5 ms·
There was a thread about this on HN -- too lazy to look it up now or repeat some of the longer comments about it. But going into this assuming that FB has no il
by danso 9y ago
There was a thread about this on HN -- too lazy to look it up now or repeat some of the longer comments about it. But going into this assuming that FB has no ill-intentions, FB's proposal seems by far the best solution in a world of ugly and terrible solutions.
For starters, it's intended for victims of revenge porn, which is a fairly extreme category and one in which the harassment is distinctively aggressive and virulent. Because if it weren't, the way FB deals with abusive content generally would seem to be good enough. If you come into this thinking that FB is asking everyone to upload their nudes for "safekeeping", then you've missed the point.
Secondly, it's hard to think of an implementation that wouldn't create a potential disaster that justifies doing anything special for revenge porn victims. Using the Facebook app is the most secure channel for sending FB the photos because it is a secure app that all FB users know how to use. Having the user hash on their own requires either an external app or website.
I don't think it needs to be said how such ancillary applications can be spoofed. Even if only 0.5% of users are dumb enough to fall for these spoofs, each incident would be a complete fucking disaster, for the victims and for Facebook.
As for the prospect of FB owning people's nudes. Again, in the case of revenge porn victims, the horse is already far from the barn. If we assign the worst of motives to FB, that it's a way to secretly collect nudes from users. Again, horse, barn. This secret process would be less efficient by magnitudes compared to what FB can already do today.
- cracell 9y agoFB has a no porn policy so wtf do you have verify you are you to get a revenge porn picture removed? "We remove photographs of people displaying genitals or focusing in on fully exposed buttocks. We also restrict some images of female breasts if they include the nipple, but our intent is to allow images that are shared for medical or health purposes. We also allow photos of women actively engaged in breastfeeding or showing breasts with post-mastectomy scarring. We also allow photographs of paintings, sculptures, and other art that depicts nude figures. Restrictions on the display of sexual activity also apply to digitally created content unless the content is posted for educational, humorous, or satirical purposes. Explicit images of sexual intercourse are prohibited. Descriptions of sexual acts that go into vivid detail may also be removed." https://www.facebook.com/communitystandards#nudity https://www.facebook.com/communitystandards#nudity
- mynameisvlad 9y agoIt might prevent them from being sent in the first place. If it matches a fingerprint photo, the message stops. It's especially important in revenge porn scenarios where you don't want it seen by anyone, and even the short amount of time between report and take down can have a lot of views.
- codefined 9y agoThis is for FB messenger, not FB posts. Messenger has no such rules for no pornography. Plus, this allows them to be proactive, rather than waiting for people to report posts.
- danso 9y agoI've never been a revenge porn victim but I think you might oversimplify the problem. For instance, if a former lover of mine has nude photos of me and distributes them to other people in private channels, I'm not able to even see them to report them. And that's just a one-time stoppage of the harassment.
- ncallaway 9y agoFB removes pornographic content, but it doesn't always do so proactively. If a user shares pornographic content, it may be visible on the site for a short period of time before the content is removed by Facebook. The goal of the initiative Facebook was attempting to implement was to prevent any revenge-porn photos from being shared on the website at all. Even for a brief period of time. From a user's standpoint, one hour of pornographic content available is disturbing but not catastrophic. However, one hour of images of pornographic content of themselves being shown to their friends and family is catastrophic.
- yellow_postit 9y agoOpen source a desktop and mobile tool that generates the image hash w/o the image leaving the device and have the code publicly reviewed seems like one potential approach.
- danso 9y agoStill vulnerable to duping users via App Store fakery: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/evbakk/fake-whatsapp-android-app-1-million-downloads https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/evbakk/fake-whats...
- Splines 9y agoI disagree: - It sets a precedent for uploading nude photos to FB and for them asking for it. - You need to trust FB to delete the photos when they receive it. Yes, I understand that they probably will, but really, how many systems are those bits going to touch? How many logs are going to have this information? Can you be really sure? A better implementation would be for the FB client to hash the file and for the hash to be uploaded. Trust issues are still there but at least mitigated to devices that you have some control over. Evil users that hash legitimate photos can be overcome with the same review system that is being tested today.
- danso 9y ago> - It sets a precedent for uploading nude photos to FB and for them asking for it. Before we reduce this to a slippery slope, what scenario do you envision in which FB could coax its userbase to upload nude photos? I know the OP is about taking a selfie to prove existence. What would FB use as the basis to mandate the general user to send a self-nude? > You need to trust FB to delete the photos when they receive it...can you really be sure? No, never, of course. But that's why I point out that FB already has this potential vector of attack. Every time a user flags content for abuse, that is logged and presumably a copy of the asset made for manual verification. Nevermind all the sensitive content millions of users everyday send across Messenger or private groups. > A better implementation would be for the FB client to hash the file and for the hash to be uploaded. If the image is hashed before it reaches FB servers, then it gives every user the power and impunity to attempt to censor via a Content-ID like approach.
- phjesusthatguy3 9y ago> Before we reduce this to a slippery slope, what scenario do you envision in which FB could coax its userbase to upload nude photos? The one where FB asks its userbase to upload nude photos[0]. [0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15651710 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15651710
- danso 9y agoThat's exactly the topic we're discussing now. Sorry, with "userbase" I meant "general userbase". This initiative they're proposing -- in coordination with a safety group in Australia -- is aimed at revenge porn victims. The general userbase of Facebook aren't in that group.
- throw409452 9y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15651710 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15651710 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15648080 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15648080 https://www.google.com/search?q=ycombinator+fb+revenge+porn https://www.google.com/search?q=ycombinator+fb+revenge+porn > too lazy to look it up now People doing this frustrates me greatly. You had to type 30 key strokes. ⌘+t "ycombinator fb revenge porn" ↵ and paste the results back. How many people are going to read your comment? Maybe 10% of them want to read those links. You spared yourself a trivial amount effort by offloading it to tens or hundreds of others. I wish people would provide links and source what they say more often. Maybe more discussion sites should let others suggest edits, like on stackoverflow. We could save some of that wasted effort.
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoNow do that on mobile, with a slower, cramped keyboard, and poor multitasking. Not everyone matches your system.
- dhimes 9y agoIf would be kinda cool if HN were to start working on an algo to find those links automatically (a "possibly related" section at the top, for instance).
- danso 9y agoI sometimes misunderestimate how long it'll take me to write out my thoughts or how much time I'll have before I need to get back to work. By the time I finished my comment I realize I wrote enough for the comment to be a fleshed-out enough argument; anyone wanting to see those past threads could look them up if necessary. I guess I could have saved you some angst by jumping up to the top of my comment and removing the sentence about me being lazy.
- aoetsuh34tn 9y ago> ... it's hard to think of an implementation that wouldn't create a potential disaster that justifies doing anything special for revenge porn victims. > ...Having the user hash on their own requires either an external app or website. What? Why can't the hashing take place in the FB Messenger app on your phone? Why does the picture need to be uploaded to FB's servers? That just goes to what Troy Hunt was saying earlier today in his testimony to Congress about how corporations are collecting data that they shouldn't even want to have. They should collect only the hash from your phone, not the picture. The hashing should be done locally to your device.