7 ms·
All they are doing is arbitraging loopholes in the tax systems. Politicians have been trying to solve way too many problems by taxes (taxing differently x and y
by cm2187 9y ago
All they are doing is arbitraging loopholes in the tax systems. Politicians have been trying to solve way too many problems by taxes (taxing differently x and y) or giving tax gifts to donors and various organised interests. As a result it creates an arbitrage-able tax system. I wouldn't point your annoyance to those who are optimising their taxes (after all this is merely their fiduciary duties to their share holders) but to the designers of this tax system. Create a flat tax and pretty much all tax avoidance schemes disappear.
- eru 9y agoA flat tax on income would help, but it's still a tax on income, and so you can move that around with clever transfer pricing etc. Land value tax works even better: it's physically impossible to move or hide land.
- cm2187 9y agoFlat tax is not just about removing thresholds, but also using the same tax rate across the board. If you tax in the same way income, capital gains or corporate profits, don't give a tax exemption for debt, don't charge a stamp duty on property (or charge the same rate on the purchase of all assets, property or not), etc, then you kill all these tax schemes.
- eru 9y agoIsn't that usually called a broad based tax or so? I mean I mostly agree with what you are saying, just noting that I'm used to different terminology. Yes, it's a good idea to put eg debt and equity on the same level; don't tax transactions that improve economic efficiency (tax consumption instead for example). Land value tax is still a great idea for these and other reasons. Eg you can jack the lvt really high and basically tax away all land rent without negatively impacting the economy. So even in an otherwise 'flat tax world' like you describe, it might be a good idea to get the majority of revenue from taxing land rent (and in the wider sense, resource extraction and commons like pollution carrying capacity).
- chii 9y agoLVT sounds good in theory, but a large number of rich people _are_ acting as rent seekers (they own property, and extract value via rents on people who work/produce actual value on it). It would not be politically feasible, unless the gov't is prepared to fight against those powerful land owners.
- eru 9y agoYes, the political feasibility is one big problem. (The other challenge is to figure out how much revenue you could raise---there are some good theoretical arguments that elimination a tax on something else like labour income should increase the local land value and thus land value tax by enough to offset that loss, but I don't know whether that works out in practice.) There is some hope for the political feasibility: some countries already have land value taxes with various imperfections like Estonia, and some Australian states, and some counties in the US.
- yardie 9y agoSomehow I doubt the person making $20k/year paying the government 20% would see it the same way as the person making $100k/year.
- eru 9y agoWhat do you mean? A few points, but I am not sure which one you are referring to: - interesting enough actual taxation in the US seems to be mostly flat in practice (after a certain threshold): rich people get more deductions and can hire lawyers to use all the loopholes - you can have a mostly fixed marginal rate of taxation on income, but still have progression in average rates. Eg give everyone $10k/year as an allowance, and tax at a fixed 20%. - for taxes on income there's a trade-off between equality, ability to pay, but also blunting incentives and raising revenue. Luckily, if you tax land value instead, you can tax away essentially the whole of land rent without blunting any incentives to work or invest. (So the whole conundrum about the right way to tax income can be mostly side-stepped.) I'm about to move to Singapore. They have a progressive income tax system with almost no deductions, but the maximum marginal rate is 22%. (VAT is 7%.) Since there system is so simple and rates are low, it's usually easier to just pay instead of trying to find loopholes.
- yardie 9y agoI mean that flat-tax rates punish the poor. One may have to miss a meal to pay their taxes. The other will have a few less bottles of champagne to purchase. Even in your follow up post as soon as we make provisions for the reality we live in the flat tax goes back to being a progressive tax, again. So what we really need is a simpler progressive tax rather than a gradually complex flat tax.
- eru 9y agoThe main argument for a flat tax is to simplify the system and make it harder to game. What really punishes the poor are complicated taxes--the kind that people who can afford lawyers and accounts don't pay. Singapore and Hong Kong seem to do the right thing in terms of taxation: their systems are simple and the income tax is progressive, but the top marginal rates are pretty low by European standards (around 20%). To help the poor, universal basic income seems like a good idea. It pairs well with my favourite kind of taxation: land value tax. See https://medium.com/basic-income/why-land-value-tax-and-universal-basic-income-need-each-other-42ba999f7322 https://medium.com/basic-income/why-land-value-tax-and-unive... for a pretty insightful rant. If an income tax is necessary at all, giving everybody a flat allowance per head plus a pretty flat rate should be good enough on the poor? (Otherwise, do whatever Singapore or Hong Kong or Estonia are doing.)
- dontreact 9y agoI think you are fundamentally missing the nature of the loopholes being exploited. They have less to do with the complexity of the taxes in one country but rather the complexity that emerges naturally from different countries having different tax codes. How would a flat tax help avoid this scheme for example?: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2012/04/28/business/Double-Irish-With-A-Dutch-Sandwich.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2012/04/28/business/Doubl... The whole point is they skip the U.S. tax code entirely.
- eru 9y agoThere are taxes that are harder to skip than others. (At the risk of sounding like a broken record, land value taxation is basically impossible to avoid if you are using land.)
- dontreact 9y agoWould that really be effective? A lot of very large companies may just own very little land.
- eru 9y agoYou'd pay for land by value, not amount. So Google owning an block in Manhattan to put their office on would probably garner a higher bill than a farmer with a bunch of fields. But yes, you can side-step the tax by using less land and eg more capital. (But that's fine, somebody else will use that land you are not using, and pay the tax for it. And if everyone is doing that substitution, it'll make land more expensive in the end.)
- cm2187 9y agoIf you don't have control over foreign loopholes, you eliminate them by applying to companies what you apply to individuals in the US. I.e. that US companies may not pay less taxes than they would pay if their activity was all in the US. It would of course increase the effective tax rate in for US large companies a lot, but the US corporate tax rate is very high vs other countries. If it becomes efficient you can afford to reduce it.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>All they are doing is arbitraging loopholes in the tax systems. Politicians have been trying to solve way too many problems by taxes (taxing differently x and y) or giving tax gifts to donors and various organised interests. As a result it creates an arbitrage-able tax system. The loopholes themselves are gifts to friends, lobbyists and donors. >I wouldn't point your annoyance to those who are optimising their taxes (after all this is merely their fiduciary duties to their share holders) but to the designers of this tax system. Why are you pretending that those optimizing their taxes are not furiously lobbying to keep them "optimized"? >Create a flat tax and pretty much all tax avoidance schemes disappear. The flat tax is possibly the most regressive tax system ever conceived. If you want to reward owning for a living and punish working for a living then it's almost the perfect tax.