20 ms·
Amazon Sellers Brood as States Come Calling for Taxes
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- quuquuquu 9y agoHaha, jokes on them, I had to quit selling on Amazon years ago anyway because of fake chargebacks and supreme unprofitability! Seriously, the ratio of "shops that make worthwhile profit" to "shops that barely break even" is like 1:10,000 on Amazon EDIT: anyone downvoting this instantly is an Amazon shill or virtue signaling "we don't like reddit-style comments here" ninny
- bdcravens 9y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > Don't accuse others of astroturfing or shillage. > Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.
- quuquuquu 9y agoYeah I know the rule, I've been here too long to not know it. "Please don't comment on our biased censorship. It might expose our scheme."
- sctb 9y agoWe would've just warned you, but since you've acknowledged the guidelines and chosen not to follow them we've banned the account. But please don't tell anyone about our secret scheme to try to have discussions on the internet that are just a bit more thoughtful and informative.
- bradleyjg 9y ago> virtue signaling "we don't like reddit-style comments here" ninny An anonymous action cannot possibly be signaling of any kind. Words mean things.
- quuquuquu 9y agoRight, so if we downvote (literally censor) comments based on style and not content, but we also do it anonymously, it's all good, right?
- bradleyjg 9y agoI'm objecting to your bastardization of the English language. "Virtue signaling" doesn't mean "something I don't like". It has a specific meaning that comes out of behavioral economics. It's a quite interesting concept actually. Unfortunately it is the process of being taken by people like you and turned into a contentless insult to fling at people. That's a destruction of the richness of our linguistic commons and you ought to be ashamed of yourself for doing so. The down-voters and rightness or wrongness of their actions are a separate matter.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y ago"That's a destruction of the richness of our linguistic commons and you ought to be ashamed of yourself for doing so." Never read a more US-centric comment on HN towards people who are a.) not native speakers b.) don't have the vocubulary which seems to be necessary to leave comments on HN. But I assume these are the times. Luckily the most common language in 50y will be Chinese. Hopefully they are more polite than this.
- lostlogin 9y ago> Luckily the most common language in 50y will be Chinese China has multiple languages and ‘Chinese’ isn’t really a single language. Mandarin is already the most spoken language by a large margin, and even that has several dialects.
- TheCowboy 9y agoAnyone downvoting this instantly correctly doesn't see any value in a post making a lot of allegations without any evidence. The "lol f u" attitude makes it easier to click the down arrow without attempting to engage someone who appears close-minded and lacking an ability to engage in civil discourse.
- quuquuquu 9y agoRight, so the burden of proof is on me to prove that selling on Amazon was in fact unprofitable. Would you like to see my receipts? Or maybe you could just take my comment as an idea that sparks interest in your brain, and then you can go Google around for stories that confirm what I'm saying? Wasn't aware that I was being held to such standards of academic rigour on this site where so many others get a free pass, if they're saying the right things that confirm HN's biases.
- TheCowboy 9y agoIf you think you're entitled to act like a jerk if other people get a free pass, then you learned the wrong lesson. Acting like you're in some battle of YOU VS HN is just avoiding what I'm talking about, while proving everything I've said is correct. You're now dishonestly focusing on only one part of what you said. I have sold on Amazon, not for large amounts, and could give a better explanation of why people should stay away. The fees are high, Amazon will arbitrarily gate off categories from experienced sellers with good records, and so on. That's not a high bar. Dismissing that you should have to support what you say with substance as "academic rigor" is just stupid. Flying the flag of censorship is disingenuous when your post is all style and no substance. (Response to another comment.)
- raker 9y agoThis seems like a rather glaring omission to have gone unaddressed for so long by such a giant? Has it not come up before?
- ghaff 9y agoThey can't be forced depending upon your definition of whether a company has a nexus in your state (Quill vs. US): https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/91-0194.ZO.html https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/91-0194.ZO.html Amazon got pressured to collect in some states by those states considering Associates and other programs to constitute a nexus. Note that in most (all?) states [that have a sales tax] the buyers supposedly have to pay sales/use taxes anyway. The debate is whether Amazon has to collect those taxes on behalf of the state.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- meritt 9y agoIt's came up since the dawn of ecommerce. The problem is answering the following questions (and likely many more) in a way that makes everyone happy. * Do you impose tax in the state where the seller resides? * Do you impose tax in the state where the buyer resides? * Do you impose tax in the state where the item is warehoused?
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoSome (all?) states already have a use tax that people are supposed to pay. So, that takes care of the second *. Personally, I lean towards that's enough.
- irrational 9y agoI live in a state that does not have sales tax. But if I purchase something for a family member, and have it shipped to their house, I pay the sales tax for their state. So even though I'm the buyer, sales tax actually works based on where the product is shipped to. So number 2 should probably not be about where the buyer resides, but where the buyer ships the product.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- beberlei 9y agoThe same is happening in the EU where marketplace sellers are using tons of shady tactics essentially pocketing the VAT for themselves and having a 10-25% (depending on EU country) extra profit compared to businesses that follow the law.
- longbrass 9y agoAnother very real and expensive proposition from the point of the marketplace seller is the cost of compliance in each State and within each State every municipal tax district. Collecting sales tax is relatively easy, filing to remit that tax in each state is a varied, difficult and expensive process that most "mom and pop" retailers can't easily comply.
- siruncledrew 9y agoI wonder if this would actually help the Chinese sellers on Amazon, since they could continue to undercut the "mom and pop" sellers, who have to factor in added costs for compliance and tax.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoThe US government already makes it cheaper for us to get Chinese goods. Admittedly, it was to protect mail service between countries, but as most things, is being gamed. http://www.nationalreview.com/article/439532/us-postal-service-subsidizes-china-other-countries-it-shouldnt http://www.nationalreview.com/article/439532/us-postal-servi...
- s73ver_ 9y agoAnd yet, this has been a thing long before Amazon existed. They were able to pull it off back then.
- ghaff 9y agoIt actually hasn't. Anyone without a presence in the buyer's state who shipped anything out of state (aside from some particular bigger ticket items that are registered to the buyer in some way) simply didn't collect sales tax and left it up to the buyer to pay any "use tax" they owed at tax time.
- lostapathy 9y agoAnd those sales were a tiny fraction of the economy compared to today, so comparatively speaking, it mattered a heck of a lot less.
- maaaats 9y ago> (...) from the millions of independent merchants who sell products through Amazon’s website It may make Amazon of lot of money, but it has become increasingly frustrating to try to buy products through Amazon. Get thousands of hits on a search. Mostly the same crap through a thousand dropshippers. Used to shop through Amazon because it was consistent and easy. Now it's like shopping on Ebay.
- dawnerd 9y agoIt gets worse the closer you get to generic items, like usb cables. What’s more annoying is filtering by prime and selecting amazon as the seller doesn’t actually stop marketplace sellers from showing up. All they have to do is be just one cent cheaper than amazons price.
- paulmd 9y agoeBay is actually better for "generic" items like USB cables, because at least you know you're getting whatever's in the picture. There's no telling what you'll get from Amazon... unless it's sold+shipped by Amazon.
- dawnerd 9y agoEven if it’s shipped and sold, because they comingle inventory there’s a chance it won’t be identical. That’s why anker products are listed the way they are. Prevents 3rd parties from coming in and selling fakes.
- paulmd 9y agoI don't think Amazon comingles "Sold and shipped by Amazon" inventory. Or at least they didn't use to - do they now?
- vturner 9y agoPurchased a Pure water filter shipped and sold by Amazon for my girlfrend...it arrived yesterday. I go over to her apartment to install it and wow what a surprise. It was a used filter. The filter element was in a ziplock bag. One of the faucet attachments was out of its packaging and the inside of the main unit was wet. It has nearly caused me to not renew Prime this spring.
- c2h5oh 9y agoIt's a clusterfuck of epic proportions. Let's say you use Amazon Fulfilment (FBA): 1. Does just storing goods in a state establish tax nexus in that state? Most states claim it does, but it hasn't been tested in court. 2. Assuming it does, Amazon keeps moving your goods between warehouses - how do you keep track which states do you have nexus in and need to have a business license in? 3. Assuming you figured it out, in some places you need to register per county, not per state (I believe it was 10+ registrations in one state, can't remember which). With all the locations with Amazon warehouses you're looking at 25+ licences. Possibly 40+. 4. Let's say you're willing to handle the 40+ business licences you're supposedly required to hold, you have to file 40+ tax returns with different deadlines, make 40 payments and keep track of law changes. Also you have to pay to get a business license and often you have to pay to keep it active every year. 5. Add being a foreign seller (let's say Canadian): - out of all the states with Amazon warehouses only 2 will accept a non-us business address when registering for a business license. The others either don't allow you to select a country, require you to select a US state or only accept The One True Zipcode Format. - taxes you remit using ACH will also routinely explode due to a non-US address on your US bank account. - sure, you can file a paper registration (usually at 3+ times the registration fee), unless the state only accepts a XFA PDF form that generates a scannable code. One DOR representative told me the only way I'm getting a licence in that case is if I show up in person. - government issued photo id is sometimes required. Guess which government often is the only one that exists ;-) By comparison in EU you collect VAT per destination country, remit it to your local tax office indicating where it should go and forget about the whole thing.
- mysterypie 9y agoPossible solutions (speaking about the US of course): 1. Let the federal government establish a uniform national sales tax and outlaw all state and local sales taxes. 2. Even better, eliminate sales taxes entirely. Replace it with higher income taxes or property taxes. Yes, yes, I know, regressive, not progressive, taxing consumption is better, but there's something to be said about an economy without crazy levels of bureaucracy and regulations. 3. Just keep fighting off the states until they accept that Internet orders should be non-taxable. The Internet has completely changed the business models of music delivery, porn, and newspapers. No reason it can't eventually convince states to back off on sales taxes.
- PatientTrades 9y ago> Caught in the middle are Amazon’s marketplace sellers, who run the gamut from small mom-and-pop operations This will be a nightmare to fix, especially for the small sellers. Taxes based on where the seller is, taxes based on where the buyer is, taxes based on where the warehouse is, etc. Plus accounting and declaring profits government.
- armenarmen 9y agoMy guess is that people/voters in these states aren't chomping at the bit to pay extra for their amazon goods. Hopefully the desire to not get unelected is greater than the desire to have not tax money to play with
- lsaferite 9y agoIt sounds like Amazon should collect taxes for the 3rd Party and FBA merchants. The states need to indemnify Amazon against sellers messing up so Amazon is not legally on the hook for any additional taxes owed by a seller. And Amazon could pass along the compliance costs to the sellers easily enough. Doing it as a whole for Amazon would simplify the matter and make it 'fair' for the merchants since it would be for all of them.
- throwawaylalala 9y agoAmazon has the ability to easily fix this. Also, I would say that I believe the reason why Amazon isn't collecting and paying taxes is not because of US sellers; it's because of foreign sellers. Their existing process allows them to put it on the seller, who may be one of the thousands of chinese sellers they are signing up. This allows them to outcompete Walmart because they can say it's the sellers responsibility. The seller, not located in the states, is under no threat to ever have to pay that state tax.
- wdn 9y agoI thought the law is the buyer is response to pay for usage (sales) tax for item they purchase online. Now, it is the seller's responsibility when the sellers don't even live or ship from that state?
- macawfish 9y agoMeanwhile in Congress...
- Glyptodon 9y agoI honestly don't think sales tax as currently structured is worth the complexities (and is also - uninformed armchair lawyering opinion incoming - conceivably a violation of the commerce clause since its taxed rate is not reflective of anything that explicitly occurred within state borders as it would be with a VAT or similar). I also feel like taxes are something that deserves to be in a the transaction handling layers rather than the buyer/seller layers. Of course this would drive people to cryptocurrency, but imagine if taxes were just added to your credit card bill based on its billing zipcode and merchants didn't have to think about it at all. I mean for all kinds of reasons it's not feasible, but it seems like the least pain point to deal with transaction taxes is at the transaction.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> imagine if taxes were just added to your credit card bill based on its billing zipcode and merchants didn't have to think about it at all That would be great, for customers. You can have your billing zipcode anywhere you want, regardless of where you might technically live or buy things.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoNo that would be terrible for customers because the .gov would hike taxes and they wouldn't notice.
- sha256link 9y agoI think blockchain will help us with this. Immutable entry of places the product has been stored that is public. Then taxes can be divided out based on time etc.
- inopinatus 9y agoMy inner frustrated cyberpunk novelist says that this will be resolved when Congress admits Amazon as the 51st state.
- coin 9y ago> over Amazon’s resistance to charging state sales tax Correction, it should be "collecting sales tax". The one charging state sales tax is the state, they want Amazon to collect it on their behalf.
- Gustomaximus 9y agoI was paywalled form the article but wouldn't an easy solution be to rule; 1) Businesses are responsible to collect tax at point of payment. 2) Sales tax is paid at the rate of, and to the state where-ever the item is delivered to/or picked-up by purchaser.
- ballenf 9y agoThe next issue is going to be the Alibaba's and AliExpress's. Good luck trying to collect taxes there, so that means that they have an artificial advantage over domestic sellers (or reseller/dropshippers). Personally become a big fan of AliExpress. It's a much better experience than buying a 3rd party item on Amazon. Although, only if you're flexible on shipping times.