30 ms·
Splitting off from that comment, is the matter of reasonable valuations. Allow me to propose that something like Buzzfeed, with $300 million in expected 2017 s
by adventured 9y ago
Splitting off from that comment, is the matter of reasonable valuations.
Allow me to propose that something like Buzzfeed, with $300 million in expected 2017 sales, is really worth more like $400 to $500 million, less than two times sales. Why? Its future growth rate is likely to diminish going forward with scale (ie its fastest growth days are almost guaranteed to be behind it). Its present growth rate is already down toward 10%-20%. Entities like the NY Times set the ceiling on what Buzzfeed can ever likely hope to be (in terms of business size), and that would be an extraordinary outcome. The NYT is worth $2.8 billion, with $1.5 billion in sales (so less than 2x sales), and has always struggled to have even OK net income margins of 10%.
Buzzfeed was perhaps once worth a reasonably high multiple on sales, back when it had $20 million in sales and a high growth rate. All of these companies have similarly rapidly run out of growth steam: HuffingtonPost, Business Insider, Gawker, Mashable, and so on.
What's a low to medium growth, low max ceiling, low margin, high competition, no-moat business worth? An appropriately low multiple, that's what. Anything else is playing with fire, where you see a $1.5 billion valuation turn into $200 million in a liquidation sale.
The dotcom bubble had a version of this. The Industry Standard was actually highly valued (similar to Mashable's prior $250m valuation) for a brief time back then.
So what's the argument for Buzzfeed being worth a future $5-$10 billion or more (such that a venture capitalist would value it at $1.5 billion in a round)? There's only one argument: another rich person wanting power, narrative control, media influence, and to just generally play in that rich person's sandbox, which is a story that gets repeated over and over again whether it's a traditional tycoon or just a rich venture capitalist. Rich people play in the news & media world like they do in art, swapping the assets around at prices seemingly disconnected from reality, dumping them when times are tough, paying hilariously overpriced rates for them when things are booming.