8 ms·
The end of the housing supply debate (maybe)
- bobsman123 9y agoTLDR Econ 101. Supply and demand is an immutable law.
- empath75 9y agoIf you build new luxury housing presumably people now living in less desirable housing will upgrade, making their housing available at lower prices, etc.
- 1_2__4 9y agoThis claim keeps popping up. I’ve yet to see it include a citation. Maybe today will be different.
- unfiltered 9y agoIt is called "filtering" and the process is well-established. http://faculty.maxwell.syr.edu/rosenthal/recent%20papers/Is_Filtering_a_Viable_Source_of_Low-Income_Housing_%206_18_13.pdf http://faculty.maxwell.syr.edu/rosenthal/recent%20papers/Is_...
- drawnwren 9y agoThe article you're commenting on is literally the citation for this. Here's his citation, http://www.sightline.org/2017/09/21/yes-you-can-build-your-way-to-affordable-housing/ http://www.sightline.org/2017/09/21/yes-you-can-build-your-w...
- IpV8 9y agoThis kind of mentality that someone's news article counts as a source is poisonous. People read these articles and think that because a few facts have hyperlinks then they must be valid. Half of those links on that page go to other blogs and news site. One even goes to Youtube. Blogs and news agencies don't count as citations to base an argument on. Policy needs to start at peer reviewed research and build up from there.
- xcryogenicx 9y ago> This kind of mentality that someone's news article counts as a source is poisonous. Most underrated comment in the world. This coupled with for-profit journalism and the atrophy of critical thinking is giving rise to nonsense like anti-vax, chemtrails, and flat Earth. In America, the public has been led so astray by both the media and the government about things like basic macronutrients that a recent report found 1/3 of Americans, 100 million people, are diabetic are prediabetic (will have type II diabetes in 5 years). https://www.cdc.gov/diabetes/data/statistics/statistics-report.html https://www.cdc.gov/diabetes/data/statistics/statistics-repo...
- OrwellianChild 9y agoWhat, other than an article summarizing research, could possibly be provided as citation? Fund me some peer-reviewed research. In the meantime, we'll just have to make policy by flipping a coin, as there is clearly no other standard of knowledge available to us. /s
- empath75 9y agoIt’s in this very article. What other outcome could happen?
- throwawaymsft 9y agoThat new luxury housing makes a city more attractive and induces demand from outside. Adding new roads can make driving more attractive and worsen congestion. Not saying that’s what happens, but a simple supply/demand analysis (ceteris paribus) may not suffice.
- OrwellianChild 9y agoNo one has seen fit to build much luxury housing in Cleveland, OH lately, but what exists already (at rock-bottom prices) doesn't seem to be attracting much population from outside... Induced demand is definitely a thing for roads, but that demand is from fixed supply of people. In the roads case, it is counter-intuitive specifically because it causes the same number of people to drive more, on average. That dynamic simply doesn't hold for luxury goods in general or luxury housing in particular. There are effectively no replicable instances of more luxury good = more buyers unless price falls or supply was previously constrained.
- throwawaymsft 9y agoI'd posit it's hard to know what the dynamic would be. Consider certain luxury goods (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good) where increasing the price increases the demand. (Conveniently, economists have a model and also a name for things that don't follow the model. The universe can be divided into bananas and non-bananas.) Cleveland isn't a prestigious world-class city attractive to the wealthy, but if new luxury condos in a tier-1 city come online, it may induce demand from wealthy/speculators who would not otherwise have considered that city, or were picking between alternatives. (Investment, signaling/status-seeking, etc.) Treated as an investment vehicle, increasing supply (e.g., having an IPO where no shares existed before) can unlock latent demand (people divert income into that investment and drive up the price). Perhaps housing needs to be modeled as a mix of investment, local demand for shelter, status symbol, tax haven, political baton (keeping existing homeowners above water), etc. Again, not sure how housing actually behaves but it seems complex enough to defy my econ 101 understanding.
- ng12 9y agoHow about this: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-03-09/manhattan-rents-decline-for-every-apartment-size-even-studios https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-03-09/manhattan... Virtually all new construction in Manhattan is luxury.
- kevinburke 9y agohere's one from the California Legislative Office about "Helping Low-Income People Afford Housing", the gist is that building more market rate housing reduces displacement: http://www.lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/3345 http://www.lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/3345. Other headlines from the report: "Building Less Housing Than People Demand Drives High Housing Costs", "More Private Housing Construction in Coastal Urban Areas", "California Is Building Too Little Housing in Coastal Areas."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hardlianotion 9y agoInteresting article. However: "Rent increases, which were measured in the double digits eighteen months ago, have gone negative." I call those kind of increases: decreases.
- elhudy 9y agoThat kind of wording leads me to believe that he is referring to the rate. I.e. Rent increases are still occurring but at a decreasing rate. Maybe?
- icahnvalyou 9y agoPossible, but I think it's more likely poor wording than linguistic calculus.
- quotemstr 9y agoThat there was ever a debate at all is still astounding. Economics has fuzzy areas, but basic principles of supply and demand are very well-established. It's clearly nonsensical to imagine that we can simultaneously lower prices, limit supply, and allow for demand growth. The longevity of this bizarre idea demonstrates how strongly political ideas of how the world ought to work blind us to how the world does work. We'd do well to take the wool from our eyes in other contentious disputes.
- jjxw 9y agoIt is perplexing to me why the burden of proof was ever placed on "increasing supply decreases prices" when the mechanism by which rent control + limiting construction is supposed to benefit anyone besides those already occupying those units is totally unclear. I don't even think it's "ought" vs "does" - it's more NIMBY interests being more ingrained into local politics allowing them to somehow gaslight everyone into thinking the laws of supply and demand don't apply to housing.
- meric 9y agoThe ones who occupy the residences have the votes...
- hkmurakami 9y agoDon't renters also have votes? If so then it's a matter of ratio and willingness to mobilize/fund efforts.
- notatoad 9y agoNot direct votes. The renters can vote for representatives, but city councils are overwhelmingly made up of homeowners. (and a disturbingly high proportion of property developers)
- kevinburke 9y agoRenters vote but tend to be under-represented on City Councils and such because they are a) younger, b) have less money, c) move more often than people with homes. Renters don't vote as regularly as homeowners.
- rayiner 9y ago> . . it has become an article of faith that building market-rate housing raises rents, rather than lowers them. The logic of Econ 101 — that an increase in supply lowers price — is alien to many progressives, both in the Bay Area and around the country. Pretty much. I'm progressive on a lot of issues but many public-interest minded people are immune to economic realities. The example about subsidized versus market-rate housing is a great one. Subsidized housing reducing displacement twice as effectively as a market-rate house sounds great. But put another way: permitting two market-rate houses that bring in tax additional tax revenue is as effective as building a subsidized unit, which costs the government a bunch of money. The "trickle down" effect is also real. > Building more market rate housing isn’t so much about “trickle down” as it is building enough new housing to keep higher income households from moving down-market and bidding up the price of older housing that would otherwise be affordable to moderate and lower income households. In Chicago, which has never had rent controls, there are tons of high-end highrises going up. But the high-end units there were built in the 1970's and 1980's have been retargeted now as more value offerings.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoExactly. Affordable, market-rate housing is just old housing that used to be luxury. It's not that much different from cars. In the US, working class people can largely afford cars, they just buy used.
- sliverstorm 9y agoThis doesn't seem to address high end housing vs (unsubsidized) low end housing. Is a hundred new units with marble countertops as good, holistically, as a hundred with laminate? I think a lot of the opposition revolves around frustration with developers building luxury when the intent of the given policy was low or mid market units, combined with a belief that units targeted at the needy market segment would be the best solution.
- unfiltered 9y agoThe point is if nobody builds the nicer dwelling, the person with the money that could have afforded the higher price will just turf out a lower-earning person living in a worse house, because the main feature of the house is that it provides access to the occupant's job.
- jogjayr 9y agoThere are reasons for developers to prefer to build high-end housing over low-end housing. 1. City parking requirements drive up the cost of construction to the point that only luxury units would be profitable. 2. Land acquisition costs (referenced in the article) are high due to zoning laws, so developers prefer to build high-end housing to recoup those costs. 3. Labor costs the same no matter what you're building (beyond some extra for a marble installer or whatever). Labor cost is a function of cost-of-living in the area, which itself is proportional to housing costs. Since the cost of construction is high, a builder is going to build the highest-value product possible at that cost. So really all the problems boil down to city regulations, zoning, and unaffordable housing creating more unaffordable housing. "Trickle-down" is a dirty word in many circles but I think it does apply to a certain extent for housing. Today's luxury apartment is tomorrow's mid-market apartment. If I could get a better apartment than what I have for slightly more rent, I'd probably upgrade, but the difference is stupid high (nearly double). In turn, my current apartment would probably be rented by a middle-income earner if it was located somewhere other than Silicon Valley.
- sliverstorm 9y agoIt's pretty obvious why luxury development is preferred; anybody, in any market, would prefer to make luxury units. Yet no other market seems to operate by supplying only luxury units and depending on trickle down. Why are there Corollas, instead of just more Lexuses?
- cwperkins 9y agoThis is something I've been trying to understand for a long time. In New York City because of the rent controls it seems like the market rate has diverged alarmingly from the subsidized rents. From my perspective it seems like this propagates the "Tale of Two Cities" and makes it a much wider leap to go from rent-control or subsidized housing to market-rate. In my naive opinion it seems like in a system without all of the controls in place there may be a more even spectrum of price points and make jumping to the next level of housing easier. There are other forces at play here too such as foreign buyers speculating on the Manhattan Condo market, look no further then the foreclosure at One57 penthouse to show how it has gotten. I think building more housing at all levels is the best way to solve the affordability crisis, but naturally the higher-end of the market would be built out first due to developers wanting to cater to the highest bidder. The cities current approach of providing tax-incentives to developers to allot a certain portion of housing to affordable housing is seemingly a good strategy to tackle the problem of affordable housing as well as integration.
- cwperkins 9y agoDoes anyone know anyone from Starsky robotics? I think it would be interesting to deploy the remote technology used in it's trucks to construction vehicles. Imagine being able to have continuous delivery at construction sites. For example, excavation is a relatively quiet activity that seems like it just requires a back hoe and a dumpster to haul away waste. If we can be able to control these remotely, would we be able to increase the efficiency of construction sites?
- verulito 9y agoWe don't build housing, builders do. We simply decide what is permitted to happen. We could eliminate restrictions on construction and that would help but the rate of housing growth would still be limited by money available to pay for new housing, which is a lower bound to affordability. It's actually a worse problem than it sounds for, if we're decreasing building restrictions then we're slowing price growth and decreasing the attractiveness of housing to investors. To accelerate affordability, we probably also need to subsidize or at least incentivize then. That gets to be fairly expensive so where's the money going to come from? My proposal is a national growth tax, whose money is redistributed from areas which don't grow to those which do. That money will be used to pay for infrastructure improvements needed to house those people as well.
- iandanforth 9y agoI live in a very interesting area, across the street from me is a different city with housing costs roughly 10x the costs of mine. I am daily confronted with the absurdity of pricing of housing. In addition as I've watched rents around me rise, and anticipated my own rent rising, I wonder at the expectation that we should continually get less for more. My house isn't getting any newer after all. If my employer decided to cut my pay by 10 or 20% every year there's no way I would stay, and yet I must admit that I have tolerated this behavior from my landlords. Unlike commodities or consumables, for which unrestrained markets influenced by collective expectations of supply and demand are not routinely shocking, the expectation that my house, in which I already live, and for which I have been paying consistently for years, suddenly being much more expensive ... well that feels like a hole in the social contract. A problem to be remedied by legislation if the governing societal expectations do not naturally lead to a different equilibrium. What if the expectation was that if you let someone live in your home you are granting them significant rights, significant stability, and are assuming significant risk of losing money? This set of expectations is well known elsewhere, but not so much where I live. So while I am willing to be convinced that a humane and equitable improvement to a cities housing situation can be achieved by building more housing, I would hate for legislative restrictions to be ignored as complimentary and beneficial efforts.
- unfiltered 9y agoHow did you manage to find a housing price gradient that sharp? East Palo Alto vs. Palo Alto or something?
- bhauer 9y ago> my house ... for which I have been paying consistently for years If you are paying for it, not past-tense, then it's not technically your house. The apparently uneven market for real estate is shocking to buyers because of the variability of supply constraints, caused by geography but also in great measure by zoning regulation. The hackneyed refrain of "location, location, location" as the chief determinant of the value of a property illustrates this point. > I must admit that I have tolerated this behavior from my landlords. You have tolerated it precisely because you actually know that the value of property is not fixed. As demand increases while supply does not, the value/price goes up. Clearly you like the location, so you've not moved away. You are part of the demand that is moving prices upward. Your willingness to pay more is precisely what sets the price, along with supply. > A problem to be remedied by legislation if the governing societal expectations do not naturally lead to a different equilibrium. As the article points out, legislation focused on remedying the problem would relax constraints on supply caused by zoning, regulatory hurdles, etc. But so often the people complaining about the cost of housing are the same people voting to keep supply constrained.
- alexasmyths 9y agoFolks - please add immigration. Why on earth people don't grasp that when population is increasing mostly due to newcomers it affects housing ... this bothers me - because it's politicized, nobody can talk about it it seems. Immigration is just a reality, it's part of the equation - it has real effects on housing costs and wages, one can't ignore it because sometimes the answers might not jive with one's politics. So, immigration (or rather, population change, which can include births etc.) - is an important driving factor. Which includes migration between states/regions obviously.
- ouid 9y agojust build more housing.
- Danihan 9y agoNot everyone wants to live in a super over-populated / densely populated area... In general, more saturation of humans == more problems. People make fun of NIMBY, but at the end of the day who better to manage the neighborhood than the people who are already invested in it..?
- OrwellianChild 9y agoYou wish to extend control of property beyond the borders of what they own outright?
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoBut that happens all the time. Neighborhood zoning restrictions, restrictive covenants, homeowner association rules, and so on. So Danihan's position is, de facto, what the situation already is in many instances. So: You wish to not allow any control of property by anyone other than the property owner? Are you sure you really want that?
- OrwellianChild 9y ago
- RangerScience 9y agoSo, it sounds like: 1) Building any kind of more housing is beneficial 2) Building subsidized housing is more beneficial than market-rate housing This leaves me with two questions: 1) Does subsidized have double the effect because you can build twice as many? 2) Zoning laws seem to prevent cheap housing from being cost-effective for developers to build. If you made it possible to build cheap housing (in LA, maybe by reducing parking requirements), would developers be building cheap housing on their own, without prompting / subsidies?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- OrwellianChild 9y agoIn order: 1) Yes. 2) More beneficial in limiting displacement only. No considerations of cost. Answer 1) Subsidized housing provides more benefit because it provides immediate housing stock at lower prices, replacing any stock lost to luxury construction. It is definitely not cheaper or easier to build more - the same areas that need subsidized housing are the ones where housing in general is more expensive to build. Answer 2) Absolutely yes, zoning laws increase the cost of construction, leading to more expensive housing units. Explicit recommendations in favor of more affordable housing include: A) Removing parking requirements B) Allowing more density (more floors, smaller required sq. ft per unit - yes, this is a thing, and fewer yards, set-backs, etc.)
- ouid 9y agoI said it before here, but the situation in oregon is fucked up more than normal. The state constitution limits the rate at which property taxes can be raised to 4% a year, provided no new construction occurs. Increasing housing supply is actually penalized here.
- jackcosgrove 9y agoI think that's the point. Didn't the governor of Oregon tell people from other parts of the country not to move to Oregon in the 70s? Everyone wants their own private paradise without having to share.
- purplezooey 9y agoA major part of the problem is that it costs too much to build. Too many construction entities living on cheap funny money and a supply shortage after the real estate crash that has still not rebounded. Why does it cost $200,000 to add a second story to a house, for example.
- gech 9y agoAs long as we don't have developers that are willing to build only luxury, bought by speculators and remaining vacant. Please answer this.
- xenadu02 9y agoThe idea that a government - at any level - is going to fund enough subsidized housing to make even a tiny dent in the housing problem is completely laughable. Anyone proposing such nonsense isn’t serious about the problem in the least. That’s what bugs me so much about so-called progressives who oppose more housing. There is no half-plausible scenario where SF or CA comes up with the hundred billion it would take to solve the bay area’s housing shortage.