7 ms·
Concorde moment
- tbrock 9y agoIf it weren’t for the iPod, Apple Computer would be on that list. RethinkDB comes to mind. In the vein of palm pilot: The Apple Knewton.
- lisper 9y agoOS X Snow Leopard. That was the last time a computer operating system Just Worked.
- lisper 9y agoIf the FCC ends net neutrality, that will be a Concorde moment for the internet.
- phinnaeus 9y agoPerhaps not, as the motivations behind it are fairly obvious (profit at the expense of all else).
- tomphoolery 9y agoIt's strange how this article was written as if the author doesn't realize that there are more things than just power/speed dictating what it means for a technology to be successful. Technology like the Concorde or Bugatti Veyron wasn't taken away from us, it was just rendered obsolete. What killed the Concorde? Broadband Internet. Who needs to fly to Europe all the time if you can just video chat? The Concorde is noisy, uncomfortable, and highly polluting. If one could make a better version of the Concorde I'm sure people would be into it...but really the "big win" of using this jet was that you got somewhere a couple hours faster, and it cost 3x the normal price of an airline. What normal person would really be doing this? What killed the Bugatti Veyron? I guess this one is a general sense of "YAGNI", because seriously who gives a shit. The car doesn't look all that nice, who cares if it can go real fast. Fast engines are not what makes good cars, there are lots of other factors involved.
- mikeash 9y agoI’d argue that the 70s oil crises killed Concorde. It was basically DOA. It limped along for decades having built only 12 airplanes and serving only two routes in the long term. It never really made money, roughly breaking even operationally but not paying back its R&D. It was ultimately a prestige project. It got that job done pretty well, but it was never successful in a way that would persist. The Veyron is an even more extreme example of that. It was intended to be a prestige product from the start. It wasn’t supposed to make money and it only gets produced until the company comes up with a different way to spend that marketing or research budget. Edit: the Veyron is a particularly terrible example here because it was discontinued in favor of a new model that's even more insane. The Veyron was succeeded by the Chiron, which has an anticipated top speed of 288MPH, although it's currently electronically limited to "only" 261MPH. I don't see any way in which the Chiron is substantially inferior, so I don't see how it could possibly be an example of a major technological advance fading away.
- gok 9y agoThe US ban on supersonic overflight killed supersonic travel, and therefore Concorde. 1960s tech was only able to build planes that could go about 3500 nm, and a huge proportion of flights in that range at that time was transcontinental flights across North America. The cancellation of all American operator orders made the project impossible to break even. The fuel costs were nasty, but not the end of the world. The existence of first class travel shows that there’s a market for expensive, inefficient long haul flights. If supersonic passenger flight had been able to survive American protectionism, it would have avoided missing out on the last 50 years of R&D, so SSTs today would have gotten much more efficient, just like today’s sub sonic jets have become.
- cstross 9y agoHark back to 1973 when Concorde production began and they had around 120 advance orders/options. Most of which evaporated because of not only the oil shock but, significantly, the discovery that the Boeing 747 (and other wide-bodies) could make huge amounts of revenue by carrying more passengers, cheaper. The 747 was originally expected to be a cargo freighter, once SSTs like Concorde ate the passenger market in the 80s, hence the high cockpit positioned over the nose door on the cargo variants. Concorde was the last gasp of the idea that air travel was a very expensive form of transport for the elite, who would pay to save time over taking an ocean liner. Instead we got the democratization of air travel. It's no accident that the cruise liner died out as a normal form of international transport (as opposed to a recreational vehicle) at the same time that wide-body airliners caught on. (Side-note: the plans for Concorde B are worth googling — an incremental upgrade with quieter engines and a range that could have stretched to 5000 miles, opening up a bunch more routes, and due to enter production by 1982.) Graffiti: I used it and I don't miss it! While early on-screen multitouch keyboards sucked, what really makes Graffiti show its age is modern gesture-based systems like Swype or SwiftKey, where each word is a unique ideogram composed by dragging a finger across a QWERTY map in letter order. Graffiti typically took 2-3 gestures to enter a letter: with Swype I'm typically on 5-7 gestures per word, which overall is much faster (average word length in English is 5.5 letters). Graffiti has in fact been ported to iOS and Android ... but relatively few people use it because times have moved on.
- michaelfeathers 9y agoThis was a Concorde moment for software: the move away from 'The Structure and Interpretation of Computer Programs' at MIT. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14167453 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14167453
- blhack 9y agoConcorde moments for tech: -When RIM stopped making the blackberry 7520, which (paired with nextel, with push-to-talk) was the best phone, with the best UI, ever made. They made the phones thinner, and shinier...and less useful in the process. -Dropping 3.5mm headphone jacks, an example of a standard that works, and has worked, flawlessly, for a very long time (I know this horse is beaten to death). -Getting rid of iPods for "iPod touch" (neutered iPhones)
- raldi 9y agoWhy don't we have push-to-talk on every Android and iPhone in 2017?
- blhack 9y agoBecause it was all replaced with a software implementation of it that wasn't as good, which soured people against the idea.
- raldi 9y agoWhat are you referring to?
- csours 9y agoPush to talk by Nextel had it's own allocated bandwidth. Bandwidth = MONEY, so they shut down PTT and sold the bandwidth. In the manufacturing plant where I worked, we went from being almost able to understand people on Nextel PTT to completely unable to understand people with the software implementation. The plant has since switched to local walkie talkies with repeaters - with Nextel you could easily start chatting with anyone else on the network, pretty much anywhere.
- blhack 9y agoCsours explained it. For a while, when nextel disappeared and the PTT bandwidth got reallocated, the other carriers tried to sell "PTT" as well, but it was contained in an app like Zello (or their own proprietary app). Old Nextel PTT phones had dedicated hardware buttons specifically for it. So you didnt' have to unlock a phone, find the app, open it, etc. Your phone was a walkie talkie.
- pesenti 9y agoConcord moments are just parenthesis in the history of humanity. 5 years ago the electric car would have been on that list. Faster than sound planes will come back, it's just a matter of time and technology being mature enough for the product to be economically viable.
- raldi 9y ago> 5 years ago the electric car would have been on that list. I don't understand -- are you saying that at some point prior to 2012, electric cars had been in frequent use, and then that stopped at some point?
- chkuendig 9y agoYes, this was a widespread believe, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who_Killed_the_Electric_Car%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who_Killed_the_Electric_Car%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_EV1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_EV1
- raldi 9y agoThe EV1 was never in widespread use.
- raldi 9y agoIn 2002, when I got a call on my landline, the Caller ID would show the caller's name (either an individual's name, or their business) without my having to maintain any sort of contact list. The phone company would transmit this information to my phone's screen, populated from their own database. I can't understand why an iPhone in 2017 lacks this feature.
- bluedino 9y agoHas nothing to do with the phone. The cell providers don't have, or send the information with the call like your landline phone company does.
- raldi 9y agoMy cell provider absolutely has my name. And the continued existence of phone books demonstrates that there's still a database of businesses and their phone numbers. Google has this information, too: I can type the name of just about any local business into their web search or maps product and be given their phone number. Apple has it too: I can launch Apple Maps on my iPhone, and it knows all the phone numbers of local businesses. I believe they get this information from Yelp. > The cell providers don't [...] send the information with the call like your landline phone company does. Exactly. Why not?
- ThePadawan 9y agoI also believe that this feature has been somewhat deprecated since there is no authentication involved in caller ID at all. That resulted in cold callers camouflaging themselves using either suppressed or incorrect phone numbers, reducing the value of called ID to zero. It's equivalent to someone shouting through your door "Open up, this is the police". You would not do that without a chain or peephole, either.
- raldi 9y agoThe value wasn’t zero; even with spoofing, there’s a big difference between “this unknown caller is camouflaging their name to something I don’t recognize” vs “Oh, it’s the dry cleaners; I’d better pick up.”
- michaelfeathers 9y agoIsn't it strange that the concorde moment for aviation was the retirement of the SR-71?
- regularfry 9y agoThe Thinkpad T420. Last model with that keyboard.
- noir_lord 9y agoNot convinced by that, I was a massive fan of that era's keyboard but having recently come back to the fold with a T470P (having use Dell's for most of a decade) I love it's keyboard as well (even the smaller function keys simply aren't an issue once I adapted to them). I still have an old R series with the old style keyboard kicking around and I tried them side by side, it was (and is) a great keyboard but it's simply not better than the keyboard on the T470P in any way I actually care about.
- raldi 9y agoA lot of these moments come from changing norms regarding risk-aversion and willingness to be inconvenienced. For example, the airport-security experience reached its peak in August 2001 and will never be that good again. The Empire State Building was built in less than 14 months using 1930s technology, but only because of safety standards much more lax than we'd allow today (five construction workers died). In fact, a lot of great buildings could never be built today simply because of zoning restrictions about height and boxiness. Another example is the NY subway system. Construction of the original line began in 1900 and was complete in 1904. A century later, it's taking about ten times as long to build the Second Avenue Subway. But a big part of that is that we used to just rip up the ground and inconvenience everyone nearby with yearlong street closures and dynamite vibrations. That doesn't fly anymore.
- mikeash 9y agoSurely airport security was at its peak before the 70s when they started actually screening things? Before that you just got on the plane. On the topic of subways, I'm always fascinated by the example of Beijing's line 2. It was planned as a circular route approximately following the old city wall. They couldn't afford to bore the tunnel, and had to use cut-and-cover instead. This consists of digging a trench to the desired depth, then covering the top. Of course, this requires destroying whatever is on the surface there. This would have destroyed a lot of people's homes. But a solution was found: rather than approximately following the old city wall, how about exactly following the old city wall, and destroying that instead of people's houses? Nobody lives in it, after all. And thus Beijing's line 2 was born, and the centuries-old historic city wall is no more, aside from a few preserved gatehouses. Imagine trying something like that in a place like New York City.
- mikestew 9y agoSurely airport security was at its peak before the 70s when they started actually screening things? Before that you just got on the plane. Until 2001, you essentially just got on the plane. Oh, they made you walk through a metal detector, so take your keys out of your pocket. Other than that, walk right to the gate whether you hold a ticket or not. Don’t tell my wife this, but one of the pluses of increased security is I just dump her at the door now instead of parking he car and navigating the airport concourse just so I can give her a kiss seconds before she walks on the plane. And I don’t have to be waiting at the gate when she comes home. (I know, real sentimental guy I am. She’s fine with it, which is what matters.) OTOH, we did lose the ability to just go to the airport and watch planes take off. Yup, just drive to your local international airport, with no ticket and no money spent otherwise, go through the metal detector, pick a random terminal and watch them come and go. Leave your I. D. at home, no one will want to look at it. I remember having the spouse come to a screeching stop in front of the airport 20 minutes before my flight, carry-on in hand, doing “an O. J.” (re: old commercial w/O. J. running through an airport to catch a plane). Made it, too. They’d scan checked bags and carry-ones, but that was on a separate thread, so one didn’t notice most of the time. In summary, yeah, it was slightly better before the hijackings of the 70s, but not by much IMO.
- jakobegger 9y agoThe decline of HyperCard was a Concorde moment for me. HyperCard was a brilliant tool that allowed anybody to produce interactive software. It had a pretty simple model (stacks of cards) and could be used to build databases, presentations, or games. It was never updated with proper color support, so people lost interest. Nothing ever came close to the simplicity and power of Hypercard.
- nawitus 9y agoThe Bugatti Veyron shouldn't qualify as a Concorde moment, because there is a successor called the Bugatti Chiron.
- amelius 9y ago> In the end, it turned out to be too noisy, too polluting, and too expensive, never really making money. Thus I think "Concorde moment" is really misnomer. A technological solution is always a balance, and if your balance tips the wrong way, your solution sucks. That's the hard reality of what engineers have to deal with.
- vzcx 9y agoIndeed, and I would frame this story as more the construction and operation of the Concorde was more ahead of it's time than it's grounding a step backwards. The way I see it: there is simply not enough wealth accumulated to keep these flights running. Perhaps in a future world were aviation kerosene is cheaper, engines more efficient, and airframe and power plant maintenance more heavily automated, we'll see a revival of supersonic transportation. Until then, I'd rather airlines not bleed money keeping these planes flying. One might get teary-eye'd over the shuttering of the program, but more efficient allocation of resources is a real cause for celebration! The notion of "'progress' at all costs" is an insane one.
- 11235813213455 9y agoit was not environment-friendly, and people should do less trips anyway, Earth is dying
- Jdam 9y agoVoIP is my Concord moment. The telco provider forced virtually all customers to do their phone calls through VoIP, instead of the ordinary old phone network. Every other week my router sends me an E-Mail about a call that failed, service unavailabilities and so on. There were even widespread outages that affected whole states. In terms of the plain old phone lines, I cannot think of a single outage in the past 20 years. It even worked when power supply itself failed.
- tomohawk 9y agoThe Concorde was a project that could have only happened due to the lavish government spending by Britain and France, as well as the tying in of national pride. It made no economic sense at all, and they hardly made any of them. The 20707 Boeing effort was more practical, but had the same genesis as the Concorde. It was also canned once the US pulled the funding and the oil shocks showed it would likely never be profitable. At least they stopped throwing good money after bad. The 747 was considerably more practical, and completely demolished the competition for years. It was the result of Pan Am (which owned the international flight scene at the time) coming to Boeing with real requirements, instead of just national pride, for a much larger jet. Boeing also decided to make it possible for it to be a freighter as well. The 747 was the truly revolutionary plane.
- TrisMcC 9y agoFrom my small sphere of existence: Gnome 1 -> Gnome 2. Some people just wanted Gnome 1 with antialiased fonts Gnome 2 -> Gnome 3. Just when Gnome 2 got as useful as Gnome 1, bubye Gnome 2. NNTP -> expertsexchange/slashdot Eudora -> yahoo mail Not all of these were permanent.