7 ms·
The Greek science (and literature) predated the Islamic one by over a thousand years.
by Koshkin 9y ago
The Greek science (and literature) predated the Islamic one by over a thousand years.
- ozmodiar 9y agoI believe his point isn't that they influenced the Greeks, but that they are largely credited with maintaining the recordings of Greek science/literature/philosophy that allowed them to endure to this day.
- iorrus 9y agoThis isn't true the vast majority were preserved in Byzantium. "The real influence of Dionysius in the West began with the gift in 827 of a Greek copy of his works by the Byzantine Emperor Michael II to the Carolingian King Louis the Pious. " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pseudo-Dionysius_the_Areopagite https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pseudo-Dionysius_the_Areopagit... Most were disseminated in Europe after the fourth crusade in which Constantinople was sacked. See also: https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/byz/byz-mss-art.asp https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/byz/byz-mss-art.asp
- InitialLastName 9y agoI think what GP is referring to is Arab scholars' role in preserving classical science and literature after the fall of the Roman Empire in the west (so that, as the narrative goes, it could be brought back by European explorers to trigger the Renaissance).
- Koshkin 9y agoWhy assume that the Greeks themselves were not able to preserve their own heritage? The Eastern Roman Empire survived well into the second millennium.
- InitialLastName 9y ago1) I'm referring to a commonly known narrative, not necessarily the truth (I've recently been trying to encourage myself to recognize when my "knowledge" is of limited veracity). 2) I think the assumption is less that they were unable and more that they did not. I'm not familiar enough with the history of library science to judge this.
- cristianpascu 9y agoThere's this book, Aristotle at the Mountain of Saint-Michele, that has caused some controversy around the idea that only muslim scholars have preserved ancient greek knowledge. https://www.brusselsjournal.com/node/3732 https://www.brusselsjournal.com/node/3732
- dekhn 9y agoWhat was key is that Islamic scholars translated the Greek works and made them available in Europe. I'm not discounting the amazing engineering works done by the Greeks and Turks.
- mkempe 9y agoActually, Byzantine monks regularly travelled to Italy for centuries, bringing scrolls with them to teach Ancient Greek. This movement accelerated during the crusades, and got its final major impetus at the final fall of Constantinople. The myth that somehow the West owes access to the texts of Ancient Greece to the anti-reason Moslem world is very misleading. One would have to believe that there was zero contact for one thousand years between Western Europe and Byzantium -- an utterly, bizarrely wrong notion.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoThe Moslem world wasn't anti-reason for much of that era of history.
- mkempe 9y agoScholars argue that Averroes was the last of the significant pro-reason philosophers in the Moslem world, and he lost that battle.
- Nomentatus 9y agoIndeed. I have read that we wouldn't know of Averroes had his works not been preserved in the West, since all traces of him were expunged from the Islamic world.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoByzantine monks had the same neoplatonic ideas that were common in Western Europe, having been established around Constantine's reign. Aristotelian ideas lived on in the Arab world, and it is contact with their philosophical works that led to Aristotelian ideas in Christianity. I can own a book my entire life, it doesn't make me an expert on it and people I interact with won't gain an interest in it.
- hyperpallium 9y ago"in the west"