23 ms·
Laptops Are Great, But Not During a Lecture or a Meeting
- cjsuk 9y agoI will sit there in a meeting (or retrospectively in a university lecture) and regularly derive nothing of value at all from my notes, be they written or typed. It's the media that is wrong, not the note taking medium. You can't rewind a meeting or a lecture. You can't pause to think. You can't review the text in the middle. Everything is immediate, transient. If you lose the pace, then everything after that point is wasted. Lectures and meetings are broken, not the notes. Now I will tend to write up my own notes in my own time on matters (in Pages for lack of any motivation to try anything else).
- austincheney 9y agoSounds like ADHD.
- bebe3000 9y agoOr a too hard course. Or a bad lecturer. Or you skipped the previous lecture and it's all gibberish again.
- cjsuk 9y agoHard course (electrical engineering, laplace fun!), shit lecturer (complacent, dismissive of questions), skipped lecture (never although I probably should have just stuck my face in the course books).
- cholantesh 9y agoDo Laplace Transforms get very difficult? I'm taking a course right now that teaches Differential and Integral Calculus, followed by Differential Equations and Laplace Transforms. Laplace Transforms have, so far, been the least challenging portion of the course.
- cjsuk 9y agoIf you get them crammed into one hour then yes. In your own time they are quite easy. I required a bit of tutor support if I'm honest but if you can get over the basic calculus hill you will be fine. There's a lot more material out there to support you than there was in the mid-1990s! No having to fight for the last copy of referenced text in the university library either. I have literally never used anything I learned on that part of the course however.
- cholantesh 9y agoI found integration to be nothing short of brutal, personally. Laplace has been taught over 3 weeks and has been fairly pleasant - pure algebra. I'm doing this course as part of the requirements for a degree in Eng. Technology, focusing on Software. It's common to all streams, but none of the subsequent courses Software students have to take will use this material. Damned if it isn't fun though.
- hashkb 9y agoNote taking exists to combat what you're talking about. You can improve your note taking, and how you use your notes, on paper or on a device.
- Joe-Z 9y agoAlso I'd say you _can_ pause a lecture. Simply lift up your hand and ask a question: That's the great thing about person-to-person teaching. Painting all lectures and meetings as 'broken' because one would prefer to have video for everything (that's how I understood it) is pretty hyperbolic.
- cjsuk 9y agoI don't want a video. I want the material written down in a formal tutorial style that can be reviewed and updated and consumed at a suitable pace. That pace can be faster for the bits I understand and slower for the bits I don't.
- mseebach 9y agoThat's basically a textbook, and lectures are supposed to augment the book, not replace it. From personal experience, and anecdotal supporting evidence, lectures are the hardest when you haven't actually prepared for them (at the other end of the scale are the lectures you did prepare for, but enough others did, and the lecturer decides to indulge them by re-stating what's already covered in the book instead of, well, lecturing).
- cjsuk 9y agoYes and no. The textbooks we were given were reference structured. Ergo the path through them was defined by the lectures and the course which was mostly undocumented. There needs to be a course guide that spans the entire material with independent guidance. A good modern example of this is The Art of Electronics which is a textbook format. There is a companion book which is Learning the Art of Electronics which contains exactly the structure I want to see, which is your lectures, tutorials and labs in a structured format on paper. You can complete these with guidance, without guidance, with or without lectures and tutorials. The lectures should be more interactive and be a result of the above. Build your knowledge on more than one pillar and some structure so to speak. Some of the course ecosystems you see are very closed with respect to structure and you are carried through without being permitted to see the path.
- lvoudour 9y agoAgree 100%. I went to college before tablets and affordable laptops became ubiquitous, but the same problem applied to handwritten notes. After a few tries to keep notes and re-read them at my leisure I gave up, it was exhausting to take them and in the end I was missing too much. The best solution is audio/video recording. I think every lecturer can record their lectures and publish them online later in the college's database or wherever. Cheap, easy and you don't have to worry about taking notes and missing anything
- afarrell 9y ago> publish them online later Note that you also need to have someone add captions to them for accessibility.
- cjsuk 9y agoTo clarify, I too was before the time of laptops and recording technology being available. MiniDiscs had just come on the scene then and the notes are worth nothing without what appears on the OHP and the contextual timing of them. Video recording was impossible. Really every lecture should be recorded and links handed out to students. A big killer is that the lecturer has been doing the same lecture for 20 odd years and is complacent or prefers to defer feedback to the end. Everyone is lost then. Same with meetings. Questions at the end? Context gone!
- dmartinez 9y agoI wonder if the answer to meetings is making participation more meaningful? In some MBA programs, the purpose of the class is the discussion of some case that everyone has read. In this way, you get more out of participation by listening to other people’s thoughts and combining them with yours. There is also a strong case to be made for the “radical transparency” that has made Bridgewater so successful [0]. This system has the capacity to accelerate learning if it were implemented more widely. [0] https://www.ted.com/talks/ray_dalio_how_to_build_a_company_where_the_best_ideas_win#t-546470 https://www.ted.com/talks/ray_dalio_how_to_build_a_company_w...
- chrisper 9y agoWhen I was in college I preferred laptops for this reason. I can type way faster than I can write by hand. So it was way easier to keep up and write everything down. I read my notes on some other day to learn, but during the lecture it was all about writing down enough to be able to recall the lecture from my notes on some later day.
- ptero 9y agoPeople learn in different ways and my experience is completely different: note taking, on paper, was critical for me to learn. Whether it is a differential geometry lecture (in college) or a test planning meeting having written notes is very important for me -- it allows me to think through the topics again at leisure. The most important thing for me is to keep note taking at the "high secondary" importance level: not preempt thinking or participation in real time but high enough to ensure writing at least a couple of words or a quick diagram for each main topic. Break either and note taking starts to be a problem and not a help. Just my 2c, YMMV.
- dkarl 9y agoIn school, I never got anything out of looking at my notes, but I had much better retention when I took notes. Now I take a lot of notes and actually use them, because I take down tons of information that isn't very interesting and can't be learned by connecting it to a conceptual framework but which I will definitely need later.
- coding123 9y agoSame here, I would write down everything I heard and everything I understood, and I would draw arrows connecting concepts. A given lecture would probably fill up like 5 pages back and front in a notebook. I rarely actually read the notes - everything got retained simply by writing them in the first place.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoPeople learn in different ways is the answer. Different people have different ways of cementing understanding in their heads. My ideal form is to record the meeting, and then later review it and write notes.
- Griffinsauce 9y agoIdeal for learning yes but very time consuming. Do you feel it's worth it in that way?
- Dave_TRS 9y agoCompletely agree. One time I faced a laptop ban and purchased a tiny tripod to take steady pictures in dim light of what the professor was writing on the board. For many of us it's mentally taxing to write with pen and paper what the professor is saying, banning technology is not the best way to get students to learn.
- kurthr 9y agoAs far as I understand meetings (and lectures) are to derive consensus. Slides are regularly available before meetings while reading is normally required before lectures. Lecture presentation is not the time for the details of complex unfamiliar derivations, but for familiar motivation of larger goals and big questions. If you feel the need to take notes of every point rather than summarising the most salient/important concepts, or recording your questions/disagreements, someone is doing it wrong. At a lecture communication should be about conclusions, possibly single critical details, but not the entire texture and flow of every detail. If the material is so unfamiliar and surprising that you don't understand and can't ask relevant questions, I would say it's a failure of the speaker or yourself. Certainly, after a convincing talk, question, and answer, you should feel like you understand both the material and the motivation/goal better even without notes.
- bpyne 9y agoI'm of the same opinion. I realized in college that I can write or think about the material being presented, but I can't do them simultaneously. So, I stopped taking notes and relied much more on memory and text books. I'm still that way in the work world. My major was math. It would have been significantly better for my learning if we spent class time solving problems rather than watching the professor write out a proof, which was often enough already in the text. Active learning is really critical for me.
- shortoncash 9y agoWe are similar and I studied math as well. I solved this problem by just buying a friend coffee regularly in exchange for notes. She used to take fantastic notes and they were probably the reason I even excelled in a lot of classes. However, there was no substitute for being deeply engrossed in whatever the lecturer was saying. My only regret is not having figured this out sooner.
- sand500 9y agoSame for me. I could take notes but then I would just be blindly copying what was on the board.
- amorphid 9y agoThat's why lectures suck for me. I can't "listen fast enough", and I lost track of the lecture when I try to take notes. This is where something like Khan Academy is way awesome-r for my style of learning.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ska 9y agoLectures as part of course are designed to be attended after reviewing the material at least once on your own. That way you know what to look out for, and your notes will be a concise revision. Its astonishing how many students resist this fact, even when it is clearly spelled out for them. Trying to write down everything the lecturer says is at best inefficient, and at worst a complete waste of time when you lose the thread.
- distances 9y agoInteresting, I have never heard of this, and definitely none of my professors instructed me to familiarize with the material before a lecture. So I never did. I suppose this could've been a useful technique.
- ska 9y agoWhen I was teaching undergrads I always told them that a good minimum target was 3 hours of work for every 1 hour of lecture. Roughly one of those hours was to be spent on the lecture material beforehand. Think about it this way. If all you are doing is rushing to copy down what the lecturer says, you don't really hear it or have a chance to think about it. So you have to review anyway - if you spend that same time beforehand, you are ready with questions and already know what parts you are unsure of. With a short revision of your notes following also, you're in great shape.
- anotheryou 9y agoHow much lecture is there than? Here in germany 3 Seminars a day with 2h each are often the norm. That would mean 18h of prep and 6h of seminars a day.
- timthelion 9y agoI agree. While not a direct replacement for lectures, I've been prototyping an audio media which does not have these same disadvantages, called push to talk. You can find the prototype here: http://thobbs.cz/push-to-talk/index.html http://thobbs.cz/push-to-talk/index.html Click on the first track, and then use the arrow keys to move through the essay. Note that you can rewind, review, pause to think, just like with text. But it is speech.
- mtpn 9y agoThis seems awesome. I can’t get it to play from my phone but the concept is really really useful. I used to want to make something like this for audio-based exams for people with dyslexia, for example. In Ireland people with reading difficulties have a person sit with them and read the questions in a whole other room. It’s expensive compared to just having a group with headphones working through on computers.
- timthelion 9y agoI just tested it and it works with icecat mobile but not Androids default browser. Which browser are you using? Also, I haven't optimized for mobile with regards to "arrow keys" not being a thing on the cell phone. I'll probably have to add arrow buttons that are visible only on the cell phone or something. Perhaps a swipe...
- mtpn 9y agoI’m on chrome on iOS
- AlexCoventry 9y agoThe ability to stick your hand up and ask a question is orders of magnitude more valuable than a rewind button.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rockostrich 9y agoI don't think your points apply to lectures like they do to meetings, at least for me. Meetings are more collaborative and most of my recall during a meeting is due to participation. If I'm not participating at all then I will most likely forget everything that happened during the meeting. Lectures are different because I tend to use my notes as a way of interacting with the lecture (and usually you can't really interact much in a lecture unless it's a small class). Maybe it was my way of taking notes, but marking up lecture slides or essentially copying proofs/problems during an engineering or math lecture during my undergrad was most of my learning besides doing problem sets. Problem sets were very important, but they were only there to reinforce what I learned while taking my notes during the lecture. I ended up recalling much less whenever I didn't take notes and just tried to listen and participate as much as I could in the lecture.
- r00fus 9y ago> You can't rewind a meeting or a lecture. You can't pause to think. You can't review the text in the middle. I disagree about meetings. I often ask to repeat a pivotal discourse in a multi-party meeting simply to emphasize it's being understood by all participants. Also notes help to structure the meeting so you don't take 1hr to discuss 30m of content. I prefer to share my notes on screen (either as email minutes I'm taking or preferably something collaborative like Google Sheets). Notes, well used, can keep everyone on the same page. If the agenda is prepared in advance, it can turn a 1hr ramble-fest that achieves nothing into a concise 10m confirmation session.
- npsimons 9y ago> Lectures and meetings are broken, not the notes. For as long I can remember, I have had trouble staying awake in lectures, meetings and watching videos. It has nothing to do with the content, nothing to do with how 'engaging' it is. It has everything to do with passively sitting and attempting to consume data. Having a way to take notes and edit them in real-time increases my retention enormously. It's also incredibly useful to me as I can org-capture a TODO item to look up references (from which I learn very well) later. If I could have afforded access to a laptop in college and org-mode existed back then, I can't imagine how much more I would have retained, not to mention having greppable notes, as opposed to my paper notes that have vanished over the years. ETA: Lectures/meetings seem really inefficient and ineffective to me. It's a data stream you can't rewind, and if you wait for everyone to "get it", you'll never make any progress, and you can't pack enough information in to justify everyone being in the same place at the same time. Just record a video and make it really good (ala TED) or release your very well refined overview paper/slides with copious references.
- Spooky23 9y agoTry changing how you take notes. I felt the same way until I discovered mind mapping. Writing and linking concepts is almost like putting chapter markers in a video or flags on a page. It helps you recall what was said in what context.
- jimbokun 9y agoYou are not describing a meeting. Meetings should only invite people who will actively participate and provide their input. Anyone not meeting that description should not be invited. You are describing a lecture, or perhaps a presentation, or series of presentations. Which classically have all the problems you cite of losing the thread and not being able to catch up again. In meetings where you actively participate, give input, and ask questions, that shouldn't be a problem.
- mjevans 9y agoI hate the term "meeting" as that's merely a super-class of event. Technically a lecture is a meeting, a movie screening is a meeting, a concert is a meeting. I find things are more productive when there's an actual expectation about what people do when gathered. * brainstorming * problem identification (a type of brain storming) * solution identification (a type of brain storming) * Question and Answer* (I tend to not find these very productive) * Presentation (possibly of answers to submitted questions)
- Griffinsauce 9y agoYour point needs to be applied to your first option. Brainstorming is a method, meetings should not be defined by their method but by their goal (and preferably with a known method to reach that goal).
- Pyxl101 9y agoWhat's wrong with inviting people who wish to observe the input provided by others, and subsequent discussion?
- emodendroket 9y agoThe problem is more having people who don't really want to be there and won't pay attention, or having too many people sidetracking the discussion or making it difficult to reach consensus.
- jimbokun 9y ago
- emodendroket 9y agoThe value of taking notes is in my opinion less about going back to them (often I'll never look at them) and often more about the help in recall having to summarize the information is. Similarly, people remember books better if they go through highlighting stuff.
- greggman 9y agoI agree lectures are a waste of time. I'm imagining conferences when I think of this. While I enjoy seeing a good presentation live I've mostly realized I can just watch the recording later. Of course I want to meet others between presentations/lectures but the lectures themselves can be more easily consumed on youtube at 2x speed and more easily skipped if the first 5-10mins make it relatively clear it's unlikely to be a good lecture/presentation. A meeting on the other hand, actually discussing things, at least in my situations the notebook is required as reference for things in the discussions. If it's really just a lecture held in a meeting room (no discussion) then it seems like a waste of time. The original article seems to be about lectures at school. Wasn't Khan Academy kind of founded on the principle that lectures are bad schooling? IIRC the suggestion was that lecture material should be something watched at home and classroom time should be for getting help with the material.
- mk89 9y agoThat's what private lessons are for. If you really want something similar, record your lessons (with a phone or whatever) and listen to them as you wish - maybe transcribe them. It's tedious but worth it.
- betterunix2 9y agoI have long known this to be the case for myself, and switched back to pen and paper for taking notes. I also learned shorthand to reduce the amount of time and mental effort I spend on taking notes, though I sometimes revert to longhand when I need something to be more readable. It is also great for diagrams, math notation, etc. Touchscreens may someday get there, but so far I have found that even the best touchscreens/tablets (yes, even the iPad Pro) still wind up slowing me down.
- itronitron 9y agoif I am taking a course on a new unfamiliar subject I copy relevant material from the textbook into a handwritten journal before each lecture, which makes it much easier to pay attention to the teacher and catch all of their side comments (such as caveats on when to use various methods)
- regularfry 9y agoResearch on disfluency implies that you might be better off with longhand after all. Increasing the mental effort in taking the notes has a positive effect on how well people absorb material (subject to a few caveats).
- retrac98 9y agoTo be honest, I found lectures to be a complete waste of time at University, with or without a laptop. You could just download the lecturer's slides and speaker notes outside of class and learn the material ahead of exams/coursework. I managed to come near the top of my class this way with something like 5% attendance at lectures. I expect this isn't the case in the top Universities, but I left my University thinking I could have just paid to take the exams and self-taught the rest of the material. In hindsight, I was really taking out huge loans for a few years of drinking, socialising and playing video games. In the working world, I've found meetings to be similarly pointless. 95% of the time I'd rather hash out a problem on an email thread where thoughts are expressed clearly, re-read and understood by others in their own time.
- vturner 9y agoAgreed, I would on occasion skip class and read the text for an hour in grad school. It was amazing how much more I learned by reading and processing the ideas at my own pace instead of the lecture. The issue was you never knew when the professor would say something not in the text yet on the exam. I was in applied mathematics. Meetings are equally pointless. Usually the most verbal people dominate the meeting. I've noticed how outspoken one is rarely correlated with critical thinking ability.
- azernik 9y agoI found the discussion sections to be the real value proposition of university - after reading the lecture material, got to spend time with a grad student and ask questions about the material.
- cyphar 9y agoI found that the usefulness of lectures depends very strongly on how good the lecturer is, as well as the topic being discussed. When studying physics I found that the lectures were incredibly useful, because it's quite hard to get in the "zone" of understanding the derivation being discussed when at home. However, with mathematics subjects the textbook was almost always a much better learning tool, because the derivation did not require a discussion of the physics that justified said derivation. Computer Science lectures were almost unilaterally a waste of time.
- brndnmtthws 9y agoNY times makes an amazing discovery: being distracted from whatever it is you're trying to do isn't good for productivity. The idea of 'multitasking' is a foolish thing, and I think most people have discovered now that to be successful at any task you need to focus without distractions. Singletasking is much more productive than multitasking. I might even argue that multitasking isn't possible, since humans can't switch context as fast as computers.
- mikeokner 9y agoYeah this seems like a no-brainer for anyone who has had a laptop in front of them during a meeting or a lecture.
- txcwpalpha 9y agoAgreed that this seems to be a no-brainer. But then again, if you look at the responses in this thread, apparently it's not a no-brainer to some people. On the other hand, if you read the article in full, the debate isn't just about distractions and multi-tasking. Even when not being distracted, the use of a laptop to take notes is less effective than hand-writing notes. This is because laptops encourage a note-taking style where you don't necessarily need to actually process the information before typing it out: > The researchers hypothesized that, because students can type faster than they can write, the lecturer’s words flowed right to the students’ typing fingers without stopping in their brains for substantive processing. Students writing by hand had to process and condense the spoken material simply to enable their pens to keep up with the lecture. Indeed, the notes of the laptop users more closely resembled transcripts than lecture summaries. The handwritten versions were more succinct but included the salient issues discussed in the lecture. In another study[1], it was found that this happens even when students are warned against this "transcript" style of note-taking. It all very much depends on the person doing the note taking, the information being taught, and the person doing the speaking, but in general it appears that laptops encourage bad note-taking and bad listening habits that hand-writing notes don't. 1: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/next/body/taking-notes-by-hand-could-improve-memory-wt/ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/next/body/taking-notes-by-hand-...
- 9y ago
- codingdave 9y agoLaptops are tools that can be used to help you with your tasks, or to waste time. I'm sure the article is correct that many people use them poorly, but that doesn't mean banning the tool is the right answer. Maybe training better usage of them would be wise.
- melling 9y agoThis story was posted 5 times within the past 3 days (never by me). I was wondering why it never took off because it’s one of those HN stories. Anyway, Monday morning at 7am EST seemed to do the trick. For anyone wondering why their stories don’t initially gain traction, timing is important.
- cdancette 9y agoI think it's better to take notes with a pen and paper, because you need to summarize what you hear, and you can't just write everything. This helps a lot the learning process, because summarizing makes you understand better the content, and the relations between concepts
- rocqua 9y agoFor a very long time in university, I never took notes and suffered nothing for it. Near the end, the only exceptions were classes taught from very succinct paper material where a lot of supplementary examples were only treated in lectures and so complicated as not to be (easily) found on the internet. Beyond that I always got a much better return on paying more attention to the lecture, and trying to see how what is told fits with what I know rather than how to fit it into my notes.
- proginthebox 9y agoI am not sure about meetings since I do not have much experience with them. But if you do not want people to use laptops during lectures 1. Record your lectures and make them available later (course website, internal network anywhere). 2. Create PDF of your own notes and distribute them BEFORE lecture. 3. Ideally, though this is a huge amount of work, so not always possible, write down in detail the steps in your lecture like a book chapter and distibute this BEFORE lecture. Alternatively, assign a book chapter pre-reading. In short, if you want people to pay attention to the content during the lecture, remove the incentive to take notes during the lecture.
- xenophonf 9y agoI'm sick to death of old school instructors making me put my tablet PC away on the assumption that I lack self-control or won't pay attention or can't take good notes. The whole point of a device capable of drawing stuff is the synthesis of digital recording and writing/drawing. Dunno about anyone else but OneNote has made me a way better student as a result, plus it makes my logs and notes available (and shareable) in ways that no paper lab notebook can replicate. By all means let's encourage students to not simply take dictation during lectures, but let's also not simply throw away a great tool in the process.
- walshemj 9y agoActually laptops in a meetings can be useful as they can replace a lot of paper.
- walshemj 9y agoReally down voted ever worked in properly run organisations with proper procedures ISO 9000 or BS 7570? even more so in parliamentary based orgs having to lug around 4 or 5 ring binders of paper gets old quickly
- simion314 9y agoInteresting how many people prefer videos, my experience is that some professors are bad but the others are good, you can skip writing notes and just listen and later xerox the notes from others or get the book from the library. The advantages or the lectures is that you can ask questions, the professor gets feedback and provide more examples then needed, the professors will tell some interesting side story that you will remember it forever and it will help you remember the concepts. I am wondering if the people that hate lectures are more likely to have paid for the university studies so maybe they resent the entire institution and prefer learning from internet.
- markussss 9y agoI don't think taking notes is the most important part of learning from a lecture. For me, throughout the years, actively participating in lectures through asking questions or discussing the concept being talked about, either with the lecturer or the person I'm sitting beside. Compared to taking notes, this has lead to me gaining a deeper understanding than when writing or typing everything that is being said during the meeting or the lecture. Usually, the only things I write down in meetings and lectures are words or concepts I don't already understand so I can research those later, or specific tasks that I am going to do as a result of the meeting or lecture.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoI've never understood the thing about taking notes myself (mind you I never did any higher education); what is the lecture explaining that isn't in the textbook? The textbook should be all the notes and information you need, maybe supplemented with online; not keeping notes will allow you to focus on the lecture itself, which should be an extra on top of the book.
- txcwpalpha 9y agoThe actual act of taking the information and processing it into your own words, and then also the act of actually writing those words down, has been shown to improve memory retention and understanding of that information over what you would get from simply reading the same information in a textbook.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- LyndsySimon 9y agoI didn't get much value from notes until I started using fountain pens and focusing on my penmanship. Once I did, I had to slow down and take more concise notes to avoid falling behind, which in turn lead to my needing to actually understand what was being presented so I could write it in fewer words instead of just writing down key points verbatim.
- alchemism 9y agoI've found (full-sized) tablets to work out better in these environments than laptops. Both in terms of focused-usage as a information recording or reference/retrieval tool, and the favorable reception it gets from other participants when used for such purposes.
- Dave_TRS 9y agoMy experience is that the bad professors are almost always the ones to ban laptops. Students pay attention to engaging professors and use their laptops for notes, and those good professors aren't phased by the laptops and rarely ban them. But When students listen out of one ear and spend the rest of the class processing email, it's almost always an indication that the lecture is poor. That's what I've seen over and over in 7 years of post secondary classes. I don't know much about the professor in the article, but I would suspect improving his lectures will be more effective in helping students learn than banning laptops.
- valine 9y agoAgreed. It’s also an issue of time management. If I can find a YouTube video that explains a concept better in 5 minutes than the hour long lecture explains it, I would rather spend my time working during the lecture than taking notes.
- foldr 9y agoThen why go to the lecture? You don't want to be there, and the lecturer probably doesn't want you there either.
- nambit 9y agoMy university classes had mandatory attendance. If not for that, I would also attend only 5% of lectures like a commenter above. I find most of my learning happens through books on my own time.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoDisagree. I think it's confirmation bias. You don't notice when good professors deviate from the norm (e.g. banning laptops).
- ttlaxia 9y agoI took notes in college in org-mode on a little eeepc and graduated summa. Instead of banning laptops to cater to the least common denominator, why not just tell the kids not to surf the web during lectures? Have the TA sit in the back of the class or make a video recording from the back if it's a problem. It's hard not to imagine that the ones who surf the net on their laptops are the same ones who would be busy doodling in their notebooks otherwise. And I'm not too sure about the study they cite that claims that other people are distracted. The assumption seems to be that people using laptops are ipso facto on Youtube and Twitter all the time. And the questionnaires they gave the test subjects beforehand practically begged them to be distracted during the test.
- txcwpalpha 9y agoIt's not just about distractions. Laptops also encourage a note taking style where you simply are transcribing every word that the lecturer says. This is a less effective way to learn material, as you can go on "auto pilot" where the words flow from your ears to your fingers without you really having to synthesize any information or really understand it. Studies[1] have shown that this happens even when students are warned against doing this. Hand-writing notes, on the other hand, encourages you to process the information you are hearing and summarize it into your own words, improving understanding and memory of the information. Anecdotally, my entire school (the business school at UT Austin) banned laptops in all classrooms, and I think it was hugely beneficial to my understanding of the materials. In other, non-business classes that allowed laptops, I tended to have to spend a lot longer re-reading my notes and textbooks before I felt like I really understood the information. 1: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/next/body/taking-notes-by-hand-could-improve-memory-wt/ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/next/body/taking-notes-by-hand-...
- Communitivity 9y agoThe idea that we can't use laptops in meetings is outdated. You can do active listening while taking notes, as long as you practice good note-taking instead of verbatim transcription. I typically use a concept-mapping tool such as CMapTools from the great folks at the Institute for Human and Machine Cognition (IHMC) in Florida. That lets me capture the essential concepts from the meeting and the relations among those concepts.
- txcwpalpha 9y agoOne of the arguments against laptops is that even when people are aware of the fact that they shouldn't take verbatim transcriptions, they still tend to do so when using laptops. Hand-writing notes tends to make it almost impossible to write verbatim transcriptions, which forces active listening and processing the information as it comes in. It's very much a "YMMV" thing, as it's certainly possible to take great notes and listen well while using a laptop, but for the average person, laptops encourage bad meeting/lecture habits.
- pellanti 9y agoIn a digital age, where we should be recording lectures, we still talk about the merits of note taking (whatever medium) vs. learning. I agree the value is in the teaching itself and learning in the moment; however, I would still like to go back and access that lecture/class.
- djtriptych 9y agoI bought an iPad Pro 2 this september and it immediately replace my laptop for meetings. Light computing when I need it, but primarily a note-taking advice. Really great.
- criddell 9y agoWhat software do you use on the iPad? I also have one but have things scattered between Nebo, GoodNotes, Apple Notes, Bear, Pages, and Evernote. I really need to pick the best app and focus everything there, but each one has different strengths.
- djtriptych 9y agoyeah they're all kidna terrible. I started a roundup review but gave up due to costs of downloading each app. I've settled so far on Linea. It has plenty of problems but hit my key points. I was aiming for a paper-like experience to replace my favorite tools: a technical pen/pencil and a nice graph paper pad. - Use finger to erase (like a whiteboard). - Focus mode with no toolbars / chrome. - Good-looking graph paper background. - Technical pens and pencils. - Zoomable. All the apps have layers - that's table stakes. Linea does NOT allow you to make selections and move components individually. I think I might do better design work with a few technical restrictions.
- ontouchstart 9y agoI am reading the book "Sweating Bullets: Notes about Inventing PowerPoint (2012)" on the iPad https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15745202 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15745202 and it seems that PowerPoint kind of "solved” the first half of interactive classroom information exchange: presentation (output). Note taking (with laptop or tablet) can be think of as the second half of the problem (input). Perhaps we need to rethink the challenge of "realtime face-to-face group interactive information exchange" in a more integrated way and come up with more revolutionary solutions.
- k__ 9y agoI studied computer science while WoW was hyped. Many students sat in the back row and played it in the lectures.
- sandworm101 9y agoI always allowed laptops in my lectures. I encouraged the kids to google things and challenge me when they thought me wrong. If i was unsure of a fact id have them look it up. That back-and-forth kept them engaged, and made my life much easier. If your lecture isnt more interesting than facebook you have to up your game.
- dredmorbius 9y agoEducation isn't entertainment. That's not to say it cannot be entertaining, at times, but there's also a lot of POHW: plain old hard work.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI have such terrible attention problems that I have secretly recorded just about every class, meeting, and discussion in the last ten years. Legalities and ethics aside, afterward I'll listen and make detailed notes, then depending on the content, destroy or keep the audio. The legalities and ethics will always trouble me but without the audio I get very lost. The medium has never made a difference, nor the delivery method.
- Double_a_92 9y agoI don't remember needing to take notes for any lecture I've been in. Either the lecture was designed to take "notes", i.e. the prof would literally explain and write a nice recap on the board that he wanted us to copy. Or we got prints of the slides, where we could just add a few comments were needed. Or we just got a printed "textbook" that the prof wrote, and the lecture was just to get an overview and see which parts are important...
- nicebill8 9y agoI’m at university and often find myself ignoring the lecturer and reading through the slides in my own time, making my own notes. The only reason I show up is because the lecturers often give extra information they don’t put on the slides, so I always keep an ear open.
- ptman 9y agoIt's not the laptops that are the problem, it's the lectures. Check out flipped classroom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flipped_classroom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flipped_classroom - watch lectures/read a book/etc on your own time and attend problem solving with teachers / TAs available.
- wpietri 9y agoWow! Yes, this seems much better. The key opportunity of being all together in a room is interactivity. Large lectures mostly waste that: the time gap between having a question and getting it answered can be large. (E.g., having to wait until discussion section puts a gap of hours to days between the Q and the A.) But when I'm trying to apply the material, I'm not in passive listening mode. There, hopefully my feedback loop with the material is in the seconds-to-minutes range. If I'm stuck, being able to get a question answered can keep me in the zone of fast learning.
- Taylor_OD 9y agoIf I have my laptop or phone our during a meeting it's because I've either already had this meeting with whoever if giving out the information and don't need to pay full attention to it or I'm in a meeting that I shouldnt be in because I have nothing to add. I assume everyone else is the same way and It's a really easy way to tell who does and doesnt need to be in future meetings for me.
- btbuildem 9y ago> Students writing by hand had to process and condense the spoken material simply to enable their pens to keep up with the lecture. Indeed, the notes of the laptop users more closely resembled transcripts than lecture summaries. The handwritten versions were more succinct but included the salient issues discussed in the lecture. This seems to be the key point -- when taking notes by hand, you have to think about what you're hearing and writing down. In a way, you're translating the lecturer's language to your own, and that seems to help retain the information better.
- pacbard 9y agoThe other important finding is the "negative externality" of laptop use on other people that are not using it. Even if someone is taking notes on paper and the student next to him/her is using a computer, research has found negative impacts on both the student using the laptop and the student using paper (akin to second-hand smoke). I think that this is important from a policy prospective because students can make whatever choices for themselves, but the instructor should step in when those choices are impacting others' learning.
- SPBS 9y agoThere's no reason why one can't type notes the same way as well, first listening and understanding before distilling that information into a few choice sentences. I find writing better because you can freely draw on your lecture notes. The benefit is twofold: one, you don't have have to slavishly transcribe everything your professor says if it's already in the slides. Two, the mental overhead is very low as your thoughts go straight from pen to paper. If you type from scratch, you end having having to 'transcribe'. If you annotate the slides on your laptop, you have to deal with the high overhead of textbox and geometric shape manipulation with a keyboard and trackpad. If my lectures didn't have so much diagrams or equations(unlikely in an engineering major), I think a purely text based notetaking software like org-mode would be pretty good.
- jdblair 9y agoI prefer a notebook to a laptop in business meetings, but then I have to spend time afterward transcribing the notes so I can share them (something expected at my workplace). I'm experimenting with using Evernote on a tablet computer along with a Bluetooth keyboard. So far this is working well - there's no laptop screen separating me from my colleagues, I can sketch diagrams and the notes are instantly available. I have no disagreement that paper is better for learning. Computers were first starting to be available in lectures when I was an undergrad, and while I could type like mad I wouldn't retain as much information.
- malkia 9y agoWhile I worked at Google, laptops @ meeting were pretty much the norm. A note-taker (in our case the oncall person, or build master) would open a Google Docs document, or continue from a long going one (well known to everyone) and start typing notes, agenda, action items. At the same time the rest of the team can join (especially useful, if meeting is happening in more than one room, with people working from home, remote offices, etc.). And everyone can correct, fix, assign, comment. Now there is a time, when the manager would say - please close your laptops, there is something important, sensitive, etc needs to be discussed. I've never seen more productive use of them. And the oncall person for the week can respond to alerts, msgs, etc. - the build master person can check updates. I mean technically you can do whatever you like, as long as your attention is not needed. People can leave if they see that this part of the meeting no longer concern them, or any other reason.
- qznc 9y agoI love the collaborative style for remote meetings. I'm still waiting for an opportunity to try it for meetings in a single room. I believe it could be nice. http://beza1e1.tuxen.de/articles/meeting.html http://beza1e1.tuxen.de/articles/meeting.html
- andrewla 9y agoI can second this; at Google I've found that meetings are unusually productive because of the practice. For the most part, regular meetings will follow a fairly strict agenda, which keeps them moving and stops them from going off on tangents (not always, sometimes tangents do happen, for better or worse, but I've found that it's for better significantly more often than at previous workplaces). And the presence of laptops helps here -- people can add bullet items to upcoming agenda items to ensure that they are discussed, without having to interrupt the conversation currently in progress, and the use of a single document means that the historical record is easily accessible. For meetings that are more oriented as design sessions or free-form discussions, the laptops tend to go away because they are not useful in that situation, unless you're at a point where data that can be quickly acquired can be useful.
- 9y ago
- frou_dh 9y agoI'm so glad that I attended university before it was the done thing for students to be on laptops during lectures. If nothing else, it's simply a distraction to have all the other peoples' bright and animated screens in your field of vision.
- slantyyz 9y ago>> I'm so glad that I attended university before it was the done thing for students to be on laptops during lectures. I'm also glad I finished before laptops (and even www) became a thing. For me, the clicking and clacking of the keyboards would drive me bonkers.
- baldfat 9y agoI used OneNote with a microphone on my 2003 PC Tablet. Syncing my lecture notes with my the professor was amazing in Graduate School. I searched my notes for test and the audio of the professor was right there. Had to repeat Art History and do a Freshman Course due to a mess up from the registrar's office = Civ 3 but still got an A.
- bargl 9y agoI think my preference is a table with a stylus followed by pencil and paper over a computer. I never found computers to be useful in meetings but something I can write on and get handwriting recognition has been useful for me.
- pklausler 9y agoI don't mind laptops being used in meetings, so long as their use is relevant to the meeting. But I find it highly distracting when somebody is pounding away on a keyboard while paying no attention to what the rest of us in the room are trying to accomplish.
- gilbetron 9y agoOddly, I've found that I pay better attention if I use a laptop during a meeting, but not for taking notes. Rather I will either lightly browse related information, or look for the answer to a question that pops in my mind. It can't be intense usage, but just simple. It seems to keep my mind more alert and I'm able to absorb the meeting better. I also can tune out if they are talking about something I already know. If I don't have a laptop or phone, I tend to zone out or fall asleep. On the other hand, I get pissed if someone is in my meeting using a laptop and isn't paying attention at all. It's a weird thing.
- kkylin 9y agoI think an effective strategy depends highly on the subject matter. Also, appropriate use of technology by the lecturer makes a huge difference. For mathematics (my field) or something similar like theoretical physics, the pace at which the lecturer can write on a blackboard with a piece of chalk is just about the right information rate for the audience to absorb. Not to say one cannot teach well using more modern media, but it has to be done with careful thought and planning to be effective. (Same applies to lecturing at the board; we just have more practice at it.) As for note-taking, I used to write everything down in class when I was in college & grad school. Sometimes this worked, sometimes not -- what's right for a course in abstract algebra isn't going to be right for a course in computational neuroscience. What I think is very effective, but requires some discipline, is: - take minimal notes (or even photos) in class - reconstruct lecture after class - go to office hours and clear up any questions that arise. It would be hard to do this for everything. For the subjects you really care about, this might be a useful approach.
- deleted 9y ago
- otakucode 9y agoThe problem here lies not with the laptops or with their use. It lies with the continued existence of such radically and absurdly inefficient and pointless traditions as 'lectures' and 'meetings'. They were started because physical co-location was necessary for knowledge transmission. Physical co-location is no longer necessary for, and indeed is severely hampering of, knowledge transmission. Anyone who proposes an in-person meeting is planning to abuse the frailties of human biology rather than meet with you honestly. They intend to use bluster and charm to convince you of ostensibly objective claims - and it will probably work. It usually does. That's one of the reasons they fight so hard to avoid being put on an actual even playing field where their ideas must stand or fall solely on their own merits.
- dgacmu 9y ago[Citation needed] Here's a competing citation that disagrees with you and suggests that people pay more attention in-person: https://www.maritzmotivation.com/~/media/Files/MaritzInstitute/White-Papers/The-Case-for-Face-to-Face-Meetings-The-Maritz-Institute.pdf https://www.maritzmotivation.com/~/media/Files/MaritzInstitu...
- grogenaut 9y agoIt's pretty common where I work to bring laptops to meetings. If the meeting is engaging they close, and sometimes in deep meetings they are asked to be closed. In other meetings it helps to have many hands on keyboards updating the sprint board in jira and entering new tasks, or the meeting is rolling attention and people are there and do work until they are needed by the meeting. This is often what happens in all hands on deck situations or launches. People who are holding meetings where I work realize when they're wasting time and generally dismiss people if they're not needed and everyone is generally free to just leave if the meeting isn't of use to them.
- anotheryou 9y agoIf you want me to remember more than just some big picture, let me write it down. And if you let me write it down, please let me use my tools. Just teach people how to use tech right, the younger generation is surprisingly much better at this. I have a full screen white on black text editor and turn off the display while not typing (sometimes I even keep it off while typing). And yea, lectures... just gave me the stream so I can play it at double speed and repeat the interesting parts. The only things I need paper for are geometry, layout and surprisingly: math. With math for me it's super valuable to keep something like nested contexts. I write things down to free the brain for more, but need to be able to jump back in on demand. Easier on a 2D pane than in a linear way. With OpalCal/Soulver i tend to do more on the PC though, variables are damn nice.
- Fomite 9y agoI have never been able to stay awake in lectures. Never. Being able to have a laptop in class helped me stay awake, and get through graduate school. I'll never ban them in my classes. Students know what they need.
- jupp0r 9y agoIt seems like the more obvious conclusion from the facts stated in the article would be: lectures are more efficient when people can dedicate their brain to understanding the content instead of having to write down everything being said/shown. I never understood why some lecturers thought that making students write things down would be a good way to teach them anything. Certainly did not work for me. I got much more value from mentally following the lecture and thinking about the topic.
- mcfunk 9y agoIt's unfortunate to see laptops conflated with "all electronics" here. I benefitted greatly from using SoundNote on an iPad in grad school, which allowed me to make recordings of lectures that I could then annotate in real time. Rather than taking a transcript or feeling I had to record all key concepts, I could stick to noting where in the lecture was an especially important concept, or where I had spaced out and should re-listen. More valuable than any written notes I could have taken.
- another-dave 9y agoI think banning laptops is a good idea, but I think it should be coupled with other study aids, like fully recorded lectures to let students learn in their own way. One of the best lecturers I had at university passed round a printed copy of the lecture summary at the start, allowing students to concentrate on making their own notes & transcribing the lecture that the article talks about. Many, many other lecturers objected though to lectures being recorded (by individual students, e.g. dictaphone, we didn't have campus-wide video/audio recording). Most meetings are completely different beasts to lectures, I think — e.g. if you have ten people round a table in a room, people should be participants not audience members; the dynamic is completely different. That said, I would agree with banning laptops from meetings for the most part!
- 839083 9y agoLittle late, but my two cents as someone who majored in a humanities field (although working in tech now): Our lectures were almost always intended to be heard after doing the readings. They were comprised of helpful info professors knew from academic experience, not easily found in any print material. Relevant historical context was especially hard to pick up without knowing what exactly to look for. I felt like my humanities lectures were more analogous to demos and labs in my STEM courses, learning that relies on a certain spontaneity and physical presence, even if not all of the material is strictly "necessary". As for a counterpart to my STEM lectures, I too would've been bored out of my mind listening to most humanities professors read our readings to us...
- chasedehan 9y agoAs a former economics professor, I did exactly the same thing these authors were suggesting. While some students did use their technology effectively, the vast majority of whom were just distracted, not to mention probably taking far worse notes. One small story, I was teaching a class during March one year and I had a student obviously not paying attention. Then, all of a sudden, this student's hands went in the air and an audible "Yes!" came out. I then asked him if there was something important - "Kentucky just won in a buzzer beater!" The vividness of this memory and the difficulty I had in containing my rage is still at the forefront of my mind. For me, the impact was that while students should be able to do what they want for the most effective solution, it becomes a problem when activities disrupt the learning of the students around them. Someone not paying attention and watching cat videos is infectious as there is a lower percentage of participation and others start to watch the offending student's screen. My perspective is (although unproven) is that the real reason laptops don't work is because of the temptation to do something else, not necessarily because of the medium.
- perseusprime11 9y agoDear NYTimes, please write a story in why Laptops are great and why meetings suck.
- snambi 9y agoIf the professor is really interesting, why would someone look into a laptop?
- emodendroket 9y ago> The researchers hypothesized that, because students can type faster than they can write, the lecturer’s words flowed right to the students’ typing fingers without stopping in their brains for substantive processing. Students writing by hand had to process and condense the spoken material simply to enable their pens to keep up with the lecture. Indeed, the notes of the laptop users more closely resembled transcripts than lecture summaries. The handwritten versions were more succinct but included the salient issues discussed in the lecture. I mean, that's possible, but my experience is if I'm using my laptop during a lecture I'm more likely to start surfing the Web and not pay attention to the lecture.
- catchmeifyoucan 9y agoStudent here. 200 people in a class, I can't even get my questions answered. True story, miss one sentence, and you're lost at a point of no return. It makes sense for me to learn it on my own pace outside of class and visit during office hours. Let me use my laptop in class so that I can still continue to be productive during the hour. (doing other work) Whether I take notes or not should be up to me as a student. Banning electronics does not guarantee learning. If I don't want to learn/listen, then I won't. You can take a horse to the water, but you can't get it to drink.
- racecliffer 9y agoFrom the article: "The strongest argument against allowing that choice is that one student’s use of a laptop harms the learning of students around them. In a series of lab experiments, researchers at York University and McMaster University in Canada tested the effect of laptops on students who weren’t using them. Some students were told to perform small tasks on their laptops unrelated to the lecture, like looking up movie times. As expected, these students retained less of the lecture material. But what is really interesting is that the learning of students seated near the laptop users was also negatively affected."
- Cu3PO42 9y agoI dislike the style of note taking described in the article, i.e. mindlessly writing down what the professor is saying. I don't believe however that this is necessarily tied to typing rather than writing with pen and paper. I have a lecture where no notes or textbook is provided and it is required that you copy everything written on the board. Personally I'm not great at writing fast, so I usually lag behind a bit with writing which makes it that much harder to follow along with what the professor is saying. In a situation like this, writing with pen and paper may be worse than typing (except the specific course I'm talking about is maths and short of writing LaTeX in real time, handwriting is necessary). From my personal experience as a student the most effective way for me to take notes is to annotate existing material, i.e. slides or lecture notes. In some classes where material is available beforehand that would be possible by printing it all, bringing it to class, annotating it and then digitalizing it again to make it searchable (and create backups). However I feel this is highly inefficient and a massive waste of paper. Suppose there are roughly 60 slides per lecture, 8 lectures a week across courses and I can get roughly 4 slides on a sheet of paper in such a way that I can work with them comfortably; that is 120 pages of paper a week! For many lectures where material is not provided in advance, but only at the beginning of the lecture, presumably to prevent students to only selectively attend the lectures it would be impossible to work in the way I find to be best for me. That is not to say, the problems described in the article don't exist. I remember many instances of people browsing social media rather than following the lecture. Ignoring any detriment it has on themselves (it is their choice to not pay attention after all) we are left with the negative impact it has on others. As I outlined in another comment, there are approaches to combating this that I feel to be more appropriate than a blanket ban. One is to have people using electronic devices to sit somewhere else, usually behind people not using them, so they can only distract other people using electronic devices. This offers people the choice of either using their devices and being potentially exposed to visual noise or not use them and be free from these distractions. I also had a professor that disallowed electronic devices for everything but slides of the lecture and related material. I can only hypothesize how he managed to do this consistently, but I believe he was able to tell by the expressions on peoples' faces and if people sitting nearby stole glances at other screens.
- ALee 9y agoBtw, an executive at Twitter did this. And well, it seems like it's working well: http://www.nextgov.com/cio-briefing/wired-workplace/2017/11/twitter-executive-banished-laptops-his-meeting-and-reactions-were-excellent/142367/ http://www.nextgov.com/cio-briefing/wired-workplace/2017/11/...