10 ms·
The GOP Tax Plan Will Destroy Graduate Education
- jiqiren 9y agoDestroy is certainly too strong of a word to use. This tax plan would likely mean more student loan debt. That's also bad - but it isn't going to destroy graduate education.
- jparse 9y agoU.S. education is absurdly expensive already. That's another topic but by the time you get to graduate school, you are already in debt...a lot of debt. Considering graduate school is also unduly expensive to begin with, many people are not going to want to take on a big loan they won't be able to pay back. The result will be a lack of higher skilled graduates from U.S. universities. It's already a problem for the U.S. and it will get far worse. That's not good for the U.S.
- spott 9y agoPhD programs (which are the ones that are usually getting tuition wavers) don't usually increase lifetime earnings. Generally speaking, when you graduate, you make about as much as you would have if you had been working for 5-7 years... and you don't have 5-7 years of salary behind you.
- kd0amg 9y agoIf I can't make rent doing this, I am unlikely to keep at it.
- nategri 9y agoPhD programs already have insane attrition rates. Not difficult to imagine that any factor that makes it even slightly more untenable than it already is could have a big impact.
- hcknwscommenter 9y agoWaivers are generally provided in graduate programs where most of the students do not accrue education debt (e.g., STEM). Thus, for most graduate students affected by this, we are not talking about "more student loan debt" being the difference. We are talking about a difference between no student loan debt (the current situation for most STEM grad students) and a great deal of student loan debt (the situation if this passes). I do not think "destroy" is too strong of a word to use.
- bklyn11201 9y agoMy alternate headline: GOP Tax Plan will force institutions to alter graduate tuition accounting Tuition waivers are currently used, especially in the science disciplines, to have outside research grant dollars pay for grad-student tuition. If this tax plan passes, tuition waivers would no longer make sense and the dollars from research grants would need to shift. This probably means lower tuition for certain programs and more money from the research grant going to institutional administrative costs.
- numbsafari 9y agoExactly. Personally, I'd like to see a balanced approach: shift some of the money to increase those laughable stipends into something livable, and put the rest where it belongs: on admin costs. The shell game universities are playing is part of the problem. Hopefully, if this change makes it into the final bill, Universities do the right thing and don't stick it to their Grad Students.
- test6554 9y agoCan you elaborate more on what is going on at universities? Are you saying that grant money comes in for research, but gets funneled back to the university through tuition?
- HarryHirsch 9y agoThat's correct, part of grant money is allocated to salaries for graduate students and postdocs, sometimes even salaries for the professor himself. The corollary is that any PhD program in the sciences where it's the student who pays the tuition is worthless. Another part of a research grant goes to the institution, that's the dreaded "indirect costs".
- wahern 9y agoThe default tax rule in the U.S. is that any benefit you receive, in any form, is earned income and taxable. Layered atop that default rule are a long list of exceptions, which are generally categorized as (1) exemptions and (2) deductions. If you attend a Ph.D program where the advertised tuition is $30k per year, and you get a tuition waiver (or w'ever it's called), the default tax rule says that you still earned income because you received a benefit. The nominal value of that benefit is $30k, therefore the student would need to pay taxes on that $30k. Apparently there's an exemption or deduction that excepts tuition waivers from the default rule, meaning such tuition waivers wouldn't be considered taxable income. As part of the GOP plan to pay for corporate income tax rate cuts, they must discard many kinds of exemptions and deductions to replace lost revenue from the corporate rate cuts. To those who say that this is a shell game[1], note that if it was just a shell game then the change wouldn't have been made. In other words, there's an expectation that discarding this exclusion will generate more revenue. That revenue would directly come from students and/or universities, one way or another. Universities could lower tuition, but one reason for the disparity between nominal tuition and effective tuition is that foreign students disproportionately pay the nominal tuition. Reduce nominal tuition and you reduce the foreign subsidy for domestic students. Not only does the effective price of a graduate education go up, but you're likely to see even more foreign students. Depending on which country you hold citizenship, that's either good for your career prospects or bad for your career prospects. [1] All the news reports make a point of saying that the university "pays" the tuition waiver. It's a distinction without a difference. The student still derives a benefit, and however the university cares to balance its books (e.g. with double-entry accounting) is entirely irrelevant unless there's incredibly esoteric technical requirement to the particular earned income exception. Such esoteric technical requirements are rare since the 1986 reform as the text of modern rules emphasize underlying economic benefits and not accounting practices, as focusing on the latter create more opportunities for gaming the tax code.
- JonFish85 9y agoNo, it won't. The sensationalism all around is just infuriating; I know it's basically politics in a nutshell, but this sort of crap is getting really old. It's not going to destroy higher education; it might raise the bar a bit of who goes to graduate school, and force schools to do more to entice top tier talent to come to their school, but it's not going to destroy it.
- sorrymate 9y agoCan you provide any specific details on how the new suggested tax plan will raise the bar? It seems as though we should be encouraging Graduate and PhD students. It seems as though it would force additional students into taking out loans if their tuition is not waived?
- sharemywin 9y agoor stop pursuing a graduate degree and go get a job making 30k-50k or more working in industry.
- citrate05 9y agoA PhD (and sometimes a postdoc) is a requirement if you want to do more than low pay lab-tech work in some fields, like pharma. In the life sciences a PhD is more of a professional degree.
- JonFish85 9y agoIf the only thing standing in the way of a student continuing on Graduate or PhD studies is grant money, they shouldn't have trouble finding a job. In that case, if the university wants to attract those students from the private sector, they'll have to find a way to increase a student's stipend to cover these expenses. At top-tier schools where tuition is the highest, their endowment is likely large enough to support this move. Alternatively, the schools could adjust what they charge students for tuition. As the article states, the cost of a year at Princeton's grad school is $49k/yr. Somehow I suspect that this sticker price is not tied to much in terms of their cost, but if it means charging less to students if that allows them to attract top talent, they could probably do that as well. In terms of raising the bar, to me this would mean that if graduate schools want top talent, they'll have to find a way to do it: raise the stipend, lower the cost of tuition or something else. In this case, a very bright student who can't afford graduate school will either have to go into industry or the schools will have to find a way to keep them. On the downside, if we follow the pattern of the last 30 years, the reaction will go something like: 1) Students struggle to afford college tuition 2) Government steps in to make large cheap-ish loans available beyond what might be reasonable (). 3) Students now have access to loans to go to any school they want 4) Colleges notice that they can raise price because students don't price shop 5) Colleges raise their prices () They're government backed loans that are difficult to discharge, mostly because there is nothing to repossess and interest rates would likely go through the roof if students could graduate and immediately discharge their loans.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI think this is a good thing. Graduate education is grossly overpriced, because institutions know the government will help pickup the tab.
- taylodl 9y agoI don't follow your line of thought. How is the government picking up the tab? The government isn't making any payment back to the institution.
- pkaye 9y agoMy understanding is that universities jack up the tuition knowing the students can get government subsidized loans and grants. Then they give tuition waivers to those who cant because the prices are jacked up and getting something from them is better than nothing.
- taylodl 9y agoBut these students aren't getting loans - they're having their tuition waived. Now the government wants to tax the amount waived as income. If anything, graduate students will now be forced to get loans in order to pay their taxes - which is absurd.
- lostapathy 9y agoOr maybe tuition will come back down to a level that actually matches what it costs to run the school, and grad student instructors will get paid a wage instead?
- taylodl 9y agoWhich costs the institutions money in the form of paid wages to grad student instructors - which is an actual outlay of money. Lowering the tuition across the board for grad students lowers it for all grad students, not just the grad student instructors. Either way the institution, the grad student, or both, are out more money out of pocket as a result of this plan.
- blakesterz 9y agoSo the plan is... >> Under the new GOP tax plan, however, those tuition waivers would be taxed as regular income... Sensationalist headlines aside... Why is this being targeted in the new tax plan? Usually I can find something with a quote from someone that explains.
- theli0nheart 9y agoFrom my brief assessment, it seems like tuition waivers are a form of barter. Other forms of bartering are taxable, so they're eliminating this exception.
- derekp7 9y agoAs for bartering being taxable, I wonder how employee-only discounts at retail establishments work? Is the discount amount taxable (or should it be taxable)? From my understanding of research tuition waivers, the PhD student is working for the university, and as an employee is getting a steep discount on the product (education) they normally sell.
- theli0nheart 9y ago> As for bartering being taxable, I wonder how employee-only discounts at retail establishments work? Is the discount amount taxable (or should it be taxable)? I just looked this up on the IRS Employer's Tax Guide to Fringe Benefits [1], and it looks like only discounts on products that are less than gross profit margin are income tax exempt. E.g, if you sell a Widget for $10 and make $2 profit on every sale, you can provide a $2 discount to the employee, and then deduct that $2 from the employee's wages. Furthermore, employees that are 5% owners or that make more than $120,000 are unable to claim any employee discount deduction. [1]: https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p15b.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p15b.pdf (p10)
- kurthr 9y agoWell, if you have to ask... because Education, the Elite (not the rich, those are fine), and Science are bad. They interfere with accumulation of stagnant wealth and power.. along with election prospects. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/09/opinion/sunday/trump-epa-pruitt-science.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/09/opinion/sunday/trump-epa-... Also, they cause people to question biblical authority.
- heyitsguay 9y agoThe misinformation in this thread is astounding. This is targeting graduate student tuition waivers: waivers given to students who are usually also receiving a stipend, who are almost never taking out loans to manage degree costs. It's likely that there is a better way for universities to quantify the net movement of money between student and institution, but to have lowly-paid graduate students bear the brunt of the change is unconscionable.
- luckydude 9y agoUh, it worked the same way for Masters degrees at Wisconsin (source: I have one and this tax "reform" would have screwed me). I don't understand your undergrad comment, the tax bill doesn't change anything there so far as I know.
- heyitsguay 9y agoYou're right, it would've been more accurate to just say "graduate" instead of "PhD", I'll edit it. I don't think I mentioned undergrads though.
- lewis500 9y agoI don't understand this. During my PhD my "scholarship" was just basically the university choosing not to charge me money. It's not as though I sat down and set on fire $20k worth of paper every year. So now they have to pay tax on to the amount they would have otherwise charged me? Isn't that kind of a hypothetical concept? Like, can't they say, "Oh the tuition for the civil engineering PhD program is now zero"? Virtually no one in my program had ever paid tuition before. Maybe what they could do is claim we are first and foremost employees and that the PhD is a certificate of on-the-job training. Presumably they are not going to charge Facebook for the training courses they give their employees.
- madcaptenor 9y agoI've got a PhD in math. I've been wondering this too. I remember that one of the institutions that accepted me, said, in the acceptance letter, that my offer was worth something like $60k a year ($20k in actual stipend and $40k in tuition I wouldn't be paying). That was good for a laugh then, but it would have actual meaning now.
- turc1656 9y agoThis is similar in concept to how debt forgiveness works. Generally (there are exceptions), debt that was defaulted on gets taxed as though it was income because it was planned/expected to be income for the creditor, upon which taxes would be paid. It's also similar to how other non-monetary transactions are treated in the tax code. For example - bartering. Legally, if I agree to fix your roof if you repair my vehicle, that is, under the law, a taxable event. It's just that such things are very hard to enforce in that kind of situation. This is essentially applying the same concept. It's not hypothetical. Something of value is being received/transferred. That is a taxable event, but here it is much easier to enforce because there are numerous records proving that it occurred.
- ISL 9y agoGraduate students cost research groups about as much as postdocs cost, precisely because we're paying the University for the analog of the tuition waiver.
- 9y ago
- PatientTrades 9y agoSensationalism at its finest. At some point we have to demand some sort of integrity from our media. This is getting out of hand. The tax plan will force schools to alter graduate tuition accounting. But "Destroy" really?
- hcknwscommenter 9y agoAs a former Ph.D. student and now graduate, I would have to say the title is is not sensationalist at all. This aspect of the tax plan will raise additional funds (to at least partially offset the magnitude of the revenue reductions). Where do you think those funds are going to come from? They come from the graduate students who will now be taxed on these tuition waiver amounts. It is extremely facile to just waive arms and assert that, somehow, the schools will simply get around the issue by changing their accounting. If that were the case, why would this even be in the tax bill?
- PatientTrades 9y ago> I would have to say the title is not sensationalist at all It's appalling that you don't find the title extreme. No way will a tax plan completely destroy higher education as we know it. > Where do you think those funds are going to come from? Its simple. The schools are going to start including the cost of taxes when covering the grad students tuition costs. For example, if tuition is 50k + a tax of 10k. The schools will cover the 60k for tuition for a full ride. No school with a conscious is going to slap a grad student with a sizable tax bill.
- hcknwscommenter 9y agoAppalling? Now who is being sensationalist? What you are saying is that the school is going to bear the cost rather than the student. Probably. But then, the Ph.D. program just becomes much more expensive for the school to administer. As such, all but the most well-endowed are going to simply stop admitting Ph.D. students. Your simplified, and actually unworkable, accounting trick achieves the same effect of destroying our world-class and unparalleled STEM graduate system.
- rayiner 9y agoUnder the logic of the tax code, tuition waivers should obviously be taxable. The University is basically paying for graduate student labor with a vastly below-minimum wage stipend, along with a very valuable free education. "In kind" benefits (such as the use of an apartment) provided by an employer are generally taxable. That doesn't mean tuition waivers should be taxed. It just means you have to be intellectually honest and call them what they are: a tax break. But viewed in that light, maybe they're not so defensible. While a small minority of graduate students may come from the lowest income backgrounds, on average they're highly educated and privileged. So in essence, it's a tax break for among the most advantaged people. Why is that "fair?"
- tanderson92 9y agoAt the same time, repealing the tax break hurts those least privileged the most. Why is that making things more "fair"?
- rayiner 9y agoGraduate students, as a class, are not the "least privileged." Most are from families that are pretty educated and well-off to begin with.
- tanderson92 9y agoThat is true, and is unrelated to my comment. I was referring to the least privileged members as a subset of that class. I know plenty of PhD students who were the first in their family to attend college, or graduate high school.
- rayiner 9y agoIt depends on what you do with the extra revenue after you repeal. Repealing it and using the revenue to lower corporate taxes may or may not be fair (maybe it creates more jobs for lower-income people, who knows). Repealing it to increase the earned-income tax credit would almost certainly be fair. You'd be getting rid of a tax break that disproportionately benefits more privileged people, and expanding a tax break that disproportionately benefits less advantaged people.
- bo1024 9y agoDespite all the comments, it seems hard to gauge what would happen if something this insane were to actually pass. Hopefully universities would find a way to "creatively adjust" their accounting such that graduate students are paid the same net amount as they were, but universities are big bureaucratic institutions and slow to change or adapt. I'll only speak to what I know, which is fully-funded PhD programs in STEM. If this change hit students directly, it would be devastating. If you look at top private institutions in the USA, you might notice that the socioeconomics of the undergrads skew rich-rich-rich but the STEM PhD students come from all walks of life (and countries all over the world). That's because the programs pay them enough to live on, albeit barely in many cases. If that fact goes away, so will the students. Now maybe universities will be able to adapt and either pay enough to make up for it, or change their accounting. But most likely there will be a dichotomy where the richest and most successful programs have the easiest time negotiating the change while the others get hit hard.
- bklyn11201 9y agoSTEM PhD students provide USA universities with inexpensive teaching labor, prestige, future donation revenue, future patent revenue, and the labor to complete research grants. The best research institutions will move quickly to keep the graduate system in place.
- wbraun 9y agoA similar analysis has been circulating mailing lists at MIT over the past few days and all the grad students are already freaked out by this. As someone who is in the process of applying to phd programs and has already made peace with the lost earnings this really sucks. If this provision makes it into the tax code I will have to strongly reconsider my plans, as will many other students.
- eli_gottlieb 9y agoIt might be better to start the program, and then, if the finances of all academia get nuked by Congressional Republicans, your adviser can help you find some place outside the USA to transfer or something.
- elijahwright 9y agoIt's probably a bit late to worry about graduate education being destroyed. 30 or 35 years ago might have been more helpful.