11 ms·
VW engineer sentenced to 40-month prison term in diesel case
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- neya 9y agoWhile the article does mention one more guy (Oliver Schmidt), it's a shame they just put the whole thing on this Engineer, when in reality there is no way this could have been pulled off by two people without the rest of management's knowledge/approval. Are you seriously telling me that only this single guy was responsible for all the emissions that were found in the TDI range of diesels, all the way from A3 to A8? Sorry, I'm not buying it.
- chrischen 9y agoThe article implies other executives to be sentenced. Liang happens to be the lowest ranking executive. Also from the looks of Schmidt’s sentencing it seems the orher executives probably had longer sentences.
- tinco 9y agoNope, the articles says there are 7 more higher ranking executives due to be judged. And from the looks of it their sentences might be significantly higher as well.
- Tomte 9y agoThis is a common sentiment here on HN, and it is entirely devoid of factual grounding. This is one guy who happened to travel to the USA (stupid move: asking US authorities before travelling "hey, are you going to arrest me?" and taking their word that no, they don't plan to…). Another American VW guy has already been sentenced. The "real culprits" are all living in Germany. And the investigation in Germany is ongoing. It may not make a splash in the US press, but there have been raids at VW offices and in managers' private homes. Former CEO Martin Winterkorn is amongst the now thirty-seven people investigated (so it is certainly not the case that German prosecutors focus on a few lowly engineers as "fall guys", as HN commenteers love to claim). The investigation is ongoing, and it is generally expected that there will be criminal charges. But this takes time. Press release by the public prosecutor: http://www.staatsanwaltschaften.niedersachsen.de/startseite/staatsanwaltschaften/braunschweig/presseinformationen/zahl-der-beschuldigten-steigt-150570.html http://www.staatsanwaltschaften.niedersachsen.de/startseite/...
- kome 9y agoVW and the German government are basically "cooperating" on everything [1] [2] [3]. It's extremely naive to think that VW will get a fair trail in Germany. [1] https://qz.com/1045619/germanys-diesel-scandal-shines-a-light-on-how-indulgent-the-government-is-with-carmakers/ https://qz.com/1045619/germanys-diesel-scandal-shines-a-ligh... [2] http://www.climatechangenews.com/2017/09/05/lobbying-data-reveals-carmakers-influence-berlin/ http://www.climatechangenews.com/2017/09/05/lobbying-data-re... [3] https://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/02/world/europe/germany-volkswagen-autos-merkel.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/02/world/europe/germany-volk...
- Tomte 9y agoThe German government doesn't control the prosecution. Especially not because it's not a federal investigation. Criminal matters are state matters, with very few exceptions. And to counter your next try: No, the government of Lower Saxony does not control the prosecution either.
- kome 9y agogovernment doesn't control the prosecution but government makes the laws and regulations. that's enough. And government in Germany is super cozy [1] [2] with car makers. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/02/business/energy-environment/germany-diesel-car-emissions.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/02/business/energy-environme... [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-18/germany-wrestles-with-diesel-s-future-as-large-cities-plan-bans https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-18/germany-w...
- germanier 9y agoLast time I checked the prosecution was bound by instructions (§ 147 GVG), in this case by the government of Lower Saxony. Of course there are some limits to this and I'm not saying anything like that happened here.
- goldesel 9y ago
- Hamuko 9y agoThe guy lead the emission compliance unit in the US. He was most likely in charge of taking the software designed in Germany and adapting it so that it works with the emission tests performed in the US. As far as I can remember, the software was pretty closely monitoring the driving style and comparing it to the test suite that was performed in the EU in order to activate the cheats. They probably had to perform the same kind of thing in the US, as I assume that the tests differ.
- wslh 9y agoAnd QA engineers or security reviewers never detected this in the source code? I would love to see how many people participated in those source code repositories.
- roman_savchuk 9y agoExcept, they don't work with actual source code. An engineering team responsible for adaptation for certain market, most likely works in calibration space, that's it, just data (flags, thresholds and tables, thousands of them). To access this data they rely on ASAP2 description databases which are simply very large text files [1] containing ROM addresses, parameter names, etc. I don't know the whole VW workflow, but can imagine how one could define a set of switching parameters for cheating, and then delete their definitions, leaving these parameters invisible. [1] https://vector.com/vi_datadescription_ecu1_en.html https://vector.com/vi_datadescription_ecu1_en.html
- wslh 9y agoAre you saying that once the configuration is fonr there is not a QA environment?
- roman_savchuk 9y agoNo, I'm only saying this calibration QA has no readable source code to work with. And there are ways to obscure some parts of the ECU behaviour.
- baddox 9y agoI don’t see any claim or implication that this is intended to represent the entire punishment for the incident.
- Kenji 9y ago> former engineer James Liang Former engineer? Does one ever stop being an engineer?
- skrebbel 9y agoFantastic precedent. When your boss tells you to do something unethical and possibly illegal, you now have a great reason to say no.
- baddox 9y agoIs it a good enough reason though? That would depend on the likelihood of losing your job by refusing, the ease of finding a different job, the seriousness of the unethical request, and the likelihood of getting caught.
- mseebach 9y agoWhat's good enough is always going to be an individual decision, but it's better to be able to reference a concrete expectation of jail time.
- baddox 9y agoThat’s certainly true. Deterrence is one of the classic justifications for punishment (and for crimes like this that don’t involve direct violence or specific victims, it’s perhaps the best or most significant justification). But still, the strength of the deterrence is related not just to the specific punishment, but also the likelihood of being caught. I don’t have any data to back this up, but my intuition is that crimes like this of this magnitude are very difficult and thus unlikely to discover and successfully prosecute, especially down to the level of specific engineers. My guess is that this whole situation will provide some deterrence at the large corporation level, but probably not much deterrence at the individual engineer level.
- jogundas 9y agoIt is not the expectation of jail time, but certainty of a punishment is what matters. See https://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2016/03/criminal-justice https://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2016/03/crimina... and references therein for actual research.
- w_t_payne 9y ago
- dreen 9y agoGood. For context, air pollution kills 200,000 in the US and 40,000 in UK every year. You have to consider ethics in your work as an Engineer. Refusing an unethical task is your moral duty.
- w_t_payne 9y agoYes ... but as engineers we need to support the professional organisations that in turn will support us when we need to make these difficult and politically courageous decisions.
- drdeadringer 9y agoWho are such organisations?
- mistersquid 9y agoWithout putting words into w_t_payne's mouth (and at risk of incurring the ire of HNers who are wary of them), unions would be one such form of organization. Other such organizations might include software engineering guilds but I don't think such guilds generally act to protect the interests of software engineers collectively or individually. For various historical and professional reasons, software developers have not seriously considered unionization as a means of advancing their interests. However, unions typically do protect their members from arbitrary and unfair work termination. YMMV EDIT: change indirect object of first sentence in last paragraph.
- dreen 9y agoWithout getting too much into politics, I agree with you 100%, unions are the way to go.
- DonHopkins 9y agoTagged unions are an even better variant.
- tryingagainbro 9y agoNot enough, and I have a feeling that he should've been one of the dozens, if not hundreds. Fraud in the case is commuted upon the buyers and everyone that breathes that air (cancers, asthma...etc). You're talking tens of billions. Go rob a store and you get a lot more jail time. Yeah the store owner and 3 customer were traumatized but so were the thousands or millions of people that suffered (directly or indirectly) from your fraud.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoI think the re-calibrated software that hurt performance and fuel economy caused customers to suffer a lot more than the pollution did.
- yhbgffvv 9y agoI am thoroughly enjoying the fact that your comment is at the bottom of the page.
- jpdus 9y agoAnd all this, while the VW share just reached new record highs...
- lifty 9y agoEverybody is riding the high winds of quantitative easing to growth and prosperity!
- marenkay 9y ago... which is kind of weird, considering they promised low emission cars since the 1980s and have not been able to deliver on that. And now all of a sudden the invest marginal sums (lower than what gets invested for new car models usually) to make electric cars work, and suddenly bankers think they'll make it work? I seriously doubt it.
- Dowwie 9y agoLet this be a lesson to all that refusing unethical Management decisions might get you fired but at least you won't go to prison.
- saas_co_de 9y agoUnfortunately I think most people will conclude that this kind of enforcement only applies to non-US companies. I guess people from the US might start worrying about travel to the EU though.
- jacquesm 9y agoI'd love for that to happen but it probably won't. US companies routinely break EU laws and get away with it.
- jacquesm 9y agoLooking forward to Mark Zuckerberg and Eric Schmidt being arrested on their next EU trip for breaking the law here.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- marenkay 9y agoThat will rather be interesting as with the enactment of the GDPR the most promising part is not punishment by arresting people but by cashing in 4% of global revenue for breaking privacy and consumer protection laws in EU. And in the end, it's the money that hurts. Jails breaks can be made nice with cash in every country.
- JohnGB 9y agoOkay, so it's okay to go after an engineer at VW for gaming the system, and causing higher emissions than everyone thought, but not okay to go after bankers for fraud which screwed the world economy? I'm not saying that the engineer shouldn't be responsible - he should - but it's an extreme double standard.
- ju-st 9y agoBanks are too big to fail in the US. German car companies are not too big to fail in the US.
- taneq 9y agoI'm starting to think that the measure of "too big to fail" is campaign donations, not percentage of GDP or something.
- b4lancesh33t 9y agoNon-flippant answer, in case this question is genuine: there are no laws against what any individual banker did, or else there is insufficient evidence to prosecute the bankers under any law they hypothetically broke. Not so with this engineer.
- atc 9y ago"What they did was technically legal" etc etc Anyway, I think it makes sense to prosecute _everyone_ involved, not just (but at least) the senior management who were responsible. If you send the message that everyone along the chain of events -- including the software engineers that are all the more relevant in today's products -- that this shit isn't ok, then aren't people going to fight against these sorts of goings-on?
- ewoodrich 9y agoSetting aside the environmental impact of the false emissions claims -- deceiving millions of customers about a big ticket product should have a commensurate punishment. I hope this isn't the last VW conviction.
- eeZah7Ux 9y agoPunish one engineer and leave manager and other companies alone?
- hutzlibu 9y agoThe astonishing thing for me is, that this is not at all new: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defeat_device https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defeat_device Yet everybody involved acts totally surprised. So good, that they do strong punishments, but maybe don't stop with VW, as others apparently do the same now (or working on it to put it silently under the carpet). Which makes me wonder if there is some backdoor agreement, that VW gets the public shame now, but recieves funding/legal aid, etc. from other companies as they are all involved in this and they don't want VW do the aggressive defense, of "everybody else is doing it as well" ...
- zardo 9y agoThis is a baseless conspiracy theory. Cheating is not par for the course, it was shocking to the emissions compliance community that VW had blatently lied and cheated. The history of defeat devices is... complicated. Keep in mind the EPA chief is a political appointment. Their own interpretations of their own regulations can vary significantly from one administration to the next.
- hutzlibu 9y agoErm, do you count the wikipedia article as a conspiracy theory as well? edit: which is the base of my "baseless" theory which I clearly stated as a possible theory, not a fact edit2: and maybe mark your edits, as edits? Otherwise it looks like manipulative arguing. And to me defeat devices seem not so complicated. Simply cheating. VW just took it to a new level.
- mankash666 9y agoExecutives need to be punished - not just lowly engineers who followed orders under the duress of losing employment
- stonogo 9y agoHe moved to the US specifically to lie to federal authorities. Lowly?
- mankash666 9y agoWho was the boss who suggested this be done?
- eninetytwo 9y agoWho said it was his job on the line if he didn't? Quite frankly, it was his choice to engineer the cheat, whether he was ordered to by threat of employment or not.
- peckrob 9y agoI don't disagree that some of the executives should be face similar, perhaps even harsher, sentences, but just "following orders," even under "duress" does not relieve a person of responsibility for their actions. Someone telling you to do something illegal does not suddenly make it legal. Ethics is a big deal in many engineering disciplines, and breaking those ethical codes can cost your your license in addition to facing legal consequences.
- gxh8N 9y ago"U.S. prosecutors have charged eight current and former Volkswagen executives in connection with the diesel emissions cheating probe. Liang is one of the lowest-ranking executives charged so far." Other executives are charged too.
- akira2501 9y ago> just lowly engineers He was an engineering _manager_. His official job title was "Leader of Diesel Competence." Let's not pretend he was all that "lowly."
- basicsbeauty 9y agoDomestic companies get a free pass even if their cars literally kill people. But rules are different for foreign companies.
- coldtea 9y agoOf course, who else would be responsible but an engineer?
- SZJX 9y agoThe problem I find with the whole episode is that it would be incredibly naive to think that only VW cheats the emission tests (as apparently also evidenced by the recent news that Fiat Chrysler also did it, with likely many other carmakers doing it as well. There was also news about Samsung cheating the emission tests on their electronic products, but that made no splash whatsoever). Though all the provisions for fining VW and sentencing those guys are theoretically sound in legal terms, I can't help but feel it highly political, just like the EU's crackdown and fines on Google, Microsoft etc. There's basically an implicit trade war and accompanying trade protectionism going on.