3 ms·
> Resisting this is simple FUD? There's some psychology at work as well. Say self-driving cars cut the road accident and fatality rate in half but in the remai
by criddell 9y ago
> Resisting this is simple FUD?
There's some psychology at work as well. Say self-driving cars cut the road accident and fatality rate in half but in the remaining incidents, half of those are driver error but the rest are all due to hardware and software problems.
I think a lot of people would have a problem if half of all fatalities are due to system glitches even if the net result is fewer deaths and I don't think that's entirely unreasonable.
- ghaff 9y agoIt will also be somewhat new ground. As I've noted before, there are relatively few examples of consumer-facing technologies/products where properly maintained and used (or sometimes even misused) products kill and maim--and people are just fine with that because "stuff happens" and the cost/benefit is reasonable. Drug interactions are one of the relatively few areas today and even those often lead to lawsuits. (And the US even basically indemnifies drug companies against side effects from standard childhood vaccines.)
- criddell 9y agoMaybe self-driving car companies should be indemnified for anything other than gross-negligence until the technology matures a little.
- MBCook 9y agoThat will probably have to happen at some point. My big concern is we’ve seen how reckless companies have been (Samsung with Note 7 batteries, Facebook/Twitter with the election, AirBNB(?) with reviews about unsafe places, Uber with basically everything...) I don’t want those companies making self driving cars without strong oversight. ‘Move fast and break things’ has done a lot of damage over the last few years. I don’t want them to be allowed to apply that strategy to cars. We couldn’t trust their judgement for simpler things, the risk is way too high for cars.
- nsgi 9y agoCigarettes are probably the best example, they look a lot more people than cars.
- ghaff 9y agoThey're an example although I would argue that, in this case, "properly used" equates to not used at all. Also cigarettes were the subject of long drawn-out legal cases and a substantial settlement so they're something of a unique product.
- leadingthenet 9y ago> I think a lot of people would have a problem if half of all fatalities are due to system glitches even if the net result is fewer deaths and I don't think that's entirely unreasonable. Why is it not unreasonable?
- MBCook 9y agoBecause you’re preventing 30k deaths that would have happened but causing 8k that wouldn’t... it seems fair for people to be mad about that 8k. Maybe we shouldn’t have rushed into things until that number was way smaller. ‘Diverless cars cause 30% of road fatalities’ is not a good headline.
- leadingthenet 9y agoIt’s still a huge net reduction in deaths anyway you look at it, and there are huge gains in other areas (speed, covenience). I remain very unmoved by that argument. I’d rather be hit by software than a human. At least I know we did as much as we could to alleviate the problem.
- MBCook 9y agoI’m not arguing it’s perfectly logical. If people behaved that way the sunk cost fallacy wouldn’t exist. I think it would be a real problem. If the death count becomes non-trivial before the death count from people becomes relatively trivial I think there’s will be a big mess in the media.
- gowld 9y agoIt's all in the spin: ‘Drivered cars cause 70% of road fatalities’ is not a good headline for drivers.
- MBCook 9y agoThat’s not new. Right now that number is 100%. People just accept it as status quo. But people would be outraged by the 30% number.