2 ms·
You’re right, it’s not easy. But even specifying hilariously trivial stuff like HTTPS, certificate pinning, no hardocded backdoors, and per-device random initia
by MBCook 9y ago
You’re right, it’s not easy. But even specifying hilariously trivial stuff like HTTPS, certificate pinning, no hardocded backdoors, and per-device random initial passwords would probably be a huge boon. Simple security without even talking about the problems on the service servers.
I imagine a market would appear for some of the basic software (Linux diaries, etc) to help make things easy for small companies that do want to do it all themselves.
I like the government idea because frankly I can’t think of anything else that would work (outside a rediculously improbable change in consumer behavior).
- maltalex 9y ago> HTTPS, certificate pinning, no hardocded backdoors, and per-device random initial passwords would probably be a huge boon That's what I meant by check-mark security. Yes, it is better than nothing, and by all means let's do that. It's low hanging fruit, and it should be plucked. But in the end it amounts to little more than hanging an air re-freshener on a huge pile of garbage. I'm just pointing out that such certification might cause executives in companies that today put more effort into securing their devices to stop putting in that effort. If it's all the same to the consumer, why spend any more than the bare minimum to get a check mark? Today there's no clear bar, and a good engineering team will always be able to convince a responsible management that they need to put effort in security. But once that fairly low bar is set, I think that the next order from the management will be "make our devices certifiable and nothing more".
- MBCook 9y agoJust like car safety we have to keep raising the bar. Checklist car safety means a pretty safe car these days, and the companies that go beyond do amazing things.
- collinmanderson 9y ago> I like the government idea because frankly I can’t think of anything else that would work (outside a rediculously improbable change in consumer behavior). I'm surprised PCI (payment card industry) security standards have not been mentioned on this thread. There's a case where non-government regulation has, by some definition, worked. PCI isn't perfect: if you check all of the boxes, it doesn't mean you're secure, but I'd rather have the industry self-regulate than have politics come into play.