3 ms·
So I was chatting to my 8 yo about this and he made the analogy that as in 2D we have infinite numbers of polygons meaning that at the limit a circle would be a
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
So I was chatting to my 8 yo about this and he made the analogy that as in 2D we have infinite numbers of polygons meaning that at the limit a circle would be a polygon of infinite sides(?), to 3D where a sphere would be a polyhedron with infinite faces ... I can't really see a flaw there except through definition.
Or do we say that the circle itself is not in the set of polygons?
In other words why isn't a sphere a platonic solid?
- ajnin 9y agoThat's what the article is about, you can divide a circle in an infinite number of polygons, but, somewhat unintuitively, you can't do that with spheres, only 5 divisions are possible ! If you try with hexagons, for example, you'll find that you can't join them without distorting them.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI only got as far as 'Approximations' before we started chatting. I can entirely understand it not working for polygons "tiling" the sphere up until they become infinitesimal, at which point they'd occupy all points on the sphere.
- kybernetikos 9y agoBut what shape are you using for your tiles?
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoUm, I thought it didn't matter, that's like how long is the point that you make a curve out of when you're integrating to determine the length of a functions curve. But we could say square (or any shape that will tile a 2D plane), because at the limit as the side approaches zero, on the surface of a sphere, any region looks like a flat 2D plane? I'm flying by the seat of my pants a bit here [in case you couldn't tell], it's a long time since I did any formal maths.
- maweki 9y agoIt doesn't actually work in 2D for infinity, just for arbitrarily large integers (and there is an infinite amount of them). If it actually were infinite, three "neighbouring" points wouldn't actually describe a face but just a point, since they all fall onto each other. You could look at the Banach–Tarski paradox for a better understanding. "Half" the set of points is still enough to describe a sphere since there are infinitely many.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoSurely then there's arbitrarily large numbers of polygons but not infinite, because if they're infinite then the spacing between points will be zero? In Banach-Tarski In thought that the assemblage of points relied on creating, eg, a new pair of spheres that worked under different non-Euclidean measures. But I'll need to review it, it's outside my domain (heh!).
- maweki 9y agoI was trying to convey that a sphere-sphere is an infinite amount of points with some unintuitive properties, like half the points are still an infinite amount. For a set of faces defined by an arbitrarily large but finite subset of points of the sphere, the important properties no longer hold.
- kuschku 9y ago> Surely then there's arbitrarily large numbers of polygons but not infinite, because if they're infinite then the spacing between points will be zero? If we describe the set of these polgons as P, then |P| = |N|, for N referring to the Natural Numbers. This is usually called "abzählbar unendlich" (countable infinite).
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoThat's kinda my point, if there are aleph_0 polygons, then surely the length of a side has to tend to 0. As you increase the number of vertices then the difference between the points occupied by the vertices and those of a coincidental circle reduces, ultimately the vertices must describe a circle if they form a set of size aleph_0? If you want the sides of the polygons to have a length then the polygons, to me, seem necessarily to be unable to have an infinite number of vertices, they could only have a very large number but one necessarily less than infinity. Perhaps it's my misunderstanding how a curve works? If you form a second set from an infinite number of equally spaced points between two arbitrary points on a continuous curve (the first set) then it seems, to me [ie intuitively, always a risk in maths], that the second set must also be a continuous curve? The corollary of that would seem to be that if you have an infinite number of vertices for your polygon it also forms a circle, to not form a circle it simply has to have a number of sides less than infinite. My contention would then be that either the set of polytopes in 2D is < aleph_0 or the set in 3D is 6 (ie applying the same rules makes circles and spheres both parts of the set of polytopes in the particular n-dimensional space).
- trentmb 9y agoBecause each side would need to have the 'length' of a point- > In particular, the geometric points do not have any length, area, volume or any other dimensional attribute. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Point_%28geometry%29 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Point_%28geometry%29