4 ms·
> eliminate the lottery and sort applications by salary and take the top N This is exactly what should happen.
by sitkack 9y ago
> eliminate the lottery and sort applications by salary and take the top N
This is exactly what should happen.
- conanbatt 9y agoWhy?
- wallace_f 9y agoConsider the Brain Drain argument that is used to explain why poorer countries have a hard time catching and keeping up with already-developed countries. It's the other side of that.
- conanbatt 9y agoBut someone that could provide enormous value in the future, might not qualify today. It is also a harm in the terms of brain drain. There should be very little doubt on the fact that any restriction will harm everyone in that 'ladder of skill'. It particularly harms those who would acquire those skills later on and dont have them today.
- pfisch 9y agoThose skills are more in demand and probably much rarer. It makes more sense that employers would need to look beyond US borders to fill those positions.
- Nrsolis 9y agoORRRRR....maybe they should pay higher wages to stimulate demand for people to enter in those occupations. I can't help but think that the H-1B VISA program should be tightly restricted by industry and time-limited. If we can't find programmers, our immigration policy should be to recruit them abroad and then find a way to put them onto a fast-track to citizenship. NAY...we should COMPEL them towards the process of citizenship lest they forfeit some amount of tribute. In no way or shape should our immigration policy serve to distort the labor market here to corporate benefit. We should be seeking every possible mechanism to help our economy grow via the increasing demand for skilled labor here in the USA. That doesn't happen when you collapse demand for entry-level positions in the USA like H-1B has ben demonstrated to do. We should also BAN in the strongest possible terms the practice of forcing an employee to train their replacement or put it under such onerous terms that no corporation would do it. I'm talking about the equivalent of a years salary in severance or more. If you can't do the job on day one, you have no business replacing a native worker who is doing the job.
- sitkack 9y agoI believe you should be assisting in writing a goal statement for a revised H-1B VISA program.
- jabretti 9y agoCounterargument: this would lead to the H1B visa allotment being taken almost entirely by tech and finance companies in HCOL areas. Universities, for instance, would have real problems. Universities can often use other visa classes, but not always -- eg the J1 visa can't be renewed after five years.
- Nrsolis 9y agoWell...sure....but you could argue that universities shouldn't be competing for H-1B VISA slots anyhow. The whole point of restricting immigration is to avoid the sort of race to the bottom that accompanies the corporate directive to get the best possible labor at the cheapest possible price. You only get that when you're able to cast a very wide net and allow in a population of people who can exploit geographic arbitrage to earn money in one area while planning to spend it in another. I'm specifically talking about people who have zero intention of ever relocating to the USA long-term. It only makes sense to reserve the benefits of this country to those who invest in it. I'm specifically including corporations in that calculus. The goal of our immigration policy is to balance the needs of private industry against the interest of the state to compete on a global basis.
- raincom 9y agoUniversities are exempt from H1b cap.
- Antrikshy 9y agoUniversities are cap-exempt, but yes, this will harm industries that have lower salaries on average. As an alternative, they could normalize for the median salary in the applicant's industry.
- conanbatt 9y agoSalary can be gamed hard tho. For example, you can offer higher salaries and lower equity (or no equity), to make sure you make the cut. As a foreign prospective employee you are willing to let go of almost anything to get your nominal salary up high enough to be on the list. Its still a perverse incentive.
- trishume 9y agoYah, but this doesn't seem like a big problem to me. Sure H1B employees will get a different salary/equity/bonus split than normal employees, but assuming total compensation is similar, what does it matter? At least when I value offers I just add up the salary+bonus+liquid equity and look at total compensation.
- conanbatt 9y agoIt matters so much that its part of the fuel of why some people think the situation of the bottom of the h1b's today is so heinous. Companies can make second class citizens within: higher intensity and time of labor + lower benefits. You can reduce PTO, you can reduce the quality of the healthcare plan, you can increase working times (ex. be on call on saturdays), you can assign the even worse and worse quality job opportunities (lots of current H1B's do bank-jobs, maintenance and dying tech jobs) etc. If it were just the same, then what you need to pass is a law that bans all these other instruments like bonuses and equity. Id like to see americans in general say "it doesnt really matter, because I always looked at total compensation". This just harms the poorer immigration in favor of the richer immigration. Its an active ingredient of inequality. For whose benefit?
- trishume 9y agoThat's a reasonable criticism, it would indeed create an unfortunate incentive to trade benefits for salary. It's not ideal, but I still think it would be better than the status quo since it would still be voluntary. I wouldn't take a high-stress poor quality job even if it payed really well. The companies wanting to hire people do have to pay enough to win the lottery, but still have to offer enough benefits to entice the in-demand worker. It would increase inequality (marginally, H1B pool is still small), but I only think inequality is bad insofar as the poor are worse off. This just creates more wealth since in theory Google would only pay $200k+ if they're at least that productive at developing new useful things people want to pay Google money for. The US also gets more tax dollars, and more "innovation" insofar as that is a thing. You could still argue it's better to give the large salary increases to poorer people though. I wrote another comment elsewhere with a list of reasonable potential arguments against top N sorting and this was one of them.