11 ms·
The U.S. Flooded One of Houston’s Richest Neighborhoods to Save Everyone Else
- naturalgradient 9y agoReader mode is not displaying the article, what kind of dark-pattern trickery is this? (Safari)
- brogrammernot 9y agoWorks fine in Reader mode for me.
- aneidon 9y agoBroken for me too, I just get everything up to the first big image.
- kome 9y agoWith Firefox 57 reader mode works fine.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zzzeek 9y ago> total damages claimed could reach $10 billion or more, especially if the big energy and oil companies—whose presence in one section of West Houston gave it the nickname the Energy Corridor—sue over their flooded headquarters. the irony that the home neighborhood of many of the worlds largest oil companies would want to sue because the global warming they're at the core of causing contributed towards the damage of their own buildings.
- Edmond 9y agomy thought exactly.
- cma 9y agoI'm sure the suit will just ask for FEMA trailers for everyone.
- _jal 9y agoA two-person company with the right friends can make this right in a jiff. If they can fix PR, they can fix Houston, right?
- briandear 9y agoCrazy. All those oil companies forcing you to buy stuff that gets transported by trucks that use oil. You’re blaming the drug dealers for people choosing to shoot heroin. Feel free to stop consuming oil. Even your Tesla has plastics made from oil and uses power generated using oil. If you buy a single thing made in China, you are buying products generally made using coal-fired electricity. Unless you live in a grass hut, you are part of the “problem.”
- vardump 9y agoThe rest of the argument seemed kinda valid, but one nitpick: > Even your Tesla has plastics made from oil I think nearly all plastics are made out of natural gas, not oil.
- codycraven 9y ago> I think nearly all plastics are made out of natural gas, not oil. Fracking monster
- libertyEQ 9y agoTo elaborate further: "Chemical plants produce olefins by steam cracking of natural gas liquids like ethane and propane. Olefins are the basis for polymers and oligomers used in plastics, resins, fibers, elastomers, lubricants, and gels."
- zzzeek 9y ago> You’re blaming the drug dealers for people choosing to shoot heroin. Grade-school libertarianism doesn't apply here. I'm blaming them for using their billions of dollars to pack my government with people like James Inhofe who willingly spread lies and misinformation about a regulatory subject they know nothing about: http://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/234026-sen-inhofe-throws-snowball-to-disprove-climate-change http://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/234026-sen-inho... > Take a look at Inhofe's campaign funding. The major source, contributing half a million dollars over the past five years, has been the oil and gas industry... If Inhofe were to change his position on man-made global warming, is it credible that he would retain all this funding? No. He receives money from fossil fuel companies because he articulates the views to which these funders subscribe, and because he advances their interests in the Senate. Given that keeping your seat means spending a fortune on television advertising and other forms of campaigning, changing your views on a matter of great interest to your sponsors is likely to be political suicide. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/georgemonbiot/2012/aug/02/climate-change-political-funding-us https://www.theguardian.com/environment/georgemonbiot/2012/a...
- specializeded 9y agoWhat a weirdly nice pick-me-up of a headline in this day and age here. Thoughts and prayers to the homeowners
- LeifCarrotson 9y ago> Thoughts and prayers to the homeowners I can't tell if this is a genuine expression of sympathy for people who, while perhaps wealthy, have suffered significant loss of their time, homes, and heirlooms. Or if it's a sarcastic jab at these same people who, when other, less wealthy people are suffering, send "thoughts and prayers" via Facebook chain messages instead of sending actions and dollars.
- goda90 9y agoAlmost certainly the latter.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yardie 9y agoI find this article beautifully ironic. Climate change denying executives have homes and offices flooded by climate changed storm water.
- murtnowski 9y agoWhy? Houston was been flooded several times before. Particularly in 1929 and 1935 when the county finally decided to form a flood control agency. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harris_County_Flood_Control_District https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harris_County_Flood_Control_... Climate change is real, but if every time we get bad weather you call it that it’s a little like crying wolf.
- zdragnar 9y agoNot only that, but wasn't that hurricane demonstrated to have formed over waters that were at normal temperature levels? If anything, that sort of comment actively hurts the cause.
- yardie 9y agoEven in its natural state the Gulf is an extremely warm body of water. A storm that enters it immediately Hulks up. We’ve normally relied on the Gulfstream (goes North) and Jetstream (goes East) to push these storms back out to sea.
- todayiamme 9y agoExcept the argument isn't about the frequency of storms nor the occurrence of a severe storm, but the increase in frequency of severe storms. Essentially, if we put more energy into the system, then we shouldn't be surprised if more energy is outputted as a result of the same system. > A sustained upward trend is found between the global proportion of Cat 4–5 hurricanes and ACCI (Fig. 4), balanced by a similar decrease in Cat 1–2 hurricanes. The results are independent of the choice of models to calculate the ACCI as can be seen by comparing Fig. 4a and b. In both cases the ACCI explains 80–85 % of the variance in the smoothed annual hurricane proportions with p < 0.01 (using unsmoothed data). This finding is consistent with the SST-related increases in Cat 4–5 and decreases in Cat 1–2 found by Kishtawal et al. (2012), the relationship of intense hurricanes with SST found by Hoyos et al. (2010), and the Atlantic landfall hurricane changes noted by Grinsted et al. (2012). Diagram: https://static-content.springer.com/image/art%3A10.1007%2Fs00382-013-1713-0/MediaObjects/382_2013_1713_Fig4_HTML.gif https://static-content.springer.com/image/art%3A10.1007%2Fs0... https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/S00382-013-1713-0 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/S00382-013-1713-0
- jasonmaydie 9y agoThis happened to us too (different country). They intentionally held up water using the dams and caused flooding in places that haven't seen a flood in 50 years to prevent downstream flooding. It really sucks.
- yardie 9y agoSorry that happened to you but I believe the corps made the right call. The choices were release into a high density downtown or low density suburbs. I do believe this happening in a rich suburb with the means to rebuild makes the victims less sympathetic than if they were lower middle class and had to bootstrap from measly FEMA checks.
- losvedir 9y agoSomething like this happened a few years ago where I live.[0] Basically, the Army blew the levee to save a town, Cairo, IL, at the expense of (a few) homes and (lots of) farmland on the MO side. Maciej (HN user idlewords) mentioned it in one of his interesting blog posts[1]. The blog post asserts: > The farmers downriver got their fields fertilized with rich river silt and are wealthier and more resentful than ever. Like so many beneficiaries of big government, they remain its implacable foes. which I've never been able to source, though I've been curious about it. AFAICT most of the farmers left and never returned to the area. [0]http://www.stltoday.com/news/local/columns/pat-gauen/saving-cairo-meant-choosing-between-catastrophes/article_cd42495f-0237-5528-8d98-008a0e3d95da.html http://www.stltoday.com/news/local/columns/pat-gauen/saving-... [1] http://idlewords.com/2015/07/confronting_new_madrid_part_2.htm http://idlewords.com/2015/07/confronting_new_madrid_part_2.h...
- tdb7893 9y agoFun Midwest fact: The name of Cairo, IL is pronounced differently than the city in Egypt. I've always heard it pronounced more like "Care-O"
- jccc 9y agoAnd in Missouri we have New Madrid ("New MAD-rid") and Versailles ("Ver-SAILS") among several other similar re-pronunciations. Many locals pronounce Johnny Carson's teenage hometown Norfolk, Nebraska as "Norfork." I don't think it comes from ignorance though (and I'm not saying you're saying it does) but instead just a way of taking local ownership.
- kyleblarson 9y agoMy grandfather in Kentucky pronounced Missouri 'Mizurah'.
- jccc 9y agoI lived in the middle of Missouri from 1994 through 2014 and never once heard a voice say Missour-ah that wasn't coming from a candidate for office on TV. (To be fair, there might have been some people in rural parts of the state who did talk like that. But usually it's coming from people who probably shouldn't.)
- Ajedi32 9y agoInteresting. So it's like a real-life version of the trolley problem, but with property damage instead of human lives.
- an_account 9y agoHad a damn failed there would have been far more loss of human life. Army corps definitely made the right call. They were getting sued either way.
- Spooky23 9y agoMy first house had flooding problems every spring and heavy rain. Lesson learned: live on a hill.
- jcranberry 9y agoGood luck finding one of those in Houston!
- junkcollector 9y agoWhen a proper developer builds a home or sub-division in Houston, they bring in fill dirt and do compactions until the houses rest on small hills. You get frequent flooding (about once a year) but it rarely reaches the house before the flood prevention systems have a chance to divert and control it. The problem here is two-fold, as discussed in the article, these people built there homes INSIDE the flood diversion systems and never did due diligence on their home purchase to find out that they were in homes literally designed to be flooded and unscrupulous developers who improperly built or ignored the creation of new flood control when up-building developments that made previously safe areas at risk like the HP plant that flooded. Of course this implies that the city code/design/inspectors/etc. were not doing their jobs as well.
- pyre 9y agoAs others were saying, the developers actively wanted to exclude disclosure the flood status of these plots to potential buyers. Eventually the city "compromised" with them to hide a one-sentence warning deep in the paperwork. Now granted, this did not prevent the homeowners from doing their own due-diligence, but I really think that the city officials that agreed to this, and the developers that lobbied for it should all be taken to task for their actions (and I think this regardless of what happened during the hurricane).
- rurban 9y agoThere are some junk hills, filled with toxic waste. You wouldn't even try to snowboard these, lest build a home there. The good thing about Houston is that everyone is there in together, the rich and the super rich.
- mortehu 9y agoLooks like a variant of the trolley problem, with the water playing the part of the trolley. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem
- lostboys67 9y agoWhen I worked in London near London bridge years ago one of the reasons we had two datacentres (with a whopping 10Mbs link) was they where worried about the Thames flooding our building - that was before the barrier was finished.
- kahnpro 9y agohttps://pics.me.me/the-trolley-problem-multi-track-drifting-22049890.png https://pics.me.me/the-trolley-problem-multi-track-drifting-...
- vita17 9y agoWith an interesting twist to it. Is it more or less immoral to switch tracks if they’ve already been run over by another trolley? Do we try to minimize the total amount of suffering or maximize the number of people with no suffering? Do you reflood a neighborhood to spare another that hasn’t flooded yet?
- danschumann 9y agoPeople are cheering at this, but what if we raise the stakes a little: The government lined up 50 random people and executed them, to appease a foreign government that was holding 500x people captive. We're talking houses vs houses, not people vs people, but how is the morality different? Scape goat. Since it is property, the engineers probably assumed they'd be sued, and I bet they knew exactly what they were doing, and it was still cheaper than the alternative. If you like this, then you should also support eminent domain, where the government can take whatever it wants to make the neighborhood better. It definitely irks me when people say "oh they're just energy sector republicans", as if political disagreements makes anyone less deserving of rights under the law. Equality, people, is something you must enforce ESPECIALLY when you don't like the person receiving equality. This was a true thing to say to racists in the past, and to republican haters of the present. To really get side-tracked: Is it okay to hate haters? Are you justified to do to them what they do? No, I would say love your enemy, if he is thirsty, give him something to drink. Your gifts will be like hot coals on his head.
- rootlocus 9y ago> We're talking houses vs houses, not people vs people, but how is the morality different? If we'd be talking paperclips vs paperclips would that be morally similar? Or is the monetary value of houses somehow large enough to justify a similarity to human lives?
- danschumann 9y agoLets say you lose 10000 dollars worth of paper clips. Big deal, buy more. But if you lose 10000 dollars worth of photos, computers, files, etc, it is a big deal because they are harder to replace.
- parenthephobia 9y agoPeople are harder to replace than houses.
- 9y ago
- philjohn 9y agoZeeland (and other parts of the Netherlands) now have a similar strategy in place - they've spent billions over the years on sea defences, which are absolutely stunning to behold, but have now done the sums and realised they've entered diminishing returns. It's cheaper to let certain areas flood and compensate than it is to build ever more expensive defences.
- dgritsko 9y agoThere was an interesting story a few months back about how the city of Nashville has a process where they buy homes in flood-prone areas at a "fair market price", then demolish the homes and convert the property to "green space" (preventing new buildings from being constructed). The main idea was that this is cheaper in the long run than the continuing cost of disaster recovery, emergency services, etc. for people in these areas. I don't think Nashville is the only city doing this sort of thing, but it was news to me when I heard about it. http://www.tennessean.com/story/news/2017/09/08/nashville-makes-push-buy-flooded-homes-and-replace-open-space/645566001/ http://www.tennessean.com/story/news/2017/09/08/nashville-ma...
- chiph 9y agoAustin has done that to homes along Onion Creek. Like you said - it's cheaper in the long run to buy the property so that people's homes don't get flooded, with all the knock-on effects afterwards.
- pyre 9y agoI have a feeling that at _some_ point, a politician is going to see all of this land that the city owns and get dollar signs in their eyes, and it will eventually be privately-owned and built-up again.
- ocschwar 9y agoThe only real problem is that this was a decision made ad hoc. People whose neighborhoods are likely to be flooded by such a decision should know years in advance that they are designated for it.
- creaghpatr 9y agoI had a friend in Houston who knew well in advance that his street was in the splash zone, so to speak. He got out way before it became bad but his building was later completely destroyed (he was a renter so it couldve been much worse.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jonwachob91 9y ago>> The only real problem is that this was a decision made ad hoc. >> People whose neighborhoods are likely to be flooded by such a decision should know years in advance that they are designated for it. From the Article: "This land and many of the homes to the north and west of the dams are located in what’s known as the flood pool — the upstream portion of the reservoirs. [...] Many homeowners west of the Barker dam claim they didn’t know they were in a flood pool, that they hadn’t spotted the fine print on the bottom of some of their subdivision maps. (“Who looks at a subdivision map?” one resident asks.) The text of one such map reads, “This subdivision is adjacent to Barker Reservoir and is subject to extended controlled inundation under the management of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.” " Sounds like they were told, but didn't care enough. Other parts of the article state that many lawyers are refusing to take a lot of these lawsuits b/c they were in regions that are marked for exactly this scenario.
- ars 9y agoIt's really disturbing reading comments cheering the destruction because the victims are rich, or because they work for energy companies. If hate is a necessary part of believing in climate change I'm not surprised people want nothing to do with that.
- maxerickson 9y agoI wonder, is your comment intentional or is it just a failure of critical reasoning? It's become a common tactic in public discourse to pretend as if issues are cleanly split between two coherent sides, with all action and words associated with the issue fully ascribable to one side or the other. But of course this is ridiculous, yahoos should get full credit for their yahoo ideas without it being necessary for anyone with even a vaguely similar position to denounce them.
- zeveb 9y agoIt seems to me that flooding the neighbourhood to save the city was a perfectly justifiable decision, but it also seems perfectly reasonable to compensate those whose homes were thereby destroyed.
- mbillie1 9y agoI agree, it seems exactly that simple.
- Filligree 9y agoThat's what flood insurance is for. In a socialist democracy you'd be right, but in case of the USA, it seems more appropriate to require that homeowners get insurance.
- kodablah 9y agoI think in this case, you would actually require federal-government-decision insurance. The downstream residents very well might not have flooded had the federal government done nothing (of course we can agree that what they did was probably best). We should not pretend that another entity directly causing this shouldn't be held responsible, even if it was the right decision.
- Filligree 9y agoThey might have, sure, but the plan for doing so was in place before the houses were built. They can't claim to be surprised about this.
- amaranth 9y agoFlood insurance is a government run program that is pretty "socialist" in the sense you seem to be implying. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Flood_Insurance_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Flood_Insurance_Progr...
- jhall1468 9y ago
- dcole2929 9y agoI'm sorry these people lost their homes, but it does seem pretty straightforward that if you build in a flood plane your home might flood. If there is any failure here it's that they weren't given adequate warning before they flooded the neighborhoods. It sounds like they announced it for the next morning but because of the pace of the water rising they had to blow it over night instead. That's something you start announcing over loudspeakers if you have to at that point. The other issue I see is that for some reason Houston didn't require all of these people to have flood insurance. I feel like if you live in an area that gets hit with Hurricanes flood insurance should be a requirement period. This would all be a moot point if these people were adequately covered by insurance
- cmiles74 9y agoThere was recently another article covering the construction of homes in the flood reservoir area. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15472082 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15472082 According to the article, it sounds pretty bad. The city and county knew where the flood reservoirs were. The developers knew, there were "small notices on the plats" for these properties (which developers fought). Homewoner's never saw these plats and had no idea they were in a flood zone. "In the end, over significant opposition from developers, the county agreed to put a one-sentence disclosure of possible “controlled inundation” for plots of land in neighborhoods inside Barker. But the sentence was buried in the plat documents, which are not typically shown to homebuyers."
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> the sentence was buried in the plat documents, which are not typically shown to homebuyers Sounds like the developers withheld material information from the homeowners. If so, it seems clear who is liable.
- cmiles74 9y agoIt sounds like the city or county (it was unclear to me from the article) also holds some responsibility. They agreed to this "compromise" with the developers.
- rurban 9y agoI don't understand what's there to litigate. If they wouldn't have done the controlled release, the dams would have broken, and the very same homes wouldn't not only have been flooded even more, most of them would have been gone. Nada. Plus 10x more homes. Plus broken dams, without protection for the next storm. When there is a storm in Houston, streets do flood for 30 minutes and traffic has to wait. Without the canals and the dams the city would stand still much longer, the damage would be intolerable. Government did the right thing, but they should have warned them more timely. At 10pm, not 1am. With some acoustic alarm.