9 ms·
That's been the most annoying part of search for a while now. Most searches result in hyper commercialised results, with SEO heavy sites winning out, and of cou
by ehnto 9y ago
That's been the most annoying part of search for a while now. Most searches result in hyper commercialised results, with SEO heavy sites winning out, and of course SEO heavy sites are going to be sites selling you stuff.
If you're searching for a real human's thoughts on a particular mountain bike for one example, it will be nothing but product pages. Add in the word Reviews and you get the productized review sites. Even searching for "Best trails in {my area}" gives me an ecommerce site's blog laden with product links and not-so-subtle sells.
Want to read a discussion about a book? Google will only show you product pages with review sections on the first page, on the next page the search results have already devolved into unrelated nonsense or spin sites.
It's hard to find the humans on the internet through all the commercial pages. I can't blame Google entirely of course, they are helped by the SEO industry's incessant bombardment in the 2010ish era that filled the web with so much pointless crap, and the ongoing efforts of e-commerce stores with deep pockets to be the only heard voice for particular subjects.
- doomlaser 9y agoI do a lot of Twitter searches for that kind of thing when I want raw feedback about a particular topic. I've had a 't' custom search engine address bar hotkey for Twitter for years.
- md224 9y agoKind of interesting how searching social network content can often be more useful than searching the entire Internet. Edit: makes me wonder if the web is evolving in the direction of more social/curated search, less global search
- Trav5 9y agoYeah, social media is just too easy to use (and free). When people take the time to make a website, they often commercialize it, then it's not really a personal website anymore.
- rorykoehler 9y agoThe issue here is that the same companies who can afford good SEO can afford Google Adwords. While a search engine that can find you non-commercial information would be very useful it is, un-ironically, very hard to find a commercially viable business model for such a service. The profit incentive that needs to be attached to everything in a our current commercialist world really narrows the scope of feasibility for potentially cool services.
- Buge 9y agoWhy can't you provide search results of reddit and HN threads while also serving commercial ads in an ad section?
- putonyourshoes 9y agoHey, I work on Google search. For any of the search queries you mentioned, would you be able to share examples of webpages you would have rather seen in the results?
- speedplane 9y agoSearch just about any health related query, the vast majority are pure snake-oil salesmen. Product reviews basically either point to CNet or some relatively trusted source, or if they don't, they point to complete garbage. Try looking for any public records, most bring you to "people search" websites that trick users into thinking they do more than they do. Searching for anything historical brings up wikipedia, and if your lucky, some google books results, which is good, except that Google stopped scanning books. I could go on. It seems like Google is fine at picking the major trusted sources that everyone knows about, but is really bad at differentiating smaller quality sources from spammers. I mostly use Google as my Wikipedia/StackOverflow search machine. I usually find better material searching the references of a wikipedia article.
- WalterBright 9y ago> except that Google stopped scanning books That's really a shame (and an opportunity for someone else).
- speedplane 9y agoIf you want a specific example, here's one that came up in the news recently. Try searching for "rasberry ketones", a nutritional supplement. It's filled with hyper tuned SEO pages with very little content. Many suggest they are informational, but are really article/adverts tuned for search engines. Even those that appear on ostensibly legit websites have ridiculously click-baity titles like "What They Don’t Want You to Know About Raspberry Ketones", which in my mind raises red flags that BS is ahead. If you read a newspaper, you clearly know when someone is trying to sell you something, but on Google search, you don't. I don't mind being marketed to, but I would like to know when I'm marketed to, and the vast majority of google results are organic search marketing.
- aero-002 9y agoI always go to reddit for that kind of stuff. Either site:reddit.com or !reddit on DuckDuckGo does the trick
- QML 9y ago+1 Reddit is a pretty good source of quality reviews for products ranging from niche (mechanical keyboards) to mainstream (MacBooks).
- wslh 9y agoSome communities on Reddit are incredible, I receive answers on critical stuff that is never answered in *stackexchange.com or where you suppose are more in topic places (AWS communities).
- mark_l_watson 9y ago+1 reddit, DuckDuckGo and HN make up the bulk of my web time. Otherwise I read books.
- amelius 9y agoThis raises the question why commercial interests haven't eroded the quality of Reddit already, like they have in the rest of the net?
- agumonkey 9y agoit's a bit sad how business replaces human activities... for lesser value in the end (except to the eyes of "jobmakers~") how to avoid that ?
- inopinatus 9y agoThis is why I abandoned Google search too. The results are just so spammy. But like any dinosaur, it'll be a long time until the head notices you kicked it in the tail. I have abandoned other Google services as well now. Firefox is now my preferred browser for development. Apple Maps is good for navigation. Gmail I still use, as one notch above mailinator: it's my dumping ground for unwelcome mandatory site signup. All the mail I want to receive is on Fastmail. Microsoft's office software is vastly better than G Suite. And so on. I trust Google as much as I trust Facebook or any other advertising network: not at all, and I welcome and adopt alternatives.