7 ms·
How Julian Jaynes’ consciousness theory is faring in the neuroscience age (2015)
- booleandilemma 9y agoFrom 2015.
- barce 9y agoAnd it's really hard to verify what people heard in the past. “Our kings, presidents, judges, and officers begin their tenures with oaths to the now-silent deities, taken upon the writings of those who have last heard them.” How do we know that they weren't just doing poetry or fiction, or creating religion to control the masses?
- blechinger 9y agoI think that acceptance is less an acquiescence and more a charity for convenience.
- whatshisface 9y agoNietzsche wrote at length about the "death of god," which was his way of symbolizing the unseating of god from society's abstract throne, and the dangerous power vacuum that blood would be shed to re-fill. You can't walk three feet through the past couple centuries before finding some text discussing, cheering on or mourning the transition from a society where god is generally assumed to be behind things to one where he isn't. If a similar phase change had occured 3000 years ago, I'm pretty sure it would have been well-documented. I have a hard time believing that this event is for the first time being seen clearly from a vantage point three thousand years distant!
- 21 9y ago> If a similar phase change had occured 3000 years ago, I'm pretty sure it would have been well-documented Documented where? The Sapiens book makes a similar assertion, that something changed in the brain about 10000 years ago, when agriculture was invented. Before that people hunted and gathered for 200k years with little progress and suddenly there was an explosion.
- nfg 9y ago“O, what a world of unseen visions and heard silences, this insubstantial country of the mind! A secret theater of speechless monologue and prevenient counsel, an invisible mansion of all moods, musings, and mysteries, an infinite resort of disappointments and discoveries.” If you’re intrigued reading the article, or have had the book on your ‘todo’ for years now I’d really encourage you to just go get a copy and take it on. It provides a wealth of food for thought - a lovely example of a theory that in all likelihood is in its details totally wrong, but enriches the reader regardless.
- uoaei 9y agoA lot of people discount Jayne's theory for the inaccuracy regarding its assertions about the physical mechanisms, namely that specific modules in one half of the brain talk across the corpus callosum to specific modules in the other half. But IMO they're throwing the baby out with the bathwater. What I haven't seen yet are investigations into the nature of self-awareness and agency assuming that his theory holds water on the mental aspects. Studies have shown that we make decisions whole seconds before we are conscious of our coming to a conclusion. Could this not be some remnant of the potential fact that our internal decision processes are based around a similar mechanism as what he proposes? The only difference is that we think that "voice" telling us what to do is ourselves, and not some imposition from outside.
- vinceguidry 9y agoAny useful theory of consciousness has to be able to explain animal consciousness too. Language is really the only differentiator between us and other primates, cognitively. (naturally it's a powerful difference) Primates far and away clear the bar for sentience, we know enough about dogs and cats to grudgingly accept them into the fold too. Plenty of birds are extremely intelligent and social as well.
- gizmo686 9y agoI'm not sure how important "langauge" is for cognition. I think it is clear that the cognitive facilities that, in humans, we attribute to language, are a significant part of human cognition. However, when we test for language in other animals, we do not test for these underlying cognitive abilities. Rather, rather, we test for the animals ability to express these facilities through some communication system with other animals (either in the same species, or with humans). It is conceivable to have an animal that has all of the cognitive abilities we associate with language except the ability to serialize/deserialize [0] it. While this ability is significant at the species level, it does not seem like it would be particularly significant at an individual level. Further if you take the view that language was evolved primarily as a tool for thinking (rather than a tool for communicating), this possibilities seems even more likely. Under this view, we would first develop the cognitive aspects, then develop the communicative aspects on top of them (in the same way that we evolved our "speech organs" on our digestive (tongue) and respiratory (lungs/airway) ones. It also seems plausible that it was this adaptation that allowed humans to pass the singularity point necessary to reach modern society (which grew up very quickly on an evolutionary timeline). If this were the case, then I would expect to see that the rest of the cognitive abilities associated with speech are actually present and similar in related species. [0] Our current model of human language is that of a tree. We do not see processes that act on a linear structure until we get into phonology.
- vinceguidry 9y ago> I'm not sure how important "langauge" is for cognition. It's not. That's why I said that any good theory is going to have to account for all the sentience in the world that doesn't talk to each other.
- paulsutter 9y agoCrucially, Jayne's definition of "consciousness" is basically introspection. If you replace the word "consciousness" with "introspection", all the controversy evaporates and the story becomes (only mildly) interesting. > Jaynes ... decides to read early texts, including The Iliad and The Odyssey, to look for signs of people who aren’t capable of introspection—people who are all sea, no rime. And he believes he sees that in The Iliad. He writes that the characters in The Iliad do not look inward, and they take no independent initiative. Suitcase words like "consciousness" are tricky to work with. https://alexvermeer.com/unpacking-suitcase-words/ https://alexvermeer.com/unpacking-suitcase-words/
- adekok 9y ago> Crucially, Jayne's definition of "consciousness" is basically introspection. With language as a key portion. See any discussion of deaf people who aren't taught language until late in life, such a Helen Keller. The stories consistently have them emotionally overwhelmed when the first learn language. They want to know the names of everything. And also, they consistently talk about "before" and "after". Before language, they were a collection of emotions, fears, desires, etc. After language, they existed for the first time. They could name things, including themselves. This looks a lot like the transition to self aware consciousness. Which means Jayne isn't entirely wrong.
- nyir 9y agoA quick search yielded something from a book about Keller - do you have some other good sources for what you mention?
- uoaei 9y agoI'm still astounded by all the different things people mean when they say "consciousness." I think a better term for the discussion surrounding Jaynes and his theory is "awareness"--understanding and conceptualizing reality via a semantic framework, rather than merely processing inputs and directing outputs. The ego (or the default mode network, in which I hypothesize the ego "resides") basically connects those disparate parts of the brain and makes the leap to turn the brain from a few interacting modules into an integrated whole, giving rise to the sense of the self as we understand it today. This must somehow activate our self-awareness by us understanding not only that we inhabit a body, but that the mind doing so can also be identified.
- alyx 9y agoFor those interested in thoughts about consciousness, I highly recommend Bernardo Kastrup. He comes from a comp sci background but has several books and very well structured arguments for Idealism. His manner of delivering his insights I think particularly appeal to those with analytical and critical thinking backgrounds. He has several very good videos on YouTube as well. https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/4552692.Bernardo_Kastrup https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/4552692.Bernardo_Kastr... https://www.youtube.com/user/bernardokastrup/ https://www.youtube.com/user/bernardokastrup/
- diminish 9y agoprevious discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9617268 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9617268
- Method-X 9y agoIf you find this sort of thing interesting, I highly recommend HBO's Westworld. It's really well done and thoroughly thought provoking.
- k__ 9y agoThat series brought me to read about the theory. But almost all pschological educated people I talked to found it too muddy.
- nabla9 9y agoWacky and entertaining idea. The theory rests on another idea that many people assume is obviously true without ever thinking twice. It's the notion that verbal thought and verbal thinking is required and fundamental part of consciousness and self awareness. When I started to read about the philosophy of consciousness, it became obvious that most people experience their own consciousness differently than I do. Their inner starting point is completely off from my personal epistemology and it may be hard for them to see the alternative viewpoint interesting. For me, verbal thoughts have always been just one cognitive ability in par with spatial reasoning. I have always had trouble understanding why people link verbal thinking and consciousness and self awareness. Temple Grandin's has really good insight into the differences of thinking: Thinking the Way Animals Do: Unique insights from a person with a singular understanding http://www.grandin.com/references/thinking.animals.html http://www.grandin.com/references/thinking.animals.html
- rusk 9y ago> I have always had trouble understanding why people link verbal thinking and consciousness I came across the same conundrum when I was studying psychology. It all came down to the medium becoming the message. Language is the prime means through which we convey experience. Of course there are other means visual, spacial but when you're "studying consciousness" you're typically reading books. Serious treatise in the area are delivered in the form of books. We come to think of thought as being predominantly verbal because that's the predominant means through which we acquire an "objective" appreciation for what consciousness "is". Even to use a word "consciousness" puts that set of concepts in a delineated box. I could go on ... but I risk becoming stream of consciousness ...
- nabla9 9y agoI had interesting discussion about logical thinking once. My fried claimed that it's impossible to think logically (btw. etymology of word logic is "word" or "what is spoken") without verbally running the the words and sentences in your head. Then I explained that I have always used logic visuospatially. "and" is choice between places or fork in the road, "or" is combining two objects in the same place and so on. Content of our consciousness seems to be based on sensory input and sensor fusion. Thinking is running simulated sequences and scenarios in our head. Different people use different sensory content more than others. I wouldn't be surprised if some people use feelings or motor imaginary more than others. We have visuospatial ability, audioverbal perception and motor imagery/proprioception. Interoceptive senses seem to relate feelings somehow. If you really drill and analyze what if feels to love, hate or fear. The feeling is related to our internal senses.
- falcor84 9y agoThese ideas are mentioned by the character of Ford (played by Anthony Hopkins) in Westworld, in regards to creating consciousness in robots, and they made quite a bit of sense to me in that context.
- tzahola 9y agoI’ve been familiar with this idea for a while, although whenever it comes up, I can’t help but think about Hitchens’s razor: “What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence”
- _0ffh 9y agoI read that book about 15 years ago, it's a fantastic read. I picked it up because either Dennett or Dawkins called it something like "the most insightful and thought provoking idea that is probably not true" (I think it was the latter).
- gok 9y agoSo other people are rewatching Westworld too? :)
- a_lieb 9y agoThere seems to be an accepted idea that ancient people had a totally different way of thinking: that up to around 300 BC, humans navigated through the world with a dream-like, pre-scientific logic, and didn't view the world as comprehensible or subject to predictable laws and patterns. I've always wondered, do we actually know this for sure? What's the evidence? Just by introspection, it is so hard for me to imagine being in a state of mind where I didn't believe that if I dropped a rock off a cliff twice, under similar conditions, it would do pretty much the same thing the second time. Or that if I did it over and over again, I would start to see patterns that I could rely on for later. This feels as hard-wired as just about anything in my mind. To me, it makes more sense to think that humans have always thought the same way, and these days we just have better tools and have learned to refine the cognitive abilities that are wired into us. But I'm really interested to hear the case for the other side.
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoI'm curious about how people who think that way react when you tell them about Babylonian mathematics; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babylonian_mathematics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babylonian_mathematics For instance, there is a Babylonian clay tablet from ~1700 BC that gives an approximation of sqrt(2) as 1.414213 (correct to 6 decimal digits).
- wahern 9y agoI don't think that's a generally accepted idea at all. It's an idea that, in various forms, some modern philosophers have floated. Because it's so radical it's something you'll hear (and remember) people chatter about, but that doesn't mean many people take it literally, especially people familiar with ancient works. At best I think such ideas help challenge beliefs about ourselves in the modern era. At worst I think they perpetuate a tendency for people to dehumanize those whom we can't personally identify with.
- a_lieb 9y agoI'm glad to hear that. I've definitely seen it mentioned by a bunch of experts/academics as if it were accepted fact (Jordan Peterson is the only one that comes right to mind). I think the idea might partly come from the dream-like quality of ancient myths, but I feel like that underestimates the ability of people to partition those myths from daily life. It's not like our current religious stories are exactly logical.
- kingkawn 9y agoSum ergo cogito always made much more sense to me
- FrozenVoid 9y agoI think the trigger event for modern consciousness mode is a critical percent of population being literate. It could been happening a few millenia earlier than his book suggests, and shaped the brain around reading the "fixed language"(i.e. written words) allowing abstraction levels not possible with earlier purely verbal communication. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reading_(process)#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reading_(process)#History The history of reading dates back to the invention of writing during the 4th millennium BC. Although reading print text is now an important way for the general population to access information, this has not always been the case. With some exceptions, only a small percentage of the population in many countries was considered literate before the Industrial Revolution. Some of the pre-modern societies with generally high literacy rates included classical Athens and the Islamic Caliphate.[41] Scholars assume that reading aloud (Latin clare legere) was the more common practice in antiquity, and that reading silently (legere tacite or legere sibi) was unusual.[42] In his Confessions, Saint Augustine remarks on Saint Ambrose's unusual habit of reading silently in the 4th century AD.[42][43]
- adekok 9y agoNeal Stephenson's novel "Snow Crash" depended entirely on this theory. I'm not sure if I believe it, but it made for a good novel.
- dang 9y agoDiscussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9617268 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9617268.
- gfodor 9y agoI haven't read the book so this may just be an easy to refute idea, but it seems to me if introspection is a cultural construct that grew out of necessity then there should be mechanisms to disprove this theory in the modern day. For example, by looking for evidence of introspection in cultures that are isolated from modern civilization or in individuals who were raised in isolation.
- remir 9y agoI had a couple of episodes of sleep paralysis where I experienced auditory hallucinations. Often times, the voices I heard were clear as day, which was strange since I wore ear plugs during a lot of these experiences. Also, I saw an article on the news about a treatment involving VR for people who hears voices in their head. In the video, the person described the voices as distinct and she could even interact with them. So I would say there's something to explore there.
- hugheth 9y agoFor me this is one of the most interesting concepts which has only been briefly touched on - Jaynes proposes that in the Iliad the Greeks "heard the voices of the gods" and used those to make decisions. In our modern society I'm sure a lot of religious people would find God(s) speaking directly to them a fabrication of the mind, but auditory hallucinations are common and well documented. I often find on the edge of sleep I can lucidly think of a tune or song and hear at as clearly as if it was actually being played in the room. I think Jaynes made a really interesting observation about older theistic societies that took for granted the ability for people to receive instructions in their heads from the gods. It seems commonplace in religious literature at the least that people can interact with gods and hear what they have to say, something which we tend to interpret more as a metaphor nowadays. If we reject his theory on consciousness as being a modern substitute for heavenly direction, I don't think that necessarily rules out a cognitive function that we've lost over the past few thousand years - one which could have developed from a young age by not writing off auditory hallucinations as mental noise...
- _nedR 9y agoAs a Computer Engineer by training I am curious about the field of research regarding conciousness. Is there any contemporary book or resource that summarizes the current academic views and discoveries on the subject?