10 ms·
Air Travelers Resisting the ‘Incredible Shrinking Airline Seat’
- luckyt 9y agoMakes sense, seat space isn't really something you consider when shopping for plane tickets. Airlines have nothing to gain by making bigger seats, so the natural progression down this road is smaller and smaller seats -- already, some seats for budget airlines are half-standing [1]. [1]: https://thepointsguy.com/2017/06/standing-seats-on-vivacolombia/ https://thepointsguy.com/2017/06/standing-seats-on-vivacolom...
- gxs 9y agoWow, that's like something out of the onion. Someone should create a travel site like Kayak with a lot more details about the airline you're flying - how often they are late, CSAT score (can be bogus, I know), seating room, etc. The old adage is that you can't manage what you don't measure, I'd love to see this stuff quantified every time I search so that I can manage my travel/money better.
- hboon 9y agohttps://www.seatguru.com https://www.seatguru.com maybe
- konschubert 9y agoI call bullshit on the standing seats. "May introduce"... That's a marketing gag to establish the airline as low budget. Ryanair did the same thing some years ago. Such seats would need to get approved by the FAA and I'm pretty sure they haven't been.
- bjelkeman-again 9y agoI am sure Ryanair say just this to anchor the current shitty conditions. "At least I don't have to pay for the toilet [1] and I still have a seat". [1] https://www.theguardian.com/money/2009/feb/27/ryanair-toilet-charge https://www.theguardian.com/money/2009/feb/27/ryanair-toilet...
- secfirstmd 9y agoMichael O'Leary said ages ago he was taking the piss out of people and getting free oublicitt with those two concepts.
- peteretep 9y ago> Makes sense, seat space isn't really > something you consider when shopping > for plane tickets And at the other end, international business class seats keep getting better and better because it's absolutely a consideration. Hence: premium economy.
- carlmr 9y agoOn most comparison shopping websites, seat space isn't mentioned. Business class is out of reach for most people traveling economy.
- cm2187 9y agoThat's not true for all passengers. I am sure I am not the only one to maintain a personal blacklist of airlines on which I had consistently horrendous experiences and will not fly with unless I have no other choice.
- sleavey 9y agoI'm often surprised just how much more expensive premium economy tickets are. I get that some people are willing to pay more for extra legroom, free/better food and drink and so on, but the cost is often 5x that of standard economy. To me, that seems a ridiculous markup to pay for slightly more comfort for only a few hours, but I guess it works because airlines sell and fill these seats.
- viraptor 9y ago> for slightly more comfort for only a few hours If it's only a few hours, sure, not a big difference. But when I fly Melbourne-London, premium economy is a difference between being a zombie for the next 48h, or arriving just tired. How much is the day after travel worth for you?
- grkvlt 9y agoyeah, for TATL (LHR to JFK minimum) or longer (SFO etc) travel, there is a quantifiable difference in comfort for premium economy, at least in BA which i normally fly. although, i actually had a reasonable flight in economy from EWR to EDI recently in United recently, but only because i ended up with a row of three seats to myself!
- randycupertino 9y agoI exclusively fly Virgin because their seats are 1.5" bigger and have 2" bigger leg room.
- colde 9y agoWhich Virgin is that? Atlantic, Australia og US?
- arnvald 9y agoI think the first time I read about "standing seats" was in Ryanair magazine in 2010. They didn't introduce it, I'm sure it was because of regulations (but they're from EU, maybe airlines in other parts of the world could do that).
- IshKebab 9y agoNo they never intended to introduce it. They says something crazy like that every now and then to get in the news and to remind people they are cheap. They've had: * Pay for the toilet * Standing 'seats' * Allow customers to watch porn Probably others I've forgotten. They've even admitted they are marketing stunts.
- viraptor 9y agoThey also did tiny beds, stacked. Which is annoying, because I'd actually pay extra to fly laying down. I don't even care how much space is available.
- grkvlt 9y agoWhich you can already do. This is exactly what business class is, right now! For example, the top deck of a BA 747 is entirely lay-flat business seats, which are incredibly comfortable for long haul. But, as you say, you have to pay (somewhat) extra, or live in hope that the computer gods decide to upgrade you...
- Jedd 9y ago> Airlines have nothing to gain by making bigger seats ... This is only because airlines are not obliged to -- or have not yet engaged in a marketing war with each other by -- advertising seat dimensions, either during the booking process, or via more general marketing. I expect it'd be more useful, way more effective, and naturally less cost, to do it during the booking phase. While this may seem like it'd risk losing customers, word of mouth is powerful in this sector. A succinct addenda such as 'compared to Xyz airline that has 50mm less space', and a hover-over picture that shows someone being annoyed by the less spacious seat, perhaps being served a meal of dubious origin by someone wearing Xyz uniform, just to drive it home. I should be in advertising. (My understanding is that 'attack' advertising is more acceptable within the US. Here in AU we're unlikely to see this kind of thing due to a dearth of carrier choice. No idea about other parts of the world.)
- mathgeek 9y agoSome airlines already do promote it, but in a sneaky way. I've seen "the most legroom in economy class" but it doesn't specify the dimensions.
- Jedd 9y agoI've seen those claims too, but as you say, they never specify dimensions, so they're in the same credibility category as 'the best pizza in town'.
- splonk 9y agoThe conventional wisdom on this is that historically, any attempt by airlines to differentiate their economy class product on any dimension other than price has failed. There's always a vocal subset of people complaining, but when push comes to shove, the large majority of customers will pick the flight with the lowest price. Arguably we will eventually reach some level of service that is so unbelievably crappy that people will be willing to pay more to avoid it, but the success of the low cost carriers suggests to me that we're not there yet.
- 9y ago
- prostoalex 9y ago> Airlines have nothing to gain by making bigger seats They do gain revenue from upselling "premium economy".
- ojiikun 9y agoPretty much anyone who has so much as heard about seatguru will beg to differ! A few of the kayak / goog flights sites even display seat pitch in search results, now.
- curtis 9y agoMy most recent flight was on a United 737-900 with 38 or 39 rows. The seat pitch can't have been more than 30 inches, and might have been 29. It was as cramped as I have ever seen on a 737. But the thing that really pissed me off was the incredibly cramped bathroom. This link (https://services.airbus.com/upgrade/cabin/layout-optimisation/smart-lav https://services.airbus.com/upgrade/cabin/layout-optimisatio...) is actually an Airbus design, but it is almost exactly what I remember on this 737. Not only was it cock-eyed (I don't know what to call it), it was incredibly narrow, even for a 737 bathroom.
- pls2halp 9y ago>Compared with the standard lavatories, Smart-Lav brings 5.5 additional inches for more seats and 10 additional inches for recline space. Yet they claim it "allows up to 6 additional seats in the cabin". Assuming they're in a row, I fail to see how you can fit a seat in 5.5 inches. >The interior of Smart-Lav has been designed to enhance the spaciousness and the hygiene perception by the passengers. It's blatantly focusing on perceptions over reality. I got sick in a plane with a similar layout(I think it was with Emirates) and I remember it being significantly more uncomfortable than any other plane I'd been on, and I think I managed to hit my head while throwing up.
- grenoire 9y agoProbably they take away seat space from others and put an extra row in the back (3 in 2 rows). Likely it gives just enough space to pass a threshold.
- nollbit 9y agoIf you take an inch of pitch from many other rows + the 5,5 that allows you to fit an extra row or two. Compare Lufthansas seatmap for the A320 vs A320neo. The neo has the Smartlav and two additional rows of seats. http://magazin.lufthansa.com/content/uploads/2016/07/a320_sitzplan_168.jpg http://magazin.lufthansa.com/content/uploads/2016/07/a320_si... http://www.lufthansa.com/mediapool/pdf/08/media_1555228708.pdf http://www.lufthansa.com/mediapool/pdf/08/media_1555228708.p...
- 9y ago
- Teknoman117 9y agoAs a 6'4" individual, I've already stopped flying the major airlines due to seat shrinking. Been flying JetBlue whenever it's available since their standard seat pitch is 36". Nearly got kicked off a Delta flight once because "I refused to stop pushing my knees into the passenger in front of me." I'm sorry, but with the middle seat populated and not being allowed to put my leg in the aisle, my legs go forward - and there is not enough room to not have contact with the seat in front of me.
- ciguy 9y agoAnd with the new thinner seat types discussed in the article, the passenger in front feels your knees much more than they used to. I'm 6'3" and while I've never been in trouble I have gotten a lot of dirty looks from the people in front of me. Airlines need to start reserving the aisle or bulkhead seats for taller passengers or something, this isn't sustainable otherwise.
- paulsutter 9y agoI finally gave up and now just pay to sit up front (6’6” here)
- regularfry 9y ago6'7" here. I don't fly long-haul any more.
- dmckeon 9y agoAs a person of similar height, I would happily pay 10% more for a seat pitch that is 10% greater, just as airlines now charge for exit rows, bulkheads, etc. Make a few rows deeper, charge more for seats that pax reserve in those rows. Don't need a hot towel or free booze, thanks, just a seat that my femurs fit into, but not at 2x price of coach, darn it.
- hkmurakami 9y agoI'm not even tall, but I have had flight anxiety/claustrophobia on flights before and I can only fly aisle seats. I'm often happy to pay for exit as well. What's the current markup on exit rows? 15-25%?
- geetfun 9y agoNot to mention those of us who travel with families. It’s quite a mess to say the least. Flying has become such a hassle I just rather drive and take a few extra days off to accommodate the commute.
- baby 9y agoSame here. If there is a train to go there I’ll pay extra and take the train. Flying sucks so much. It’s not just the airport and the plane. But getting to the airport or back home is also a hassle here in London.
- userbinator 9y agoDriving is not always possible, especially when there's an ocean in the middle of the trip. In that case, spending a dozen hours in a plane is much preferable to a week or more on a ship.
- userbinator 9y agoThe push to shrink the space between rows of seats comes as major carriers are squeezing 10 abreast in more long-haul jets, so that the middle section has four seats — and, by definition, two middle seats — rather than three. 3-4-3 in a 747 feels quite comfortable, but I would certainly not like it on any smaller plane.
- hkmurakami 9y agoI was thinking the same. 3-4-3 on a 747 is fine, but the same arrangement on a 777 does not sound appetizing.
- sitepodmatt 9y agoIts not. Qatar Airways made my no fly list recently, they used to be great but densification on 777 is painful, especially after stepping off an equally cramped new sardineliner. Back to above-average Emirates and A380, the densification programs esp on 777,and new cans like 787, have actually made aircraft like a380, a330, and 747 rate higher than ever.
- randycupertino 9y agoPeople getting bigger. Seats getting smaller. Something's got to give.
- jpalomaki 9y agoA good start we would be to make it mandatory for airlines to give information about the seat size during booking. Then customer could make informed decision. I would assume there are already some standards defined for how to measure these things.
- sleavey 9y agoI doubt they'd go for that. Airlines have to have flexibility to swap aircraft running a particular route to account for delays. If they swapped to a smaller seat pitch aircraft between a customer's booking and takeoff time, that'd lead to confusion and complaints.
- viraptor 9y agoYou're already losing the allocated seat and maybe even the booked class if that happens. I don't think a seat would matter in this case.
- otterley 9y agoSo they'd have to make the seat pitches in all their aircraft the same. Sounds like a desirable outcome, especially if the seat pitches grow as a result.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cousin_it 9y agoThis is why libertarianism doesn't prevail. Most people don't want to live in a caveat emptor world. All goods have hidden qualities you can't check before buying, which need to be regulated.
- muninn_ 9y agoThis is nonsense. You can be critical of libertarianism but this is not a “reason that libertarianism doesn’t prevail”. You can easily find reviews online - airline x has bad service, airline y has small seats, etc. and then make a choice whether to fly on the airline. And to be frank, right now the airlines suck pretty hardcore (and airports too) because they are regulated (TSA anyone?). I’m all for critiquing politics ideologies, I’m a social democrat and I think it’s valuable to find flaws and improve them, but this is a very silly “critique” of libertarianism that just doesn’t hold up to any scrutiny.
- iamnothere 9y agoMuninn_'s response was flagged to death, but it was a good faith response to the parent. (Sad to see this kind of behavior creeping into HN, where disagreement is flagged instead of being engaged with directly.) I am also sympathetic to the libertarian impulse (competition will fix it!), but as you pointed out, heavy regulation likely prevents that. I'm sure that there are SOME airline regulations we can safely roll back, but how many, and would this actually have a measurable impact on the competitive landscape? (Serious question!) I suspect that there is some regulatory capture going on, but it isn't likely to be visible except to industry insiders.
- Clubber 9y agoI believe competition can fix a lot of things, but to ensure competition, you have to block most, if not all mergers.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoIt's not about libertarianism, it's about a race to the bottom and apparently, there's more than enough people willing to sit in smaller seats if it saves them a few bucks.
- ubernostrum 9y agoMost of the action on this is in something the article only barely mentions: safety. First of all there's the evacuation angle. Regulations require the ability to evacuate the plane within 90 seconds, using only half of the exits. And by "evacuate" they don't mean people lined up at the door waiting to get off -- they mean the order to evacuate is given, and then 90 seconds later there is nobody left inside the plane. There's a strong argument to be made that this is no longer physically possible with high-density seat configurations. The tests for this are already unrealistic (they involve people who are told in advance what's going to happen, who know they aren't in danger, who don't face any issues such as smoke to confuse them, and who have no particular attachment to each other or to any baggage in the cabin), and as those tests have remained static their detachment from reality has grown. The second issue is survivability in an economy-class seat. This diagram is instructive: https://img.thedailybeast.com/image/upload/d_placeholder_euli9k/dpr_2.0/c_limit,w_585/fl_lossy,q_auto/170912-irving-coach-embed3_khqwee https://img.thedailybeast.com/image/upload/d_placeholder_eul... That's used by airlines... for flight crew seats. It lays out an area to be kept free of obstructions, as anything in that area could cause devastating head or neck injuries in an accident (due to the seat's occupant being jerked suddenly and their head sweeping through that area). The diagram notes the area is 35 inches deep, but it's easy to miss an important point: the 35 inches is measured from the front of the seat cushion to the rear edge of any object in front of the seat. For passengers, airlines measure pitch from the rear edge of one seat to the rear edge of the next, meaning a 30-inch pitch (typical for US economy class) is not 5 inches (35 - 30) short of the safety margin, it's more like 8 or even 10 inches short depending on the depth of the seat cushions and frame. There are court cases going right now over whether the FAA is inappropriately ignoring safety concerns. A victory in court would, as a side effect, probably make flying more comfortable but also slightly more expensive.
- twobyfour 9y agoYup, that's pretty scary. I'm pretty short (under 5'6") and on a recent flight I was unable to pick up an item I'd dropped on the floor quite simply because the seat in front of me was too close to permit leaning down far enough even before the person in front of me reclined. Also, I seem to remember that decades ago, when you flew, the instructions used to be that if the aircraft was expected to crash you were supposed to bend over and put your head between your knees for protection during the crash. Did they give that up because it was ineffective advice or because seat pitch no longer permits it?
- chmaynard 9y agoWhen I'm seated next to a window and the middle seat is vacant (rare), travel in coach becomes much more bearable. Do airlines allow a passenger traveling alone to purchase two adjacent seats? Probably not, but it would be an interesting social experiment to do this and observe how passengers and crew respond during boarding.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoThey probably do actually, the larger overweight people don't fit in a single seat.
- koolba 9y agoYes they do though I think you need to coordinate with the airlines to book it properly so the second seat doesn't get canceled/replaced at the last min. If you're overweight to the point that you overflow into the neighboring seats some airlines mandate you buy two seats: http://www.nbcnews.com/id/35406030/ns/travel-news/t/oversize.. http://www.nbcnews.com/id/35406030/ns/travel-news/t/oversize....
- splonk 9y agoThis is possible but also requires a bit more coordination than just buying two seats. If no one checks in for the second seat, the airline may decide it's available if you haven't made special arrangements when booking. Air New Zealand (and I think some Chinese airline) also have a program where if you're traveling as a group of two, there are special rows in economy where you can buy out the middle seat for less than it would normally cost. These rows also have locking fold up extensions that fill the space between your seat and the seat in front, so if you and your partner are both pretty small and extremely friendly, you can both sleep lying down.
- hkmurakami 9y agoI remember the days before the United Continental merger where this would happen all the time. RIP Good Days.
- ajeet_dhaliwal 9y agoI'm 6'2", so not super tall but I can barely fit in most economy seats and I also cannot fit my legs in a London bus without manspreading. I'm hoping my son is about 5'10" or 5'11" or so, otherwise I'm going to tell him, you've got to get rich if you're planning on travelling otherwise it's rather uncomfortable.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- misja111 9y agoI'm 6'4" and although it's not very comfortable, I can just squeeze myself into an economy seat. However recently when I was flying I had a neighbour who was quite big. Not even obese but just big shoulders. His arms simply didn't fit within his arm rests so part of his shoulder was inside my seat area. There was nothing else for me to do than bend to the side of my seat. Not very pleasant, especially since this was a 5 hour flight.
- WkndTriathlete 9y agoI think the key is femur length. If you're 6'4" but have the Michael Phelps body type (all torso, short legs) you might fit in the seat just fine. I'm 6'1" and have the opposite body type - short torso, long femurs - and the seat pitch in Delta economy is uncomfortable to me, so much that I usually pay the upgrade for Economy Comfort.
- lancebeet 9y agoThis is one of the very, very few cases where being tall isn't a major advantage. Being tall is correlated with being richer, being more likely to be hired and being found attractive. Wishing yourself or someone else to be shorter for this particular issue is borderline ridiculous to be honest.
- ajeet_dhaliwal 9y agoIf there is such a correlation (I didn't know there was) couldn't that just be due to people in wealthier countries generally being taller due to better nutrition? Most of the world's billionaire's couldn't double up as NBA players. I'm not saying I wish anyone to be short just so they can fit in a bus seat better, being tall is great, but not too tall, I don't want to be any taller than I am and wouldn't mind being a couple of inches shorter. Even washing the dishes can be a pain.
- megaman22 9y agoIt's awful. I can't sit in aisle seats anymore; I'm a particularly awkward combination of tall and broad-shouldered, so my knees are already jammed into the seat in front just sitting there, and my shoulders jut out a couple inches over the width of the seat on each side. With a window seat, I can kind of twist myself around into the window well on all but the smallest planes, but on the aisle I get trucked constantly by the drink cart or people streaming to the bathroom.
- true_religion 9y agoHave you considered paying for additional space on the plane? Perhaps as a higher flight class?