5 ms·
Now we have two (more) major newsoutlets owned by activist owners --WaPo and Time Mag. Wish there were more independence in the media. Or at least fewer owners
by mc32 9y ago
Now we have two (more) major newsoutlets owned by activist owners --WaPo and Time Mag.
Wish there were more independence in the media. Or at least fewer owners who will push agendas. Time will tell.
- knowaveragejoe 9y agoHas WaPo's "activist" owner had any real impact on what they choose to cover?
- danso 9y agoWe don't truly know because we don't/can't/won't know all the stories that WaPo killed because of influence. However, worrying about stories being "killed" is the wrong way to think of the potentially nefarious effects. The much more common problem, and much harder to detect, are knowing the stories that the WaPo (or any news org) just didn't put priority into pursuing because of institutional inertia and unspoken rules. If WaPo had a reporter/editor who specialized in particular zealous investigations into Amazon, we would likely hear murmurs and off-the-record complaints about how WaPo has been going unexpectedly soft on Amazon post-acquisition. In contrast, there is no possibility of knowing how the average Wapo tech reporter would have covered Amazon in an alternate universe in 2017.
- forapurpose 9y agoI'm not sure what the parent's conclusion is, but AFAICT they are saying that there is no evidence of activism/bias. (I assume we are excluding opinion pages, which are supposed to be biased.) I don't agree with the general point that bias is necessarily difficult to detect. For example, with Murdoch there is a large amount of explicit evidence.
- dragontamer 9y agoEhh? If WashPo kills a story, the other news outlets would most likely be running those stories. Lets say WashPo kills a story, why wouldn't Fox News run that story in the headlines? Or New York times? Or Politico, or... any media organization worth a darn?
- hiharryhere 9y agoNot all stories are widely known before they break. For instance, Wapo might not pursue an investigative piece on Amazon as enthusiastically, or another investigation may get prioritised because of the owner. A story that isn't pursued might not see the light of day. Big stories, like the Weinstein disclosures, are broken after long periods of investigation and journalistic grunt-work. Only after they break do you see all the other news outlets pounce on the story and start reporting it. Historically, Wapo has been an important place for investigative work, they broke the Watergate story. I think that's more the worry.
- dragontamer 9y ago> Not all stories are widely known before they break. For instance, Wapo might not pursue an investigative piece on Amazon as enthusiastically, or another investigation may get prioritised because of the owner. As is true of all Media. I don't recall any major Fox News articles or pieces on the Sexual Harassment claims of Bill O'Reily. But the story got out, because we have competing media companies in the USA. That's the benefit of free-market competition. Unfortunately, it also means that whenever one media company sounds the alarm, the readers need to be careful with the evidence.
- sumedh 9y ago> But the story got out, because we have competing media companies in the USA. How long did it take for the Kevin Spacey story to get out even though there were rumours from early 2000. Some stories can remain buried for a very long time. Free market is not the answer to everything.
- colordrops 9y agoYes. They commonly report negative SpaceX stories, and trashed the hell out of Bernie Sanders during the election, publishing 16 negatives stories in less than a day.
- rhcom2 9y agoHow are those connected to the owner though?
- colordrops 9y agoJeff Bezos owns SpaceX competitor Blue Origin, and was a big Hillary Clinton supporter.
- rhcom2 9y agoIt's still an assumption to connect the paper's content to Bezos though. That he has William Randolph Hearst level control in the WaPo seems like a common conspiracy theory.
- colordrops 9y agoIt's a fundamental denial of obvious facts to claim that editorial control by the owner of a media outlet is conspiracy theory. There are plenty of well known examples, though most people only acknowledge the ones that are opposite their own political beliefs.
- rhcom2 9y agoWhat are the well known examples and the obvious facts connecting Bezos with the editorial direction of the WaPo? Saying he makes editorial decisions in the newspaper because they printed criticism of Sanders or his competition doesn't cut it for me.
- colordrops 9y ago
- arca_vorago 9y agoWaPo is an operation mockingbird outlet through and through now, and has no credibility left over from its olden days.
- knowaveragejoe 9y agoYikes, really saddened to hear this far-reaching conspiracy claptrap on HN.
- arca_vorago 9y agoYikes, really sad to see people burying their head in the sand on HN. Don't be so patronizing.
- pavlov 9y agoYou’re counting Jeff Bezos as an activist but not Rupert Murdoch? That makes no sense. Most of his media conglomerate is openly political all the time (Fox News, New York Post, The Sun etc.) while some maintains a pretense of objectivity (Wall Street Journal).
- mc32 9y agoThey are all problematic, but an additional issue is that Conservative views tend to be labeled such more then Progressive views get labeled such -so the presentation is that Progressive views are more "normal" than conservative views. As in your post, you're implying that most of Murdoch's outlets are politically biased but make no implication about progressive outlets.
- xapata 9y agoOnly two? Murdoch, Turner ... I'm sure there are many more.
- mc32 9y agoTurner's network didn't turn full on opposition till recently though and he's out of the picture anyway. HuffPo but she's been at it for a while. I meant to say major ownership changes to activist owners in the last two years --though there may be some other big ones.
- indubitable 9y agoTurner's network was one of the first that has some clear record of proposals to do what it (and most other media) has done today. You might find this hot mic moment [1] interesting. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VCUIlV-AKY4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VCUIlV-AKY4
- Lazare 9y agoI think that's what "independence" in the media looks like. The alternative is ownership by massive conglomerates. GE owns NBC, does that make NBC more "independent" than the New York Times (which is owned by the Sulzberger family)? Media outlets are valuable, thus your options for ownership are 1) very rich individuals or families or 2) large corporations. Which one of those did you want to see more of?
- twblalock 9y agoI like the British media, because they don't pretend to be impartial. Impartiality is impossible, so it's better to be honest about that fact than to pretend to be impartial as the American media does.
- mc32 9y agoOn the other hand the state sponsored one forces you to pay an involuntary fee and it is not all that balanced a source.
- TylerE 9y agoIt's hardly involuntary. No one's holding a gun to your head to own a TV receiver.
- mc32 9y agoSo you buy a receiver will never watch the channel, yet you must pay whether or not you even agree with their programming and somehow that is voluntary excise? It's strongarming.
- grigjd3 9y agoThere are plenty of things my government does (like invade Iraq or charge zero dollars for mineral rights) that I am forced to pay for. Cry me a river.
- mc32 9y agoPresumably, at least, you can vote your gov out, PM, MPs --can you vote away that tax?
- clintonb 9y agoI am not quite familiar with the UK's parliamentary system but, I would assume you can lobby your representatives to eliminate the tax. So, yes, you can vote the tax away. I would be greatly surprised if folks can vote on Brexit but not a simple tax.
- door 9y agomedia companies, given that they can't make a profit in 2017, are a service that should be publicly-owned
- api 9y agoHas there ever been such a thing? Were the newspaper barons of the past neutral?
- johannes1234321 9y agoThere's no true neutrality. You always have a bias. The statements "the coin was tossed and shows head" and "tail didn't come up" are both true and correct equally valid description of the same fact. For more complex issues the description is even harder. Especially if you add selection of areas to cover, due to limited space, time and authors.