3 ms·
Two words: incremental improvement. 3d printing is getting better and cheaper all the time. Cameras and software are getting better all the time. If someone
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
Two words: incremental improvement.
3d printing is getting better and cheaper all the time.
Cameras and software are getting better all the time.
If someone cares enough to invest the R&D it should be pretty easy to automate everything between getting photos someone and printing the mask.
The point is that using biometric authentication as an all-in-one isn't secure.
- simonh 9y agoPhotos are not enough, they would need a high resolution 3D scan on the person’s face as well. Also they didn’t just use 3D printing, they had to use different fabrication methods and materials for different parts of the face part of which was ‘simply’ hand sculpted. This is not at all trivial to automate. But then we already know it’s not as secure as two factor authentication and a random passcode. Touch ID could be fooled with predict fingerprints as well, though with the deep subcutaneous scanning in later versions it was much harder than with the first version. Anyway, Nobody who critically depends on the security of their phone should use Face ID or Touch ID anyway.
- blensor 9y agoWhy do you know that photos are not enough? If you have good enough photos you can produce higher resolution 3D models than with a Kinect like depth sensor (which in the end is just a stereo "camera" anyway). And since the Face ID probably does not work with any arbitrary 3D object but only with faces you just need to reconstruct the target face to a degree so that the Face ID system can detect the landmarks it is looking for. My guess on how those attacks will develop in the future are: 1. Exploit occlusions. As far as I know the FaceID System does work with occluded faces (glasses, maybe scarfs in the winter, ...). Once you know what the minimum required visible area is, you can focus on partial faces. If the algorithm has less features to identify, it probably makes more mistakes and is easier to fool. 2. Create a low-dimensional (in terms of parameters, not vertices) representation of a face that can be tuned to mimic a wide variety of target faces and still is correctly identified by Face ID. Once you have that you can take a few photos of your target person and tune the parameters in your generic model to fit the person in the photos, and probably be even able to reconstruct a mask from far away. 3. Try to create a real mask with a flexible surface that can be tuned to fit a wide range of faces. If at all possible try to span the same feature space as in 2.) as it would allow you to create a real face mask from only the few parameters that directly come from your fitting process. If all of the above works an attacker can create an Iphone stealing pipeline: Have several cameras set up in a crowded tourist spot. Match persons in different views and try to reconstruct their faces. Once the system has found a person that has been viewed from enough angles, "retrieve" his phone unlock it with the mask and reset it. I know that does sound pessimistic, but your face is a "security token" but one which you can not realistically protect from theft. Unless you want it to have serious negative impact on your daily routine. And if someone wants to hide his face while in public (i.e. with a surgical mask), he can no longer travel to certain countries. I live in Austria and there just recently came a law into effect that bars everyone from occluding their face while in public.
- Retric 9y agoOne photo is not enough, but several let's you create a high quality 3D model.
- amelius 9y ago> Two words: incremental improvement. Well, the same applies to the iPhoneX and its software, I suppose.