8 ms·
Argentina says abnormal noise heard after submarine's last contact as hopes fade
- nasredin 9y agoThis reminds me of Kursk, the Russian sub. Specifically the third-world government fumbling the response to the missing submarine. Considering the USN had two deadly above-surface collisions recently it is either a miracle or speaks to the professionalism of the submariners in avoiding these deadly accidents. (Unfortunately not in this case)
- positr0n 9y agoI'd think surface collisions would happen a lot more than underwater collisions with the same level of professionalism/carelessness due to 1. There are way more surface craft than submarines 2. For a surface crash two boats need to be in the same point in 2D space. For an underwater crash two subs also need to be at the same depth in the water column.
- entropie 9y agoSurface collisons happen more often than one might think.
- dogruck 9y agoA couple US Navy ships have recently had them IIRC.
- nradov 9y agoDuring the Cold War there were multiple underwater collisions with Soviet submarines. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/jan/25/nuclear-submarine-collision-cold-war-cia-scotland https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/jan/25/nuclear-subm... http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/1992-russian-nuclear-attack-submarine-slammed-american-sub-18735 http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/1992-russian-nucle...
- cmdkeen 9y agoUsually because the Western submarine was tailing them at the time, a fundamentally risky business. There was a collision between UK and French SSBNs on patrol a few years back, and indication as to how quiet they can be - and SSBNs warrant the absolutely best ASW technology and techniques. An SSK, like the one missing, that has lost power isn't going to be making any sound at all unless the crew are doing it. If it is on the bottom you're essentially going to have to do a sea bed survey. The UK's Holland 1 submarine was lost under tow in 1913 only 1.5 miles outside Plymouth breakwater and remained undetected until 1981.
- fiftyacorn 9y agoThere were amazing cold war submarine battles during the cold war. Not full fighting, but skirmishing. There was a story of a UK submarine which stole the communications turret off a USSR submarine. It was classified for years - but this sort of thing is slowly being declassified
- nasredin 9y agoNot a collision but I always find the "Whiskey on the Rocks" grounding amusing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_submarine_S-363 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_submarine_S-363
- ubernostrum 9y agoSpecifically the third-world government fumbling the response to the missing submarine. Nitpick: I know the connotations it's picked up since then, but the term "third world" still should not be used to describe Russia. As coined, the "first world" was NATO + NATO-aligned nations (so, US and US allies/sphere of influence); the "second world" was the Warsaw Pact + aligned nations (so, USSR and USSR allies/sphere of influence); and the "third world" was the nations not included in the first two classifications, and in which the US/USSR tended to try to cultivate ties or fight proxy wars with each other.
- nwrk 9y agoLet me express deep solidary and hope for the crew and families. On technical note, I keep wondering with all the technology available (satelites, sonars, airplans, thermo, etc.), how is it possible that they are not able to find / detect it ? Understand weather conditions are rough. And this is the case of multi nations collaboration (best of the best ?). Looks like submarine is very very powerfull attack vector. (?) EDIT: Update from Guardian "Justifying the delay, navy chiefs said that military protocol advises a 48-hour waiting period before beginning search efforts for submarines lost at sea." [0]https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/nov/22/search-for-missing-argentinian-submarine-enters-critical-phase https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/nov/22/search-for-mis...
- Cyberdog 9y ago> how is it possible that they are not able to find / detect it ? The ocean is a very large thing, especially when it needs to be searched in three dimensions.
- DuskStar 9y agoEven more so when the thing you're searching for is intended to be hard to find.
- icelancer 9y ago>>three dimensions This is definitely the big snag people lose themselves on. They are thinking about the search being in two dimensions, like a map. They aren't thinking about lost ships or planes in three dimensions; a formula squared vs. a formula cubed and how much faster the latter gets out of hand.
- averagewall 9y agoBut we know it's either on the bottom or the surface right? It needs to use power to balance in the middle somewhere.
- NikolaeVarius 9y ago
- averagewall 9y agoFor those of you who feel sad for strangers that you never knew existed until now, why not direct your feelings to something productive like looking through local obituaries and contacting their survivors to show some support and kindness? There are real human beings dying all around us but they don't have dramatic movie-style deaths so we don't care. Even better, don't wait till they're dead. Go and seek out old, sick, and lonely people and make them feel better. I think news-cycle internet sadness drains our capacity to care about others while also doing nothing for those who died or who're genuinely sad about it. The sinking submarine is interesting, the people on it aren't.
- cgmg 9y agoThat sounds like a false dilemma.
- averagewall 9y agoNot false - we have limited capacity to care about people so we have to make tradeoffs. If anything, just because of the time it takes up. More people die each day than we could even name if that was our full time job. That's not even counting the possible emotional limits on people. So why not spend your limited caring on someone who's ignored by the world and didn't even put themselves in danger, even better if it's someone who's not a professional killer like these victims were.
- Boothroid 9y agoWhatever happened I hope for the submariners' sake it was quick.
- teniutza 9y agoMy total knowledge regarding submarines is practically 0. I have a (somewhat) technical question that I hope my better qualified fellow readers can answer. Are there any "distress call devices" which are/could be used in such situations? If not, what would the technical difficulties be, for creating and vertically launching a torpedo equipped with a beacon? If the sub is unable to move and/or broadcast, the beacon would begin transmitting when reaching the surface. I would imagine that launching such a beacon (visual & GPS & ...) would reduce the search area.
- koliber 9y agoThere is a device called an EPIRB that is often carried on sailboats. It is a floating radio transmitter that contacts a global satellite network in case of emergencies. It transmits a distress signal as well as its location. It can be manually activated. It also activates automatically on contact with water. I would imagine it would be possible to create an EPIRB-like device for submarines.
- NikolaeVarius 9y agoSubmarines do have the EPIRB. This submarine was also confirmed to be equipped with one. One of the reasons that this disappearance was weird was that there wasn't even a trace of the EPIRB activating on this sub so we're not even sure if it "sank" https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/11/us-navy-sends-underwater-robots-to-assist-in-search-for-argentine-sub/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/11/us-na...
- gruturo 9y ago(some) Submarines have one or more emergency beacons which automatically detach if they reach crush depth, rising to the surface and starting to transmit. In a very shallow area the sub might be sitting on the bed but not below crush depth, so the buoy would not automatically detach. Of course it can also be operated by the crew, but it's really an absolute last resort thing.
- squarefoot 9y agoAs someone who knows nothing about submariners, I wonder if they could have "reprogrammed" a torpedo to explode at a safe distance shortly after launch, that is without a target, in order to produce enough noise and attract attention in their area. Could seismograph networks or satellites pinpoint such an event?
- tbihl 9y agoThe biggest issue I see with this: they presumably suffered a loss of all electric, and in that case they're going to have limited pressure in their hydraulic systems. Hydraulics are probably responsible for both steering and torpedo launches, and you're going to give priority to maneuvering in this situation.