10 ms·
> High housing prices are great for those who already owned houses Not really. Rising prices (not high prices) are great for people holding houses as investme
by lisper 9y ago
> High housing prices are great for those who already owned houses
Not really. Rising prices (not high prices) are great for people holding houses as investments. But for owner-occupied houses, rising prices are as bad for the owners as they are for everyone else.
my wife and I own a house in Northern California, which we bought during the sub-prime crash. Since then it has nearly doubled in price. It is also too big for us, so we'd like to sell it and move to a smaller house. But we can't. Why? Because by the time you factor in:
1. Capital gains tax
2. Real estate agent fees
3. Higher property taxes (even a smaller house costs much more than the prop-13 basis in our current house)
we can't afford to move!
- dmode 9y agoI am very confused on your reasons not being able to downsize. Capital gains should have no impact, since first 500K is exempt. So you will have at least 500K in cash. Real estate agent fees are everywhere and can be negotiated to 2%. Property taxes are not really high. I live in Union City, and pay 1.2%. I guess you cannot downsize because a smaller home costs a lot of money these days. Which is fair enough, but you can book your profits, invest that cash in other assets and rent for a few years till the market comes down.
- lisper 9y agoThat's true, we could do that. But then we'd have to move twice, and at this point in our lives (we're both >50) moving is a non-trivial hassle. It's also not a given that prices will come down, so this strategy carries some risk that we end up stuck in a rental.
- Retric 9y ago#3 is real, but more a sign of California's disfunction than an inherent problem with high property values. PS: #1 only consumes a percentage of profits, so it can't make a sale unprofitable.
- lisper 9y ago> #1 only consumes a percentage of profits, sit it can't make a sale unprofitable. Yes, that's true, but it makes a move less efficient. If we sell our house and buy another one of equal value, the higher the price, the more we lose in capital gain tax in the transition. If our house had not appreciated, we would pay zero cap gains. The higher prices go, the more expensive it becomes to move locally.
- Retric 9y agoThe first 500,000$ of capital gains are excluded when selling a primary residence jointly. So, if your net profit > 500,000$ yes it costs money, but if your actually downsizing then you will very likely come out ahead. Further, your new home is also worth more money in the event you move out of the area.
- lisper 9y ago> if your net profit > 500,000$ It is. > yes it costs money but assuming you want to down size that should hardly be an issue. Why? A loss is a loss. What difference does it make if it comes out of your checking account or your home equity?
- Marazan 9y agoYou home equity is only realised when you sell. There is no loss. There is only the money you get net after the sale.
- Retric 9y agoYou also save that 500,000$ of appreciation when selling the second house. AKA, if house 1 gained 2 million and house 2 gained 2 million your better off than if house 1 gained 4 million. Now, you can get into cash flow issues etc. But, with home interest being tax deductible and long term capital gains being below normal taxes your almost always better off over time to sell after a bubble than before. PS: If your investment makes 4% and your mortgage is 5% then you have a net savings after taxes.
- Dylan16807 9y agoThat's more because prop-13 is a garbage fire than any other factor.
- lisper 9y agoThe cap gains is also a big factor. Even if prop 13 were not a factor, the higher prices go, the more expensive it becomes to make a lateral move, or even to downsize.
- notyourday 9y agoThis is pure nonsense. Lateral move or downsize are two different transactions. Capital gains has no effect on the second one. People who are complaining about the capital gains taxes pretending that such taxes prevent them from either moving laterally or downsizing are complaining that other properties also appreciated in price. What they would have preferred is that their property appreciated and the properties they wanted to move to did not.
- Shaanie 9y agoIf I buy a house for 50k and want to immediately move laterally to another house worth 50k then the cost is 0 + overhead. If I buy a house for 50k and want to move laterally when it's worth 100k then the cost is the taxes of the 50k profit + overhead. This gets even worse if you want to buy a larger house (if appreciation is percentage based).
- notyourday 9y agoThat's not correct. In the second case: You bought a house for $50k, which in a year appreciated to $100k. You sell the house for $100k, pay the capital gains of X% on the $50k of appreciation which gets you $100k - ($50k * X% ) to play with. You lateral move would not be to a house worth $100k, it would be to a house worth $100k-($50k * X%) because you d not have $100k, you only have $100 - (50k * X%). If you wanted to defer capital gains and play with entire 100k, then instead of doing a sale you would do 1031 exchange.
- sigi45 9y ago'nearly doubled' is more like gambling than investing. Investemnt would be fine if your money is little above inflation. 1-8% with renting it out.
- lisper 9y agoJust to be clear, we didn't buy this house as an investment, we bought it to live in. We're actually hoping for prices to come down so we can downsize without taking a huge financial hit in the process.
- coderholic 9y agoWon't you only pay a % of the gain in price in tax? In that case you're strictly worse if it goes down in price. You'd pay less tax, yes, but as tax is % of gains you're net worse off. If this really isn't the case can you share some example numbers showing how you can be worse off with a house that's worth more?
- lisper 9y agoSuppose we bought our house for $1M and now it's worth $2M. We have to pay 25% cap gains (federal + state) on $500k so it costs us $125k to move to a house of equal value. If prices were stable, we could move without taking that hit. The higher prices go, the higher the cost of moving.
- tostitos1979 9y agoYou are better off unless you bought the large house for cash. Otherwise, you made a big gain in leveraged terms.
- lisper 9y agoWhat you say is true, but it misses the point, which is that big gains only help you if you actually cash out. If you're making a lateral move, or downsizing in the same area, it doesn't matter whether you're leveraged or not. A loss is still a loss.
- astura 9y agoDo you have to pay capital gains tax on your primary home? I was under the impression you didn't if you lived in it for X number of years.
- lisper 9y agoThere's a 500k exemption, but our house has appreciated more than that. The more it goes up, the more we lose if we move.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mbesto 9y agoBut you're not "losing" more...you're only losing more in relation to the gain that has appreciated. Are you inferring to the fact that the rest of the market is appreciating at the same rate, and thus "losing" out when you buy on the downsize?
- lisper 9y agoYes, exactly. The higher prices go, the more it costs to make a local move. We only "win" if we actually cash out and move to a different, less expensive area, but we don't want to do that. We like it here.
- kgwgk 9y agoDo you mean “win” compared to the counterfactual where the house has appreciated and you don’t move to a similar one, or compared to the counterfactual where the house didn’t appreciate and you move to another one at the original price? If there had been no appreciation, your final wealth (cash + home equity) would be lower than in the case where the houses are more expensive, even after paying taxes, so it’s hard to see where is the loss. But of course if you expect prices to go down it’s a good idea to avoid paying taxes on a gain that may be reduced in the future.
- mbesto 9y agoFellow Northern California homeowner here. You can sell it and you will net a return. I'm not sure I understand your gripe. It sounds like you're annoyed about the hassle of moving , the associated fees, etc. But the parent's point is valid - the appreciation of value of your house is great for you. > 1. Capital gains tax Note - if it's your primary residence you get capital gains relief on the first $500k. > 2. Real estate agent fees If you're in the bay area, then you negotiate these down to the minimum (IIRC 2.5%) because the market is so liquid and the agents add very little value (if you're smart). Also, you can negotiate not to pay the commission if you're the buyer. So the only burden is on the sale, which is less impactful since you've already made a profit on it. > 3. Higher property taxes Yes, this is a bitch in CA...see next point. > we can't afford to move! Clarification - you can't afford to move in the general vicinity, but you could certainly move to Nevada (for example). If you are not viewing your house as an investment, then guess what? You get to live in an area that is high demand! Good for you for timing the market appropriately when you bought.
- lisper 9y ago> if it's your primary residence you get capital gains relief on the first $500k. Yes, I know. But our appreciation is substantially more than that. The higher it goes, the more expensive it becomes to make a move. > which is less impactful since you've already made a profit on it Only if we move to a less expensive area. If we make a local move, that "profit" just gets rolled in to the next house. There's no way to cash out without leaving the area. > Clarification - you can't afford to move in the general vicinity, but you could certainly move to Nevada (for example). Yes, exactly right. What we really want to do, but can't because it's too expensive, is downsize. This would not be the case if prices were stable.
- ttul 9y agoAwww poor baby. You’ve made more than $500K, much of which will be untaxed, simply by owning a house. Jesus fucking Christ. Cry me a river. Most people would trade their arm in for that kind of leveraged gain.
- 9y ago
- paulsutter 9y agoConsider renting out your current house and buying that smaller house to live in. Talk to your tax person, you may get depreciation and more. EDIT: person
- whatyoucantsay 9y agoNot every reader of HN possesses "a tax guy".
- paulcole 9y agoI can only imagine the pain of owning a house that has increased over $500k in value in less than a decade. Are there support groups in your area you can turn to?
- scarmig 9y agoOh, for Christ's sake. The OP isn't saying that he's being lynched or thrown into a gas chamber. Just that spiraling housing costs aren't an unalloyed good for home owners who want to stay in the area they live in.
- bernawil 9y ago> Rising prices (not high prices) are great for people holding houses as investments This is right. Part of the problem is that we don't refer to this by what it is: Inflation in housing prices. The thing about housing is that you can't choose not to consume it. You can't anticipate your consumption to beat inflation either. The only way to win with housing inflation is by exploting some subsidy like cheap leverage and the like.
- conanbatt 9y ago> Inflation in housing prices. Self-defeating definition. Inflation is generalized prices increases. It stops being generalized if you pick an asset type.
- pimmen 9y agoAnd this is the problem with Sweden; we got rid of the property tax, but we kept the capital gains tax meaning people are less incentivized to sell since the prices are rising anyway, meaning fewer houses end up on the market, meaning the prices rise. This is one of the many contributors to this crisis; high capital gains taxes for people selling their house, no property tax for people keeping it. Add to that our tax deductions on interest rates and local government monopoly on what types of houses gets built (obviously not affordable housing projects, they pay terrible taxes compared to the nice people who would move into luxury condos) and you have a recipe for disaster. There's many, many other reasons too but those things are what the government could and should work on.
- grouseway 9y agoCanada has no capital gains tax on housing and it has similar housing inflation to Sweden. I would say people are frantic to buy a home in Canada because it's tax free and the alternative (stocks/bonds/etc..) isn't.
- stuxnet79 9y agoIs this really true?? I think if you are selling a home that is not your primary residence then there is some sort of tax but I'm not 100% sure of the details.
- grouseway 9y agoIt's true for the primary residence. For secondary properties most people are just going to move in for 2 years to meet the requirement.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- opportune 9y agoCapital gains is only applicable when you sell the house and it's not your primary residence, or if you made a ton of money on it. And it's only a tax on the appreciation of the house, not its market value. Real estate agent fees are only applicable on x% of the value of the house you sell. Higher property taxes do stink but are not applicable after you sell the house. I'm not sure why you can't afford to move. Have you talked to a tax specialist or a financial advisor? If you bought a house at X and sold it at 2x, even if you haven't paid any of the principal of your mortgage(if you have one), you would likely pay a maximum of ~25% of X between capital gains (if you own multiple homes) and real estate agent fees. So you still made 75% of X from appreciation. I don't really understand what you think your problem is.
- Danihan 9y agoThank you -- this post did not add up to me either. Do a FSBO if you're that worried about brokerage fees.
- ralusek 9y agoYou're right on 2/3 of those things. Capital gains is never a "cost" to them, they are by definition only going to be taxed on their gains. Real estate agent fees, like you said, are based off of the sell value, so unless their commission starts approaching 50% of the value of the house on a 2x gain...they make money. And if their mega-agent charges them 50% of the value of the house, then at least there are no longer any gains to be taxed on :) The property taxes, however, make sense. Some places lock you in to a certain rate at the purchase price, and they said they bought very low. The argument is that they would be paying more in property taxes for a cheaper house, because they would no longer be locked in to their favorable current rate, which is entire likely given their circumstance.
- opportune 9y agoYou're right, I thought the parent was complaining about higher property taxes, not that property taxes would increase if they were to move to a similarly valued house. That does disincentivize moving into an equally valued house, but moving into that house would have the parent paying about ~2% of X each year in property taxes as opposed to ~1% of X. The appreciation of the house still covers the increase in property taxes for the next 75 years.
- robrenaud 9y agoIt seems like 3. is the real problem? If taxes were a function of current home value rather than at purchase home value, you wouldn't be stuck.
- lisper 9y agoWell, it's all of the above really. But does it really matter? The point is that we'd be better off relative to our goals if prices were stable. So we are a counter-example to the claim that rising prices benefit all home owners. They don't.
- r00fus 9y agoRent it and use the rental income to establish finance for the 2nd house.