5 ms·
I was gobsmacked when I asked as a postdoc: "How do new species evolve" and was told: "something something physical seperation between breeding populations lead
by dekhn 9y ago
I was gobsmacked when I asked as a postdoc: "How do new species evolve" and was told: "something something physical seperation between breeding populations leading to breeding incompatibilities, but we don't really know something something"
- otp124 9y agoSo they couldn’t give you evidence, just assumptions?
- Retric 9y agoTheir is plenty of evidence for population drift. Why did native Americans have a different skin coloration than the rest of the world? Remember, the land bridge was recent and humans with a long reproductive cycle still had very noticeable drift over ~1,000 generations. Which was not simply adaptation like reducing pigmentation when moving North. Genetic incompatibility is actually rather difficult to understand in detail as in what specifically stops working and why that occurred, but easy to understand at a high level.
- EGreg 9y agoExactly. The biggest real example I know of is ring species. Everything else seems to be total handwaving. In fact "evolution" is just an umbrella term for many different theories about how speciation happens. I have no problem with the theory of common ancestry. That has a lot of proof. But the idea that speciation happens EXCLUSIVELY by random mutation and "natural selection" is just handwaving theorizing. It's super hard to prove and we haven't even begun to get close to what constitutes as a proof. It's on the level of ancient people thinking the ONLY way to get fire is by rubbing some sticks together. And yet I see the latter ("natural selection") being used by many in the scientific community to suppress other theories even though it is completely handwavy and vague. That is bullying. Basically common descent can be rigorously defined and shown. The PROCESS by which speciation happens is poorly understood and has been a subject of much posturing by the scientific community (including popularizers like Dawkins) for decades. (PS: if you're going to knee jerk downvote this because it criticizes "evolution", at least address it with substance.)
- Retric 9y agoWhat is your specific objection? Their is plenty of examples where even short term separation results in population drift: EX: Skin tone among native Americans is unique even with only ~1,000 generations separating the land bridge from modern times. In the short term this may be adaptation to a new envornment but eventually random mutation takes over. Their is evidence that closely related members may have difficulty breading with anything from 1% reductions in fertility to 99%. Which arguably makes them the same species as they can still in theory breed. However, adaptation can make it's own issues. Grizzly's + Polar bears is a solid example where offspring is fertile but poorly adapted to either of their parents environment. So, now you have examples of drops in fertility and reductions in reproductive success as populations are separated. Nothing is going to stop this process from hitting zero net fertility and thus a new species.
- EGreg 9y agoMy objection is just that: genetic drift != speciation. They are still completely interfertile with Europeans after 1000 generstions! Yet here we have a breathless article reporting noting more than an existing male from a "separate species", which is in fact interfertile and had viable offspring, as being proof of "evolution"! We don't know how speciation happens, and many people including scientists use a lot of unscientific "just so" stories. To claim we know that every instance of speciation happens through 1. random mutation and 2. "natural selection", a catch-all term which is not well-defined and signifies very little, is not very scientific. But worse than that, it is then conflated with the theory of common descent, and the emergent sociological result is that many scientists and non-scientists constantly co-opt the word "evolution" to say "evolution is true and creationism is therefore false" or whatever. There have been different theories such as punctuated equilibria but we don't actually KNOW how speciation happens. It's all posturing and catch-all terms.
- Retric 9y ago1,000 generations is an incredibly short period ed: genetically. Dinosaurs to people is ~20,000,000 generations depending on changes in reproductive cycles likely significantly more than that. The shocking thing is how many differences showed up not that we are still mostly though again not 100% comparable. Remember, fertility treatments among young people are a thing and incompatibility first shows up as an increase in the natural abortion (miscarriage) rate ~(30% to 50%). You can find set's of people such that A/B and C/D are more fertile than A/D or C/B.