3 ms·
The positive response to this seems down right bizarre to me. "People could use them to go on remote vacations, he said, touring the streets of a faraway count
by jimbokun 16y ago
The positive response to this seems down right bizarre to me.
"People could use them to go on remote vacations, he said, touring the streets of a faraway country or interacting with the locals without ever leaving their bedrooms."
This seems to be a serious suggestion. Um, so the vision of the future from Wall*E is something to aspire to? No reason to ever leave your bedroom again, for anything? Not even vacation? That's the value proposition?
Except, all the people there are in their bedrooms controlling their robots, so your robot is just interacting with the other robots there. Except, the people living there are probably controlling a robot near where you live, anyway, so your robot is probably just hanging out with other robot tourists.
For remote work arrangements, the thing that is lacking is the massive amount of information conveyed through body language. 100% of the body language of the person controlling the robot is still not conveyed. So what problem is this actually solving?
I'm still trying to wrap my mind around the idea that what we really need is one less reason to get up off our asses and move our bodies.
- nazgulnarsil 16y agotry the movie surrogates.
- rsaarelm 16y agoYeah, there's a dissonance. People stay from being messed up physically and mentally by moving around and keeping their surroundings varied. On the other hand, you keep your mainframe CPU in a nice stable server room, not rolling around on the factory floor where it gets crushed when a bot slips and drops an airplane engine block on it. What I'm thinking about this is what will it look like 50 or 100 years on, if it catches up. People becoming physically and mentally unwell from staying still is mostly a mechanical problem beyond the lack of changing stimuli and surroundings, and the telepresence rig would provide those. The low bandwidth thing can get gradually better. The ultimate solution would be some kind of direct neural interface which would give pretty much the same sensory bandwidth as you get from your biological senses, but that would require an entirely new and really difficult to develop technology stack. What we can do now is develop VR and augmented reality technologies. At the operator end, a VR headset or some kind of CAVE environment to give 360° view of the bot's surroundings. At bot end, you could use augmented reality to project an image of the human operator captured from multiple directions as a 3D avatar that shows the operator's body language to people wearing headsets around the bot. I'm not seeing intrinsic value in people moving around in person, though of course lots of instrumental value which would need to be patched in with technology. There is, on the other hand, value in many people not moving long distances much, in the massive amounts of transportation fuel it would save.
- meric 16y agoHmm, it doesn't have to be my robot... I could rent a robot in Hong Kong from RentARobot for $20 an hour, while staying at work, so I can go visit my grandma or something without having the need to catch a flight. Stay at work and save the plane ticket... Or, visit multiple countries on the same day, if my relatives are spread across the continent.
- tlb 16y agoMost people can't manage to take time off and travel overseas more than once a year. They might see more of the world if it were easier. Also, there are a lot of elderly, infirm, or handicapped people in the world who can't physically travel.
- mseebach 16y agoI think the vacation example is a typical example of journalist dumbing-down. Travel is about actually being there, not a very good candidate for telepresense. If it was, HD travelshows would be a substitute for vacation. Think outside the box, of cases where the presense of the flesh of the practitioner is undesirable, either for safety, space, logistics, or costs. Someone mentioned taxi-drivers, which is a very good example.
- aufreak3 16y agoIf it was, HD travelshows would be a substitute for vacation. They don't substitute for vacation. They might very well satisfy that urge to travel ... just like people watching Discovery or Nat Geo in the comfort of their homes. You can do this everyday as opposed only a few times a year .. which you can still do.