10 ms·
What I'm Telling US Congress about Data Breaches
- thisisit 9y agoIn case someone is wondering, the previous post - "I'm Testifying to Congress about Data Breaches – What Should I Say? " was discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15751344 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15751344 Some of the replies really touch upon what can go wrong with government regulation. That said, I do really want something done about this: > An attitude of “data maximisation” is causing services to request extensive personal information well beyond the scope of what is needed to provide that service Stop collecting information which is not required. Most of this information ends up in some form of advertisers/advertisement in guise of creating "more engagement with users".
- ashark 9y agoIMO there should be expensive data breach bond/insurance requirements for any company storing data about people, scaled by how much and possibly which kinds of data are stored. Discourage holding a bunch of stuff "just in case". And FFS, at least outlaw the required arbitration BS for data breaches. Let the bond or insurer pay out when it happens, then jack up their prices on the breached company until they cry.
- pc86 9y agoBy "until they cry" I assume you mean "until they can no longer continue passing the costs directly to the consumer, at which point they simply go into bankruptcy and reincorporate 6 months later at the lower insurance rate?"
- ashark 9y ago1) if they have competitors, they can't do much "passing along to consumers" to begin with, and 2) I thought insurance companies were supposed to be really good at assessing risk, and markets are magically efficient and all that, so shouldn't the better insurers unravel such schemes? Plus it's not like losing, you know, brand recognition and such is nothing. Point is it should hurt a lot to leak personal data, and it's this or directly regulate (this sort of thing used to be the right-wing way of doing things, but now doing anything at all about these problems, no matter the mechanism, is "left", at least in the US—see also health care)
- abakker 9y agoIf the data you hold as a business is so valuable that the insurable risk of loss is too expensive for your business, then ask, "do we really need to hold that data?" If your business needs to pass that on to consumers because you can't afford the hit to your margins, then consumers need to ask, "is [service/product] really worth that much to me?" The downside is that the most critical components of information which tie to identity itself, are the ones that businesses most commonly need to hold to verify identity. More challenging is that without a way to modify identity data (i.e. change your SSN), the insurable risk is huge because it needs to include a discounted cost of identity monitoring forever, and the cost of the individual losses that someone might encounter for the loss of that data. Then of course, if a person's identity is compromised more than once, how do you discount the responsibility across multiple careless parties? IMO it all comes down to never using immutable information (Name, DOB, etc) to firmly define identity online. That information should be for display purposes only. At the backend, we need an identity that is tolerant of change, and can easily be updated if it is ever lost. In reality this will probably mean that instead of an ID, we have ID probability, which would include photos, addresses, ID numbers, Credit card account access, and companies that needed to verify it would be able to evaluate how certain they were the identity was real, and to insure against mishandling of the individual components of information.
- ashark 9y ago> The downside is that the most critical components of information which tie to identity itself, are the ones that businesses most commonly need to hold to verify identity. More challenging is that without a way to modify identity data (i.e. change your SSN), the insurable risk is huge because it needs to include a discounted cost of identity monitoring forever, and the cost of the individual losses that someone might encounter for the loss of that data. Then of course, if a person's identity is compromised more than once, how do you discount the responsibility across multiple careless parties? If it gets expensive enough, maybe banks and CC companies and such will finally get off their asses and fix the whole "identity theft" issue. That's a feature, not a bug. I think the US is too allergic to anything with even a whiff of "secure national ID" for us to let the government fix it, so this is the next best (or, better, depending on your perspective) option. I frankly don't care how we do it, but it's really stupid this is still a thing people have to worry about, and making it cheaper for the banks to fix it than not to fix it seems like the most politically viable solution.
- curun1r 9y agoOne would hope that insurers would start proactively setting the rates for their policies based on several factors and not just in response to breaches and payouts. For instance, an insurers exposure would be greatly affected by the types of information collected, so they could offer a lower costs to a business that was only collecting email addresses than to one that collected many more types of PII. You'd also hope that insurers would start to give preferential rates to companies that complete (and resolve) periodic security audits from trusted auditors. The benefits of insurers getting involved is that they can de facto mandate these kinds of security audits and practices by making insurance policies unaffordable without them. And, unlike government regulation, the requirements from insurers can evolve rapidly over time in a way that's difficult for laws to evolve. Insurers will hire security experts to advise on best practices and each have their own ideas of what security means. If a business finds a single security practice onerous, they can shop for an insurer that doesn't require it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sbov 9y agoWhat data about people would apply? What about public records? Note that if you own property, your name and address are already public.
- syshum 9y ago"Public Records" is part of the maximization problem The Government is more guilty than any business on collecting, hoarding, and making public all kinds of personal information about you. If the government wants to curb data breaches it needs to start cleaning its own house. 90% of "public data" should not be public at all
- loeg 9y agoThe information has already been collected and breached, or will be breached eventually. Data minimalism isn't going to put the horse back in the barn, so to speak. (It may help anyone too young to have a credit card, and younger generations.) So we need to do something about identification not relying on knowledge factors for everyone currently over 16.
- glitcher 9y agoWhile he presents a great overview of all the problems with static knowledge based authentication, I get the feeling that the very fact that this hearing was called for implies there is already a strong consensus that the current status quo is a big problem. To me it falls a bit short because he primarily elaborates on the details of the problem without offering any suggestions on how to move forward towards a solution. I mean, the details may help understanding which could inform improved policy, but these politicians also need guidance on what actions to consider.
- mtgx 9y agoIndeed, and if impartial security experts won't offer them, the politicians will have to rely on corporate lobbyists to write their own rules and penalties affecting those companies.
- kbenson 9y agoI believe the scope of what he was asked to address might not have included suggested solutions, beyond the obvious "don't suggest all the stuff I'm saying is causing a problem." He does specifically go out of his way to say, in bold and isolated text, Do keep in mind that the context here is the impact on identity verification in "a post-breach world".
- bklaasen 9y agoFrom the article: "I've had some great suggestions around tackling the root cause of data breaches and I'd love to have another opportunity in the future to talk about that, but it goes beyond the specific focus of this hearing. That said, who knows what I'll be asked by congressmen and congresswomen on the day and they may well question what can be done to combat the alarming rise in these incidents. I've now got a lot of great references on hand to go to should that happen so once again, thank you!"
- WhoBeI 9y agoNo, they need facts, the willingness to learn and the courage to think for themselves. "Guidance" is just another way of saying "my way".
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoI don't mean to sound cynical (as in, this is a genuine question) but do these hearings amount to anything more than political grandstanding so that the relevant Congresspersons can claim to have been 'tough' on whatever topic was discussed?
- advisedwang 9y agoHearings like this are part of the process towards actual action, and if the process continues, then it's not grandstanding. However if they do hearings and no more, it's worthless. We can't tell from the hearings themselves whether they will lead to action... which is why it's such effective way to grandstand!
- cmurf 9y agoIt depends very much on the particular Congresscritter in question.
- komali2 9y agoHard to say in 2017 :/ I'm of the opinion that the US is irretrievably lost in the hole of plutocracy / oligarchy. Recall during the election Donald Trump bragging he can buy politicians [1]. I'm finding "hero politicians" to be less and less common, and dare they raise their head, the establishment usually does everything in their power to mow the lawn. See - Bernie Sanders, alongside a couple other rare US Federal politicans, an actual good egg that appears to not be bought and paid for by corporate lobbyists. There's lots of people trying to paint in black in white how obvious it is you can pay a politician to pass laws to protect you - we can go on for hours about Big Telecom minging about in local jurisdictions to prevent new providers, Big Oil essentially preventing a nuclear revolution in the USA, etc, but this site[2] paints a pretty clear picture in my opinion: Given that a corporation is expected to generate profit on dollars spent, why would BlueCross BlueShield and UnitedHealthcare be dumping money onto politicians? What reason could there possibly be other than to protect their profits? I dunno man, other people are better than espousing the problem of money in politics than me, I just am cynical as hell after seeing time and time again obviously anti-WeThePeople votes bought for mere thousands. So, to answer your question, in my un-professional opinion, the reason these hearings are good is they can inform the media and general public. They can get something on the record. We still reference hearings from decades ago - and can use that to apply pressure. "Senator, weren't you in x hearing, why then did you not do anything about y?" It can also inform the select few Hero politicians who can actually do good work for us with this new information - they're busy as fuck and this is one hell of a way to get data to them. Ancillaries include giving new ammunition to Word Wars - various politicians can use buzzlines from the hearing to further their own goal, which might help us, might not, god only knows. So my opinion, I'm glad these happen, but I think afterwards it'd be cool if people like Troy Hunt used their position to drum up donations to buy a couple of the politicians in the hearing, or at the very least throw more money at Twitter so that the Comcast and BroadBandForAmerica lobbyist propaganda promoted tweets can be buried under pro-WeThePeople material. [1](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-bragged-that-his-money-bought-off-politicians-just-not-this-time/2016/09/07/00a9d1e4-750b-11e6-be4f-3f42f2e5a49e_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-bragged-that-h...) [2](https://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/issuesum.php?id=HCR&year=2017 https://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/issuesum.php?id=HCR&year=2...)
- rrggrr 9y agoNice overview, but more importantly, what will Troy say when members ask him for solutions. Notably absent are details on whom to hold accountable, how to hold them accountable, and what penalties should be in-place.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI hope they won't use the hearing for blaming foreign adversaries that need to be fought with offensive capabilities. It should be made clear that the problems are homegrown.
- GrinningFool 9y agoSomething I would have liked to see - but perhaps this letter wasn't the right place. Let's talk about how the ubiquitous use of SSN and credit reports puts a massively unfair burden on every US citizen. Right now, it's all on me. I need to safeguard everything related to my government-issued nine digit ID that I never asked for - yet is somehow accepted as my financial identity, well beyond its intended scope. If I fail to do so, or if I fail to aggressively identify fraudulent use of it by monitoring reports from 3-4 different agencies, it's on me. It's my credit that's screwed. It's hard to emphasize enough how unreasonable that is. This isn't a house or other peace of real property that's in my control - it's 4 bytes of data that is assigned to me, but that I fundamentally have no control over. In spite of that, I am accountable for any and all uses of that data. It's hours of my life each time a breach occurs - more if it's actually misused. The assumption of 'bad credit risk unless and until you convince the reporting agencies that fraud has happened' is a fundamentally flawed one. I can't opt out. I can only keep spending my time and money to play the game - because it's the only one in town.
- jaredandrews 9y agoIndeed! I have recently been trying to come up with a new term to use instead of "identity theft" (open to suggestions). As the term itself seems almost Orwellian to me. My identity wasn't stolen! You gave a loan/credit card/whatever to someone and didn't verify who they were. How is your organization not doing the proper work a "theft" of my identity? I'm not involved and I don't want to be!
- greenleafjacob 9y agoI’ve heard “bank fraud” used here.
- jacquesm 9y ago> identity theft Impersonation.
- dotancohen 9y agoNo, this implies that the victim is the end user, not the bank.
- FiveSquared 9y agoI have a amazing idea. Why not let the companies be liable for their own data breaches. Wow, what an amazing idea! /s
- jacquesm 9y agoThe EU is well underway to establishing this. What would be even better is to move the lack of reporting of a breach to the criminal branch of the law.
- syshum 9y agoLiable how? And to what extent, the idea "let the companies be liable for their own data breaches." sounds good until you think about for more than 10 seconds. Identity Fraud is not normally carried out using just 1 breach, so it is several breaches combined that give a criminal what they need to commit full Identity fraud. Credit Card Fraud can almost never be traced back to a single breach. Are you holding the company that collected the data, or the company that the data was stolen from liable, often times these are not the same entities. I can probably come up with about 1000 other things to bring up in relation to "let the companies be liable for their own data breaches."
- cabaalis 9y agoI hope some good comes from this testimony. I help run a product that works with a tremendous amount of data. I welcome additional accountability as well as the security that would come from knowing that any regulatory requirements are properly met. On a second note, will this be the historic first time anyone says the word "Pwned" before congress?
- ndesaulniers 9y agoVery cool to see Troy use my suggestion: from https://www.troyhunt.com/im-testifying-in-front-of-congress-in-washington-dc-about-data-breaches-what-should-i-say/ https://www.troyhunt.com/im-testifying-in-front-of-congress-...: "Troy, to your point "Data breaches can take years to discover," I think it's helpful to put in layman's terms that breaches are closer to making photocopies where there are now two people in possession rather than a theft where the owner is deprived of access. How do you detect that a document has been photocopied?" In the final (this link): "However, unlike a physical commodity, the trading of data breaches replicates the asset as each party retains their original version, just like making a perfectly reproduced photocopy." :) To expand on my point and > We Often Don’t Know Until Years Later You notice someone's stolen physical property from you, because you are deprived of it. You don't notice someone's stolen digital property from you, because now there are more copies of it. (maybe "stolen" and "property" aren't the correct terms to use for digital assets?)
- severine 9y ago> maybe "stolen" and "property" aren't the correct terms to use for digital assets? Indeed. See, for example, https://www.stallman.org/articles/ft-response.html https://www.stallman.org/articles/ft-response.html
- dragonwriter 9y ago> (maybe "stolen" and "property" aren't the correct terms to use for digital assets?) Stolen is rarely the right word (that is, it's possible to steal digital assets, notably if also stealing the physical medium on which they are stored, but usually the term is used in only a loosely figurative sense), but “property” is often correct; there are all kinds of nonphysical property that share important features with physical property, and there are equally important distinctions within classes of tangible property as between tangible and intangible property.
- dstroot 9y agoTroy: HUGE kudos for how you managed such an open and transparent process. Don’t recall any other examples of such inclusiveness and openness for a senate testimony. Bruce Schnier did a good job sharing his testimony after the fact but you went all in.
- sova 9y agoI'm glad you hit the main points, but you did not offer any solutions, and I think partial encryption is one that is really important to lay out. Our social security numbers and valued information (that cannot be changed, like where you were born) need to be encrypted all the time, not just when convenient.
- Nomentatus 9y agoEncryption is good. Even better, for credit cards, use reference numbers from the CC company instead that identify an individual account (to the CC company) but aren't the number can't be used for obtaining credit, just discussing the account. Encryption fine, but better not to store volatiles at all if you don't have to.
- loeg 9y agoEncryption doesn't really help when 1/3 of Americans' SSNs have been publicized already. It's shutting the barn doors after the horses are long gone. SSN needs to be at most a username, rather than a credential.
- sova 9y agoTrue, but whatever supplants SSNs must be safeguarded via partial encryption.
- feelin_googley 9y ago"4. An attitude of "data maximisation" is causing services to request extensive personal information well beyond the scope of what is needed to provide that service. That data is usually then retained for perpetuity thus adding to an individual's overall risk." And HIBP is an example of this attitude because it collects data dumps and then (at least) collects and retains user-submitted email addresses and a record of presence/absence of such "live" email addresses in the data dumps. This is beyond the scope of what is needed to provide the service, namely, copies of the data dumps available for download. The user need not share their search terms with any third party, such as HIBP. A means to search these dumps locally (offline) without sharing the searches with third parties such as HIBP exists. "Online tools" are vectors for gathering the sort of data that is later the subject of "data breaches". Offline tools do not suffer from this problem. "6. Data breaches are redistributed extensively. There's an active trading scene exchanging data both for monetary gain and simply as a hobby; people collect (and thus replicate) breaches." HIBP is collecting and thus replicating data breaches for "monetary gain" or "simply as a hobby"? Or is it something else? As above, HIBP does not provide users with the data dumps they need to check them locally (offline) without submitting contributing more data to third parties in the process (e.g., working email addresses, associated search terms, associated originating IPs, etc.). Further, users are not provided with transparency into what HIBP is doing i.e., what it is storing and how and where it is stored. Users cannot evaluate the security practices of HIBP as yet another online repository of sensitive user data that by virtue of its existence could be a target. In summary, what he is not telling US Congress is that 1. "online services" or so-called "online tools", HIBP being one, are a major part of the problem and 2. there are alternative solutions, i.e., offline service and offline tools, and what HIBP provides is an excellent example of where an online service is unnecessary and is collecting large amounts of user data, unnecessarily. Addendum: "What I'm telling you" is that I believe the problem is data collection. Any "solution" which collects data, and in this case data it is not supposed to have (e.g., a data breach), then collects more data (e.g., metadata) from users and finally asks users to trust the "new collector" is not a solution, IMO. Especially where the new collector shares no technical details about his operation (e.g. storage of user data). This practice ignores simple, obvious solutions to the problem of data collection, such as performance of tasks offline which if performed online would likely lead to the collection of user data. It reinforces the mindset that perpetuates the problem: that data collection and trusting third parties is always necessary.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoIt is unfortunate that he uses "date of birth" and "home address" as exemplars of information that is "of no use to the service." That is because these two pieces of information are most frequently used to establish that the user is of the age of majority (an adult) and under which set of licensing regimes is the product operating. Both of which may be critical to the function of the service. Much better examples would be "Gender" and "telephone number". I completely agree with the notion that data maximization (or aggregation of meta data associated with a unique ID) are the roots of many evils and risks.
- dingoonline 9y agoThe data doesn't need to be kept though. It can be requested, checked, verified and erased.
- astura 9y agoUnless there are compliance audits.
- PeterisP 9y agoVerifying jurisdiction doesn't require you to know the whole address, just the country code and possibly the state. Verifying if someone is legally an adult doesn't require you to know the exact age and definitely not the birthday, simply "yes" would be sufficient.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI don't disagree with your analysis, however I have been informed that there are reasons for asking things this way. At a class for booth volunteers for selling alcohol for example we were told to ask for someone's birthday rather than their age. The reasoning in that training was that someone could quickly lie about their age but they had to work at it to back compute a birth date that would fall within the range of legal drinking age and not be ridiculous for someone of their apparent youth. I am not saying that this is a reason that everyone uses for asking these questions obliquely. I am simply sharing a situation for which I was explicitly told that was the reasoning behind asking the question in that way.
- cdevs 9y agoClear and to the point, hopefully sparks conversations about how to fix these issues moving forward.
- btilly 9y agoI'm replying in the hope that Troy Hunt reads it, because I am commenting too late for conversation to happen. This presentation involves a lot of complex terminology from the get go. This keeps it from engaging people's logical brains, and means that you are too easy to ignore. Our first pass at analyzing people is to figure out whether they can be safely ignored. This response is well before rational thought, and the part of our brain that decides it is unable to handle complex language. It doesn't matter how right you are, you are literally not heard. You can't fix the document. But you'll be talking in person to lawmakers. You can address the challenge there. Don't open with something like, Data breaches occur via a variety of different “vectors” including malicious activity by attackers exploiting vulnerabilities, misconfiguration on behalf of system owners and software products intentionally exposing data by design. Open with something like, Anyone can steal your identity. Your wife's as well. My site shows you some of the security breaches that criminals can use to pretend to be you. Nobody knows how many more are out there. Make it simple and straightforward. Make the threat personal. This requires their full attention to figure out what you are saying. That makes their logical brains connect. Good luck. You have an important message and I really hope that they hear you.