9 ms·
> Very unconvincing article. Would have been better if it had stuck to the core assertion that Sure is. In the parts of the world where I'm living (EasternEuro
by paganel 9y ago
> Very unconvincing article. Would have been better if it had stuck to the core assertion that
Sure is. In the parts of the world where I'm living (EasternEurope - Northern Balkans) the retreat of the Romans and the subsequent waves of migratory peoples sure as hell looked like a civilisational collapse, even archaeologically. When the Romans were here they had indoor bathrooms and heating, they had writing, they had amphitheaters, but after they left (or were wiped out, no-one knows for sure), which happened roughly between 250 CE and 300 CE, then another 600-700 years would pass until writing would make its archaeological presence felt again (around year 1000), ~1400-1500 years until regular theater shows would be held again (in the late 1700s) and even now half of the country doesn't have indoor bathrooms like the Romans did (my parents don't, for example).
- Retric 9y agoIndoor bathrooms did not go away on some specific Tuesday, they also where not that common around 250 CE. The real question is what happens to the 98% of the population that actually maintain day to day civilization not what happens to the people who make it into history books even as a footnote of a footnote.
- marcosdumay 9y agoThey very likely did. It takes a single small war for destroying what is already constructed, and then the population realizes they can't build those anymore because the know-how is dispersed, and many key people aren't around anymore.
- Retric 9y agoI don't think this was a know how thing so much as an efficiency issue. If you're rich you can have a servant to draw water and maintain a chaimber pot easily. However, having indoor plumbing in an area that freezes is a complex issue that requires a lot of infrastructure and maintenance. Outside of novelty factor the gains seem minimal relative to the costs. Now, indoor plumbing has larger benifits for city's, but again I suspect it was considered not worth the cost instead of simply being 'lost'.
- namlem 9y agoIt probably started with cost due to economic collapse, but eventually people would have lost the know-how as well.
- Retric 9y agoI don't agree that economic collapse is the correct term as it suggests total production drops alongside things like hyperinflation etc. Rome allowed for an incredible amount of wealth transfer, but the total economic output of Europe at say 500CE was not significantly lower than the total economic output of Eurpoe at say 200CE. Watermills were developed by the Romans, but continued to improve though the middle ages. Iron smelting has a long history, but was improved though the middle ages. You can look at a huge range of productivity increases throughout the middle ages as yields improved due to constant innovation.
- quotemstr 9y agoLead refining collapsed after Rome's crisis of the third century. There are Greenland ice cores saying so. Lead production didn't recover to Roman levels until the 16th century. A few individual technologies progressed through the middle ages (but noticably not during the dark ages in the west), but social organization to build large scale projects is also technology, and that technology was utterly lost for a thousand years. Rome had what we would recognize as Adam-Smith-like industry, a market economy, long distance trade, and mass production. It was a surprisingly modern world, and it collapsed. We're basically the second modern world, and we can collapse too.
- Retric 9y agoLead is a very poor proxy for economic development. It was actually known to be somewhat toxic though very useful even back then. And it's use declined in part because people got better at metallurgy not simply because the overall economy declined. Flying buttress are an example of a significant and complex innovation in architecture developed soon after the fall of the Rome. Though it took a while to really develop. So, evidence for 'loss of knowledge' with building large structures is rather simplified. Loss of political and economic structures to build large scale projects is far more clear. Rome at it's peak had ~70 million people across Europe, the middle east, and North Africa. Adding up all the individual peaces after it's fall presents a different story than looking at just Europe while ignoring the huge influx of goods and slaves from other territories.
- yourapostasy 9y ago> ...and then the population realizes they can't build those anymore because the know-how is dispersed, and many key people aren't around anymore. Yes, this is the "civilization has so far been binary-only, not open source" problem I observed when I started looking into reproducing civilization on a space habitat, for an eventual transition into a generation ship. It turns out a heck of a lot of civilizational artifacts are "write many times, read once" across generations: lots of iterative tinkering, used until the next "git commit"-like widespread adoption, then quickly receding from memory. It was once known that longbowmen could shoot arrows curving around an obstacle. Scantly recorded, then the actual skill was forgotten until an archer geek who knew about the obscure written references worked out how to do it again from scratch. So we have that skill in our civilization now, yay. Except: he hasn't published his experiences, fleshed out into lessons for newcomers, etc. If he passes away before doing that, then we're likely to lose that skill again. Piles and piles of human experiential information like this is simply not efficiently recorded, much less transmitted even in our "advanced" civilization today. I'm keen on learning machining and tool making. The more I look into it, the more I realize what is written down barely scratches the surface. Lots of master machinists talk about a feel for doing the job right the first time such that only about 10% of machinists are really good, 20% can follow explicit directions, and the rest should find another line of work. This is I believe the foundation of why civilizations are so brittle and fragile, and so damnably difficult and time-consuming to build back up aspects that are lost. What worries me these days: the elites do not grasp this; if they did, they'd be a fuck ton more scared of war than they are. They'd also be way less sanguine about globalization and losing vast swathes of this binary-only technological know-how. The Shenzhen ecosystem is starting to show that even the "we'll out-innovate them, and they'll 'just' always manufacture our ideas" canard is wearing mighty thin over time. If this feels overwhelming, then it gets worse: just tackle a scaled-down problem space, "prepping" or "self sufficiency", and you quickly realize that at an individual level, the challenges are magnified. You have to wind back the technological level (and quality of life) quite a few centuries before you can reasonably do everything yourself...nearly.
- Retric 9y agoBecause this stuff is discoverable it's less important than you might think. When you have 10's of millions of archers doing that as a job then curving an arrow is not going to stay secret for that long. The really major discoveries of our history are things like a positional number system aka zero. That's the kind of thing that's likely to survive because it's both really useful, easy to teach, and really common. Germ theory might not stick around, but it's really widespread and also both useful and the kind of thing we can pick up again. The jump from an 8080 including an understanding of Quantum Mechanics getting to a modern multi billion transistor i7 is 100's of billions in research. But, going from an 8080's took us less than 100 years and we could do it again assuming a large relatively stable global economy.
- mcguire 9y agoThere's a bit of a difference between "not common" in 250CE and "nowhere to be found" in 600CE. I think I've seen one Lamborghini in the last 20 years. That's a different statement than "there are no running Lamborghinis in existence."