13 ms·
Some commentators here have difficulty of understanding how small farming can be profitable. It's relatively easy to explain. They are not selling just the pro
by nabla9 9y ago
Some commentators here have difficulty of understanding how small farming can be profitable. It's relatively easy to explain.
They are not selling just the product. Just like microbreweries, small farms sell for people who want more than just a beer or lettuce. They want to distinguish themselves and buy the feeling of authentic life and values. Consumer pays more for "small farm" even if the product is not any different from neighboring farm product that is not marketing itself as "small farm".
Modern consumer marketing sells identity, lifestyle, and values. There is no reason why small farm products can't create value from association and self–identification just like Pepsi is not selling sugar water or Nike is not selling sneakers. Everything that is sold using words classic, authentic, natural, original can be more expensive for segment who wants those tings.
Traditional farmers who produce standard grain or milk in bulk quantities are selling for different market segment.
- ratacat 9y agoI pay ten dollars a gallon for fresh non pasteurized milk from a local family that has seven cows. I don't buy a lifestyle from them, I buy fucking good milk from animals that are loved like family, and I'm proud to be helping them make a living doing something that is good for everyone(including the cows). It's not a lifestyle, it's just supporting people who aren't shitting on everyone's future.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tested23 9y agoKeep telling yourself that
- sctb 9y agoYou've been posting only comments that break the guidelines. Could you please stop? We ban accounts that continue like this. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- nilkn 9y ago> it's just supporting people who aren't shitting on everyone's future. If all dairy cows were treated exactly the same as the cows you're getting milk from, would milk be sufficiently plentiful and affordable for everyone to be able to get milk? If you really want something that's better for cows and the environment, why not just drink soy milk (or any of a pretty big variety of milk that doesn't come from cows)?
- shiven 9y agoAnd what happens to cows, as a species, a few decades from now?
- nilkn 9y agoI don't fully understand what you're asking. Could you clarify? Are you suggesting they might go extinct? Or something else?
- reificator 9y agoNot the above poster, but relevant SMBC: https://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=3105 https://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=3105
- j1elo 9y agoI can see how that mom in the comic would be a supporter of bullfighting - they tend to use similar justifications around the idea that, if it wasn't because the bull was raised and taken care (to ultimatelly be killed in the sports), it wouldn't have existed at all. I say that's BS, if you ask me.
- shiven 9y agoThere is more than one question I am asking - (1). Is there any scientifically sound study proving that the quality of protein from plant sources is equivalent to or better than from dairy products? (2). Is there any reproducible, quantitative data on leaving milk producing cows to fend for themselves vs caring for them in small -to- mid size "cow caring" setups (farms, one-cow ops etc.)? I ask this because both my maternal and paternal grandparents had 1 to 3 milk producing cows at any given point in time - from what I recall, they were well cared for (food, medicine, weather etc.) (3). If we, as a species, were to stop consuming dairy products today, or cut consumption by, say 90% over the next year, what would become of the current cow population? How is that better than the current situation for the animals? I am personally, utterly and deeply biased towards the survive-and-let-survive school of life --- so take what I say colored by my very, very, un-apologetically biased PoV.
- vanjoe 9y agoIs that legal? In Canada I'm not sure your allowed to sell unpasteurised milk.
- wil421 9y agoSimilar laws in the US, some places in my state label it as something not to be consumed by humans to get around the laws. I forget what the labels say exactly. People forget we pasteurize for a reason.
- walshemj 9y agoyou don't have the eqvielent of green top milk like we have in the UK ie a herd that has much stricter regulation and testing?
- justincormack 9y agoIn the UK you can only buy unpasteurised milk direct from a farm, not from a shop.
- scruple 9y agoThe answer is it depends and it's complicated, as raw milk is actually fairly highly regulated. The FDA has laws that prohibit the sale of raw milk across state borders. State laws vary, obviously. In some states it is legal and can be found in stores on shelves, in some states it is legal and can only be sold on the farm, and in some states it is illegal to sell. And, of course, those state laws can be superseded by local laws. You really have to put a little effort in to reading the local and state regulations in each area to sort it out. I feel that if I was going to buy raw milk from a very small scale operation that I would want to personally see their operation. You have to ensure that the farmers milking are really paying attention to what they're doing. I've had some particularly nasty food poisoning in my life, one instance of which landed me in the ER and had me on a quasi quarantine watch by the county CDC, in fact, and so I don't really play around with my food too much. Milk is a tough one because a healthy cow can become a sick cow overnight. It's also made more challenging by the daily goings-ons with the milking process. Having said all of that, my wife and I buy raw milk from a mid-scale creamery in Los Angeles, near where my wife grew up, whenever we are in the area. I've never really had much concern over it, because this creamery has been in operation for many decades and is quite reputable, but we are also well aware of the risk.
- ryguytilidie 9y ago>I don't buy a lifestyle from them, I buy fucking good milk from animals that are loved like family, and I'm proud to be helping them make a living doing something that is good for everyone(including the cows). It's not a lifestyle, it's just supporting people who aren't shitting on everyone's future. The things you say here seem like you are ABSOLUTELY buying a lifestyle here. ie. values for how animals should be treated, values for supporting families and values for "not shitting on everyones future" are very much lifestyle choices imo.
- eitland 9y agoPartially agree. 2 things though: - taste. The difference is real - and while I think this is a lifestyle thing I'd say that word has different connotations
- dsff56 9y agoI think you are wrong here as you are mistaking lifestyle with principles and ideals. Lifestyle is something very different than principles and ideals. Strange that you don't see the difference...
- freeflight 9y ago> Lifestyle is something very different than principles and ideals. Are you leading a lifestyle that goes contrary to your ideals and principles? Isn't that a rather depressing and dishonest way to live? Why would you want to live like that? Sure, not everybody can "afford" to live by the ideals/principles they ascribed to, depending on what these might be, but that's not a choice by those people, it's a choice made for them by their circumstances. If they had an actual free choice, I'm pretty certain the vast majority of people would prefer a lifestyle matching their principles and ideals, instead of being stuck in a place where they have to throw their principles and ideals overboard just to get along. > Strange that you don't see the difference. Even stranger that you didn't try to explain that difference, which leaves the rest of us wondering what you are actually trying to allude to.
- 9y ago
- nabla9 9y agoLifestyle is your interests, opinions, and behaviour. Words you are using: proud , helping, doing good, supporting. These are all values that form the basis for your lifestyle. ps. non-pasteurized milk aka raw milk is not healthier and it's less safe. It's organic-natural consumer fad.
- eru 9y agoMight tastes different / better though? I do know that I like non-homogenized milk better. (But that's a different process.)
- tluyben2 9y agoTo me it tastes better; maybe it's what i'm used to but I find pasteurized milk quite horrible. Maybe it's just taste and other people love the taste of pasteurized. Never met those people, but that says nothing either. Raw milk cheese is also a lot nicer in my opinion.
- sumedh 9y agoHave you done a blind test, if not whatever you are saying is meaningless
- free_everybody 9y agoWhy are you calling a random person's milk preferences meaningless? They just like raw milk. It's not a big deal. I like pink lady apples. Do I need to do a blind test to confirm that? No, I don't.
- sumedh 9y agoI gave you the reason why I am calling it meaningless. What part did you not understand. > Do I need to do a blind test to confirm that? Why not, go ahead, you might be surprised with the result.
- tluyben2 9y ago
- astura 9y agoYou say you don't buy for lifestyle reasons but then go on to describe lifestyle reasons for your purchase: "animals that are loved like family" "helping [small farmers] make a living doing something that is good for everyone" "supporting people who aren't shitting on everyone's future." These are all lifestyle choices. You make your purchase not just because of the product but because of your identity, feelings, and values. If there were an identical product produced by a big company using factory farming methods it would be less appealing to you. That's not a bad thing and I don't make a judgment about it, everyone has lifestyle reasons for some of their purchases, it's just a fact. Just like how probably half (or more) of the beer I consume is from the brewery down the street. If they are releasing a new beer I'm going to be there, either on release day or the day after if I'm busy. This is not only because the beer is good, the prices are on par with similar beers, and the location convenient but: -I like supporting local independently owned business. I believe that to be virtuous in and of itself. -The owners and staff are really nice and they all know me by name. -The owners and brewer take time to come up front and say hi and chat when they see me. We talk about what's new in life. -Their presence helps keep my property value high and my neighborhood characteristic. My purchase makes me feel good and feel like I'm helping a friend out rather than just consuming a product I enjoy. If those lifestyle factors weren't there I'd probably vary my purchases more and buy their beer only a couple times a year.
- ShabbosGoy 9y ago> These are all lifestyle choices. You make your purchase not just because of the product but because of your identity, feelings, and values. I think it's the other way around. A product can have such good marketing that it gives the illusion of identity, feelings, and values - for example, fair trade coffee.
- astura 9y agoSo what? That's irrelevant, it doesn't matter. The purchase is still made at least partly because of the purchaser's identity, feelings, and values. It doesn't matter if the traits in question are all marketing or objective.
- 9y ago
- eitland 9y agoAs someone who grew up on a farm: yes, there is a real difference in taste between fresh milk and processed milk. IIRC My dad told me it was more about the homogenization part than a the pasteurization part (which is good because it means you can get milk that tastes well totally without risk.) That said: I'd drink fresh unprocessed milk again without hesitation as long as I know the farmer.
- icebraining 9y agoAs someone who spent his summers getting fresh milk (often still warm) from a nearby farm, and pasteurized milk the rest of the year, I can't say I ever tasted much of a difference.
- jkoll 9y agoThat's a lifestyle.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- danmaz74 9y ago"Buying a lifestyle" sounds bad because it's associated with big brands for which that's just a marketing tactic, and where the lifestyle is artificial. But you're actually - and proudly - supporting an authentic lifestyle, there's nothing bad in that.
- Spooky23 9y agoAmen, brother. I pay $5/gallon for a family farm to deliver milk to my house, and have been since 2006. People think that we're nuts for doing this, then they have the milk or the yogurt I make with it. It's helped my in my efforts to lose weight an improve my family's health. When you pay more for better product, whether it be milk or chicken or beef or vegetables, you eat less and utilize it more. Instead of seeking bulk, we chase flavor and quality.
- goialoq 9y ago> When you pay more for better product, whether it be milk or chicken or beef or vegetables, you eat less and utilize it more. That strategy works equally well for any product, not just "better" product.
- icebraining 9y agoThe problem is identifying the better products. Price alone doesn't work.
- Spooky23 9y agoIn my case, I'll go for volume if satisfaction with the product isn't there.
- goialoq 9y agoHow is it good for the cows? If you want cows that are "loved like family", then please explain how milking a cow is worse than a human woman getting (well, being forced into) a job as a milk producer? (Which goes far beyond "wet nursing" in terms of milk production) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wet_nurse#/media/File:Wet_Nurse.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wet_nurse#/media/File:Wet_Nurs...
- why15characters 9y ago> then please explain how milking a cow is worse than a human woman getting (well, being forced into) a job as a milk producer? It isn't about the cow, it is about the babies those cows must have to be able to lactate. They are chained up or crated and then killed.
- X86BSD 9y agoReading most of the replies here reminds me the gun debate. It’s one side that has experience with said subject and the other side that has zero. And they argue. Some posters don’t believe there is any difference between eggs from a small farm where the chickens roam the yard eating naturally and Tyson sized operations where they are all cooped in a mountain together. Ethics of the two approaches aside I grew up in a small farm town in Kansas. I’ve eaten eggs straight out of the chicken my entire life. They not only taste better they last longer too. I can take freshly laid eggs and put them in a dark coolish place like my basement on a shelf and they will last well over a month. Do that with store bought eggs. I dare you Another example is raw milk. If you’ve ever had raw milk and then bought store bought milk it’s shocking how different in taste, mouth feel, and richness there is. Raw milk is flavorful, slightly off white from the grass diet, rich from a lot of cream and if you compare that to milk at the store which is watery, chalk colored, sweetened with sugar, and lacks any cream. It’s night and day. One is healthy for you the other is watered down, profit maximized chalk water. There is a big difference in veg as well. So for those posters to say there is no real difference clearly have never eaten on a farm. There is a noticeable and large difference in quality, taste, smell, longevity, and nutrition between small farm non gmo and organic produce and dairy and store bought garbage.
- phil21 9y ago> can take freshly laid eggs and put them in a dark coolish place like my basement on a shelf and they will last well over a month. Do that with store bought eggs. I dare you The only reason this is true is that commercial eggs in the US are typically washed, which removes the protective impermeable membrane that both covers the egg and makes it look a little icky. In many jurisdictions is is a legal requirement. In Europe/pretty much anywhere else in the world there are stacks of factory produced eggs sitting out on the floor/counter. Anywhere else in the world would take your dare any time since that's exactly what they currently do :) > There is a big difference in veg as well. So for those posters to say there is no real difference clearly have never eaten on a farm. Grew up on/around farms as well. My parents are organic vegetable farmers. Blind taste tests prove the difference is highly variable. Some items (tomatoes in particular) are quite obvious, other items you can tell no difference.
- 9y ago
- perl4ever 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brucellosis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brucellosis
- jsemrau 9y agoI'm with you. My family in Japan is living extremely countryside. Most of the immediate friends are farmers for generations. So we get access to fresh eggs, strawberries, blueberries, onions, and milk on a quality level that is off the charts. Their products never end up in supermarkets. Still they exist. Is it a lifestyle choice? It yes, it is not an active one.
- syedkarim 9y ago>>animals that are loved like family What about the calves that are taken away from their mothers (and mothers that have their calves taken from them) for that fucking good milk?
- metamet 9y ago> They want to distinguish themselves and buy the feeling of authentic life and values. More than this, I think there is a substantial portion of consumers who aren't as much attempting to distinguish themselves as they are realizing how important their dollar vote is. Buying from a small or local farm keeps money circulating locally (ideally). When there is a community of local businesses, this becomes amplified. It's the primary reason why the whole "farm to table" concept with restaurants caught on. By choosing to eat at a diner that gets their eggs from a local farm, rather than, say, buying a breakfast sandwich from McDonalds, you're not only supporting the local restaurant, but also the local farmer. So while there is certainly an appeal (not exclusively, either) to purchasing something labeled as classic, authentic, natural or original, there's a less selfish reasoning tied to the root of it. An interesting part of this is the way primarily Liberal-metro local/organic movements have been ignored as a common ground, and even mocked as purely an aesthetic, by the "anti-globalists".
- huehehue 9y agoThere's at least a third explanation as well, which is the fact that eggs from farmer Tom down the road are likely to taste 1000x better than the egg-inspired food product in a McGriddle. I can't imagine many people are thinking "Screw local farmers, I want Tyson Chicken Nuggets!". That might be a bad example but the point is that cost is probably the bigger factor here, not politics or lifestyle or even taste.
- krrrh 9y agoI’m not disagreeing with the trust of your comment, but despite popular belief, McDonalds does use real eggs.[1,2] Though there’s no doubt that an egg from a chicken who has walked around, eating bits of grass and bugs, will taste better and have a better nutritional profile. [1] https://yourquestions.mcdonalds.ca/answer/does-your-egg-mcmuffin-use-real-eggs-they-look-too-perfect/ https://yourquestions.mcdonalds.ca/answer/does-your-egg-mcmu... [2] https://www.cnbc.com/2015/01/27/are-mcdonalds-eggs-real-fast-food-giant-cracks-mystery.html https://www.cnbc.com/2015/01/27/are-mcdonalds-eggs-real-fast...
- hkmurakami 9y agoThis reminds me of what an operator of a small, high end, boutique winery told me: "we sell a lifestyle"
- afpx 9y agoHmm. To this unfashionable middle-aged guy, that sounds too complicated. I buy local produce simply because it often tastes better. And, I can afford to pay 50% more for better taste. I guess you could spin it to describe it as a lifestyle choice - my boring, middle-aged lifestyle. Like, my ‘I buy costco toilet paper’ lifestyle. That seems like a stretch. Or, maybe not.
- astura 9y agoJust because some people buy local produce for lifestyle reasons doesn't mean that's the reason everyone does.
- digitalengineer 9y agoIf you think it will taste better, it will... (taste is based on more than your tongue).
- steve-benjamins 9y agoIt’s not psychosomatic- fresh vegetables taste much better. A salad that was picked the morning of is much different.
- thevardanian 9y agoBuying tomatoes even from wholefoods vs literally getting them freshly picked is a world of a difference. Carrots that come from Costco vs. carrots that were picked yesterday make a world of a difference. Onions look, and taste better than the ones you get in bulk. And I can go on. I've made side by side comparisons of both, and regardless of how you feel, I know personally that buying even the "organic" wholefoods variety of produce is a lot worse than freshly delivered CSA from a farm.
- liveoneggs 9y agoLook, gramps, you either fit into the box or you don't matter. Get with the program and start buying your groceries from costco or your toilet paper from apple. Also watch "Raise the Steaks" episode of King of the Hill.
- kyleblarson 9y agoSo if I switch from drinking Racer 5 to drinking Budweiser I won't be able to tell the difference?
- bordercases 9y agoYou'd only tell the difference if it was Guinness http://isomorphismes.faith/post/54831080606/perception-is-reality-any-beer-drinker-who-is http://isomorphismes.faith/post/54831080606/perception-is-re...
- rmason 9y agoMost farmers are producing a commodity and there efficiency will win out every time over the small farmer. But farm to table restaurants are willing to pay a premium for a steady local supply. Some people are willing to pay a premium for organic and non-GMO produce. The small farmer is able to do something the larger farmer is unable or unwilling to do and receives a much higher price for it. Small farms are exploding in Detroit. But they're having a problem getting title to the land they're farming. https://www.pri.org/stories/2016-03-30/black-farmers-detroit-are-growing-their-own-food-theyre-having-trouble-owning https://www.pri.org/stories/2016-03-30/black-farmers-detroit...
- crimsonalucard 9y agoAny developers have aquaponics systems setup? I've been thinking of doing this.
- iancmceachern 9y agoLots of exciting things going on in this space. There is also an Open Source Movement that came out of the MiT Media Lab, called OpenAg (https://www.media.mit.edu/groups/open-agriculture-openag/ove... https://www.media.mit.edu/groups/open-agriculture-openag/ove...) which has created a platform for folks like our company, Open Agriculture Supply (https://www.openagriculturesupply.com/ https://www.openagriculturesupply.com/) to create "Food Computers" which are climate controlled boxes that grow food for you indoors. All open source, all on the same platform. The future of farming is indoors, distributed, hyper local, and vertical. Also check out the book that started it all "The Vertical Farm" by Dr. Dickson Despommier.
- crimsonalucard 9y agoI'm talking about a different space. A closed loop farming ecosystem where plants filter water and fish fertilize plants. There's a lot piping and artificial structure to facilitate this type of environment but the control system is largely self regulating, there is less need for a computer to intervene, although it wouldn't hurt. See: http://homeaquaponicssystem.com/basics/hydroponics-vs-aquaponics-which-is-better/ http://homeaquaponicssystem.com/basics/hydroponics-vs-aquapo... In my research, aquaponics is the most nutrient dense farming system available. My eventual goal is to produce a farming system that can live on a single typical suburban property, function with minimal care and produce enough yield to feed a single family. That's right, Fish and veggies on my plate from my farm, daily. The openAg platform seems great, however to make it fit with aquaponics it would need pH control system and a separate tank for fish.
- TomK32 9y agoAnd at the very opposite end the big retails create their own brands that sound traditional and farm-ish while the food is purely industrial. I buy at the farmer market because it's great to know the people who produce the food I eat.
- astura 9y agoFarmers markets are ripe with the same deception https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/09/24/deception-at-the-farmers-market/ https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/09/24/deception-at-the-f... http://www.tampabay.com/projects/2016/food/farm-to-fable/farmers-markets/ http://www.tampabay.com/projects/2016/food/farm-to-fable/far...
- bharath28 9y agoFor those who are interested in the topic, i just finished reading this: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3109.The_Omnivore_s_Dile.. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3109.The_Omnivore_s_Dile.... The author follows the ingredients of a meal he makes all the way back to the farms. He seems to romanticize certain notions of naturally grown foods and at other times, is given to polemic against the agriculturally industrial complex (quite justifiably at times). The book itself was a lesson in the history of agriculture, nutrition, politics, policy, cooking, animal husbandry and the organic food industry. There is a part of the book where he talks about the huge industrial setup behind organic food and tries to distinguish it from the vicissitudes of the small scale farmers life. He even turns into a hunter gatherer for a little to experience life as it was before agriculture. It was a totally fascinating read and i recommend it.
- imhoguy 9y agoThanks. Working link to the book: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3109.The_Omnivore_s_Dilemma https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3109.The_Omnivore_s_Dile...
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIf/when the economy has a major hiccup all those sellers of "distinguished" goods will have a very hard time because people will pay their mortgages first even if that means drinking PBR and eating GMO grown frozen broccoli. The upper middle class aren't a very stable or loyal set of customers.
- PeachPlum 9y agoI think you're wrong. Look up Justin Rhodes on YouTube or Joel Salatin. Small holding is profitable once you get over the hump and get customers
- why15characters 9y ago>Justin Rhodes 75 acres is not a smallholding. And he makes his living selling "how to do the farming I pretend to do on youtube" courses, not farming. >Joel Salatin 550 acres is really not a smallholding. At least he is actually a farmer though.
- Zarath 9y agoLarge corporations introduce massive negative externalities (Walmart employees are on welfare, sugar industry hides and fakes scientific research, advertising). If you contribute to small, local businesses, it's very easy to hold them accountable if they do something bad (they don't have the protection of corrupt governments, for example).