5 ms·
> Either politicians are stupid, or more likely, they know that "homeowner policy" like this can make them and their other rich buddies even richer. It's not a
by littlestymaar 9y ago
> Either politicians are stupid, or more likely, they know that "homeowner policy" like this can make them and their other rich buddies even richer.
It's not a malice vs idiocy situation, actually there is a third explaination : economy needs a growing money supply to work properly (and the money creation need to compensate the economic growth AND the reduction of money velocity[1]). But since the late seventies, money creation is only possible through the banking system via credit. That's why central banks reduces interest rates to stimulate economy, because you need to create money to enable economic growth. To get out of the rising housing prices trap, we need another money creation mechanism, but many people are affraid of the old ones (state-controlled monetary creation) and a lot of people (bankers, homeowners) have a lot to lose if we changed the system.
[1]: this is the failure of the monetarist view from the seventies, which predicted a constant money velocity, in fact we've had a declining one for the last four decades.
- hackerguy99 9y agoHow else can money be created except through credit?
- littlestymaar 9y agoDirect reserve emission by the central bank. In practice, the central bank can just give some reserve to the governement account.
- badestrand 9y ago..or they can give it directly to people. There is an initiative for Europe that wants exactly that, Quantitive Easing for People. I love the idea and am sure it would do more for the economy than just pushing banks to lend more money.
- littlestymaar 9y agoThat could be a good idea, even though we don't really know the impact it will have on inflation. Imho, the impact would be close to zero in nowadays economy where the lack of demand is much more of a problem than an hypothetical shortage of goods. In the long run though, the demand would catch up and the supply could be the limit, like it was after the first oil crisis. Personnally, I'd rather give the money to the governement like we did in the keynesian golden age, because it fuels the development of infrastructures, housing and social security. And at our point in history, it could be used to transition to a sustainable society. But that's because I don't trust the market on this, I'm kind of a socialist. > am sure it would do more for the economy than just pushing banks to lend more money. This is such a failure (esp. in the EU) I don't see how I could disagree with you on this.
- natslovR 9y agoThey did it in Australia during the GFC. Spent 10 billion dollars giving 12 million people $900 each. Share market jumped, retailers rolled out significant sales. People bought TVs.
- imtringued 9y agoThe problem with this idea is that the central bank doesn't have a list of bank accounts for the entire population and even if they did not everyone has a bank account. It's more likely that negative interest rates will be passed onto consumer bank accounts by elmininating cash.
- geezerjay 9y agoIf money is given directly to people then that money will disappear in non-productive spending such as luxury goods and services, which typically mean that the nation's trade balance would suffer greatly.
- rileyphone 9y agoVia being backed to some tangible good, eg gold.
- littlestymaar 9y agoOr bitcoin ! Wait, this is ridiculous we have like two centuries showing us that commodity currency is a failure in an industrial economy.
- novalis78 9y agoI would not be so fast in that conclusion. There is actually research that indicates that the opposite might be true: http://saifedean.com/Saifedean%20Ammous%20The%20Bitcoin%20Standard.pdf http://saifedean.com/Saifedean%20Ammous%20The%20Bitcoin%20St... A slowdown a la Thiel due to fundamentally flawed monetary policies.
- littlestymaar 9y agoThanks for the paper, but having skimmed through I don't think the word research is appropriate for this, it's more of a compilation of autrian propaganda than anything else. Gold standard failed, no matter what libertarians like to fantasize about it.
- boznz 9y agoGroan.. I think we need a version of Godwin's law for bitcoin
- nrhk 9y agoIt can be created backed up by assets instead of reputation though.
- dredmorbius 9y agoAnd what prevents the arbitrary extension of credit? The present primary reliance on fractional reserve monetary is not a carved-in-stone requirement of financial systems, only the present norm. If you're interested in ideas and thoughts on money, I'd suggest William Stanley Jevons writing as a starting point for modern views. A. Mitchell Innis's "What is Money?" (1913) is not entirely mainstream, but strikes me as among the more insightful enquiries I've read: https://www.community-exchange.org/docs/what%20is%20money.htm https://www.community-exchange.org/docs/what%20is%20money.ht... I'd stumbled across that here: http://neweconomicperspectives.org/2013/09/money-created-overcome-barter.html http://neweconomicperspectives.org/2013/09/money-created-ove...
- littlestymaar 9y ago> The present primary reliance on fractional reserve monetary is not a carved-in-stone requirement of financial systems, only the present norm. Their is no fractionnal reserve banking in the modern world anymore. And circa 2007, virtually nothing prevented the infinit expansion of credit, with the result we all know. If you want to learn more about these topics, the keen-krugman debate (more of a controversy than a civil debate) a few years ago was really enlightening.
- dredmorbius 9y agohttps://www.federalreserve.gov/pubs/feds/2010/201041/index.html https://www.federalreserve.gov/pubs/feds/2010/201041/index.h... The St. Louis Fed tends to have the largest set of articles on economic policy, generally. Here are 632 results for "fractional reserve": https://encrypted.google.com/search?hl=en&q=site%3Astlouisfed.org%20"fractional%20reserve" https://encrypted.google.com/search?hl=en&q=site%3Astlouisfe... And limiting to 2010 and subesequently, 27. None declaring the concept dead. https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=site%3Astlouisfed.org+"fractional+reserve"&hl=en&source=lnt&tbs=cdr%3A1%2Ccd_min%3A1%2F1%2F2010%2Ccd_max%3A&tbm= https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=site%3Astlouisfed.org+...
- littlestymaar 9y ago
- opportune 9y agoVery good point. My pet theory is that the emphasis on asset-ownership as a means of retirement is what is decreasing the velocity of money. For example, let's say we had a system where instead of purchasing a home/stocks/bonds to save for retirement, you could instead pay the government $X which essentially goes toward an annuity with payout determined by the age at which you retire. The government could just immediately spend that money - perhaps on other retirements - and your actual annuity is just an accounting entry. So this is similar to social security, except you can pay more if you want to. The emphasis on assets for retirement locks a lot of money up in an unproductive musical-chairs of asset transfership. For example let's say I have a pay-day and want to spend $100 on buying stock. When I buy that stock I'm purchasing it directly from someone else who now has $100 instead of the stock. They can spend that money on goods and services, but in my opinion there is a far greater chance that they will reinvest that money in some other asset. If the actual assets in the market don't change, I think you can say that my investment increased the total sum of costs of all assets. I'm not 100% sure this is solid logic but it's some rough reasoning. The problem is that at any given time more people are buying new assets instead of selling them off. This is because you can make money on purchased assets through rentiership (dividends, renting, or collateral for a leveraged investment that pays dividends/can be rented), and also because people are cautious and save more than they need, since asset prices are unstable.
- littlestymaar 9y agoThat's an interesting point, and easily challenged since my country (France) is actually doing what you suggest. And as a matter of fact, retirement here is part of the social security system (La sécurité sociale). I'll check if we see the same kind of slowdown of money during the past decades here. I have two personal pet theories (is that really a common idiom in english ? I like it !) on that topic. 1. since we now focus on low inflation, people have little incentive to spend/invest their money, they can just hoard cash for a long time with no risk of losing money. 2. The low imposition rate since Reagan accelerate the concentration of capital, and rich people buy assets with their money, not consuption goods.
- opportune 9y ago
- alexasmyths 9y ago"But since the late seventies, money creation is only possible through the banking system via credit." ? I don't know how the Kroner works, but usually a central bank issues currency into the market in exchange for some kind of asset - this is the primary mechanism for controlling interest rates. Yes, more credit is created through fractional reserver, but this is taken into account.
- littlestymaar 9y ago> more credit is created through fractional reserve There is no such thing as fractionnal reserve credit in 2017, bank don't need reserve to lend, they need reserve to hold bank accounts for their customers.
- alexasmyths 9y ago? The fact banks can lend out more than they have in deposits means there is 'fractional reserve credit', or 'fractional lending' currently, in 2017. Most of the credit in the world is created this way, actually.
- kgwgk 9y agoHave you seen the balance sheet of a bank? They don't lend out more than they have in deposits.
- alexasmyths 9y agoBanks definitely lend out more than they have in deposits. [1] It's why you've heard the term 'reserve ratios' etc.. [1] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/022416/why-banks-dont-need-your-money-make-loans.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/022416/why-b...
- kgwgk 9y agoThe link you sent doesn't say that they lend out more than they have in deposits (it says loans create deposits... so they will always have more deposits than there are loans). And the following passage doesn't make much sense: "When a bank makes a loan, there are two corresponding entries that are made on its balance sheet, one on the assets side and one on the liabilities side." If you take a loan to buy a house, it will not be a new deposit at your bank. It will be a new deposit at the seller's bank. And against that new deposit, that bank can extend new loans. Etc. http://thenextturn.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Fractional-Reserve-Banking.jpg http://thenextturn.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Fractional... Of course when you are just getting the loan it will appear as a deposit at your bank. But this is not to balance the loan. The loan is coming from a reduction in reserves. This temporary deposit (on the liabilities side) will increase the reserves temporarily (on the assets side), but only until you take the money out to do whatever you asked the money for. Definitely banks do not lend out more than they have in deposits (ignoring other forms of financing for banks, of course).
- geezerjay 9y ago> To get out of the rising housing prices trap, we need another money creation mechanism, ...or simply a way to deflate the housing market, such as public housing and urban renewal projects. I don't understand why a small issue that's easily solved and a very basic strategy all over the world is somehow interpreted as a insurmountable problem that means the entire economical system is broken.