9 ms·
I wish they’d tone it down a little. This is really interesting, but stuff like this makes it hard to take them seriously: “Apple has done this not so well. I
by mikeash 9y ago
I wish they’d tone it down a little. This is really interesting, but stuff like this makes it hard to take them seriously:
“Apple has done this not so well. I remember reading an article on Mashable, in which Apple told that iPhone X had been planned to be rolled out in 2018, but the company then decided to release it one year earlier. This shows that they haven't carried out scientific and serious estimation before deciding to replace Touch ID with Face ID.”
I’m amy case, this doesn’t worry me personally too much. I don’t expect biometrics to be more secure than a password, just reasonably secure and more convenient. Before Touch ID, my passcode was 0000 with a four-hour lock timeout. I only had it set because some apps reduced functionality if no passcode was set. Real world security for me increased a lot with biometrics.
As for fingerprints versus facial recognition, the article claims fingerprints are better, but I’m skeptical. For one thing, my phone is covered in my own fingerprints, so getting something to copy is a lot easier.
- gilleain 9y ago> As for fingerprints versus facial recognition, the article claims fingerprints are better, but I’m skeptical. For one thing, my phone is covered in my own fingerprints, so getting something to copy is a lot easier. Would it be possible to have a really secure phone that had fake fingerprints added to the material of the surface of the phone? I'm only half-serious, but it might make lifting the real prints harder... (maybe it is trivial to distinguish prints made on a surface from those in the structure of the surface)
- coldtea 9y ago>Would it be possible to have a really secure phone that had fake fingerprints added to the material of the surface of the phone? Because we don't touch 20000 other objects every day from where someone can pick our fingertips from?
- GrinningFool 9y ago_>Because we don't touch 20000 other objects every day from where someone can pick our fingertips from?_ We're less likely to lose one of those objects at the same place and time we leave our phone somewhere. It's comparable to leaving your keys in your car. Sure, someone could find those keys where you lost them and then find your car - but is sure is easier for them when they're both in the same place.
- joesb 9y ago> We're less likely to lose one of those objects at the same place and time we leave our phone somewhere. I think it's very likely that you touch something at the place where you left you phone, assuming that it wasn't dropped while you were moving.
- oneweekwonder 9y agoor good old tactics wonderfully illustrated in the xkcd: Security[0] cartoon. [0]: https://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/
- seandougall 9y agoBut you usually don’t draw a circle around the relevant print and leave a note saying “use this one to unlock my phone” (unlike the Touch ID sensor).
- mikeash 9y agoI suspect that any solution along these lines would be easy to break, because real fingerprints aren't permanent. If all else fails, make a high-resolution scan of the entire phone, then clean it and make another one. The fingerprints that are no longer present in the second scan are the real ones. You might have a better shot at coming up with some material that just doesn't get fingerprints on it in the first place. Maybe a cloth-covered phone?
- eric_h 9y ago> maybe it is trivial to distinguish prints made on a surface from those in the structure of the surface I believe it is. Fingerprints left on a surface are made with oils from the skin and are "lifted" off by applying a substance that sticks to it and literally lifting the print off the surface.
- toyg 9y agoBiometrics are weaker than anything that relies on knowledge, for the simple fact that a physical attack IRL cannot be resisted. One could die without revealing a pin or password, but a biometric device would reveal his secrets very quickly through simple coercion and even after death has occurred.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoApple specifically recommends to law enforcement using a deceased suspect’s fingerprint while the device will still accept it to bypass encryption.
- lozenge 9y agoLegally in the US you can't be forced to testify a password under the fourth amendment, but you can be forced to use your fingerprint to unlock a device. That's why repeatedly pressing the power button on an iPhone prevents any biometric unlocking.
- jasonkostempski 9y agoI'm curious if using that feature could lead to other charges.
- criddell 9y agoI'm not sure that's firmly established. Last time I looked into it, there were rulings in just about every direction, but the trend seemed to be what you suggest.
- coldtea 9y ago>One could die without revealing a pin or password, but a biometric device would reveal his secrets very quickly through simple coercion and even after death has occurred. Well, that's hardly a criterion for most people. I'd rather give the password than die.
- deleted 9y ago
- coldtea 9y ago>but stuff like this makes it hard to take them seriously What about that part makes it hard to "take them seriously"? Their claims to be "the leading security firm" etc might be, but this is a perfectly rational and plausible claim (and the part that the technology was rushed is true as told by Apple). >Before Touch ID, my passcode was 0000 with a four-hour lock timeout. Then probably you're not the target market for a secure device.
- mikeash 9y agoIt's hard to take seriously because they take a story about Apple getting the phone out a year early as somehow demonstrating that Apple hadn't properly studied how the security of Face ID compares with Touch ID. It's a total non sequitur. There's no such thing as "a secure device." There are devices which offer various levels and types of security. If you're a CIA officer carrying classified secrets on your device, you probably don't want to use Face ID. For the average user, it's a nice increase in security.
- coldtea 9y ago>It's hard to take seriously because they take a story about Apple getting the phone out a year early as somehow demonstrating that Apple hadn't properly studied how the security of Face ID compares with Touch ID. It's a total non sequitur. Non sequitur? Sounds like a totally rational argument to me, to the point of being a tautology. Rushed a feature to market by one year == they also rushed the testing.
- mikeash 9y agoThere are a lot of holes in your equation there. Apple never said they rushed the phone. They said they were able to get it out early. These are not the same thing; "rushed" implies that quality suffered, while merely getting it out early could just be due to work going faster than anticipated. Even if the phone as a whole was "rushed," that doesn't mean Face ID was. Maybe it was naturally ready by now. Even if Face ID was rushed, that doesn't mean that the security aspects were rushed. Even if Face ID's security aspects were rushed, that doesn't mean testing was rushed. It's like if you show up early to a meeting and so I accuse you of speeding. Is that sensible?
- CodeWriter23 9y ago> For one thing, my phone is covered in my own fingerprints, so getting something to copy is a lot easier. Use your pinky or ring finger for fingerprint recognition.
- seandougall 9y agoI have discovered to my surprise, since shattering my iPhone 6 screen last week, that Touch ID works perfectly well through multiple layers of Saran Wrap. So you could keep your thumb wrapped up if you’re concerned about leaving prints. ;-) In the meantime, my iPhone X arrives on Thursday, and I’m looking forward to training Face ID. All I got from this article was “these are the lengths you have to go to to defeat it”, which seems pretty darn good for my purposes.
- mikeash 9y agoFunny idea. My takeaway from the article was similar. Touch ID was already Good Enough for me, and it sounds like Face ID is quite a bit better. Which is, oddly enough, exactly what I expected. One thing I'd really be interested in learning about is how much time and how many attempts it took them before they could successfully unlock the phone. And more pertinently, what those values might look like once they get some more experience with it. In a real-world scenario, they only get 48 hours and 5 attempts, so any technique which takes more than that is still nonviable. It will also be interesting to see if Apple is able to improve their defenses against this. I get the sense that they couldn't improve Touch ID much because a good fake fingerprint looks just like a real one to the sensor. This mask definitely does not look much like the person's actual face, so they may be able to tweak things to be more resistant to this attack. Which is not to say that this attack is pointless or these guys are dumb or anything. I'm impressed with their work! It's just not a game over situation the way they make it sound in certain parts of their writeup.