17 ms·
How Politics and Bad Decisions Starved New York’s Subways
- victor106 9y agoI take the subway almost everyday since the past 7 years and its been getting worse. NYC should learn something from Toronto and London. They have the best subway systems IMHO.
- m_ke 9y agoYeah, I recently moved back to queens from the city and what used to be a 30-45 min commute 5-6 years ago now takes me 60-90 minutes.
- polymath21 9y agoIf you think London is good, wait til you try the subway in big Asian cities like Taipei, Tokyo, or Seoul.
- beisner 9y agoDon’t forget the subway lines in basically every Chinese city! Beijing has overcrowding issues, but Shanghai, Chengdu, Guangzhou all have phenomenal metros.
- leroy_masochist 9y agoAs a native New Yorker I was blown away by the Shenzhen subway when I visited last year. It's spotless, easy to navigate (lots of language-free signs with really clear intuitive diagrams of where to go), and almost eerily fast and smooth-riding. And 5 bars of LTE the whole time.
- dagw 9y agoA thing built 6-10 years ago will always be more modern and less run down than a thing built 60-100 years ago. Time will tell how well the Chinese systems age.
- jpatokal 9y agoTokyo's subway turns 90 this year, and while the older stations aren't as flashy as new ones, it remains remarkably efficient & functional.
- mabbo 9y agoEveryone in Toronto loves to complain about the TTC, but the few lines we have here are pretty reliable. We just need to expand the system further. The Eglinton line and the Finch LRT will help.
- allengeorge 9y agoIf you look at the TTC system as a whole it's the streetcar lines that take a lot of flack, but I blame that on: * General age of the fleet (not helped by Bombardier's delayed deliveries) * Lack of dedicated streetcar lanes; it's still shocking to me that streetcars packed full of passengers are allowed to be held up by single-passenger vehicles
- Froyoh 9y agoI'm quite shocked people think Toronto's transit system is on par with London
- throwaway2048 9y agoThe assumption that Toronto is on par with London, NYC or other large metro areas is a common delusion of those living there.
- mabbo 9y agoIt's a matter of population and density, imho. Toronto has mostly low-density housing, with spots of very high density- generally, around subway stations. From a plane the other day, I noticed you can see all the subway lines from a very far distance just by looking for lines made of tall building clusters. This is a feedback relationship though- where there is density, we put subway lines, and where there are subway stations people build more density. London, by contrast, has more of a medium-density everywhere. You could put a tube station just about anywhere in London and you'd have a large number of people who can and would walk to it. Still, I'm quite happy with the quality of the lines we do have. I just hope that as we build more, that can be maintained.
- allengeorge 9y agoI love Toronto, but its subways (and transit as a whole) need improvement as well. Not just that, council seems hell-bent on throwing 3+ billion dollars down the morass that's the Scarborough extension. [rant over]
- Kurtz79 9y agoLived in London for 1.5+ years and in Madrid for several years afterwards, and I think Madrid's system is better (not that London's is bad overall). Cleaner, more modern, frequent trains, less delays.
- melling 9y ago“17% of the budget is to pay down debt”
- trothamel 9y agoIs that bad? The real problem is when you're stuck only paying the interest, and the debt increases. If you were to buy something on your credit card, you're spending most of your money to pay down the debt - but that's not particularly a problem unless you're living above your means. The alternative - to wait until you've accumulated enough cash to build a bus depot - seems kind of a bad idea.
- traek 9y ago> The real problem is when you're stuck only paying the interest, and the debt increases. That is what is happening at the MTA.
- barney54 9y agoOne reason it's bad that MTA is only paying interest is that the transportation world is changing. Autonomy, Uber/Lyft, and other technologies may mean that subways systems like the MTA is in a death spiral where fewer riders means less fare revenue and less ability to even meet interest payments. In places like Washington, DC it looks like the death spiral is well underway.
- umanwizard 9y agoI guarantee no amount of self-driving cars, Uber, or any other car-related technology will make people stop taking the subway in New York. The car bridges and tunnels into and out of Manhattan are at full capacity all day long. It is vastly faster to take the subway in most normal cases.
- candiodari 9y agoI've often wondered though why companies like the MTA don't transform their networks into things like Elon Musk's boring company type network
- matt_wulfeck 9y ago>”... hundreds of mechanic positions have been cut because there is not enough money to pay them — even though the average total compensation for subway managers has grown to nearly $300,000 a year.” I know this isn’t the primary reason the subway is falling into disrepair, but it’s clearly a symptom of a system that lacks real accountability. There has to be some reasonable push back to compensation (backed ultimately by the tax payers of New York) that is tied to real performance and efficiency.
- jimktrains2 9y ago> I know this isn’t the primary reason the subway is falling into disrepair Isn't it a primary cause? Not having labour to perform maintenance means that maintenance isn't being done.
- joering2 9y agoIts gets worse than that; if you read further the reasoning is that "Its hard to buy apartment for less than $800,000 in Brooklyn". Great excuse next time they interview you for the job; check how much is average housing, divide roughly by three, and here is how you have reasonably arrived at your salary. If they look at you odd, just refer to NYT article.
- matt4077 9y agoYour wording is slightly ambiguous, but just to be clear: The NYT isn't making this argument, they're quoting someone. (and the quote is $700,000, by the way)
- IkmoIkmo 9y agoIt's absolutely ridiculous. I mean, median household income in Brooklyn is $45k.[0] That's household. The average household size in Brooklyn is 2.75. There'll be some kids in there, but likely the average adults per household is 1.5. So here you have a guy earning close to $300k, likely has a partner with supplemental income too, which is easily 6-8x the median household income...jeez. I mean hell, country wide there's a common 30% income spent on rent rule. Median rent in Brooklyn is about $36k a year, for a 120k salary. These guys are way beyond that. It's obviously not a matter of 'do I earn enough for a decent life?'. They could earn half, say 140k, and still earn a decent life in NY. So it becomes a question of, is there anyone willing to do these jobs for say 180k, instead of 280k, and if so, the unions are no longer working in the best interests of ordinary folks. When there's a small number of rich disproportionately salaried guys making public goods and services hugely expensive for ordinary folks, I think the Union's raison d'etre has died. (or changed into something awful). 0 https://www.census.gov/censusexplorer/censusexplorer.html https://www.census.gov/censusexplorer/censusexplorer.html
- leifaffles 9y agoI think politicians in places like New York should lead by example and show us that much-hyped, long-awaited "smart government" before they angrily demand I support the latest government program.
- dajohnson89 9y agoDC's system is pretty bad too. this morning I had to choose between a 50 minute commute via metro for $4, or a 20 minute Uber ride for $10. I'm so so glad I got the Uber.
- t3po7re5 9y agoSame here it's either $12 for a total commute of 2+ hrs via metro, or $3 to drive for a total of just over an hour.
- zzzzzzzza 9y agowait you paid 3 dollars for an hour of uber? How does that make sense? The minimum wage is way more than that.
- dionidium 9y agoMaybe he's saying that he drove himself for $3 in gas (while conveniently ignoring all the other costs of car ownership, not to mention the massive externalities).
- cuckmaster 9y agoBut since the government subsidizes both the $3 ain't so bad
- vinay427 9y agoIt's reasonable that if GP needs and already has a car for other non-commuting purposes (shopping, road trips, etc.) the choice in their specific case is between paying for public transit and only paying for gas to cover the commute.
- dionidium 9y agoI understand what you're saying; it's just not a reasonable way to perform a complete or useful cost analysis.
- AznHisoka 9y agoNYC has one of the highest combined state/city tax rates.. what the heck are we paying for, if not convenient, reliable subways. and they dare increase the fares.. ok that is fine IF you decrease the tax rates. You can't have your cake and eat it too.
- nihonde 9y agoYou’re paying for guys who tear up the same street all day, every day, for years, and then leave it looking like a patchwork of sloppy, half-finished jobs. I lived on that street for ten years.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gnerix 9y agobillions debt service on MTA bonds, a Cuomo directed bail out of Ski resorts. These are the things our taxes and subway fares go towards...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mychael 9y agoThe MTA is a government mandated monopoly. What they need is free enterprise.
- MBCook 9y agoAre you suggesting other companies build their own subways? A subway seems like a natural monopoly to me.
- avn2109 9y agoThe NYC subway system was mostly privately constructed by 3-ish private-ish organizations, and later joined under a state monopoly. You can still see vestigial underground signage that says stuff like "To IRT Lines" or "BMT Lines -->," referring to now-defunct private subway operators. This is also why the rolling stock and tracking are visibly different from line to line.
- Eric_WVGG 9y agoAnother vestige is that the lettered lines were owned by one of those companies, the numbered by another
- jabretti 9y agoYou could contract different lines out to different companies. I think Tokyo does this. At the very least, though, you could contract out the running of the whole system to a company for five years a time and let different companies compete for the contract every five years. This isn't a panacea, but it can sometimes help if the main problem is corruption-induced inefficiency as it seems to be for most major cities in the US.
- rtkwe 9y agoYou'd need some kind of long term planning guidance behind that though because anything beyond the most surface level changes or additions to the system is going to take longer than 5 years and what contracting company is going sink millions of dollars into a system they're only guaranteed to be running for the next couple years?
- rayiner 9y agoI don’t understand why American governments are so bad at providing public services. Money often isn’t it. The NY subway has an operating budget of $8 billion for about 1.7 billion riders per year ($4.7 per rider per year). The London Tube has an operating budget of (2.2 billion pounds—$3.5 billion pre-Brexit) for 1.4 billion riders ($2.5 per rider). The systems are in extremely similar cities, are almost exactly the same route miles, and are similarly old. Yet NYC’s system costs almost twice as much to run.
- blintz 9y agoUh, mind sharing where you got those numbers? The budget for TfL I see here says a total operational cost of 10.2 billion pounds (http://content.tfl.gov.uk/transport-for-london-budget-2017-18.pdf http://content.tfl.gov.uk/transport-for-london-budget-2017-1...)
- rtkwe 9y agoTfL is way more than just the tube so I’m guessing op used numbers that broke out just the tube.
- michaelleslie 9y agoTfL manages more than just the London Underground. I think the other poster may be using the Tube's share of operating expenses?
- rayiner 9y agohttp://content.tfl.gov.uk/tfl-mayors-budget-2017-18.pdf http://content.tfl.gov.uk/tfl-mayors-budget-2017-18.pdf (page 10) versus http://web.mta.info/mta/budget/pdf/MTA%202017%20Adopted%20Budget%20February%20Financial%20Plan%202017-2020.pdf http://web.mta.info/mta/budget/pdf/MTA%202017%20Adopted%20Bu... (page II-A). I’m just comparing the Underground versus the subway + the Staten Island Railroad.
- AngusH 9y agoThat's interesting The TFL budget and the mayor's budget don't seem to match precisely, although roughly the same. I wonder why?
- harryh 9y agoIMHO the real source of a lot of these problems is that the subway system is a city resource that is primarily payed for by city taxes (and fares of course) but it's actually administered by the state government (which the MTA reports into). If it was a city controlled thing it would be a huge huge issue in every single mayoral election. But it gets somewhat drowned out in governor elections.
- notmtaemployee 9y agoThe subway used to be controlled by the city which lead to politicians keeping the fairs intentionally low to gain popular support. In 1968 the city could no longer afford fund the subway and it was transferred to newly created Metropolitan Commuter Transportation Authority, which was renamed to today's Metropolitan Transportation Authority. The city retaking control of subway raises the question of who will pay for the operation and capital costs. The MTA derives allot of its funding from tolls through the Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority which generated $1.8 Billion in 2016. It's unlikely the state will give TBTA back as well.
- dzonga 9y agoI have always said America is a rich 3rd world country. The politicians in NY are no different from Mugabe's Zanu PF in Zimbabwe.
- obmelvin 9y agoWhile it is bad, it is an insult to people suffering from true 3rd world problems to make that comparison
- vinay427 9y agoI can't agree enough. GP should visit a country where if you're killed in a hit and run by a relative of a politician, it's expected that your death will be a suicide and you will receive no compensation. Or even a country where that's a milder event.
- RyanZAG 9y agoThose are just conspiracy theories spread by opposition politicians. USA has exactly the same with the Clintons being accused of a large list of suspicious suicides.
- jpatokal 9y agoThe victims of hit & runs in third world countries typically do received (some) compensation. The culprits just magically avoid prosecution. One example from Thailand, where even killing a cop isn't enough to get the wheels of justice turning: http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-39427291 http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-39427291
- notmtaemployee 9y agoThe MTA's problems begin and end at a weak senior management unwilling to standup to Cuomo's frivolous micromanagement and a transit union unwilling to modernize. Politicians should be pushing for serious procurement and labor work rule reforms, otherwise the systemic managerial and operational deficiencies will ensure that the deterioration of service we see now will repeat it self in 5 to 10 years, regardless of how much money or technology is poured into the MTA. London and Toronto have been able to modernize much of their transit systems in last 5 years and its not because they have more money. Once you fix the top everything else will fall into place. Look what Andy Byford has been able to do in 4 short years at the TTC. His 5-Year Plan to modernize the TTC focused on transforming corporate culture and updating internal processes, in addition to new equipment. The results of these changes have been overwhelmingly positive with the TTC recently being named best public transit agency in North America and The TR Class of TTC subway cars in May having a MDBF of over 924,000 miles. If your interested in getting involved with transit activism in NYC I highly suggest you follow @2AvSagas on twitter.
- Chathamization 9y agoDo people in London and Toronto care enough to pressure their leaders about this? In my experience it's hard to find people in the U.S. who even bother to pay attention to who has oversight when it comes to transportation (and not just transportation, this is true for a lot of local issues).
- L_Rahman 9y agoI promise you that New Yorkers care about this deeply. https://comptroller.nyc.gov/reports/the-human-cost-of-subway-delays-a-survey-of-new-york-city-riders/ https://comptroller.nyc.gov/reports/the-human-cost-of-subway... Any survey of New Yorkers and government services will tell you how much this matters. The biggest problem is that the New York government at city and state levels is one of the most corrupt, oligarchic and undemocratic organizations in modern society. I cannot begin to describe how broken it is. Here's a good example: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/18/nyregion/new-york-politics-party-bosses.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/18/nyregion/new-york-politic... This leaves us with no levers of power over government decisions. When you take into account that the people who most heavily depend on the subway are also the poorest, we have even less power over the elected and appointed government class.
- greggman 9y agoI know this isn't a popular idea but any thoughts on why privatizing them is a bad idea? It works in Japan. There are at least 10 train/subway companies in Tokyo alone. JR, Tokyu, Keikyu, Keio, Odakyu, Eidan, Seibu, Tobu, Toei, Keisei and they seem to be best in class by most measures.
- rhizome 9y agoI know this isn't a popular idea but any thoughts on why privatizing them is a bad idea? It works in Japan. The particular competitive business environment in the US makes it almost impossible.
- Larrikin 9y agoI believe it works because it was already a good system before being privatized. Most of the cost of building the system and making it work well was done when it was private. Even now the best system in Tokyo, Tokyo Metro, is a joint venture by two different governments
- AznHisoka 9y agoOn that same idea, I would love to see private buses replace the subway. There is a large van that takes 15-20 people from Queens to Chinatown that runs everyday 12 hours a day and it costs under $5. Would love to see similar systems for Queens -> Times Square or Brooklyn -> wall street.
- mjmahone17 9y agoYes, let’s have more deadly, congestion-inducing, loud and smog-producing private buses filling up our streets, rather than making a cheap, electrified mass transit system better. The Queens to Chinatown bus fills a gap in services from Flushing to Chinatown. If that bus is really transporting multiple subway trains worth of people each day, that in my mind means we ought to build better mass transit between those two places. Not that we should cannibalize our working people-moving infrastructure for something worse.
- 9y ago
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoWhat's most obscene is that no effort is made to compensate for lost trains on partially shutdown express/local lines. The mayor could fix that immediately by just demanding more service on the sections that run rather than forcing everyone into sardine cans. It's pretty clear that MTA is using repairs as an excuse to cut spending on service and are unlikely to ever run it at full capacity. The system carried more passengers in the 40's. They did it by running trains more often. It's not rocket science.
- nerdponx 9y agoTo be fair, the 4/5 between Union Square and 125th St is a sardine can from 7-10 AM and 5-7 PM daily even when they run every 3 minutes or whatever the rush hour gap is.
- thriftwy 9y agoMoscow Metro does 40 of trains per hour (doesn't save from sardine can effect tho) so one per 3 minutes is not a hard limit.
- archagon 9y agoSt. Petersburg as well. (Actually, closer to one per 2 minutes.)
- Arnt 9y agoThe hard limit is a function of stops, layout, train length and acceleration/deceleration ability, and finally the signal system. Each train has to approach a station, brake, stop, wait while people enter and leave, start and accelerate, all at safe distance to the trains in front and behind. Braking, standing still and starting easily add up to a minute, so a two-minute cycle time is hard even if the track layout is friendly (evenly spaced stations, no mutexes in the central area, etc). Ninety seconds is really impressive.
- tialaramex 9y ago
- dogruck 9y agoAfter reading that article, it’s hard not to have the angry reaction of “wow, those idiots!” Right!? But, really, we should look inward. For example, where was the New York Times when all of these bad leadership decisions were made? Were they publishing op-eds with clearheaded prognostications of gloom, and alternative solutions? And, what about the voters who elected these politicians? Most importantly, where do we go from here?
- leifaffles 9y ago"Make government programs work": An issue politicians seem incapable of prioritizing over giving the government dominion over more areas of American life.
- flyGuyOnTheSly 9y agoI was riding the NYC Subway a year or two ago, when my brother in law asked me if I noticed anything strange about it. After thinking it through, I realized that I had ridden that exact same subway car in the past. It was a recommissioned car from Toronto! So they're obviously doing something to try and save money. It really made me question my own city's transit system as well. How could NYC make do with something that Toronto thought was worth getting rid of?
- oasisbob 9y agoIt could make sense if you consider different car series, in the same way that airliners will move between carriers depending on what kinds of fleets they want to run. Or, old OEM parts.
- fencepost 9y agoI think a good response to the guy asking "What do you want, for us to make $15 an hour?" would be "No, but bringing you down to $50 an hour might be a reasonable starting point."
- StudentStuff 9y ago$50 an hour is $104k a year, figure MTA has not been hiring many people as their effective budget has shrunk, so what started as a low $100k salary has risen as their workforce ages.
- f_allwein 9y agoIf I remember correctly, London Underground was similarly run down in the 1980s, which is one of the reasons it was renationalized. This is also debated for commuter trains now: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/oct/11/trains-buses-nationalised-london https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/oct/11/trains...
- Doctor_Fegg 9y agoLondon Underground was state-owned in the 80s too.
- apexalpha 9y ago>In one particularly egregious example, Mr. Cuomo’s administration forced the M.T.A. to send $5 million to bail out three state-run ski resorts that were struggling after a warm winter. What? Do American State-level governments not have checks in place for this kind of stuff? This sounds like something Mugabe would do for his private ski resorts, lol.
- isostatic 9y agothey do have checks - and the MTA wrote one for $5m
- matt4077 9y agoAs your quote points out: these are state-run businesses. I'm sceptical of the sate running ski resorts. But ignoring that for a second, it's not out of the ordinary to cover a loss that was the result from extraordinary events such as a warm winter. Presumably, they didn't have to bail them out in other years, meaning they ran a profit in other years.
- lmm 9y agoThe state central government bailing out a state-run business is fine. Getting the state transport authority to bail out a business unrelated to transport seems obviously wrong.
- freeone3000 9y agoOkay, so instead the money should go into general fund, and the money from general fund should pay for the ski resort? I don't see a practical difference.
- lmm 9y agoIt makes it a lot clearer to voters what money is going where.
- camillomiller 9y agoNew York's transport is baffling to me. The lack of a proper subway or special express train option to get quickly to the airports is doubly baffling. I guess the cross-state jurisdiction is one of the issues with Newark, but the AirTrain solution over at JFK is way subpar if compared to other major cities. I've been there twice in a few months and it's simply a disaster. 2.5 hrs by car to get to Newark from Williamsburg at 2pm on a Friday. I wonder what rush hour looks like.
- parent5446 9y agoHuh? NJTransit (train and bus) goes directly to Newark, and the last time I rode the AirTrain to JFK I had no problems. This is compared to other cities where I had to take a shuttle from the nearest train station to get to the airport...
- clutchski 9y agoNYC's airport transit isn't as good as other cities (Tokyo, Toronto, etc) but nobody who lives in New York would make that trip by car at that time. They'd fly from LGA or JFK or take the car.
- camillomiller 9y agoApparently helicopter is also an option for the slightly richer. Not even 1%ers, it’s like 250$ from manhattan to jfk
- crazygringo 9y agoWhat are you talking about? From Penn St you take the NJ Transit train to Newark airport, or the LIRR train to Jamaica where you transfer to the AirTrain which brings you to your desired terminal at JFK. LaGuardia doesn't have a train option though. But yeah, taking a car from Newark to Williamburg in the afternoon, I guess you've learned not to do that again. :) NJ Transit is your friend.
- mlrtime 9y agoFrom Manhattan, you need to take 3 trains to get to EWR. Subway, Path (NJT), shuttle. LGA: None JFK: Subway,AirtRain Compare this with HKG or LHR, it is pathetic.
- pattle 9y agoI've never been to New York and I've don't know much about the subway system but I was watching a documentary recently that showed they were building some new platforms underneath Grand Central station. I think from memory they were also building new lines to cope with the massive stress the service is under, so it looks like these problems are trying to be resolved?
- matt4077 9y agoThat's a different problem. They're building a new line, yes. But the problems are more with the reliability of the existing infrastructure.
- lmm 9y agoFrom the article it sounds like a big problem is politicians are (for understandable reasons) happy to allocate money for new platforms or new lines, but not allocating enough funding to the maintenance and signalling that keeps the trains running.
- a_c_s 9y agoGrand Central is having new platforms built for the Long Island Railroad (LIRR), which is a commenter train system that is separate from the subway system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_Side_Access https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_Side_Access
- nova22033 9y ago>The pay for managers is even more extraordinary. The nearly 2,500 people who work in New York subway administration make, on average, $280,000 in salary, overtime and benefits. The average elsewhere is $115,000. I know this is NYC but wow..
- kingkawn 9y agoI’ve lived in Nyc on and off my entire life. The train’s are completely utterly normal, everyone has just become impatient and whiney. You’ve always had to plan extra time, there’s always been an unmanageable mix of politics, the Unions have always been Riddled with negotiation-PTSD and can’t give an inch anywhere for fear of exploitation, the governor has always siphoned money away to pay for other things, all of this is the same old shit. It’s never gonna be whatever suburban mall everyone is comparing it to, nor will it be like other major urban areas whose transit systems were built decades or half-centuries later. Chill out and ride the train. It’s a good excuse to be late that nobody can argue with.
- untog 9y agoEvery piece of data we have disagrees with you. They all show that train reliability has been tanking and on time performance has suffered as a direct result.
- joekrill 9y agoThat's an outrageously flawed thought process. Just because it's been that way for a very long time, doesn't mean it's a good thing and that it shouldn't be fixed. By that logic, a child who has been abused their entire life should be fine with it -- it's "utterly normal" for them. It's always been that way. They just have to plan for the beatings.
- theYipster 9y agoThe Europe vs US road/rail infrastructure debate is misinformed, woefully tired, and generally meaningless. It's all state by state, or country by country anyway, and when we are specifically talking subways, it's city by city. It's at the city level that the debate leaves out of consideration the one city that is orders of magnitude above and beyond any other city in the world in terms of complexity and operational performance: Tokyo. Forget the NY Subway, forget London's Tube, forget the Paris Metro or the Berlin U-Bahn, or the Hong Kong MRT for that matter... Everyone's attention should be focused on really understanding the Tokyo system and how it works. NYC has 25 services over 20+- lines (depending on how you count.) That doesn't include PATH nor does it include Airtrain or any of the commuter lines that connect to the system and are part of the greater transit network. Tokyo, when you really look at the whole interconnected system of rapid transit, and not the small part that is arbitrary, and IMHO incorrectly, called the "subway," (referring to the Tokyo Metro and Toei lines generally situated within the Yamanote circle,) you have hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of services over hundreds and hundreds of lines... The fact that all of these lines run on time to the second, with well maintained trains, with well maintained stations, with clear and up-to-date communications, with service focused on the passenger... Tokyo should be the model for the world.
- chmaynard 9y agoOn return from a trip to Norway last week, I was shocked at how shabby, dirty, and poorly-maintained JFK is in comparison to the Oslo Airport. No doubt the New York subways are in serious trouble, but I'd encourage journalists in New York to take an even broader look at the deterioration of public assets and services throughout the city.