5 ms·
Good for him, but I really wish for a better class of business journalism. He's been doing this 4 years, and never made more than $150k/year. So he definitely i
by wpietri 9y ago
Good for him, but I really wish for a better class of business journalism. He's been doing this 4 years, and never made more than $150k/year. So he definitely isn't somebody who "makes millions".
- eli 9y agoYou're confusing the salary he pays himself with the success of the business.
- tyingq 9y agoThere's this: "Grant says the business is on track to top $8 million in total sales by the end of this year" But, the actual net margin is unclear. At least $150k, since he paid himself that. But it's not clear that it's millions.
- ssanders82 9y agothe article says "his business is making seven-figure profits"
- tyingq 9y agoHmm. Seems unlikely given the manual nature of shopping at WalMart, shipping costs, returns, etc, on an $8M revenue base. Edit: He contradicts himself..."four years later, we're a team of 11 and we're doing well over $200,000 in sales per month" $200k/month isn't even close to $8M/year. And you aren't netting 7 figures with $200k/month and 11 employees. Now I'm thinking this is just a puff piece for his get-rich-quick lecture series. Too bad, as it's probably still a decent story with the actual figures. Just not a rags to riches one. I'm also having trouble visualizing 11 people buying $8M (retail) worth of stuff from WalMart in shopping carts. That's $2k per day, per employee, every day.
- bayesian_horse 9y agoThis "company" may be doing something else, additionally to these flipping schemes. Seminars are mentioned. Consulting may be something else. Or some other form of ecommerce.
- tyingq 9y ago"Seminars are mentioned" Ahh, yes, of course.
- Mz 9y agoSo, if you knew how to make money doing x and genuinely wanted to share that info, how would you do so effectively without being perceived as a scam artist?
- tyingq 9y agoHere's his landing page: https://ose.teachable.com/p/how-to-make-your-first-1-000-selling-on-amazon https://ose.teachable.com/p/how-to-make-your-first-1-000-sel... Your call on whether it's a genuine desire to share his success.
- Mz 9y agoThat in no way answers my question.
- sliverstorm 9y agoDo it for free, perhaps
- Mz 9y agoI am trying to do exactly that. One establishment would not post the flyer "because it might be a pyramid scheme." So simply being free seems insufficient. But, thank you.
- westwooded 9y agoI agree. The article is intentionally vague. Millions of dollars in revenue is relatively easy vs. millions in net profit. That said, presumably the value of the entity could be a multiple of the revenue. Either way the article fails to shed enough light on it.
- pulse7 9y agoAnd it is written also "...his business is making seven-figure profits..."
- forkLding 9y agoThe article might be exaggerating but it did state that he had 'millions in profits' at first paragraph. Salary is a different matter, CEOs of new companies dont earn from annual revenue but more from stock sales and gains. Paying 150k is also before taxing and profits and is an expense in wages. Taking a quick guess and say that this person has 1 million in profits, but most likely 1 million to 2 million in gross profits instead of net from what I can think is more likely and 150k in his salary as well as wages for 11 people and warehouse rent which likely reaches 700k to 1 million, he likely has around 3 to 3.5 million in revenue and net profits of likely 50k as thats your average web retailer net margin
- tyingq 9y agoHe also says he's doing $200k/month in one spot, then $8M/year in another. Smells funny.
- giarc 9y agoThey are currently doing $200k in sales but "Since he started selling on Amazon, Grant says the business is on track to top $8 million in total sales by the end of this year." $8 million is sales since starting.
- tyingq 9y agoThe math still doesn't work. He's been at it 4 years, and he notes that it wasn't huge the first year.
- giarc 9y agoHe's doing $200k in sales per month now.... Black Friday and Christmas are just around the corner and are probably 80% of their business (just my guess). Either way retail sales are not linear.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoRevenue is revenue. Profits are profits. In this case, I'm guessing, it was revenue over $1m.
- rubyfan 9y agoHis high salary was $150k. You can still make millions without taking it out in the form of a salary. If he owns the company and the value of his equity increases into the millions, then he’s making millions. It sounded like he was reinvesting the money back into the business too. It’s probably a smarter use of profits if he has predictable margins that scale.
- zaroth 9y agoNo recurring revenue, no actual customers, no secret sauce. Maybe some proprietary data models, but doesn't really sound like it. So what would it be that someone was hypothetically paying for if they were to buy him out? The blog following and sales classes probably are the key IP worth paying for.
- rubyfan 9y agoHe’s pretty honest about that in the article, anyone can do it; he wants them to; and he’s spending his personal time trying to convince others to. The reinvestment is for something better than a juiced up valuation. He’s likely parlaying his profit into more inventory or scaling the team that he will profit from. Reinvestment isn’t always about selling the company.
- zaroth 9y agoAgree the large reinvestment is necessary for any growing business. But if you want that equity to be worth much there has to be something there to buy.
- coldtea 9y ago>No recurring revenue, no actual customers, no secret sauce. Maybe some proprietary data models, but doesn't really sound like it. So exactly like most of the 100s-of-millions valued internet startups? (But in this case, actually making a profit)
- anonu 9y ago"generates millions" would have been better wording in the headline
- ProAm 9y agoHow many startups would love to make this much a year??
- elvirs 9y agoexactly, lets say he really does make 200k in sales per month. and lets say he happens to enjoy 100% profit margin (very impossible) thats 200k-100k-50k (amazon fees) leaves him with 50k profit per month. 10 employees excluding him is 25-35k range, and 1.5-2k rent for warhouse and 1k for all utilities and shipping supplies. that leaves the guy making around 10k a month before taxes. very far from ‘millions’
- notyourday 9y agoThe level of hate towards someone who is successfully working for himself, making $150k a year, no being beholden to meetings, stand-ups, managers that don't understand how special the posters are while shaking as a leafs in November being afraid that they won't be able to afford the next rent increase in Silly Valley or that as they turn forty is just amazing.
- icedchai 9y agoAmazing, right? This guy is living the dream.
- wpietri 9y agoHuh. Not sure who you're talking to, but I opened with "good for him", and I meant it.
- notyourday 9y agoIt was directed at the general posture of comments disassembling and not believing his business model, saying that he cannot be as good as Walmart at predicting demand and hence should go out of business, etc.