13 ms·
Science and Tech of the Byzantine Empire
- mirimir 9y agoAnd it remains largely hidden, after reading this article :( But there are a few interesting tidbits, and it's a quick read.
- kwhitefoot 9y agoMore like notes for an article really. Or a high school exercise in creating a summary. I would give it something like "6/10, must try harder". Might have been interesting to read if there had been more than clickbait so I only read the first two of the six. The fact that the earth is a globe was known at least 1200 years earlier than Symeon Seth because the circumference had been measured by Eratosthenes <https://www.thoughtco.com/eratosthenes-biography-1435011> https://www.thoughtco.com/eratosthenes-biography-1435011>. I'm disappointed, Nautilus is usually a bit better than this.
- mcemilg 9y agoit is necessary to investigate their correctness. The "On fatal wings" story is similar to Hezarfen's story. Maybe it's a story that has been around for years.Take a look at that https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hez%C3%A2rfen_Ahmed_%C3%87elebi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hez%C3%A2rfen_Ahmed_%C3%87eleb...
- empath75 9y agoThe source ‘Choniates’ was writing 400 years before that story is supposed to have happened.
- mcemilg 9y agoWell yeah I saw it. So then we know at least there are three people exists in the history who they try to fly with robe. The Arab, Hezarfen and the French guy. People are weird. These are some kind of wingsuit prototype.
- coldtea 9y agoThere are more than three. A lot, in the later stages, died trying to create modern parachutes too, others were more modest in the heights (and above what surfaces) they tested their devices. Also the several attempts at bird-like planes to fly (with movable bird-like wings).
- UncleSlacky 9y agoEilmer of Malmesbury was fairly successful, flying some distance. He broke both legs but survived: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eilmer_of_Malmesbury#The_flight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eilmer_of_Malmesbury#The_fligh...
- kwhitefoot 9y agoI feel I must defend Aristotle. At least we would need a lot more information before we can conclude that Philoponos really knew what he was talking about. Of course he was right but for this to be effective there needs to be a theory and better experiments and that is what Galileo provided. I recommend Carlo Rovelli's essay on Aristotle's Physics: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1312.4057.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1312.4057.pdf.
- coldtea 9y ago>Of course he was right but for this to be effective there needs to be a theory and better experiments and that is what Galileo provided. It only needs the simple observation the kind of Philoponos did to refute Aristotle's thesis. And his arguments show that he knew what he was talking about -- very to the point. What would need "a theory and better experiments" would be to create a physics of falling -- Philoponos didn't do that (or said he did). He merely refuted Aristotle. We celebrate Democritus atomic theory for far less (as he did no experiments and it was just an idea he had).
- reese_john 9y agoJohn Von Neunman was particularly a huge enthusiast of the Byzantine empire. A professor of Byzantine history at Princeton once said that von Neumann had greater expertise in Byzantine history than he did. [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_von_Neumann#Early_career_and_private_life https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_von_Neumann#Early_career_...
- mandelliant 9y agoThat's an awesome fact! I'm reading Von Neumann & Morgenstern's Game Theory and Economic Behavior now and while I'm not surprised he's gifted in other disciplines, it's amazing that someone can be so deep in so many fields.
- tmccrmck 9y agoYou should read Turing's Cathedral if you are interested in Von Neumann's life.
- mandelliant 9y agoThanks for the recommendation. I'm actually reading the biography of Turing at the moment, so that sounds like a perfect follow-up.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dekhn 9y agoThe Arab Muslims also had an amazing science and tech culture which isn't well appreciated today. Many of the revolutions in Europe in the Middle Ages happened as direct outcomes of Arab Muslim tech. A few of my heros: Avicenna (Ibn Sina) and Ismail al-Jazari.
- artificial 9y agoI’d like to know more, can you point me in the direction of institutions of the period where this was taught? What are some of the highlights?
- gumby 9y agoThe simplest would be just to start with "Avicenna" and "al-Jazari" and get lost down the wikipedia rabbit hole. Also: take a look at why we have a subject called "algebra" while we have a 17th century system "calculus" named after the roman word for pebble. Nicely, the Wikipedia's entry for "algorithm" starts with the etymology of the word, which combines these threads (Hindu scholars -> Islamic scholars -> medieval scholars)º. BTW the Indian counting system's roots appear to lie in Babylonian sexagesimal counting but the Indians appear to be the first to figure out position numeration and do 5/10-based arithmetic quickly and simply by taking advantage of it. º And doesn't mention the congressional funding of the Internet at all (if you remember that hoary joke)
- dekhn 9y agoI started at the Avicenna and Al Jaziri wikipedia pages and did the equivalent of DFS on outlinks until I stopped seeing new pages. It took a while, but now I know more about 10th century hydrological engineering in Northern Africa than I did before...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Koshkin 9y agoTo be fair, Avicenna was Persian, although he had been definitely influenced by the Islamic science developed by the Arabs.
- weeha 9y agoI can highly recommend History of Byzantium podcast by Robin Pierson. "The History of Byzantium” is a podcast dedicated to the story of the Roman Empire from the collapse of the West in 476 to the fall of Constantinople in 1453. Byzantine history is fascinating, world changing and largely forgotten. Listen and discover who they were."
- weeha 9y agoForgot the link: https://thehistoryofbyzantium.com/ https://thehistoryofbyzantium.com/
- prewett 9y agoOh my goodness, he's at episode 150+ and he is only at 1000 AD! I thought Dan Carlin was thorough / long-winded, but this guy make Carlin look like a short summary!
- eropple 9y agoA more common criticism of Carlin is that he is not thorough. That isn't a shot at him, usually (though a couple of the historians I know aren't big on his sources), but a lot of that is the format he's decided to go with--when you are limited to mere hours, you're going to necessarily be shallow about things.
- xPhobophobia 9y agoThanks for the recommendation. I've been listening to Dan Carlin and his history podcasts and am almost done with all of them. I needed something to add to the queue.
- isk517 9y agoYou may want to consider checking out Mike Duncan's podcasts the History of Rome and Revolutions as well. History of Rome especially since it was the ending of that podcast at the fall of the west that encouraged the creation of the History of Byzantium podcast.
- tryingagainbro 9y agoArticle aside, an Empire that manages to last hundreds of years (1100+ in their case, and even more depending how you calculate it) must've been doing quite a few things right. Imagine how many enemies, crisis and emperors they had to go through, yet they survived for a very, very long time.
- zeveb 9y ago> Article aside, an Empire that manages to last hundreds of years (1100+ in their case, and even more depending how you calculate it) must be doing quite a few things right. I think it's fairest to calculate it from the founding of Rome (21 Apr 753 BC) to the fall of Constantinople (29 May AD 1453): 2,205 years. In that time it went from a kingdom to a republic to an empire, but the Roman government continued in one form or another.
- lostboys67 9y agoYes if only they had been obsessed with internal religious divisions and fighting the Persians (ignoring the new threat from the west). Not to mention the forth crusade!!
- tryingagainbro 9y agoQuite a few old fashion Orthodox are still upset over it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sack_of_Constantinople_(1204) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sack_of_Constantinople_(1204) . Like in Islam....different factions debate and hold grudges for ever.
- elorant 9y agoIt's kind of odd but as Greeks in school we learn little for the Byzantium as compared to Classical Greece which pretty much dominates history books. That's probably because Byzantium was never actually Greek, many emperors didn't even speak the language. For anyone interested in learning the history I would suggest John Julius Norwich's trilogy. Impeccable work.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- smitherfield 9y ago> Byzantium was never actually Greek, many emperors didn't even speak the language. Huh? I'll admit I'm not that well-read about Byzantine history, but I had always been under the impression that from the reign of Heraclius (mid-7th-century) onwards[1] the court language was always or virtually always Greek. [1] Which is also as good a dividing line as any between the "Roman" and "Byzantine" periods.
- KineticLensman 9y agoIf Byzantium (Constantinople) had lasted just another 39 years (to 1492, to be precise), then one could claim (sort-of) that the Roman Empire had lasted until the West discovered America.
- peterburkimsher 9y agoI'd argue that we are Roman. When the western capital Rome fell, people moved east (imagine moving from California to New York). But the Byzantines still called themselves Roman. When the eastern capital was invaded by the Ottoman Turks, they moved west to rebuild Rome - and started the "Renaissance". There was no Renaissance, some magical discovery of ancient knowledge, with masterful artists and scientists like the world had never seen. It was a continuation of the Roman tradition! In fact, one can even go back before Rome to Greece, to Alexander the Great conquering Darius the Mede, to Medo-Persia, to Babylon, to Assyria, to Mesopotamia. Writing was invented in 3 places: Sumeria, China, and South America. But the Mayan history is almost lost (3 books survive). Western culture split from middle-eastern, and Indian civilisation got fragmented until the British Raj forced everyone to learn English, a Latin language. Since the dawn of history, there have been Western, Middle Eastern, and China as world powers. Only in this generation do we have machine translation (Google Translate) to finally share our knowledge more easily between these cultures. I propose a translated search. Pass the query through Google Translate before loading results. Then if I want to know about the legend of a talking ox, I can find it from Pliny ( http://peterburk.github.io/pliny http://peterburk.github.io/pliny ) or from the Chinese.
- cholantesh 9y agoWhat about the Viking settlements in Newfoundland?