "it could be drug money" is a pretty clear moral evil to me. Which one of those happens more often? I'd guess the later is 100-1000x more frequent. Bitcoin is not moral, it offers circumvention to all, for better or worse.
- kasey_junk 9y agoSure but his position isn’t “ignorant”. Quite the contrary he’s one of the worlds experts on it. Disagree all you want. But ignorance isn’t the issue.
- cwkoss 9y ago
- mtgx 9y agoThe rule seems to be "If tied to the banking industry in any way then cryptocurrency ignorance."
- hitchhiker999 9y agoThe assumption "very smart people" is the reason for the fascinating disparity. IMHO a better assumption would be "well trained, well established, well rehearsed, highly skilled". Tesla was "very smart people", these are not. ...if they could just provide novel or sophisticated arguments, rather than angry & seemingly frustrated opinions - I might feel they were "smart" Decentralisation is going to change damn near everything. Yes, it's the printing press, electricity, the plane, the transistor, the internet.