5 ms·
Growth in wind power makes life difficult for grid managers
- Mz 16y agoVery interesting problem: On the afternoon of May 19, in a single chaotic hour, more than a thousand wind turbines in the Columbia River Gorge went from spinning lazily in the breeze to full throttle as a storm rolled east out of Hood River. Suddenly, almost two nuclear plants worth of extra power was sizzling down the lines -- the largest hourly spike in wind power the Northwest has ever experienced. And some potential partial solutions, if they can get them implemented: Part of the problem is that utilities buy more capacity than they need, and hoard it for emergencies. If that capacity can be freed up, BPA estimates the lines could transfer 10 to 15 percent more power. Another issue is that utilities are required to reserve line capacity an hour ahead of time. By allowing them to adjust their orders more frequently, utilities could accommodate unanticipated ebbs and flows in wind generation and maybe free up another 25 to 30 percent of capacity on the power lines.
- ww520 16y agoIt's good problem to have.
- biturd 16y agoIs interim storage of electricity too costly? I never knew that power worked this way. So power has no storage, we run this fine line of balance where we hope supply and demand are within a few points of each other? No wonder they like nuclear so much; not that I am against it, but we can generate as much or as little as needed on demand. Seems to me this is an issue of an antiquated grid system that needs an overhaul. We are still running a 10Mb/s network and needs to update to Fiber as an analogy. I would think hat if there is excess, it would be stored to use when there is a demand for which we can't supply. Apparently that is not the case?
- AngryParsley 16y agoAt the current rate of wind development, says the BPA's Mainzer, the region's system of dams and power lines will start running into consistent operational problems around 2013, when wind in the agency's territory reaches total capacity of some 6,000 megawatts. Ok, 6 gigawatts of capacity. Let's say you want to store 12 hours worth of wind capacity. 6GW * 12 hours is 260 terajoules, the equivalent of 61,000 tons of TNT. Not only do you have to build a system that can safely store and dischange that much energy, but it has to be cheaper than current power generation methods.
- Tuna-Fish 16y ago> Is interim storage of electricity too costly? For most intents and purposes, interim storage of electricity is science fiction. Batteries are woefully inadequate, and the solutions that we do have, like pumped storage, have so long turn-on times that they might as well not exist for spikes that fast. This is the biggest narrative about energy production that is left unsaid in the general discourse. There are two distinct markets for energy -- the baseline production, and peaker production. They are different enough to be thought of as entirely different industries. Wind has the misfortune of not belonging in either.
- artpop 16y agoWhat about pumping water uphill, then using turbines to catch it coming down when it is desirable to do so.
- thingie 16y agoOf course. That's very common approach and there are many such power plants ("storage"). But as you can imagine, this cannot be built anywhere, cheaply enough and in large enough quantities. (http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/33/Dlouhe_strane_horni_nadrz.jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/33/Dlouhe_st..., 2 × 325 MW for 6 hours when full, ~250 millions EUR to build)
- chopsueyar 16y agoSmith Mountain Lake around Roanoke, VA. 656MW of power generation/storage, built for $103 million in the early 1960s. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smith_Mountain_Dam http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smith_Mountain_Dam More here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricity
- MikeCapone 16y agoA smart grid + demand response could help with storage: http://www.treehugger.com/files/2010/06/smart-grid-demand-response-renewable-energy-storage.php http://www.treehugger.com/files/2010/06/smart-grid-demand-re... Basically, if you can control lots of water heaters, fridges, refrigerated wharehouses, A/Cs, etc.. You have a way to store power (f.ex. you make the water a couple degrees hotter, or the wharehouses a couple degrees lower). Not enough to affect what's in it, but enough to use that extra power and "store" it (which buys you time, and means that you can use less power later, ie. shut down a gas plant or whatever while all those things revert to normal temp).
- StavrosK 16y agoSeriously? This is a problem? We have too much energy and we must tell people to stop producing it? The absolute worst thing that can happen is that wind farm owners will have to scale production down because they can't sell it. Sure, we'll be wasting some energy but without storage, what can we do? If this problem is so frequent, get more export lines and sell the excess elsewhere (and, conversely, import when you're running low). Why is this portrayed as a problem at all?
- Tuna-Fish 16y ago> Why is this portrayed as a problem at all? Many wind farms have serious problems being economically viable because their production is too unpredictable. Those export lines might never make back their initial investment, because the price you get for suddenly selling electricity to be provided tomorrow on the open market will be at least an order of magnitude less than what you get for stable contracts, and conversely, if you need some to be provided tomorrow, you might end up paying a lot more than you expected to. The only solution that I have seen to work is to find some industry that can afford to let their equipment sit idle while they wait for cheaper electricity and make a contract with them.
- StavrosK 16y agoOr huge batteries, I guess...
- jonah 16y agoYep: "Wind Drives Growing Use of Batteries" http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/28/business/energy-environment/28storage.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/28/business/energy-environmen...
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago... like a pumped hydroelectric station. Could wind farms have local pumped water storage work available (eg for water towers) or dedicated lines to pumped hydroelectric stations so that the power output could be chosen and excess power diverted to pumping water for later use (use for power gen' or water transport). Or would fly-wheels or heating be more efficient.
- handsomeglances 16y agoi just made an account to post this question. Why can't someone just build a wind turbine that has the similar function of switching gears like the mountain bikes do? If the blade moves too fast it can switch gears and makes it harder to spin the blade - wouldn't that produce less energy and fix their problem?
- lionhearted 16y agoGood question, but the danger isn't in overloading - they can shut off the power they're getting easily enough. The problem is it's a tremendous waste. Wind power is good, it's just extremely unreliable and storing it is a harder problem than you'd think. One of the regular users here, DaniFong, posted some good comments and articles on how difficult it is to store power. If you started at her profile and clicked around, she's made some quite insightful points on the topic: http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=DaniFong http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=DaniFong
- gvb 16y agoFeathering the blades is windmill "gearing". It matches the power available from the wind to the power that can be absorbed by the generator. In the overpowered case, it scales back the power converted from the wind: it "spills" some of the wind energy by making the blades less efficient so that less power is generated (totally feathered results in no power, but the blades can be feathered to any degree necessary). Adjustable gearing would add a lot of complexity, weight, and reduce reliability. Reducing efficiency by (partially) feathering the blades is a much better method, especially since it is already a necessary capability of the windmill.
- Groxx 16y ago"Switching gears" shouldn't make a difference unless it brings the blades to a halt. There's still (roughly) the same amount of energy, it's just producing different voltage / amperage based on your gearing. Rotating the blades slightly, however, would control power generation without trouble (though possibly more cost / repair / etc, unless they do this already?).
- Groxx 16y agoBring on the smart grid + power storage (ie, flywheel) industry! That way, not only could it be absorbed and properly used, but info back to the turbines could get them to throttle down before more than can be absorbed is created. The power companies wouldn't have to worry much, and the power storage industry could off such bursts, instead of the excess pretty much being wasted.
- MikeCapone 16y agoOne underrated source of storage in the grid is water heaters, fridges and A/Cs. With some "demand response" technology (part of the smart grid), this could be tapped. See: http://www.treehugger.com/files/2010/06/smart-grid-demand-response-renewable-energy-storage.php http://www.treehugger.com/files/2010/06/smart-grid-demand-re...
- Groxx 16y agoInteresting, but labeling them "storage" is about as far down the path of false advertising as you can get. They're just saying that by reducing a commercial freezer's temperature by a fraction of a degree can result in serious energy savings if the grid is feeling a squeeze. Storage means you can get energy out of it, not simply make it use less. But yeah, a smart grid is effectively necessary for any possibility of improvement.
- delackner 16y agoIf the commercial freezer is well-insulated, doesn't making it slightly colder now allow you to draw less power for a while afterwards as the room slowly rises back towards its acceptable peak temperature? Nothing harmed by taking already frozen things and making them a bit colder for a while. Certainly it is less efficient than just maintaining the desired temperature, but probably more efficient than just throwing away all that wind energy.
- Groxx 16y agoTrue, hadn't really thought of that approach. Still, though, it's all about reducing demand, not modifying supply. Flywheel storage can literally pump juice into the grid, temporarily raising the net energy level (yes, by reducing it earlier, similar to the freezer). And because of that quality there's a huge potential market, because those high-stress times are when electricity costs the most. I guess my point is that, with flywheels, you can make money through nothing but the power grid. With a freezer, you can only reduce how much you lose.