3 ms·
The problem is the bar has been way too high until now. “He’s important/beloved/whatever, he wouldn’t do that. It’s just your word against his”. And a lot of m
by MBCook 9y ago
The problem is the bar has been way too high until now. “He’s important/beloved/whatever, he wouldn’t do that. It’s just your word against his”.
And a lot of men escaped a LOT of charges because of that.
I think we’re still pretty far from the pendulum going too extreme. We’ll have to figure out the balance.
But what’s happening right now still seems pretty healthy. The fact that so many stories can be found so easily and corroborated shows what has been waiting in the wings.
- gkya 9y agoIt's not acceptable to punish today's men for what men of past got away with. That's vendetta, blood feud, primitive. What I watch happening is lots of decisions happening based on nothing. That all or most the particular men accused at the moment are actually guilty is of no interest to me. But the way we decide on anecdotes and stories is. When we decide before the courts, we commit irreversible damage. If we say once Joe Person is a molester or a rapist or a paedophile, and then he's proven innocent, it's basically impossible to find every single person who has read the wrong accusations and convince them otherwise. Also, it's not only the bar that is lowering, the definition of what's normal advances and what's molesting is changing. In not so distant past invasive behaviour of men were even expected in some circumstances. Good that we do away with these problematic behaviours and protect people from unwanted experiences, but that in no way legitimises leaving people defenceless in front of slander.
- MBCook 9y agoWere not punishing today’s men for what yesterday’s men did. We’re punishing today’s men for what today’s men were still doing. And what yesterday’s men continued to do into today.
- gkya 9y agoThe punishment is happening before the punished is deemed guilty.
- MBCook 9y agoThere is no LEGAL punishment happening. It’s all social. People can behave how they wish, rightly or wrongly. There isn’t much of a way of stopping at. You could always try suing for libel/slander but even if you win everyone’s going to remember the lie. A big part of the problem is there are so many people with a lot of credibility making these accusations.
- gkya 9y agoFirst of all I'm not questioning the present accusations. I don't even follow them that closely, to be honest. And, I was talking about the social punishment anyways. People can behave how they wish, but that does not mean they should be pushed in a wrong direction by the media and by the accusations before there's a court decision or very strong evidence (like a cam recording, a photo, etc.). It seems to me that you're trying to not understand me, so, my participation in this thread ends here.
- MBCook 9y agoI understand what you’re saying. I simply don’t see another way. I get you’re concerned that if someone were to be given an accusation they could lose their career and then we could find out later that it was all fake. Nothing legal went down, society simply decided to shun them. Outside of making it illegal to publish any kind of accusation in less it has been proven in a court of law… I don’t see how we could avoid people deciding to shun the accused. And maybe that’s fair given the number of women who have had their career is ruined because they chose not to work day in and day out with someone who harassed and/or raped them. Who had to leave the workforce instead, or take another job and start at the bottom of the ladder again. There’s no good solutions to ANY of this. It’s a giant mess. We’ll just have to see how it society sorts it out. In the end the long victimized group has gotten some temporary power. That seems like a step forward even if it raises the possibility of false accusations a small amount.
- s73ver_ 9y ago"It's not acceptable to punish today's men for what men of past got away with. " The only men who are being punished are those who actually engaged in that behavior. I dare say that it is acceptable to punish them. "But the way we decide on anecdotes and stories is." We're not; and we're not actually sending anyone to jail based on just that. The accusations that have been publicized have been vetted, and they have been found to be quite likely true. Keep in mind that, for most of these accusations, there wouldn't be much, if any physical evidence. If I force a woman to kiss me, or grope without consent, there's not going to be any evidence of that. If I ask a woman if I can masturbate in front of her, it's highly unlikely that there would be a recording, or that she would take my semen with her. "Also, it's not only the bar that is lowering, the definition of what's normal advances and what's molesting is changing." No. What's changing is that people feel stronger and more able to stand up for themselves and come out with what happened. The behavior was never really acceptable; it's that women didn't feel strong enough to come forward and say that.
- gkya 9y agoFirst of all, punishment is two-fold: the formal punishment the court orders; and the informal one: how the community receives you after what you've done is known. I'm mostly concerned about the second. Maybe I'm not being successful at making that obvious. How a court decides is out of the scope of my argument. How the public decides is. And what I say is that ideally the precautions should be taken so that the court is first to decide. On the last paragraph, I do agree you, and don't see why it should negate my statement that you've quoted. I'm on my twenties, so maybe I don't know enough, but how people flirt is definitely changing, and what is acceptable does also change too (interpreting "acceptable" not as "moral" but as "not frowned upon").
- MBCook 9y agoSomething to ensure that courts were the first to decide would, in the current situation, only benefit the perpetrators. Does a very long history of courts not being willing to take this seriously or listen to the evidence, or problems with short statute of limitations meaning that it’s very hard to get a conviction if a woman waited before making an accusation. In abstract I think it’s a understandable/useful concept but in this particular situation I think it would only benefit the side that needs help the least (due to historical factors/biases).
- jrumbut 9y agoI hate to get into this topic on the internet, but I think you're exactly right MBCook. This has been horrifyingly common and we are still a long way from justice. Stories like this show the dedication that has gone into avoiding a "witch hunt" scenario (maybe even at the expense of victims without strong corroborating evidence). There's just so much low hanging (and very rotten) fruit.
- belorn 9y agoDefine the bar then, and make it a law. The beauty of laws is that they must be general and not arbitrary enforced. If create a law with a lower bar then society will also have to accept the addition abuse, and that is what society should look at when figuring out the balance. The bar right now is extrajudicial punishment through trial by media that get arbitrary enforced by which ever journalist that decide if a story is believable or not. In this case the journalist of WaPo made the right judgment call, but is that the role of journalists in 2017? Extrajudicial punishment is not a viable solution to social problems, and has a very long history of causing harm to individuals and society. Today its a rule rather than exception that the accused get death threats based on this kind of news articles, including targeting of the accused family and children. That is how far the pendulum has swung. I would last add that here in Sweden there is two crimes that have very similar clearing rates. Sexual violence and violence. Taken together everything from sexual harassment to rape has a total of 11% clearing rate. Similar, everything from assault to murder have a total rate of 11%. For both, the primary reason for police to stop investigating and prosecutor to not bring the case to court is a lack of evidence that is not word against word.
- MBCook 9y agoWe have laws. The bar is defined. Part of the problem is that people wouldn’t prosecute even if you met the standard of evidence. Another problem is that there are statutes of limitations, often quite short. So many people who were assaulted have no other recourse than the media to try to protect other future victims. What should happen instead? They got away with it past the statute of limitations so no one is allowed to bring it up or criticize them? No one is allowed to decide how they will behave towards the abuser now that they know the information because a court didn’t convict them? What would you solution be?
- belorn 9y agoHere in Sweden there is a dedicated prosecutor unit that only deal with sexual violence and the law is designed in such a way that sexual violence are state crime, which mean that the state must prosecute even if the victim rescind their version of events. The cause of the 11% clearing rate is not that cases met the standard of evidence and prosecutors just refuse to go after crimes of violence or sexual violence. A typical sexual assault case involve two individuals that are alone in a room. The accused says there was consent, the accuser says there wasn't. Similarly a typical assault case involve two individuals alone in a room where both accuse the other of being the aggressor. In both cases the accuser and accused know each other. What should happen in those 90%? Lets make a law. What about a national news paper which get delivered to every person in the nation for free that describe every case from the point of view of the accuser of every crime that don't get cleared? Would that protect other future victims? Would it help giving every potential victim the same privilege of trial by media, or would it just create further problems for society?