11 ms·
The Case for RSS
- 627467 9y agoI've kept my subscription list in Feedly, which I open every now and again. I like the highlights it selects for me. At peak Google Reader I suffered from "inbox zero" syndrome and recall zapping through hundreds of posts a day (being full time student in dorms help with having free time). But something rss, email and social media have thought me is that you'll never see it all. So I never pay much attention to the vast majority of the dress I subscribe to. I certainly look forward to more decentralized systems like rss in the future.
- mceoin 9y agoGoogle Trends for RSS is pretty telling: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=rss https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=rss Personally, I think it's a big loss that we have moved away from the RSS format specifically, and the open web generally.
- lj3 9y agoGoogle Trends don't necessarily equate to usage. I keep hearing rss feeds are dead, yet nearly every site on the internet has an rss feed, save for Twitter and Facebook (for obvious reasons).
- nikisweeting 9y agoRSS feeds are pretty trivial to implement, so it's worth it for most sites even if they only get a few dozen users from RSS.
- revelation 9y agoAt one point every site on the internet had a visitor counter, and don't forget about web ring! The RSS feed is the guestbook of web 2.0, it comes along for the ride with the shitty page generator.
- Semiapies 9y agoIf that's true, then the web is dead: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=web https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=web
- baby 9y agoNobody has moved away from RSS, it's just not as trendy, but major blog platforms ship with RSS by default. Every time I want to add a blog to my list I can find an RSS link (on some rare occasion there is no such link, and an email to the website developer is enough, actually I'm suspecting that most blogs have a RSS feed nowadays because at one point they received requests to create one)
- gsam 9y agoFacebook and Twitter killed theirs though. I find that deplorable.
- wtetzner 9y agoI honestly feel like the solution to that problem is to ignore content from Facebook and Twitter, but I suppose I'm in the minority.
- seanp2k2 9y agoRSS is nigh-unusable for many sites now because they only put the first few sentences of an article in the feed, then "continue reading on our site <link> [where we can show you our ads]". It makes sense from a business perspective, because RSS has no good way to embed ads. However, it greatly diminishes the value of RSS -- reading ALL of your content in one easily-organized place. The best alternative that I've found is Feedly, which can show ads inline.
- ece 9y agoIt depends, you can embed ads and content in a feed, or some content and no ads. I think depending on what you're reading, academic, non-profit, ad-supported, etc.. the published RSS feeds add more value than take away for both parties.
- trqx 9y agoOf course there is this trend of not giving more than the title/first sentence but those feeds all belong to that weird, hostile, parallel universe where advertising / tracking / consumerism of closed tech is seen as an efficient way of sharing information to the reader. Lots of content is produced there but is it worth reading it? doubt it, unless you want to be sucked into their world. I'm pretty happy with what is outside and consider the "sane" part of the internet.
- highd 9y agoApparently TCP is over too: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=tcp https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=tcp
- rainbowmverse 9y agoThat's probably a reflection of the fact that most new "protocols" are APIs built on HTTP, so no one's talking about TCP/IP even if it's still there under the hood. Compare it to API and you'll see it follows TCP down for a while as fewer people work on native software, then heads back up around 2012 with web and mobile apps becoming the norm.
- b0rsuk 9y agoOh look, Google Trends for Javascript is pretty telling: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=javascript https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=javascri... Facebook has an aardvark-shaped graph: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=facebook https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=facebook Android is on decline: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=android https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=android
- mceoin 9y agoTouché! Hadn't thought to check JavaScript. Anyone have a better source for actual RSS usage?
- Jaruzel 9y agoTwitter seems to be having a harder time: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=twitter https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=twitter But Instagram is still in ascendance: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=instagram https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=instagra... I wonder if you can really draw conclusions from any of this?
- jklinger410 9y agoCan someone name any major publications that don't have an RSS feed for me? Please?
- qznc 9y agoI don't really care, but can you get your Facebook or Twitter feed via RSS?
- hopesthoughts 9y agoThere are a lot of services that do Twitter to RSS like twitrss.me and queryfeed.net. Queryfeed also does some Facebook things.
- jklinger410 9y agoNope, those have been a walled-garden since day 1. But every blog post shared on those platforms likely has an RSS feed. Reddit publishes RSS feeds for every sub. Digg did RSS. WikiNews has RSS. So-on.
- gsam 9y agoThat's not true. Both had RSS up until 2012 or so. They were hidden to the average user though.
- xellisx 9y agoWith everything becoming centralized, the nice stuff is being ignored. I use theoldreader.com to keep up with stuff that is posted on websites, like HN, Reddit, etc.
- account0099099 9y agoI bet if someone re-wrote the specification using JSON or YAML, everyone would start using it again.
- aaronpk 9y agohttp://jsonfeed.org http://jsonfeed.org
- giobox 9y agoI really like jsonfeed, but I just can’t envisage it getting anything like the ubiquity RSS enjoyed in the mid 2000s, when even Safari had a pretty reasonable feed reader built in. Back then my main way of following news/blogs was to combine the RSS feeds of my favourite sites, giving me a single view onto all the news I cared about. What killed it for me personally though wasn’t the slow death of widespread RSS, but weirdly Twitter. Twitter can be a great news link replacement for RSS if you used RSS the way I did, as the links the people you follow share have been curated by those people themselves. I started to find a much better “hit rate” for content I wanted to read by seeing what influencers in industries I have an interest in share, rather than the hosepipe of stories that RSS was providing. I found I was still getting all the content I wanted without having to wade through all the noise, at which point I just stopped using RSS altogether. I do however agree it is another sad indicator of a dying open web though.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- s73ver_ 9y agoRSS was never difficult, and just about every language out there already has RSS libraries.
- MBCook 9y agoThe biggest problem is the number of people who rolled their own XML generators or use broken templates to generate the XML.
- 9y ago
- strong_silent_t 9y agoI love RSS and shout-out to newsblur.com for keeping the dream alive. It is wonderful to use a system that isn't being optimized around the needs of advertisers.
- blakesterz 9y agonewsblur! I've been happy with that as well since Google dumped Reader.
- briandoll 9y agoBeen really enjoying using Feedbin (https://feedbin.com/ https://feedbin.com/) to keep a curated list of things I actually want to read, but often miss via Twitter or even Facebook.
- doctornemo 9y agoHear hear! I've been arguing this for several years now, most recently: https://bryanalexander.org/2017/07/07/i-defy-the-world-and-go-back-to-rss/ https://bryanalexander.org/2017/07/07/i-defy-the-world-and-g... . Facebook's algo is deeply messed up.
- gklitt 9y agoI’ve been hacking on a Twitter client that batches your tweets and lets you consume them in a more pull-oriented daily digest format, with the ability to customize rules for which subset of tweets get included in the digest. In my personal usage I’ve found that this makes Twitter feel more like a manageable RSS feed, and limits the impact on my attention because I only get updates once a day. Is this something people would be interested in using if I released it? Any feedback on the idea?
- ekanes 9y agoI'd like this, would pay for it, and would ideally consume it by email if possible.
- toasterlovin 9y agoYes, please!
- nkantar 9y agoI would like to try this out. :) Try as I might, I just don't spend enough time actively using Twitter to make it all that interactive, but I'd still like the ability to catch up in a read-only manner.
- jmh530 9y agoSounds interesting. I'm a long-time RSS user and never made the jump to twitter. My gripe with twitter is that it seems like there is too much noise and too little signal. I suppose at this point my RSS has a lot of noise, but I'm perhaps more attuned at how to filter it out (but I do it heuristically).
- dannysu 9y agoIt's a good idea, and I do the same. Except I actually just have Twitter via a RSS feed. I wrote some code that generates RSS from Twitter lists and I consume it and filter it just the same as any other RSS feeds.
- hopesthoughts 9y ago
- strict9 9y agoIt's a good case! Though I don't use dedicated readers as I used to, it's a great format and important part of the open web. I still hold on to customizable aggregator protopage.com, though I wish iGoogle hadn't gone away. Also regularly check the fixed-selection aggregators like alltop and popurls, though the latter seems to have been abandoned. Posts like this encouraging desktop clients are fine, but where is the slickly designed web client for RSS feeds? Until I find it, I'll stick with protopage.
- hughw 9y agoIs Feedly slick? I like it
- strict9 9y agoTurns out I had an account with a bunch of follows from years ago. Thanks for the reminder!
- ninjaranter 9y agoHi! You may be interested in https://frontpage.to https://frontpage.to .Just like you, we're a group of ex-iGoogle refugees who got fed-up with the alternatives which we found to be (subjectively) badly-designed/ insecure / inflexible, and built our own. We haven't officially launched yet, but we'd love to have you take a look and tell us what you think! You may hit a few snags here and there as we prep for a more robust launch; in the meantime feel free to reach out either to me personally (contact in profile) or through support at frontpage dot to. Hope you like it!
- ptc 9y agoYeah VSS can be quite misleading, =p
- oeuviz 9y agoHuge fan of feedly.com here. I would for sure reduce my consumption of web news in favor of print if it wasn't for feedly. Just helps me organise and read content so it is usable for my own purposes.
- marojejian 9y agoSecond. I am super cheap - but i actually pay them now, so I can get "mute filters." Want to live in a world where no one mentions Trump or chatbots? I do :D This lets me focus in on my 1000s of other feeds, which have something interesting and valuable to say.
- marban 9y agoAs someone who's been working with RSS aggregation since its inception I can say that even if there's a steep decline from a trend perspective, the support from almost any major site is still alive and kicking. For those who remember popurls 1), I've recently launched a new site at http://www.hvper.com http://www.hvper.com and 90% from it is based on pure RSS. So long for its death. 1) https://medium.com/hvper/popurls-goes-hvper-2867b1b6b2bd https://medium.com/hvper/popurls-goes-hvper-2867b1b6b2bd
- strict9 9y agothis makes my day. I still use popurls, though it's covered in cobwebs and seems like abandonware. glad to see you have a new project up and running.
- webwanderings 9y agoUsed popurls for long period of time in history. It is an illusion (the grid reading that is). Don't think I will go back. The river of news per folder hierarchy (Google Reader) is better in a long run. It takes some effort upfront in organizing information and priorities, but it yields better reading results later.
- marban 9y agoThis has never been a replacement for a serious feed reader but something that should actually keep the latter clean from the short-term stuff that all the news outlets put out there. With a site like this, it's not about being informed, but about feeling connected.
- shortformblog 9y agoWhen my pieces show up on Digg, I see a lot of refers from Hvper. Good to know the philosophy behind it. Cheers.
- jklinger410 9y agoThank you for chiming in here. Reading so many of these comments of people basically talking out of their asses? Hey guys, just because you don't think about or use RSS anymore doesn't mean the entire platform is dead and no one uses it, haha. Jesus the hubris in this thread is insane. I have been using RSS via Feedly uninterrupted for 4 years and counting. No problems, haven't paid a dime, works great. Yes, not as popular. Apparently losing mindshare these days is akin to actually not existing.
- Deimorz 9y agoHaven't seen it mentioned in here yet, but I've recently started using Inoreader (https://www.inoreader.com/ https://www.inoreader.com/) as my RSS reader and am quite happy with it so far. I haven't tinkered with it very deeply yet, but it seems to have a lot of great features for organizing feeds, viewing in different formats, and so on.
- fern12 9y agoI love RSS, and have been using Inoreader since Google Reader's demise. Well worth the $15 annual subscription fee.
- zapperdapper 9y agoI mentioned it earlier, but thanks for providing the link! Yes, it's very cool.
- webwanderings 9y ago> If you’re not careful, every time you open your RSS reader, there will be 1,000 unread articles waiting for you, which completely defeats the purpose of using RSS. No, it does not. The point of RSS is that you subscribe all your interests which you consciously come into contact with. You then have a steady stream of content waiting at your fingertip. The solution for "1000 unread articles" is to have a shift of perspective in your mind, that it is okay if you cannot get to all the knowledge and information in the world. This is, as long as you have prioritized your reading lists properly.
- iamdbtoo 9y agoThis was hard for me when I was a big Google Reader user and even with Twitter. You have to accept that the world is going to go on without you and it's impossible to catch up with everything.
- est 9y agoWell, a good digest service would solve that. Good digest would only exist on aggregating technologies like RSS.
- addicted 9y agoI used NetNewsWire and my easy solution was to simply “Mark All as Read” at the end of each day (other than a selected few feeds, such as those related to college classes and some chosen feeds where I did not want to miss anything and had manageable number of posts such as daringfireball when I was still a huge Machead).
- gsam 9y agoI agree. But I like to have one particular feed of 1,000 unread articles and every now and again I like to pick a few to read. It's a stream of mostly research related news and it's constant and overwhelming. But it's nice to just randomly pick a little something which I wouldn't have encountered otherwise.
- quickthrower2 9y ago
- lj3 9y agoDoes anybody here know of a good native RSS program for Windows, Linux and/or Android? All of the ones I've tried are buggy or ugly or just unfriendly to use. My Reeder envy has gotten so bad, I've been running Reeder in a VMWare instance.
- DrPhish 9y agoI've been using https://www.feednotifier.com/ https://www.feednotifier.com/ for a while now. I publish my Caller ID info from my landline to an RSS feed, and Feed Notifier was one of the only ones that would allow me to get updates almost realtime. The popups strike a good balance between useful amount if info and too obtrusive, and I like how it uses the site favicon to let you know which feed you're looking at at a glance. I tried lots of methods on ios to get timely prompts, but 15 minutes seems to be about the best any of the apps I have found can do, and yes, they mostly seem to be bloated garbage with limited configuration options. The other good option on Windows is, surprisingly, Outlook. The RSS feeds in there are quite good.
- sassenach 9y agoOn Android I am using Flym, though it doesn't seem to get old entries upon subscription. It is built on the sparse rss app, it is GPLv3 and it has a newer relative spaRSS https://github.com/Etuldan/spaRSS https://github.com/Etuldan/spaRSS which is more recently maintained.
- lj3 9y agoThanks for bringing that to my attention! spaRSS is a decent contender. It's pretty, fast and it looks like it does what it should. One small wrinkle: it doesn't seem capable of importing opml files on newer android devices. A bug was filed 2 years ago, but it was closed without being fixed.
- 5_minutes 9y agoThe big offender here is Google. They nuked it with killing Reader and FeedBurner is also minutes away of being sunset. Choosing between evils, Google seems a better bet then Facebook, ofcourse, but these actions they've taken will backfire for them eventually. The more "open" and "accessible" web, should be in their benefit, long term thinking. But what I see, what they're busy with is self driving cars, google glasses, augmented reality and all of that: GREAT. But supporting some basic, easy, cheap, webstandards, they're just completely neglecting and they might up being the next AT&T, or IBM. They do have some charm offensives going ("Google News Lab") and, well, basically any big tech corp looks better then Facebook -- if you care about the internet in it's current form, Google is really screwing us over. I really am convinced Google is completely losing it's way. There's no real good quick adequate alternative that I can think of, but they could've just done things so much better, and it would've costed them, quite literally, nothing.
- bad_user 9y ago> Choosing between evils, Google seems a better bet then Facebook We are treating these companies as if they are sports teams. No, we don't have to choose between evils. > The more "open" and "accessible" web, should be in their benefit, long term thinking. An open Internet is only in the benefit of small and medium companies and startups. Companies like Google have virtually unlimited resources at their disposal. All doors are open for them, all possible loopholes are within reach. When all else fails they can just drop a couple of billion $ and nobody can say no to that.
- 5_minutes 9y agoThe comparison with Facebook is because, yes, we're at a point of choosing which companies ethics you believe in most, and feel most comfortable handling your personal data. Privacy, security, openness, ads, ... at least it does to me. And yes, I do think for any company out there crawling the web, RSS feeds are a good indicator. Ofcourse, Google algorithms got to the point that they don't really need RSS feeds anymore, but that's perhaps also the reason why quite often their search results kind of suck, as soon as you dive deeper. The real problem, for all of us out here - is that no-one even bothers making a search engine anymore. Everyone has given up. And Google can just do whatever they want. And that's exactly what they do.
- hopesthoughts 9y agoI love RSS! I'm between readers right now though. The one I'm using only loads a few feed items at a time so it's annoying. If someone can recommend a reader that presents feeds as a list of links, and has a bookmarklet I can use for subscriptions, I'd greatly appreciate it! Keep in mind that I'm using a screen reader. Lol it doesn't have to validate perfectly though.
- mmanfrin 9y agoGoogle will never recover in my eyes for the shuttering of Reader, which was an attempt to move people to G+.
- DonHopkins 9y agoWho remembers the time before they'd hammered out the rules for escaping html in RSS item title elements, and all the cool kids were syndicating each other's feeds on their blogs, then some chucklehead posted an item whose rhetorical title was "What happens when you put <blink> in the title?" and the whole blogosphere started blinking?
- CharlesW 9y ago> "For several years now, the trend among geeks has been to abandon the RSS format." I wish he would've named even a handful of examples that prove the point. Even Medium offers RSS feeds for users, publications, and tags. And also, RSS is also at the center of the enormous and growing medium of podcasting, which nearly a quarter of Americans enjoy every month.
- nicksergeant 9y agoIf you’re looking for an RSS reader that does away with unread counts, check out https://siftie.com https://siftie.com
- xahrepap 9y agoI really feel like RSS+<something else> could've been the standards for open social networking if the major feed readers didn't loose steam and FB and Twitter supported it (which is probably why they don't) I often wish for the Open-Social equivalent of email. Anyone can host it, I can subscribe to people on different hosts. And if I don't like the way my feed is aggregating I can choose another.
- reidacdc 9y ago> I often wish for the Open-Social equivalent of email... This is a pretty good description of the Mastodon social-network model, there are several nodes, and your account on one node can subscribe to accounts on others. It's distributed in a kind of nntp-like way. In my world, it made a pretty big splash about a year ago, but I've drifted away from it.
- jhasse 9y agoI think OStatus is what you're looking for ;)
- extide 9y agoI make heavy use of RS -- I use TT-RSS as a reader and subscribe to lots of feeds. I pretty much use it as a 'starting point' for most of my news gathering. Even if RSS seems to be dieing off, pretty much all major news sites and CMS systems still have RSS built in so it is not dead yet..
- indescions_2017 9y agoThere was a brief "Golden Age". I want to say around 2005 or so. When you had a proliferation of MP3 music blogs such as "Hype Machine". All with distinctive curatorial voices and great taste. And all distributing their MP3s using RSS. Just the music. No ads, filler or other detritus. And you could write your own little client program in like 100 lines of C#. That would aggregate all the various feeds. And download just the MP3 files overnight. Providing you with a tasty gigabyte-sized bouquet of rare bootlegs, unreleased demos, forgotten imports, and much more every morning. Spotify playlists have supplanted that particular use case. But the design favors promotion. Pushing overlooked talent to the fore. And bubbling up gems that may have been subsumed in the volume of noise. To find rarities, such as this classic R.E.M. set from the Paradise Theater in Boston, Summer '83 (where they opened for The Replacements). You have to stumble on it via Youtube. Or find a friend with an actual collection of old vinyl ;) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kok2fGjIUWI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kok2fGjIUWI
- smcnally 9y agoHype Machine is still around & active. http://hypem.com http://hypem.com
- pgnas 9y agoIt works.
- pgnas 9y agoIt works. Very tiring to have stuff that is rock solid exchanged for junk. Move on, find something else to go after.. there is so much that is just mediocre
- jasonkostempski 9y agoThe biggest case for me is no rescanning over things I've already seen. Also, filtering things I know I'll never want to read (anything from certain domains and some keywords) removes a ton of cruft, even when subscribed to otherwise high-volume feeds. Edit: Another big win, not needing yet another account to be tracked and targeted through just to get at a feed. Best example being YouTube.
- featherverse 9y agoRSS is as important as E-mail. Sure today people are mostly focused on corporate run social media like Twitter or Facebook but nobody really likes them. Everyone is constantly bitching about their practices. And you can't really make money on Social Media, which means corporate run social media is going to die some day, when they all realize there's no cash in that expensive cluster of cows. RSS is free, and everyone can use it, no matter what blogging software you use. Operating your own blog gives you more control over content and presentation, as well as smaller details such as how your commenting system works. It's the superior choice. It's free. That's important. Nobody controls RSS. Anyone can write an RSS reader. Anyone can write a blog app that publishes RSS. This ensures it will be around to survive the rise and fall of social software trends. When the smoke clears and people emerge from the rubble of the corporate landscape, RSS will be there, welcoming them home. footnote: I saw this article in my "Hacker News" RSS feed.
- robgibbons 9y agoI for one built my own RSS reader which I serve locally with NodeJS. I update the sources every minute and keep them in a MongoDB collection. I even added a Mercury API integration so if I like a summary, I can click a link and read the whole article in-line (formatted consistently, and just how I want it -- no ads) https://mercury.postlight.com/web-parser/ https://mercury.postlight.com/web-parser/
- krylon 9y agoIs RSS/Atom sufficiently unpopular that it need somebody stepping up and making a case for it? If so, that makes me sad, I rather like it. I am currently on my fourth iteration of building an RSS reader with a web UI, using a Bayes network to distinguish between interesting and boring articles. It is not very sophisticated, but it works well enough in filtering out the items I do not want to see. Needless to say, this thing relies on RSS to fetch news items. Kind of what it was made for, as far as I could gather.
- Animats 9y agoRSS is great. Most of the major news sources, from the BBC to Fox News to NPR, have useful RSS feeds. Technically, it works OK. Real content is out there. But there are two big problems. First, it doesn't add ads, as others have mentioned. Second, it's really easy to unsubscribe. This is why so-called "newsletters" are sent as spam emails. RSS could do the job just fine. If the recipient really wanted the newsletter. The first time a "newsletter" sends out "NEW OFFER BIG SALE...", the recipient clicks "unsubscribe". They're unsubscribed then and there, will never read another item, and the sender can't do a thing about it. The sender doesn't even know they're gone. RSS doesn't disempower the end user. Modern web technologies are designed to keep the user firmly under the thumb of advertisers. That's the problem with RSS.
- cJ0th 9y ago> First, it doesn't add ads, as others have mentioned. I think this is more a problem of scale. Simple, text-based ads could work if the audience is very specific. For instance, you could start each item with a one or two line message by a sponsor. Ads could be purchased for a fixed amount or even on a pay-per-click basis if the url is a referral. This could work brilliantly on a regional level I think. For instance, a local news paper could draw attention to a new restaurant that will open up soon, a sale at a mom&pop store and so on...
- luord 9y agoI use theoldreader myself, and have very little reason to stop checking my RSS feeds.
- zapperdapper 9y agoWhen we talk about RSS I hope we are including Atom in that too! After Google Reader went "tits up" I switched to Inoreader (a web-based reader). Still using it quite happily. Yes, the case of the disappearing feeds is something I wrote about recently - I believe it's all part of a plot to control the web... https://coffeeandcode.neocities.org/woeful-web.html https://coffeeandcode.neocities.org/woeful-web.html
- eitland 9y agoWhat I'm hoping to get time for to help out here is starting to write on my dumb blog again and have full RSS. I never earned anything from ads anyway (can't remember if I even activated them). Anyone else would like to try? As long as it isn't about "building an audience" and monetizing we could have blogrolls, links to post by other programmers and forget all about SEO nofollow etc etc.
- luxpir 9y agoNewsbeuter user here... usage dipped in the last year but have been looking to get back into the habit. Nice CLI speed and efficiency!
- LaSombra 9y agoI still use RSS. After Google News was discontinued I moved to NewsBlur, https://newsblur.com https://newsblur.com, and never looked back. RSS is the one way I keep track of the things I want and the speed I can follow, differently from Twitter.
- calmchaos 9y agoFilter the articles based on the rules you define: https://nodetics.com/feedbro/ https://nodetics.com/feedbro/
- nreece 9y agoContrary to trends & general opinion, RSS usage for content aggregation & monitoring is on an increase, specially in the business world and niche industries. I'm speaking from our own experience running a little startup, Feedity - https://feedity.com https://feedity.com, that helps create custom RSS feeds for any webpage.