5 ms·
Wacky and entertaining idea. The theory rests on another idea that many people assume is obviously true without ever thinking twice. It's the notion that verb
by nabla9 9y ago
Wacky and entertaining idea.
The theory rests on another idea that many people assume is obviously true without ever thinking twice.
It's the notion that verbal thought and verbal thinking is required and fundamental part of consciousness and self awareness.
When I started to read about the philosophy of consciousness, it became obvious that most people experience their own consciousness differently than I do. Their inner starting point is completely off from my personal epistemology and it may be hard for them to see the alternative viewpoint interesting.
For me, verbal thoughts have always been just one cognitive ability in par with spatial reasoning. I have always had trouble understanding why people link verbal thinking and consciousness and self awareness.
Temple Grandin's has really good insight into the differences of thinking: Thinking the Way Animals Do: Unique insights from a person with a singular understanding http://www.grandin.com/references/thinking.animals.html http://www.grandin.com/references/thinking.animals.html
- rusk 9y ago> I have always had trouble understanding why people link verbal thinking and consciousness I came across the same conundrum when I was studying psychology. It all came down to the medium becoming the message. Language is the prime means through which we convey experience. Of course there are other means visual, spacial but when you're "studying consciousness" you're typically reading books. Serious treatise in the area are delivered in the form of books. We come to think of thought as being predominantly verbal because that's the predominant means through which we acquire an "objective" appreciation for what consciousness "is". Even to use a word "consciousness" puts that set of concepts in a delineated box. I could go on ... but I risk becoming stream of consciousness ...
- nabla9 9y agoI had interesting discussion about logical thinking once. My fried claimed that it's impossible to think logically (btw. etymology of word logic is "word" or "what is spoken") without verbally running the the words and sentences in your head. Then I explained that I have always used logic visuospatially. "and" is choice between places or fork in the road, "or" is combining two objects in the same place and so on. Content of our consciousness seems to be based on sensory input and sensor fusion. Thinking is running simulated sequences and scenarios in our head. Different people use different sensory content more than others. I wouldn't be surprised if some people use feelings or motor imaginary more than others. We have visuospatial ability, audioverbal perception and motor imagery/proprioception. Interoceptive senses seem to relate feelings somehow. If you really drill and analyze what if feels to love, hate or fear. The feeling is related to our internal senses.
- alsetmusic 9y ago> My fried claimed that it's impossible to think logically (btw. etymology of word logic is "word" or "what is spoken") without verbally running the the words and sentences in your head. In this case, would numbers represent “words” in the language of mathematics? When I was younger and sharper, I used to see products of numbers physically manifest in my mind. This is a form of logic, but it also required an “alphabet” of sorts. As an aside, I once saw an interview with a mathematical genius of sorts who stated that he associated numbers with colors. He saw the product of two numbers as a third color. Again, logic without traditional language.
- hyperpallium 9y agoMathematical proof did not originate with number, but geometry.
- BurningFrog 9y agoDifferent people have different brains. Your friend was probably right about his/her brain, and you're right about yours.
- rusk 9y agoWhen you see the mathematical phrase "1 + 1" (a trite example, but please substitute something more complex if you like), your reasoning to get the answer is symbolic, but not verbal. That said, I personally have to say the math to myself to "upload" it into my brain, but somebody with more expertise in maths would just have to "see" it.
- gt_ 9y agoSo, we use words to abstract our thought, but wouldn’t it seem there to be lower levels of abstraction as well? I believe this is the point Temple Grandin is working toward. I think I agree that words tend to puts thoughts or acknowledgements in a box, but maybe the box is mutable.
- rusk 9y agoYea but different boxes are mutable for different people in different ways. When communicating by way of the written word language is the common abstraction. To be synthesised as per the receivers own “internal boxes” but in the macro structure imposed by language
- gt_ 9y agoThis is synthesizing well with me.
- lukasb 9y agoNot just psychology, look up the linguistic turn in philosophy in the 20th century. There is support for a weak version of Sapir-Whorf, but in general any time someone says "the limits of your language determine the limits of your thought" I just s/language/culture.
- humanrebar 9y agoSame here. I often mix names up or have problems learning them, especially when tired. I don't think verbally as much as I suspect others do.
- wallace_f 9y agoSame here! I am really bad with names, but I remember faces, personalities and character very well. I've actually asked people if they think in language and the answer has always either been "yes" or "what do you mean? Of course!" However, for me "rubber duck debugging," or just talking things through with someone is exceedingly helpful to help sort my thoughts out--or 'bring them into consciousness,' as the author would say.
- gt_ 9y agoI agree language should not be considered so fundamental. It gives a structure which is more formal than fundamental. Noam Chomsky also promoted a version of the fundamental-language concept in his linguistic work. I think the notion will fade with time. This Temple Grandin bit is great!
- psyc 9y agoI'm right there with you. Always find it weird that people associate language so strongly with intelligence, and consciousness. First, I'm conscious when I'm aware of anything. I don't have to be thinking. Second, my thinking is 99% non-verbal except when I'm communicating to another person or imagining doing so, and even then it's only partly verbal. Almost all of my thinking is in moving or rotating 3D spaces and objects.
- wallace_f 9y agoSo how do you think about abstract concepts, like morality, which have no visual structure?
- SideburnsOfDoom 9y agoBy analogy? They don't necessary have verbal structure either. Use of spatial analogies for abstract concepts is common: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conceptual_metaphor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conceptual_metaphor
- wallace_f 9y agoI'm convinced that different people have very different experiences thinking about the world.
- psyc 9y agoMorality is actually purely visual to me. It's daydreams about scenarios, their outcomes, even the expression on people's faces. Just about everything is visual to me.
- notduncansmith 9y agoMy understanding is that all of us do our logical reasoning spatially, but there are different interfaces to it (visual, verbal, tactile, audible, etc), and each person is likely to have preferences among those. I find words to be a powerful medium between my memory and reasoning; it’s a good indexing system for memories/associations, and by carefully verbalizing and interpreting, I can load up a new spatial reasoning context and perform whatever evaluation is necessary.
- mabbo 9y agoI generally think verbally. Then I started learning American Sign Language. For the 3 years I was actively using it, I thought differently, more with ideas than words. It was fascinating both in the change, and the fact that I've changed back.
- majos 9y agoI'm looking to learn ASL. Any recommended resources?
- mabbo 9y agoThis is going to sound like I'm joking, but alcohol is the key to learning. Find a class on it, one that's at night and one that has half the class go to the bar afterwards, ideally with Deaf people at the bar too. The social situation, the lack of inhibitions/fears to try stuff, you really pick it up fast.
- lisper 9y agoThis. Learning sign language really expands your horizons. I had always thought of language as linear strings of symbols, because that's what written and spoken language are. But sign language is spatial. It also uses facial expressions as modifiers.
- nikki93 9y agoBut whatever that information space is could be called a language too, right?
- jacobolus 9y agoI don't think so. 'Language' per se is inherently abstract-symbolic and serial. Other types of thought rely on non-symbolic types of metaphor, often quite concrete ones, and on more graph-like connections between ideas. Sometimes the relationships between nodes are very fuzzy and inexplicit. The best you'll get with 'language' is poetry and puns and outline-style hierarchies, but these don't cover anywhere near all types of thought. As stark examples, I don't think you can classify e.g. sculptures or textile patterns or mechanical designs as 'language'.
- davidgay 9y agoOn this front, and to stray closer to a topic many of us spend too much time on, how do you conceptualise programs and their structure (control, data, etc, etc)? It's clearly formalised in words (except for the occasional visual programming languages/programs), but that's mostly superficial. The actual structure, or thoughts of how to change it seem to me more abstract and often hard to explain other than by combinations of diagrams and code - but those weren't the source of the idea(s). --> it's not clear to me that programming (which is quite clearly a conscious activity) is reducible to purely verbal or visual thoughts. Similar comments apply to other intellectual endeavours.
- notduncansmith 9y agoI usually visualize data structures as pipe systems, and interfaces as 3D shapes around these pipe systems. One thing that took some getting used to was flipping between the interface and flow representations while navigating the abstraction graph, but learning more about nature/physics/math has helped enormously with building and practicing that intuition (and applying it in non-software scenarios by understanding natural phenomena as data structures).
- ivan_ah 9y agoI see programs as data (mostly atoms, tuples, and dicts) and a nested list of TODOs. Each todo is a sequence of tasks, but I don't necessarily assign names to the task parts or think of them verbally. The "local variables" have names in the final code, but not necessarily in the blueprint for the sequence of tasks. The naming of things really comes in only for the dict key names when passing data around.
- Camillo 9y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/self/comments/3yrw2i/i_never_thought_with_language_until_now_this_is/ https://www.reddit.com/r/self/comments/3yrw2i/i_never_though...
- afpx 9y agoThe Feral Child https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_child https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_child
- ACow_Adonis 9y agoCompletely. I've been surprised by the hostility/resistance to the idea that we don't think in language, especially when I'm trying to convey to people how my own mind works. In trying to convey my experience with language, I have to try to express a layer of...as best as I can get in programmer speak...multithreaded-notthreadsafe-consciousness-impressions. These I then have to translate into single-threaded verbal language in order to communicate with others. Indeed, without my years of practice to try to become a better communicator, I find this results in my natural speech being a kind of stocatto-mid-sentence-pausing way of speaking, as I have to join each thread of threaded-conscious-impressions before coercing and outputting it in the best approximation of a serial structured verbal language. Over the years I've just become better at pre-buffering before the verbal component is output and consciously shutting down other threads. When I'm thinking of logic and computer programs alternatively, I often find myself thinking visual-spatially. Indeed, when I'm really thinking hard and trying to understand some algorithms, I can sometimes be seen closing my eyes and even engaging my arms/hands as though i'm moving, conducting or manipulating physical things. Because in my head that's exactly what I'm doing: the arrays/lists/things exist as spatial objects in my mind, and I'm running things through by manipulating them in space or seeing how they fit together spatially/in relation to each other.
- humanrebar 9y ago> as best as I can get in programmer speak...multithreaded-notthreadsafe-consciousness-impressions The way I explain it, thoughts in my mind are organized in graphs, perhaps like a wiki. As I communicate, I'm constantly deciding which concepts to render inline into text, which to keep handy in case it comes up, and which to ignore. I find that I have decent memory, but it's hard to get to a story from a prompt (like: "tell me something funny from your childhood").
- tzs 9y ago> When I started to read about the philosophy of consciousness, it became obvious that most people experience their own consciousness differently than I do. Perhaps at some point you will travel into the past and do the nasty in the pasty with one of your ancestors, and that past nastification results in you being your own ancestor. That is known to be capable of causing one to have a mind that works differently from that of the rest of humanity. Huh? Yes, yes I am watching the Futurama marathon on SyFy right now. How did you know?
- perl4ever 9y agoWhen I want to figure something out, I find it helps to express it in words, written or spoken. So I could say my way of thinking is verbal more than visual or anything else. But I have the sense that I have a "background task" running that finds the answer to a problem while my conscious mind is forming the verbal expression. I am not sure I do analysis with the aware part of my mind. I also have the odd sense that I cannot think clearly about a problem while looking over someone's shoulder, but when I sit down at my own computer, putting my hands on my own keyboard allows me to concentrate.
- chrisweekly 9y ago> “There is a depth of thought untouched by words, and deeper still a depth of formless feeling untouched by thought.” - Rilke
- joe_the_user 9y agoHmm, I think the assumption that consciousness is wrapped-up in language is justified. Language involves representation. "self-consciousness" as generally expressed, is one's representation of one's self. Obviously one can have visual or spatial representation of one's body. But the unique quality of language is that it involves an easy shorthand for the manipulation of representations. "Who am I?" is the standard question of consciousness - as language, it has a thousand shades. I don't know if it can even be meaningfully expressed in other modalities but if it could, it doesn't seem like it could be easily manipulated in the fashion of language.
- nwatson 9y agoMuch of how I think involves a pretend version of my body and a manipulation of virtual objects or better yet sets of those objects in some kind of physical space, to understand, manipulate, test hypotheses, and reach conclusions (I can feel my muscles twitch often as I do this). Also, there are shadowy visuals with edges, colors, and I move around those objects to get different viewpoints. This is most concrete when contemplating how to navigate or manipulate the physical world, but even quite concrete when contemplating how I build and understand software -- hypothetical data structures, functions, objects, etc., they take on some almost tangible form, and I might give them a verbal tag, but they're very much not verbal. Even when dealing with people, social situations, my feelings for them, about them, situations I am in or might be in, or things I'm contemplating in the past -- so little of that is verbal. I flash to prior experience, prior situations, I posit new ones, I wonder how a person might sound, what their voice might show. I had a very hard time completing sentences and constructing verbal arguments before I was around 25. I was different, and my senior classmates in high school in Brazil, I don't think maliciously, voted me "most likely to go insane". The stream-of-consciousness self-dialog in some literature is a necessarily limited mapping of this mode of thinking to words. It's a hint of how I feel most people really think. Words and phrases are but one element of inner thought, and become paramount only when laying out written or verbal communications with others ... and even then, in live or recorded conversation, can be overshadowed by vocal quality and intonation, and non-verbal body-language. EDIT: added high-school superlative ... and also, I'm INFP, if there's anything to that.