3 ms·
The thing about the reviling of social networks is it generally takes this sort of media as an upsurge that came out of nowhere and could somehow stop in a fash
by joe_the_user 9y ago
The thing about the reviling of social networks is it generally takes this sort of media as an upsurge that came out of nowhere and could somehow stop in a fashion that returns things to people making nebulous "face to face" contacts, in a world that's not changed since the pre-social-network era. Actually, there was an explosion of isolation before all this[1].
It seems to me that the world has become massively more socially isolated and social networks are as much a response to this as they are an addictive phenomena unto themselves - indeed, explosion of opioids, addiction and suicide has very much also been an effect of this social isolation and is naturally more destructive.
TL;DR; If one complains about social dysfunction, give us a path to social function, please.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bowling_Alone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bowling_Alone
- Top19 9y agoThe larger issue that your getting at is the rise of “individualism” over the last 40 years. The first time I heard that I remember thinking what a ridiculous concept, people have always been interested in success and self-improvement in America. But after hearing nearly every brilliant sociologist and conservative/liberal political commentator make the same comment, I started to see things differently. The loss of community in America has been really sad. As jobs have become harder to get, as social programs from the government have decreased, as people have turned away from churches, people have either lost the community embedded in those institutions or the financial guarantees that allowed them to pursue community without worrying about-side hustles or growth hacking. Christopher Lasch’s The Age of Narcissism (1979) or anything recently by Barbara Ehrenreich, Michael Lind, or even Laura Ingraham all point to the same loss. A really sad statistic I heard the other day was the experience in suicides of those 12-14 years old. It’s doubled in the last 5 years among boys and girls. I would think childhood would be a somewhat happier place but even it is engulfed by sadness. EDIT: Just saw you mentioned Bowling Alone so I took that out. Also want to say community vs individualism is a recurring theme in the history of America, one tends to dominate for 40-50 years before succumbing to the other.
- ghostcluster 9y ago> as social programs from the government have decreased what programs are you talking about?
- Top19 9y agoProbably the best example is the TANF welfare reform passed in 1996. On the surface it had a very reasonable goal. Require workers on welfare to seek employment. However, this, combined with the shipping of jobs to China (stuff that had been manufactured in the US was instead manufactured there and shipped back), businesses forcing citizens to compete with immigrants who they knew they could threaten with deportation, along with outright cuts to welfare, kind of destroyed the program. In other words, welfare was cut while jobs were getting scarcer, and then they turned around and made getting a job a requirement to having / staying on welfare.