4 ms·
School funds should be distributed equally across the entire population. If we were a democracy, rich neighborhoods wouldn't have better schools.
by sitkack 9y ago
School funds should be distributed equally across the entire population. If we were a democracy, rich neighborhoods wouldn't have better schools.
- jknoepfler 9y agoThat's not precisely true. Because we live in a democracy, citizens of local governments can collectively vote to levy additional funds for local schools. I agree that federal and state funding should obviate this, but there's nothing intrinsically undemocratic about the current system. (Unfair or badly designed != undemocratic). Some of the best public schools in the nation exist where I grew up in the Minnesota suburbs. They served trailer parks and public housing the same as the doctors and lawyers. But they also passed levies to increase their own taxes year after year. It is unfair, and wrong, that Minneapolis inner city schools don't have the same funding, but the vibrancy of the well funded public schools was a consequence of local, effective, democratic political action.
- eric_b 9y agoMinneapolis spends an obscene amount per pupil on students, with the number getting HIGHER in the bad districts: http://www.startribune.com/where-minneapolis-public-schools-is-spending-its-building-improvement-funds/434531803/ http://www.startribune.com/where-minneapolis-public-schools-... North Minneapolis has bad outcomes not because of lack of money, that's for sure.
- jknoepfler 9y agoYeah, it's a tough problem. I did Americorps work in some of the poorer elementary schools in St. Paul, and one of the biggest problems those schools face is that they have very high special needs burdens that they have to meet before they can deal with the general population, and those are incredibly costly. That said, I completely agree with you that there are a lot of problems facing students in Northeast Minneapolis that hurt outcomes that have nothing to do with funding. I mean at the end of the day, kids like myself had well-educated parents who read to us every night, did math problems with us, and provided the scaffolding for learning long before we hit school (most of primary education was a waste, at best review). There's no substitute for that. The experience of tutoring badly off kids in poor neighborhoods was one of the more heartbreaking experiences of my life. The inertia in the students is palpable after about age nine. That said, I still struggle to call the distribution of effective resources "equitable," and I'll happily foot a tax bill to double education spending until the generational poverty problem is mitigated to a much greater degree (although I suspect non conventional methods might have better returns).
- jarcoal 9y agoUnfortunately as long as there are better parents there will always be better schools.
- selectodude 9y agoThe wealthiest school districts in the country tend to be the worst.
- aantix 9y agoCitation?
- rayiner 9y agohttp://articles.baltimoresun.com/2013-05-21/news/bs-md-ci-census-schools-20130521_1_school-system-per-pupil-spending-districts http://articles.baltimoresun.com/2013-05-21/news/bs-md-ci-ce... Out of the top 5, only Montgomery County has a high-income student population.
- s0rce 9y agoDefinitely not the case in the Bay Area -- Palo Alto, Piedmont, Orinda are wealthy and have some of the best schools.
- selectodude 9y agoNot wealthy residents. Wealthy school districts. LAUSD spends substantially more than Palo Alto per student.
- sitkack 9y agoCould it be that the wealthy in those locations predominately send their children to private schools. Public schools aren't a priority for the super rich.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- humanrebar 9y ago> If we were a democracy, rich neighborhoods wouldn't have better schools. If we were a democracy, you'd be able to have more choice in how your children were educated. Switching schools or otherwise opting for more innovative educational approaches would be much more viable. People buy into school districts because that's, bottom line, the only way to have a say in your kids' education.
- sitkack 9y agoDemocracy isn't just about choice. It includes access, privilege and equality. I think the imbalance in school district efficacy has more to do with classism and a "just universe" than anything else. The betters should have it better.
- rayiner 9y agoAt least within states, they more or less are: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/local/wp/2015/03/12/in-23-states-richer-school-districts-get-more-local-funding-than-poorer-districts/?utm_term=.bd247523e164 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/local/wp/2015/03/12/in-2... ("When federal dollars are included, just five states are spending less in their poorest districts than in their wealthiest. Nationwide, the average disparity drops from 15 percent to less than 2 percent.").
- ashark 9y agoSpending’s not the problem. Income just happens to correlate with having kids who aren’t disruptive and (are made to) care about education. The money itself isn’t the main reason for different school outcomes.