8 ms·
Faecal transplant effectively treats recurrent or unresponsive Clostridium diff
- cpncrunch 9y agoNo it doesnt. Placebo controlled trials show it has no effect. Im surprised at the nhs for this shoddy review.
- linkmotif 9y agoYou mean shitty review?
- elsherbini 9y agoHere's a randomized trial with placebos that did work. I wasn't able to find one where it didn't work. http://annals.org/aim/article-abstract/2545886/effect-fecal-microbiota-transplantation-recurrence-multiply-recurrent-clostridium-difficile-infection http://annals.org/aim/article-abstract/2545886/effect-fecal-...
- cpncrunch 9y agoI submitted on a while back. Will check later if people reverse the downvotes and assume good faith.
- AndrewDucker 9y agoYou'll provide evidence for your claims if people down downvote you for making claims without evidence? I'm not terribly impressed by that approach.
- cpncrunch 9y agoIn my world people ask politely for refs or search for it themselves, rather than downvoting first (which is saying "your comment isn't worth reading"). I got up out of bed, posted a comment and was going to look for the link later if people asked. (I did a quick search and didn't find it). However, from the comments here, it's pretty clear people aren't interested in the science. Carry on...
- icebraining 9y agoIs this the post you're referring to? "There have been a total of 2 placebo-controlled trials into fecal transplants for C.Diff AFAIK. One showed some benefit over placebo, and the other showed no difference." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10679823#10680173 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10679823#10680173
- epmaybe 9y agoIn case people can't read the article as it's behind a paywall, it's not the primary source. However, to summarize the differences, this one study should not be representative of fact, as it very well could be that in the trial that did not show any benefit, patients could have had very aggressive treatment prior to beginning the study, and thus may have already been clinically cured prior to the study actually beginning. I would definitely trust the OPs meta analysis and systematic review of multiple different trials before believing this placebo controlled trial, for a number of reasons: 1. What I already mentioned above regarding the conflicting results of these two placebo controlled trials 2. The studies used in the nhs article are all done for patients that we're currently undergoing treatment for c diff, not after a long treatment time. 3. Meta analyses and systematic reviews are always going to be higher powered statistically speaking. As long as the papers looked at don't stink of publication bias it's a very valid way of looking at all the research done on fecal transplants for c diff.
- jimrandomh 9y agoChecking the meta-analysis paper on sci-hub, Fig. 2 has 7 RCTs, all of which found large effect sizes. I think you're simply mistaken. http://sci-hub.bz/http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/apt.14201/full http://sci-hub.bz/http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111...
- cpncrunch 9y agoI think you didnt read it. It says there were no placebo controlled trials.
- foobar1234567 9y ago"The benefits, risks, burdens, and effectiveness of the new methods should be tested against those of the best current prophylactic, diagnostic, and therapeutic methods. This does not exclude the use of placebo or no treatment in studies where no proven prophylactic, or therapeutic methods exist." World Medical Association (WMA) Declaration of Helsinki. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2647647/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2647647/ for more.
- rm2889 9y agoAre you familiar with c diff? Placebo's don't work. It's dangerous to have placebo controlled trials with this disease. The current standard of care is a course of very strong antibiotics which still leave > 25% chance of recurrence. These antibiotics are most often used as a control group in c diff infections. In general, placebo controlled trials are usually conducted for diseases which don't have an effective standard of care, or for conditions which aren't serious enough to be considered life threatening. For more serious diseases where a standard of care exists (standard of care is usually scientifically discovered but validated by placebo controlled trials), you conduct trials and compare the performance of the new drug/therapy with the existing standard of care as the control group.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoYup. It's like wanting placebo controlled trials for cancer. It would be unethical and ungodly harmful to condemn people to suffering and death just so people could gather data that wouldn't even compare the results to the current best practices.
- ipunchghosts 9y agoAre you thinking of IBS?
- cpncrunch 9y agoNo, Clostridium difficile (Kelly et al, 2016, as discussed in the comments above).
- throwawayfmt 9y agoAny time someone points out crap science and the placebo effect on HN they get downvoted to hell. I'm not sure if people on HN just don't understand the placebo effect or don't want to, but it's usually best not to mention it here.
- jacobkg 9y agoI have had C Diff. It is extraordinarily unpleasant. In addition to the normal symptoms it also came with extreme fatigue and a weird sense of doom about the future. The antibiotics need to be taken every 6 hours (limiting your ability to sleep) and gave me really creepy dreams. Being stuck with recurrent C Diff sounds miserable and I'm so glad that people in that position have a way out
- srednalfden 9y agoI don’t want to make you relive the dreams, but can you elaborate on “creepy”?
- superb_herb 9y agoI have “creepy” dreams or nightmares that ruin restful sleep. They are exceptionally vivid and nightmarish: horrifying scenarios involving people I love, painfully realistic doomsday scenarios, all kinds of death, monsters who look like people but with horrifying deformities...
- PoachedSausage 9y agoThink of the most weird fever dream you've had and that is probably similar. I think one of the stranger fever dream I've had was sometime in college when I was learning about complex numbers, the red standby LED on the TV in my room seemed to be a portal into the complex plane one feverish night. Having also tried a number psychedelics, fever dreams do have quite a different quality to them.
- bitwize 9y agoOne time I dosed up on pseudoephedrine to help with a particularly nasty flu, fell asleep, and dreamed I was watching a disturbing cartoon. It was very slapstick and "wacky", like a Tex Avery cartoon, but something was... off about it, and it was horrifying.
- muramira 9y agoI bet the faecal transplant after thanksgiving would have cured 100% of the recipients!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- maxxxxx 9y agoI know two people who had serious problems for many years and recovered after doing fecal transplants. Placebo or not, I would recommend it to people who can't be helped by regular medicine. Certainly worth a try.
- cdiffthrow 9y agoThrowaway account -- I had recurrant c-diff for the better part of 2 years. For a while I had accepted that I would just be taking Vancomycin for the rest of my life. Thankfully I was able to get into a study at the U of Minnesota doing transplants. The first one didn't 'stick' and the c-diff repopulated within 6 months, but after the second one I've been clear of it. Horrible stuff. Worsened my Crohn's disease by a large amount.
- jesperlang 9y agoThis is a super interesting topic but the cynical side of me thinks it doesn't get enough attention because you can't patent bacteria(?).. For more on this, checkout the work of Martin Blaser https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KwK_O0ahDKo&t=168 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KwK_O0ahDKo&t=168
- jungletime 9y agoI wonder to what extent is Obesity contagious. If you can improve your gut bacteria, surely you can make it worse. Can you pick up gut bacteria from Obese people. Maybe going to the gym helps you lose weight because you touch surfaces and pick up bacteria from fit people. And so on. Just conjecture.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI don’t think obesity itself is contagious (unless you’re mucking about in an obese person’s fecal matter). My hunch is antibiotic usage disrupts your gut biome enough that it pushes your energy extraction balance off, causing obesity. As a society, we abuse antibiotics in the aggregate (demanding it from health care providers and pouring it into factory farms). It can’t possibly not be disrupting our guy biome. It also doesn’t help that the sugar lobby/industry is so powerful, and sugar/corn syrup is in everything.
- eru 9y agoI don't think it's the energy extraction that's changing, but people's set points for weight. > It also doesn’t help that the sugar lobby/industry is so powerful, and sugar/corn syrup is in everything. Corn syrup ain't good, but we have fat people in other parts of the world, too.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoRapidly increasing obesity rates seem to be associated with a first world/western diet.
- alexanderstears 9y agoAnd you don't need High Fructose Corn Syrup for a first world/western diet, but it does make the first world/western diet more affordable. Imo the 'western diet' is a bit of a misnomer. I don't eat like my European ancestors - who primarily ate grain and vegetables because they were poor peasants. In the week prior to thanksgiving, I've ate chana masala, sushi, pizza, hamburgers, pad thai, corn dogs, rice and beans, tortas, and burritos - collectively, those options are only available in the first world. What's 'western' about it is that the west is the only place you can get all those meals in a town of 100k/people. It's not western in the sense that there's something greco-roman about oreos. My hunch is that the variety of food really throws people for a loop. If you ate vegetable soup and bread all day, it'd be very easy to know the proper amount to eat. However, good luck pattern matching sushi, corn dogs, and rice and beans - and most people seem predisposed to overeat in light of uncertainty. I've struggled with binge eating in the past and I've changed my default meal to that of rice and beans and after an adjustment period, I've never had a binge eating episode on rice and beans. It's hypothesized that people have a set point that they eat up to, and there's something about a wide variety of food that makes it hard to feel like you've hit that set point. And some food (e.g Frito Lay snack food) is designed to increase your appetite. I've done a lot of research into nutrition - and discount my opinion because I have 0 medical training and functionally 0 training in biology - but my 'hunch' is that most people would do well to eat like their ancestors.
- stevebmark 9y agoFluoroquinolone antibiotics (cipro, levaquin, etc) are dangerous and horrific, and irreversibly destroy gut bacteria. This article is about fluoroquinolones, which are well documented to cause C.Diff infections because they destroy most gut bacteria except C.Diff, allowing it to overrun.
- ilamont 9y agoAfter initial “cure” of Clostridium difficile with antibiotics, about 15-25% of patients develop a recurrence within a few days to several months. The chance of a recurrence depends in large part on the type of antibiotic being taken, such as Flagyl, Vanco, or Dificid, as well as the age of the patient. This repeat infection can keep on recurring, even after multiple courses of antibiotics. We have seen some unfortunate patients with 10 or more attacks of C. diff in a two-year period. It can lead to chronic diarrhea, weight loss, and diminished quality of life. We think that recurrence of C. diff depends on a “Perfect Storm” of several factors: 1. Simultaneous failure of the immune system with inadequate antibody formation 2. Failure of the colonic flora to regenerate, owing to exposure to antibiotics. Failure of the immune system to generate an antibody response is quite common after age 60. The older the patient, the weaker the response to an infection or to vaccination http://cdiff.in30minutes.com/recurrent-c-diff-why-does-c-diff-sometimes-keep-coming-back/ http://cdiff.in30minutes.com/recurrent-c-diff-why-does-c-dif...
- chmike 9y agoI new someone with serious repetitive (daily) diarrhea. Not treatment helped and it lasted for years. Doctors had no solution. Don't know if it was Clostridium Difficile. It started after taking a medication. One day, a solution was found on Internet. It was to eat cheese made with raw milk. After three months eating various cheese with raw milk every day, the person had no more diarrhea. This has to be done in country with strict health control on cheese production.
- phonon 9y agoDrinking Kefir is easier and better.
- kazinator 9y agoAncient Chinese yellow soup! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fecal_microbiota_transplant#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fecal_microbiota_transplant#Hi... Orally administered, too.
- aaronheid 9y agoI happen to remember that I read on a rosecea forum two people doing faecal transplant on their own at home to cure their rosacea, the result was total relief.
- amelius 9y agoThere seems to be a correlation between gut balance and lifespan, in animal models, [1]. I wonder if a suitable fecal transplant could (somehow) promote longevity. [1] https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/01/140116130646.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/01/140116130646.h...
- BVthrowaway 9y agoI recall reading a similar clinical trial involving bacterial vaginosis. In BV, vaginal bacteria are imbalanced and thus it was hypothesized that transplanting healthy flora would be helpful.