3 ms·
So, are they going to take the driver to court? Sarcasm aside, who is deemed to be in control, who do you sue for the damage if this vehicle crashes in to you
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
So, are they going to take the driver to court?
Sarcasm aside, who is deemed to be in control, who do you sue for the damage if this vehicle crashes in to you - isn't it the manufacturer that causes the crash (not in this case necessarily, I'm talking generally).
- ams6110 9y ago> who do you sue for the damage if this vehicle crashes in to you Generally, the owner of the at-fault vehicle is responsible.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI own my vehicle, if you drive it and cause an accident aren't you primarily at fault. Assuming normal circumstances (so not considering things like me letting a child drive, or letting you drive drunk, etc.). The person/persons in control of the vehicle are surely at fault - being the owner doesn't give you power to alter the programming and so you are powerless to avoid a crash. The company directors, who instruct the system's programmers, are the one's able to avoid the crash by making the vehicle operate effectively. There may be circumstance where a crash could not be avoided but there are going to be plenty when alternative actions - for which there is a strong rationale - would avoid a crash too.
- icebraining 9y agoI agree, it should be considered a part with a manufacturing defect, not the owner's fault.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Generally, the owner of the at-fault vehicle is responsible. Generally, the driver is at fault and liable if the driver violated a traffic law; if the accident resulted from a manufacturing defect, the manufacturer is (and potentially other participants in the stream of commerce are) liable. The owner, as distinct from the driver, may be liable in certain cases, such as (IIRC) maintenance problems. The absence of a driver reduces the difficulty of ascribing liability by reducing the possibilities.
- jbb67 9y agoThe owner of the vehicle of course like anything else. They may then in turn be able to sue the manufacturer for selling them something unfit for purpose.
- Spivak 9y agoThat's not how this works even for normal cars. You don't sue by proxy. If a car malfunctions due to a defect then it's not the driver's responsibility to pay the injured parites unless you can also prove that they were somehow at fault by knowingly driving a dangerous car. In a normal defective car case the suit against the driver will be unsuccesful but the suit against the manufacturer might go through.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> You don't sue by proxy. Actually, a defendant then suing a third party as described by the grandparent is a thing, called “contribution” [0], and I'm fairly certain there are cases where it's been applied in exactly the manner he grandparent describes involving automakers. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contribution_claim_(legal) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contribution_claim_(legal)
- dragonwriter 9y agoEven with human drivers, manufacturers are liable for harm caused by defects. (The driver also be liable for failure to maintain the vehicle in a safe state if the defect was something they reasonably should have known about, and in some cases a non-driving owner or the drivers employer might also be liable; legal liability often isn't exclusive.)