7 ms·
Physicists make most precise measurement ever of the proton's magnetic moment
- raverbashing 9y agoDoesn't seem to mention how this value agrees or not with predictions The G-2 experiment at Fermilab is coming online soon and they're investigating the Muon's magnetic moment, which is suspected to not match the current predictions
- tempay 9y ago> Doesn't seem to mention how this value agrees or not with predictions I don't think there are any theoretical predictions with anywhere close to this level of precision for nucleons.
- ISL 9y agoNot a prediction, but comparison with previous work: Accepted value [1]: µ = 2.792847351 ± 0.000000009 New value: µ = 2.79284734462 ± 0.00000000082 [1] http://pdg.lbl.gov/2017/tables/rpp2017-tab-baryons-N.pdf http://pdg.lbl.gov/2017/tables/rpp2017-tab-baryons-N.pdf
- contravariant 9y agoThis is a case when it's convenient to use the following notation: Accepted value: µ = 2.792847351(9) New value: µ = 2.79284734462(82)
- amelius 9y agoWhat's that notation called, and how does it work when digits overlap, e.g. in 0.123±0.004
- geertj 9y agoNice that the new interval completely lies within the old. I remember from college that there was an important physical constant where a new, more precise measurement was pretty far outside the range of the previous best measurement. I don't remember which one..
- eru 9y agoI think the story was that the first experiment was borked but done by someone famous, so the new experimenters didn't want to disagree too much.
- semantics 9y agoThis happened (allegedly) with the the Millikan oil drop experiment[0] which measured the charge of the electron. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_drop_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_drop_experiment
- evanb 9y agoDepending on when you went to college, you may be thinking of the proton radius puzzle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proton_radius_puzzle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proton_radius_puzzle which (to gloss over an enormous amount of detail) amounts to tension between two different ways of measuring the same property of the proton.
- ISL 9y agoOther possibilities: Neutron lifetime, Newton's constant (twice!)
- evanb 9y agoFirst-principles predictions of properties of baryons are only in their infancy. Even the best lattice QCD calculations of mesonic properties at the physical pion mass are good to 1 part in 10^(4ish), nothing approaching the accuracy needed to detect new physics in the baryon sector. Calculations with baryons suffer from a severe signal-to-noise problem, and the latest calculation of a substantially-easier-to-compute quantity, the nucleon isovector axial coupling, is only at ~1% precision: https://arxiv.org/abs/1710.06523 https://arxiv.org/abs/1710.06523 (full disclosure: one author of said calculation). I don't know of a calculation of the proton magnetic moment with physical parameters.
- nine_k 9y agoWhy is the precision so low? I assume it's not due to lack of computing resources. Is it due to the limited accuracy of inputs? inherent instability of the model, like with weather prediction?
- danbruc 9y agoNot an expert but I think it is actually due to a lack of computing resources, lattice QCD calculations seem to be extremely demanding based on what I read.
- phkahler 9y agoI seem to recall reading that some calculations complexity were dramatically reduced with a new method having something to do with volumes of n-dimensional polyhedra. Can't find it with google because I don't recall enough.
- danbruc 9y agoMaybe you are thinking of the amplituhedron [1] which can make calculations of interaction amplitudes much easier than summing up a large number Feynman diagram. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amplituhedron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amplituhedron
- nurbl 9y agoThe article specifically mentions precision, but not accuracy.
- maho 9y agoThe main interesting thing about a high-precision measurement of the proton's magnetic moment is to compare the result to the magnetic moment of the antiproton. Depending on your string theory of choice, you should be able to see a difference between those two values. So far, they are identical within the measurement uncertainty. The proton team (Mooser et al in Mainz) and antiproton team (Ulmer et al at CERN) are collaberating very closely, so any improvement in one apparatus leads to an improvement in the other. The same groups are closely related to a group (Sturm et al in Mainz/Heidelberg) that measures the magnetic moment of the electron near a nucleus. The measurement precision is even higher, and QED gives predictions of similar precision, so these measurements are used as tests of QED.
- titzer 9y agoFTA: ...finding it to be 2.79284734462 plus or minus 0.00000000082 nuclear magnetons... Ok, physicists can measure this quantity to 10 decimal places and Computer "Scientists" cannot understand the systems _we built_ well enough to reliably measure a 1% speedup. /sigh
- Kenji 9y agoCome on, that's an unfair comparison. 1% speedup of what? Of a program? With what input? On what architecture? On what hardware? Ask a clear, well-defined question and a Computer _Scientist_ will give you an accurate answer.
- miko1293949 9y agoScience in CS is an abused term.
- moron4hire 9y agoNo, computer science is not the same thing as software development. There is a lot of science in computer science, you probably just haven't been exposed to it.
- phkahler 9y agoI think there is a lot of math in computer science and not as much science.
- perl4ever 9y agoMath and logic may be called "formal sciences" as opposed to "natural sciences".
- moron4hire 9y agoBenchmarking programs is runnimg an empirical experiment. There is a lot of science in computer science.
- 9y ago