3 ms·
It's the inevitable come-down from over-inflating digital media start-ups in the post great recession era. The business is mostly a terrible one with mediocre
by adventured 9y ago
It's the inevitable come-down from over-inflating digital media start-ups in the post great recession era.
The business is mostly a terrible one with mediocre margins, vast competition and audiences that are fickle. There is also no real moat, other than extremely deep pockets (which can help sustain a journalistic advantage through ups and downs in the business). Content like that is almost like food when it comes to dealing with consumers. With very modest margins, tons of competition and fickle consumers, digital media start-ups aren't too different from restaurants in their likely-to-die rate.
Venture capitalists love to invest into them because they all picture themselves as media barrons. You see the rich person getting into news / media syndrome as a trend that carries throughout time. They all want to do it: Jeff Bezos, Warren Buffett, Steve Jobs (he was fascinated with Murdoch & news in general), Patrick Soon-Shiong, Chris Hughes, Peter Barbey, Laurene Powell Jobs, Viktor Vekselberg, Carlos Slim, Michael Bloomberg, Sheldon Adelson, John Henry, Sidney Harmon, Joe Mansueto, Mortimer Zuckerman and on and on the list goes.
For every rich person that does get into it, there are a dozen more that flirt with doing so.
Rich people constantly trying to get into news / media, is the equivalent of average people trying to start restaurants, with predictable results.
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoAbsolutely this. Rich people have routinely purchased or put up news outlets to promote their agendas for ages. The difference these days is that content can be copied and distributed at zero cost, and that content (and money-making advertising) can also be targeted, monitored, and tuned. It’s a propagandist’s dream. The problem is that people still only have 24 hours in a day. Most of it is spent sleeping and working. There’s only so much information people will actively consume, which gives way to passive binge consumption of the likes of Netflix and Reddit. The latter has so much user-created or recirculated material that a potentially valuable set of eyeballs to a publisher could instead be spending their free time mindlessly clicking through a series of amusing sloth gifs. All of this leads to a race to the bottom amidst diminishing returns, both for the publisher and the reader. The Washington Post, for example, is flooded with redundancy for the sake of anti-Trump catharsis clicks. There is one silver lining for the owners behind the media glut: people have less spending money than they used to for entertainment, so free or cheap stimulation from the likes of non-or-bypassable paywalled news sources or Netflix does give publishers something resembling a captive audience.
- adventured 9y agoSplitting off from that comment, is the matter of reasonable valuations. Allow me to propose that something like Buzzfeed, with $300 million in expected 2017 sales, is really worth more like $400 to $500 million, less than two times sales. Why? Its future growth rate is likely to diminish going forward with scale (ie its fastest growth days are almost guaranteed to be behind it). Its present growth rate is already down toward 10%-20%. Entities like the NY Times set the ceiling on what Buzzfeed can ever likely hope to be (in terms of business size), and that would be an extraordinary outcome. The NYT is worth $2.8 billion, with $1.5 billion in sales (so less than 2x sales), and has always struggled to have even OK net income margins of 10%. Buzzfeed was perhaps once worth a reasonably high multiple on sales, back when it had $20 million in sales and a high growth rate. All of these companies have similarly rapidly run out of growth steam: HuffingtonPost, Business Insider, Gawker, Mashable, and so on. What's a low to medium growth, low max ceiling, low margin, high competition, no-moat business worth? An appropriately low multiple, that's what. Anything else is playing with fire, where you see a $1.5 billion valuation turn into $200 million in a liquidation sale. The dotcom bubble had a version of this. The Industry Standard was actually highly valued (similar to Mashable's prior $250m valuation) for a brief time back then. So what's the argument for Buzzfeed being worth a future $5-$10 billion or more (such that a venture capitalist would value it at $1.5 billion in a round)? There's only one argument: another rich person wanting power, narrative control, media influence, and to just generally play in that rich person's sandbox, which is a story that gets repeated over and over again whether it's a traditional tycoon or just a rich venture capitalist. Rich people play in the news & media world like they do in art, swapping the assets around at prices seemingly disconnected from reality, dumping them when times are tough, paying hilariously overpriced rates for them when things are booming.