3 ms·
Hi there, I'm an engineer on the Schools team at Duolingo and I remember looking into this a while back. A couple of important things to note here: 1. We do s
by SeanColombo 9y ago
Hi there, I'm an engineer on the Schools team at Duolingo and I remember looking into this a while back.
A couple of important things to note here:
1. We do store all passwords hashed. We do not store plaintext passwords
2. That spot in the subject line for the update is for the name of a classroom in the Schools product. When we investigated we realized this was just a case of user-error where they must have typed their password in as a classroom name when they created a class.
3. I'm not positive if we ever responded to the report... I'm trying to find the thread. If we didn't respond, that's my fault and I'm very sorry. Not a great user experience to think your password is stored in plaintext!
I'm trying to find the email thread where I first encountered this so that I can understand more thoroughly what's going on.
UPDATE: The discussion we had internally was a slack conversation, not an email. I verified that one of the user's classroom names appears to be something someone would use for a password. Once we determined there wasn't a security issue, I didn't ask for the reporter's contact info or anything like that. I'm really sorry to Arron and his wife for the poor service & bad customer experience.
- mbesto 9y agoFrom the author's article: "It is completely possible that my wife entered her password as the organization name when signing up. In which case—that's not Duolingo's fault. Thanks Hacker News for staying sharp." To the author - please delete, or refactor your slanderous article if your claims are unfounded then. EDIT: Author updated= https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15679191 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15679191
- ninjakeyboard 9y agoSo Duolingo unofficially replied here! Author, take note.
- iwritesomecode 9y agoI have.
- iwritesomecode 9y agoGood to hear, and we know stuff happens and falls through the cracks. Upon discussing it with my wife, user error did come up—should have had that discussion again before writing the post (adding an update, now). wipes egg off face
- politelemon 9y agoYes - thoroughly researching the issue is extremely important before accusations, even a 'refactored' one like yours has a lasting impact on organisations. If you go to the Duolingo Schools website or account profile, you will notice the classroom name at the top, clearly listed - this should have quelled any plaintext suspicions. https://schools.duolingo.com https://schools.duolingo.com
- tialaramex 9y agoFWIW This is yet _another_ reason, albeit probably not even in the top 100, for why we need to get rid of passwords. It's essentially inconceivable that somehow your 512-bit TLS session key, or an RSA signature, or even the seed of your one time password system would get pasted into some random field in error. But a password you're constantly typing into boxes all day to make anything work is obviously sooner or later going to get typed in somewhere it shouldn't. How many people reading this have typed their screen unlock password in, only to realise that it wasn't locked after all? Where did that end up - in a Slack chat? A Google search? Email to your best friend? Did you the rest of the day changing all your passwords? Or did you just shrug it off and get on with your life. Anyway, that's my thought on the matter, hunter2
- MBCook 9y agoThanks, glad to hear that.