4 ms·
And this will be cited for years as a case in point for why finanvial institutions should be skeptical of treating crypto currencies as a true piece of payment
by ineedasername 9y ago
And this will be cited for years as a case in point for why finanvial institutions should be skeptical of treating crypto currencies as a true piece of payment or currency infrastructure.
At the current level of use, this issue is a side note. At the envisioned level of use by crypto promoters, it woukd be a catastrophic economy-crypaling disaster that would have impacts far beyond a single institution. As infrastructure, this sort of thing is must-work cannot-fail technology on the order of nuclear reactors.
I'm not saying crypto currencies aren't in our future at that scale. I don't know if they are or not. I'm saying we have a much, much longer to go, and the order of a decade, before they have time to mature and then prove that maturity. Until then, they're a speculator side show. Heck, with so much mining capacity in China, they exist in significant part on the suffrance of the Chinese government not feeling too threating by the level of social disruption they might cause. If that threshold is crossed, significant mining capacity an transaction speed that goes with it is a few great-firewall configs away from oblivion. Yeah, miming difficulty will kick in ti alleviate pressure, but only after disaster-level and life-savings-wipeout levels of financial fallout ensue.
- nlperguiy 9y agoThese bugs can be tested. You launch a testnet, and test them. There was no reason why one wouldn't run a testnet and see how fork will go after block XYZ. I'd rather have a global ledger with consensus than allow a few companies to stop all banking at weekend so all banks arrive at a consensus.
- rothbardrand 9y agoThis repo is the financial institutions and "CEOs" pushing for an arbitrary change over the objections of the engineers, and in many cases their very own CTOs, and the travesty of how terribly poorly it was written and non-tested shows that bitcoin should never again entertain this kind of nonsense. This was never about scalability-- the actual on chain capacity more than quadrupled in August and Lightning ads a nearly infinite increase in theoretical capacity. This was always about the self important CEOs wanting to take over the project and force the engineers into their will.
- jstanley 9y agoThis is a bug in a fork of bitcoin. It shows how bad things can be if you don't use development practices that are appropriate for the project, but it doesn't show anything at all about how actual bitcoin code is developed. This is about a fork (that never ended up happening).
- Dylan16807 9y agoactual bitcoin is based on network consensus. And Segwit2x had 80-95% consensus.
- jstanley 9y agoNo it didn't. It had 80-95% consensus among miners, maybe, but that's not the same.
- Dylan16807 9y agoThere's a little room for difference, but if something stays at 95% of miner support then everyone else is almost certainly going to be dragged along for the ride.
- jstanley 9y agoI think the opposite is true: if 95% of the community wants to use something, miners will be dragged along as mining anything else would be unprofitable.