6 ms·
http://www.who.int/whr/1996/media_centre/executive_summary1/en/index9.html http://www.who.int/whr/1996/media_centre/executive_summary1/... Mosquitoes are respo
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
http://www.who.int/whr/1996/media_centre/executive_summary1/en/index9.html http://www.who.int/whr/1996/media_centre/executive_summary1/...
Mosquitoes are responsible for millions of deaths every year, and hundreds of millions of infections often with severe disability. We understand stuff pretty deeply now. According to https://www.nature.com/news/2010/100721/full/466432a.html https://www.nature.com/news/2010/100721/full/466432a.html eliminating mosquitoes would not cause major ecological issues.
So when you have millions of people dying every year from a cause on one hand and only vaguely specified fears of some nebulous future harm, the reasonable and ethical thing to do is to do what you can to eliminate mosquitoes.
- jordan801 9y agoI'm excited to see what this does to the food chain. Will it collapse? Will it kill billions? Find out on the next episode of humans trying to manipulate everything.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jackhack 9y agoThe last episode, where the honeybee population collapsed, left me on the edge of my seat. I can't wait to see what happens next. edit: Seriously, wouldn't it be best to solve existing problems with direct threat to food production than to go off tinkering with new ideas and unknown side-effects?
- maxerickson 9y agoNote that honeybees are livestock. Their presence in the US is itself an example of manipulating the environment to our own ends.
- theptip 9y agoThe problem with this argument is that it's throwing out some big numbers and bad outcomes, without making any attempt to quantify the likelihood of those outcomes. Without quantification, this position is basically unfalsifiable. Plus, there's a trivial contrapositive that is just as valid: "what if allowing mosquitoes to live causes an outbreak of a new disease that is transmitted by mosquitoes and kills billions?". Sure, that could also happen. As with total food-chain collapse from reduction of population of a non-keystone species, it seems very unlikely. Contrast that against the almost-certain probability that 0.5m will die next year (0.1 Holocausts per year, or one Holocaust per decade) from malaria. If we don't attach a probability to these outcomes there's no way of having any sort of meaningful conversation about them.
- pagnol 9y ago> We understand stuff pretty deeply now. Case in point... this is the mindset that worries us.
- bsbechtel 9y agoWe don't have millions of people dying every year in the US from mosquitoes and this is only about US policy. Millions die every year globally, but this decision will only impact a minuscule portion of those deaths.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- anonacct37 9y agoHow many planets do we have? By my count it's one. What's our track record on changing ecosystems to fix problems without creating worse problems? Zero out of how many? I hate mosquito too, and they are probably useless, but no good engineer makes changes without a backup and a tested rollback strategy, where's our backup?
- sametmax 9y agoThank you. Every time we are so sure of something being totally safe, it's just the sign we don't know enough about it. Honestly I sometimes wonder how we still haven't killed ourself already. We are very lucky bastards.
- dsjoerg 9y agoNot zero. Here are some changes we've made that affected the living things around us, but they were worth the risk 1 Indoor plumbing 2 elimination of wolves and other predators around us 3 elimination of lice and rats from our bodies and homes 4 vaccination
- 24gttghh 9y agoEliminating wolves contributed to higher deer populations and an increase in the number of deer ticks that spread Lyme disease to humans. Intensive forestry operations also help to increase deer populations as they like the more open spaces that result from clear-cuts.
- _nothing 9y agoIt's a bit different in that this isn't a permanent change. This won't wipe out mosquitos everywhere just yet. The infected males will mate with females, and their eggs will be nonviable. Then the males will die, and wild males and females will continue to mate and produce viable offspring unless the process is repeated. There's plenty of room for finding errors and fixing them --up until all mosquitos are eradicated.
- davidmr 9y agoWhen’s the last time anyone died of smallpox? As a species, we seem demonstrably better off for having arrogantly removed it from the planet.
- sametmax 9y agoEliminating an insect that has been here for millions of years, part of the food chain, helping thousands of micro-organism to mix DNA and be exposed to various conditions, thus helping evolution... That won't cause a major issue ? Sure ? 100% Safe ? You swear ? No backies in case of totally destroying our environment like we always do ? We are such an arrogant specie.
- josiahtu 9y agoYou're taking a "if it ain't broke don't fix it" approach, but the reality is that it is broken. Mosquitos kill millions.
- herbst 9y agoCould be a natural selection/control process tho.
- sametmax 9y agoYeah but to be fair, I don't want to be selected for death. If natural selection was at play, I should have died when I was 12 without my appendectomy. Human are all about saying not today to the God of death. For them self. So I just wish we continued this "not today" things, but with a broader perspective including not sawing the tree branch we are sitting on. Like destroying the entire ecosystem with our brilliant ideas.
- sametmax 9y agoNo, I'm saying killing all the bugs is as good as a solution as cutting your arm because your have arthritis in your hand. Plus, there is a lot of BS with this "killing millions" arguments. As I lived in Mali, and worked in Senegal, Uganda and Kenya, I can tell you that: - people there consider it like a big flu. It only kills the very weak, others just have it like you have a running nose in the winter. And those people are weak because we destroyed their countries, we still leach them, so they have poor infrastructures and poor access to major resources, including food, clean water and decent hygiene. - We have had a cure to most forms of malaria for several years now. Not something experimental or mysterious. I just went to the Pasteur Institute in Paris for that. You have protocols based on Malarone (surprise, it's not the preventive-only drug they tell you it is, it can cure as well). But besides tropical disease expert doctors, nobody will let you know that. And Malians don't have the money to buy it anyway. See previous point. So mosquitoes are not the problem. The problem is that our system are killing millions. Should we solve that problem by a collective suicide ? Apparently death of the mass is the popular solution to people dying.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- angersock 9y agoWouldn't having millions of people not dying every year cause problems of its own?